Two Identical Men with the Same Name Take a DNA Test, The Results Were Unexpected

DailyDose
9 followers
FOR ANY COPYRIGHT ISSUES, CONTACT US FIRST: [email protected]
-----------------------------------------------------------
Two professional baseball pitchers discovered something almost impossible: they had the same name, looked remarkably alike, were both 6'4", and had suffered the same serious elbow injury.
When the two Brady Feigls finally met, their similarities became even stranger. They even had the same surgeon and similar ancestry results. Then they took a DNA test to find out whether there was a hidden family connection.
#Did_you_know #Trending_stories #Viral_stories
For years, people had joked about having a lookalike somewhere in the world.
Someone who had the same face, the same smile, maybe even the same voice.
But for two professional baseball players, the coincidence went far beyond simply looking alike.
They had the exact same name.
They were both pitchers.
They were both 6 feet 4 inches tall.
They both had similar hair, thick beards, and glasses.
And somehow, they had even suffered the same serious elbow injury and undergone the same
surgery.
Yet they had never met.
They weren't brothers.
They weren't cousins.
As far as either man knew, they weren't related at all.
Then one phone call from a doctor's office suddenly revealed that there were actually
two Brady Feigls in professional baseball.
And that was only the beginning.
The story starts with Brady Gregory Feigl, who was born on the 27th of November, 1995,
in Missouri.
He grew up like any other kid, eventually heading to Mississippi to play college baseball
and pursue the dream that would later take him into professional baseball.
But five years earlier and hundreds of miles away, another boy had already been given almost
the exact same name.
Brady Matthew Feigl was born on the 27th of December, 1990, in Maryland.
He also grew up normally and eventually played college baseball, chasing the same dream as
the younger Brady.
Neither of them knew the other existed.
For years, their lives followed completely separate paths.
Then baseball brought them into the same world.
Brady Gregory eventually joined the Oakland Athletics' single-A affiliate, the Beloit
Snappers.
At around the same time, Brady Matthew was climbing the professional ranks with the Texas
Rangers' triple-A affiliate, the Round Rock Express.
Two different players.
Two different childhoods.
Two different families.
But when people saw their photographs, they started noticing something almost impossible
to ignore.
The two men looked remarkably similar.
They had the same general appearance, the same hair color, similar thick beards, and
both wore glasses.
And then there was their height.
Both stood exactly six feet four inches tall.
From a distance, it could be difficult to tell them apart.
In some photographs, the resemblance was so strong that even people who knew there were
two different players could find themselves staring twice just to figure out which Brady
they were looking at.
There was, however, one reliable way to tell them apart.
Their throwing arms.
Brady Matthew was a left-handed pitcher.
Brady Gregory threw right-handed.
That small difference was about the only obvious clue.
But the similarities didn't stop with their faces, names, height, and careers.
Both men had suffered the same type of devastating injury.
Each had torn the ulnar collateral ligament, commonly known as the UCL, in his elbow.
And both required surgery.
Normally, even that would already be an extraordinary coincidence.
But somehow, their paths crossed again.
Both Brady Feigls ended up being treated by the same world-famous orthopedic surgeon,
Dr. James Andrews.
And their surgeries happened within roughly six months of each other.
Two professional baseball pitchers.
Same name.
Almost identical appearance.
Same position.
Same height.
Same type of injury.
Same surgeon.
And yet, somehow, they still hadn't met.
Neither man had any idea just how strange the situation was becoming.
Then, several months after Brady Gregory's surgery, the phone rang.
It wasn't a call from a friend.
It wasn't a message from another player.
It came from the doctor's office.
And what the receptionist said made absolutely no sense.
The office contacted Gregory's team trainer and asked when Brady was going to report for
his surgery.
But there was a problem.
Brady had already had the surgery.
Months earlier.
Gregory later explained that he was already six or seven months removed from his operation
when the office called asking when he would be coming in.
The trainer had to explain that Brady had already undergone the procedure.
That was when the strange mistake finally made sense.
The doctor's office wasn't talking about the Brady they thought they were talking about.
They had contacted the wrong Brady Feigl.
That was how Brady Gregory discovered something he had never imagined.
There was another professional baseball player with exactly the same name.
And he wasn't just another Brady Feigl.
He looked remarkably like him, too.
When the two players eventually learned about each other,
neither initially treated the coincidence as some earth-shattering mystery.
They were curious, of course.
But because each man was used to seeing his own face every day,
they could notice small differences that other people couldn't.
To them, they didn't necessarily look like identical twins.
To everyone else, however, the resemblance was almost impossible to ignore.
Fans began noticing.
Sportswriters noticed.
Broadcasters noticed.
And soon, people online started mixing them up constantly.
Messages intended for one Brady Feigl would end up going to the other.
Fans would approach them at games or public appearances
with memorabilia belonging to the wrong player.
Sometimes the situation became almost comical.
Brady Matthew remembered one occasion when a fan approached him with a baseball card,
expecting him to sign it.
He recognized the problem immediately.
The card wasn't his.
The fan had mistaken him for the other Brady Feigl.
But instead of simply becoming a funny coincidence among baseball players,
the story began attracting attention far beyond the sport.
Eventually, the two Bradys were invited onto Inside Edition.
