How passengers helped stop the Flydubai emergency | DW News

24/7 around The World News
62 followers
9 Video Views·Oct 1, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Israel's prime minister says a terror attack
was averted Wednesday in the skies
between Dubai and Tel Aviv.
It happened on a Fly Dubai flight
when the co-pilot apparently stabbed the pilot
in an attempt to hijack the plane and possibly crash it.
The Boeing 737 with 127 people on board
was bound for Tel Aviv when one of the pilots
reportedly stabbed another pilot
and attempted to gain control of the aircraft.
Passengers and crew were able to subdue the co-pilot
and then safely land the jet in Saudi Arabia.
Saudi officials confirm one suspect
has been taken into custody and has been interrogated.
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu
says the pilot attempted to crash the plane
during the attack.
I salute these heroes who showed
extraordinary resourcefulness and courage.
They saved many lives.
They prevented a major disaster.
The plane landed safely at Tabuk Airport in Saudi Arabia.
All of the passengers are out of danger.
The offending pilot has been arrested
and is currently being interrogated
by the Saudi authorities.
Yeah, and that is the good news.
All of the passengers from that diverted flight
have now returned to Israel.
They arrived at Israel's Ben Gurion Airport
where many of their friends and family were waiting.
Now, on their way back to Israel,
several of the passengers gave accounts
of what happened during the attempted hijacking.
Let's take a listen now to some of those accounts.
During the flight, it was a regular flight
till we got to the Jordanian border.
Suddenly, the aircraft was dropping very sharply,
like a massive turbulence.
And we didn't understand why
because we didn't get any alert.
And we tried to buckle up and it got balanced.
After 20, 30 seconds,
and then started dropping again and balancing again.
And we saw that in front of the,
next to the cockpit, people ran.
And we understood that one of the pilots
stabbed the other one.
My little daughter was in the restroom
and my wife was accompanying her.
Then we heard screams from the cockpit
and we could hear struggles.
She brought us the attention of a pilot
who was outside.
He was a crew member we weren't aware was also a pilot.
And then another crew member entered the cockpit.
Then we could see someone was stabbed.
Then we were thrown out.
It was a very difficult event.
Three of us jumped.
We neutralized him.
And then the other pilot who was sitting with us
went inside along with the other pilot
and they essentially stabilized the plane.
A very, very difficult experience.
I found myself as a mother sitting
and saying goodbye to my daughters
and telling them that I love them
because we literally saw the end right before our eyes.
And it was a very, very traumatic event.
Well, joining me now is aviation journalist,
Andreas Spaeth.
Andreas co-hosts the podcast called Fluke Forensic,
which reconstructs aircraft accidents
and examines what caused them.
Andreas, it's good to have you with us.
What we know right now is that the plane dropped
from nearly 34,000 feet to just under 17,000 feet
in about a minute.
What does that tell you about what was happening
inside the cockpit?
Yeah, it must be a major altercation.
And Dubai has even confirmed this now
in an official press release
that there had been an altercation in the cockpit.
So apparently between the two pilots
who were supposed to fly the plane.
So we're all talking about security in the cockpit
after 9-11, 25 years ago.
And now it turns out that the danger
can also be inside the cockpit behind these locked doors.
So these two men got into a fight apparently,
which is not officially confirmed,
but it seems to emerge as the probable cause.
The co-pilot was attacking the pilot.
There was talk, and I think even some photos
of a pocket knife that he apparently used.
Don't know where this came from.
That's one of the major questions.
And apparently the aircraft spun out of control
at that one point.
And interestingly, during this horrific dive,
which is like probably caused or to put the plane
into a supersonic dive, supersonic speeds,
still somebody at the cockpit was able during that dive
to punch in an emergency code into their system
indicating a hijacking.
And then a few seconds later,
this was changed to just another code
for signaling trouble and danger of the aircraft in.
So the most amazing danger of this whole thing
was the structural integrity of the aircraft.
And we see how the main rudder had been torn off
after the aircraft luckily safely landed.
That speaks to the stress that the plane was under
as it reached, as you said, supersonic speeds.
What would the conditions have been like
inside the plane at that moment?
Just horrific because, I mean, nobody was expecting this.
And this is actually putting a heavy physical strain
on your body.
I mean, there are several G-forces,
several, much more G-forces at work
than we usually experience here on the ground with one G.
So I suspect there must be at least three G,
which is like a heavy roller coaster ride,
but having no indication of what's happening,
screaming, and all of a sudden,
this plane went out of control.
I mean, we have seen some videos of people
who actually filmed during this kind of descent.
I'm not sure if that actually came from the main dive
or a little bit later,
but it was, of course, a totally helpless situation
for the passengers and one of high danger.
The co-pilot was stabbed, indicating that a knife,
as you said, maybe a pocket knife or something similar,
was inside the cockpit.
Now, we know passengers are not allowed
to bring knives on board.
We go through security checks.
What about the security checks for crew members?
What does that look like?
