In a dramatic court hearing, Lindsay Clancy’s attorney argued there is not enough evidence to prove she killed her three children, marking a significant shift in the defense strategy after a mistrial in the high-profile Massachusetts case. Prosecutors pushed back, calling the argument "laughable" as the court weighs motions that could shape the case's future.
All right, we're joined now by Elise Hershon, criminal defense attorney and our legal expert.
So last hour we spoke about the motions that were filed today. Was there anything surprising
you found about either side? Anything that they brought up? I think something interesting that
also was confusing is that attorney Reddington got up and he was arguing that the commonwealth
in his 25b2 motion that they didn't provide enough evidence for criminal responsibility.
He also said they didn't provide any evidence that Lindsay Clancy actually killed her children.
And I wasn't in the courtroom, but I'm sure that there were some gasps in the courtroom because
as we know throughout this whole trial, he conceded Lindsay Clancy, not directly, but
through her lawyer conceded that she did this, but there's a justification, basically her mental
illness. So I think it was surprising here that he went back to basics, like all the way back
before the trial and saying there's reasonable doubt here she even did it. They didn't prove that
and they didn't prove that she was criminally responsible. So that was a little bit of a
surprise. Yes, definitely a surprise because I think a lot of people were under the impression
that that was an undisputed aspect to all of this. So all signs are pointing to another trial,
but the prosecution didn't tip their hand at all about a first degree murder charge.
If they're going to try that again, what are you making about all of that?
So I think Tim Cruz, the district attorney, it's completely his decision whether he wants to
proceed with first degree murder charges. As it stands right now, there are three first degree
murder charges that Lindsay Clancy is facing. They're the original three. Will Tim Cruz's
office come back and say we're going to reduce it to a second degree murder and maybe do a bench
trial, which is just in front of a judge with no jury? That would alleviate all of these juror
issues next time. Will he offer a manslaughter and have the punishment be civil commitment to
a hospital? Will he dismiss the charges? He has a lot of options here. I don't see any of them
likely. I see the most likely as charging forward with first degree, but no official word on that.
I think he's sitting back and watching and seeing what happens. So now we're looking ahead to
November 2nd. What could happen in between now and then? Could we hear anything about these motions
from today? Yes. So I anticipate we will hear a decision on the motions from today. So there
were only two today with regards to the juror notes being exposed to the public or open to the
public. The Globe spoke on that as well. And the 25B2 motion. Will the judge find that there was
not enough evidence presented at the trial for a rational jury to have convicted her? Unlikely,
but the judge did not want to rule on that today. He's going to take it under advisement,
likely do a written decision. And then on November 2nd, we have Marty Weinberg,
the appellate lawyer who was involved in Karen Reed coming in and arguing the double jeopardy
motion, which has a lot to do with that juror. What happened in the jury deliberation room,
not what was discussed, but was there a bias or some significant impropriety that would have
required the judge to inquire further or swap him out? So that will be argued November 2nd,
and likely that decision will be delayed until after the hearing date. And do jurors have to
come on November 2nd? No. So none of the jurors are going to be coming on November 2nd.
Required. The holdout or the loan juror may appear via his counsel. So he hired a lawyer
that's not admitted to practice in Massachusetts. That lawyer then essentially hired a lawyer
to appear today to speak. You have to have taken the bar exam in the state where you want to go
into court to be recognized as a lawyer in practice. He's not able to do that. Ed Peltzik
is his name. So the lawyer came in today and wants a continuance of basically the hearing on
all the jury discovery, the questionnaire that he filled out, that everybody filled out with
regards to going through his cell phone. Very unlikely the judge is going to allow that,
but that's going to be addressed on November 2nd. Although he's not a technical party to the case,
the loan juror, his lawyer may be there and asked to be heard to object to that motion.
Okay. Wow. A lot of complexities to this case. Well, we appreciate you being here,
Elise Hirschhorn. Thank you very much. This case, we will continue to cover both on air
and online. Make sure to stay tuned for any developments about Lindsey Clancy.
You can see our past coverage at boston25news.com.