And when they finally appeared together on television,
viewers got to see what all the online comparisons had been about.
The reaction was immediate.
People couldn't believe that two unrelated men could share the same name
while looking so remarkably similar.
Their phones filled with calls and messages.
The story spread.
And suddenly, the question that had started as a joke
became something people genuinely wanted answered.
Were these two men really complete strangers?
Or was there something connecting them that neither family had ever discovered?
Inside Edition decided there was only one way to find out.
They offered both men a DNA test.
The two Brady Feigls agreed.
Neither expected the results to reveal a hidden family secret.
But after everything that had happened,
even they had started wondering whether the impossible might somehow be true.
Maybe they were distant relatives.
Maybe they were long-lost brothers.
Maybe all those similarities weren't coincidence after all.
Then the DNA results arrived.
And the two men sat down together to finally see what their genes had to say.
The first result belonged to Brady Gregory.
It showed that he was 53% German.
Then Brady Matthew opened his result.
He stared at the report.
His ancestry was also 53% German.
For a moment, the coincidence seemed almost too perfect.
Same name.
Same face.
Same height.
Same profession.
Same injury.
Same surgeon.
And now the same percentage of German ancestry.
Everything appeared to be pointing in one direction.
But there was still one result left.
The one that would answer the question everyone had been waiting for.
Were the two Brady Feigls actually related?
The answer was finally there.
They weren't brothers.
They weren't secretly related.
Despite everything that had happened,
the DNA results showed that the two Brady Feigls didn't share any DNA at all.
Not even a little.
For the men themselves, the result confirmed what they had originally believed.
But for everyone watching, it was almost impossible to accept.
How could two unrelated people have the same unusual name,
look so much alike,
stand exactly 6 feet 4 inches tall,
become professional baseball pitchers,
suffer the same injury,
undergo the same surgery,
and even have the same percentage of German ancestry?
The coincidence seemed almost too perfect.
Even the two Bradys admitted that,
after spending so much time hearing people compare them,
they had started wondering whether there might actually be a family connection.
So, when the DNA test ruled that out,
there was a small sense of disappointment.
Brady Matthew put it in a different way.
Even though they weren't biological brothers,
he said they were still brothers in a way.
And that was perhaps the most interesting part of the entire story.
The DNA test ended one mystery.
But it didn't erase the strange connection the two men had developed.
They remained close and learned to laugh about the situation.
Meanwhile, the public couldn't let it go.
Fans flooded the internet with theories,
refusing to believe that all those similarities could simply be coincidence.
Some people wondered whether there had to be some distant family connection
that the DNA test hadn't uncovered.
Others suggested that the two men should take another test
or investigate their family histories more deeply.
One particularly wild theory even suggested that
perhaps one Brady Feigl had somehow traveled through time.
Of course, there was no evidence for that.
But the fact that people were willing to entertain ideas like that
showed just how strange the entire story appeared from the outside.
Two men had grown up in different states and different families,
without knowing the other existed.
Then both ended up pursuing baseball.
Both became pitchers.
Both reached professional baseball.
Both were six feet four inches tall.
Both had similar hair and beards.
Both wore glasses.
Both tore the same elbow ligament.
Both needed surgery.
And somehow, both were treated by the same surgeon within six months of each other.
They didn't even discover one another through some dramatic family investigation.
A receptionist simply called the wrong Brady.
That ordinary mistake opened the door to one of the strangest coincidences in baseball.
And once the two men became known publicly,
the mix-ups continued.
Fans would approach the wrong player asking for autographs.
People online would send messages to the wrong Brady.
Even photographs became a source of confusion.
The players themselves eventually learned to take it all in stride.
They understood why people found the resemblance fascinating,
even if they personally could see the differences more easily than everyone else.
There was also another interesting detail that sometimes got lost in the excitement.
The two men weren't actually identical copies of each other.
Their throwing arms were different.
Brady Matthew was a left-handed pitcher, while Brady Gregory threw right-handed.
And some people online eventually argued that
the resemblance wasn't quite as extraordinary as others claimed,
suggesting that the matching beards, glasses, hair,
and overall appearance made the similarities seem stronger.
But whether they looked like twins or simply shared an uncanny resemblance,
the coincidence remained remarkable.
The DNA test had answered the biggest question.
They weren't brothers,
but it couldn't explain why so many other pieces of their lives had lined up so perfectly.
Maybe there really was nothing deeper behind it.
Maybe two completely unrelated people simply happened to be given the same name
and then followed remarkably similar paths.
And perhaps that's what made the story so fascinating.
We tend to imagine that the people who look like us must share something with us.
A family connection.
A common ancestor.
Some hidden explanation.
But sometimes, according to the story of the two Brady Feigls,
coincidence can go much further than we expect.
Two strangers can grow up separately,
enter the same profession,
look remarkably alike,
suffer the same injury,
visit the same doctor,
and somehow still have no biological connection at all.
The two Brady Feigls eventually moved on with their careers.
They didn't pursue additional DNA testing,
despite continued requests from curious fans.
Maybe they were satisfied with the answer.
Maybe they simply didn't want to reopen a mystery they had already made peace with.
Either way, they had already discovered something more unusual than a biological twin.