Are they able to bring pocket knives with them?
Yeah, that's a very good question.
Interestingly, in Dubai, where this flight originated from,
most FlyDubai flights, I think all of them almost,
are normally proceeded and boarded in Terminal 2,
which is the low-cost terminal
on the other side of the main terminal.
This flight, Tel Aviv, specifically boarded at Terminal 3,
which is the Emirates terminal normally,
where there actually is higher security.
And from what we know, normally also in Dubai,
the crew has to go to the normal security checks.
There's sometimes a special lane,
but the rules are the same.
So, of course, bringing aboard a pocket knife is a no-go.
But coincidentally or kind of paradoxically,
inside the cockpit, there's a huge emergency axe
behind the pilot's seat.
So, of course, there's basically a weapon on board already.
So maybe in this case, I don't know why this gentleman
might have elected to bring this knife
and how he smuggled it across the security controls,
but indefinitely, it was not something
that was supposed to be there.
Okay.
Also, passengers reportedly broke in
and overpowered the co-pilot.
This, when I heard this, this reminded me
of the 9-11 plane over the state of Pennsylvania, Flight 93,
that crashed as passengers overtook the hijackers.
Now, I thought, though, that after the 9-11 attacks,
that cockpit doors on planes
were supposed to be fortified with stronger locks.
Was that not the case in this airplane?
Do we know?
Yeah, it's a very valid question.
We just discussed this recently, just in September,
which ends today.
That was the 25th anniversary of 9-11.
And no, of course, this door was in place.
This door was locked.
And apparently, it was opened.
Obviously, it was opened.
It was not clear yet if from the inside,
by one of the pilots, or from the outside.
Interestingly, there were two non-flying,
fly-to-by, qualified fly-to-by pilots
in the passenger cabin, riding as passengers.
Fly-to-by even confirmed that,
saying they were on duty,
but they did not fly there on the cockpit.
But it might have been also that there was talk
that they might have actually taken over
from both the injured pilots afterwards
and actually landed safely.
But they, of course, might have known
the special emergency code, PIN code,
to enter the cockpit,
to overcome the cockpit fortification,
as well as the purser, the main cabin attendant.
So one of these crew members, of course,
must have been assisting,
or maybe one of the pilots from the cockpit,
inside of it.
We don't know that yet.
But what we can deduce here is that
if these two extra pilots had not been on board,
the chances of this becoming a major disaster,
those chances would have been much greater.
Am I understanding that right?
Absolutely.
So as a conclusion,
we have two very lucky circumstances here.
First of it is basically the structural integrity
of the aircraft was kept.
So even this very, very stressful dive,
which is actually much more than the fuselage,
is certified for any kind of stress
that actually it held on, it didn't burst.
The tail didn't come off, easily happening.
And the other positive thing
was that these two other pilots,
not flying pilots, were on board by accident,
I think, or by chance,
and that they, from what we know and assume,
or one of them at least,
could take over and then,
as a basically fresh and qualified and uninjured pilot,
qualified to fly this very aircraft to land that safely.
So these both things, of course,
I think contributed a lot
to the positive outcome in the end.
Aviation journalist Andreas Spaeth.
Andreas, good to have you with us.
I think you've answered a lot of questions
for our viewers tonight.
We appreciate your time and your insights.
Thank you.
Thanks very much.
There's a harrowing accounts there.
I'm gonna pull in now, Maidan Bar.
He is a pilot, a captain, with the Israeli airline El Al.
He's also a member of the Israeli Pilots Association.
Captain, it's good to have you with us.
You know, you're a pilot,
you know what the security checks for the crew entail.
There are reports tonight that the co-pilot
had a knife or maybe a pocket knife on him.
We can't confirm that.
We don't know yet either how he was able
to bring that aboard.
If he did carry it through security,
how serious of a breach would that be?
All right, I think first, good night.
Thank you for having me.
It's hard and interesting to speak about
one of the events that will probably change
the way aviation behaves in the last day of September,
25 years after the Twin Towers.
But I think the issue about
if there was a pocket knife or wasn't a pocket knife,
I don't think it's the real deal
because, you know, a pilot,
if he makes a mistake or he does something intentionally,
I don't think he needs any of them.
The trust and the responsibility is our main asset.
But I can tell you that as a representative
of the Israeli Airline Pilots Association,
which really takes along six Israeli airlines,
I'm not representing any specific of them,
but this event today, it is significant.
But the good thing, and we always should look
on the good things, is that plane had landed safely.
All those passengers are home now in Israel.
And now we know the situation and the status of the plane.
We heard all the recordings.
We will see all the cameras.
It will be, let's say, not that difficult to understand.
And I will take you-
Well, Captain, let me ask you about that.
You say that today will be the most important day
for aviation since the 9-11 attacks in 2001.
Why do you say that?
What about this incident is so significant?
I don't think it will be, or I hope it won't be
the important day, but it will definitely be a day
that will change the way we think about aviation
according to the human factors.
Because the plane was okay, the weather was okay,
the route was known, the charts were like
exactly as the flight plan.
This is the human factor.
That is one of the really, let's say,
difficult challenges that we're facing.
You know-
Are you talking about trust?
Are you talking about trust between pilots?
Because there were two pilots in this cockpit.
And, I mean, you could tell us more than,
better than anyone, you have to trust the person
that you're flying with, right?
First, I think you have to trust the person
that you're working with, whether it's a plane or a train.
Doesn't matter.
But I can take you 15 years ago
when Germanwings Airbus was crashing the Alps.
And then we knew, on a, let's say, horrifying event,
then we knew that this was a human factor incident.
And, you know, we're facing now in the world
a shortage of around 400,000 pilots
for the coming 10 years.
That is a really massive challenge.
We're taking now, under European regulation,
people to fly as first officer all over Europe
with 250 hours since they first met a plane.
You know, I come from a,
if we're looking at it from a wider perspective,
I come from Israel, and it's a small country
which has been challenged by war
for, like, more than three years
and sustains its aviation as a really jet bridge.
And it's hard, because if you want to know
how does aviation act in war,
just look at Ukraine, it doesn't exist.
Well, Captain, I just want to make it clear to our viewers,
we don't know yet what the motive was for this co-pilot.
I mean, we don't know these details.
So how does a shortage of pilots
or pilots, you know, being licensed maybe prematurely,
how does that fit into what we saw happen today?
I think recruiting pilots, training pilots,
examining pilots, keeping them on shape
is one of the highest challenge there is
if we look at the future.
But as you said, we don't know yet,
because it's less than 24 hours, what were the motives,
but we will know that very soon.
And we will not be able to walk away
because this plane has everything we need to know.
Everything is recorded, everything is filmed.
So it won't take long
because the investigation already begun.
I just want to say that, you know, you cannot ignore,
as you said before, you cannot ignore the region
and the situation in the Middle East.
But I can tell you that as an Israeli,
those planes and fly Dubai,
which their pilots are our friends.
And, you know, they are suffering this incident too.
And those planes that fly more than one time a day
from the UAE to Israel are really carrying the bridges
of, let's say, normalization.
And that's a good thing.
You know, fly Dubai did not stop flying to Israel
a single day from the war.
Well, Captain, if this copilot had a knife on him,
which we don't know,
but we do know that the pilot was stabbed.
So if the copilot did have a knife on him,
then that would mean that possibly someone on the ground
helped him get through security
because the security checks are extremely high.
It's supposed to be impossible to bring a knife
on your person if you are a pilot, correct?
That is correct.
But we will know that soon because the pilots are alive
and they will be interrogated.
So don't worry, as you said.
Let me just ask you too about the door to the cockpit
because people have been asking that today as well.
After 9-11, we were told that the locks on the doors
to the cockpit were fortified
so that people could not break into the cockpit.
Here we had a situation where one of the pilots
actually wanted to be able to break out
and was able to unlock that door.
Does this incident then force a rethink
about cockpit door safety?
I don't think so because here we had a pilot
inside the cockpit that probably unlock it
because he wanted to get help and vice versa.
We had an extra crew member at the back
that knew how to get in.
So in this case, I think we had luck,
but still we don't know.
And I can tell you as a pilot,
while we're speaking now,
there are like hundreds of thousands of people
waiting to board a plane somewhere in the world.
It might be a 737, it might be from the UAE
or anywhere else in the world.
We have to tell them that pilots are here
for your safety and security,
and the airspace that is open is safe and secure,
and go ahead and fly.
This will never change, not tomorrow, not the day after.
This investigation will be short and very thoroughly.
We will know exactly, not because we wanna hang someone,
because we wanna know what we're missing
and wanna get better, that's it.
Captain, one final question I wanna ask you.
The structural integrity of the plane
was apparently pushed to its limit.
An analyst told me earlier this evening,
the nosedive had the plane descending at a supersonic speed.
Parts of the plane we understand were damaged.
How in the world were they able to stop this nosedive
and keep the plane intact and land safely?
I think that's one of the interesting questions
that no one asked before today,
and I had quite a few interviews.
They dive in, let's say, a vertical descent
that we used to do when we're losing cabin pressure.
And structural integrity was in doubt and was damaged.
This plane could have been, let's say,
fallen apart midair, but it didn't.
Whoever stabilized the plane was a pilot,
probably the captain, which was wounded,
or one of the other crews that knew what to do.
And you have to do it very slowly.
And when the nose is down, it's hard to reach that yoke,
but they did it.
As you said, some of the plane's parts are missing
because of that.
But those planes are very reliable, very strong.
I fly one like that.
I did it this morning, came into Berlin,
and those planes are, let's say, working horses,
and they are strong and reliable.
And you know, thank God it ended up that way.
Yeah, well, I mean, it definitely is amazing
that they were able to keep the plane intact,
land it, and that everyone is safe tonight.
Captain May Dunbar with the Israeli Pilots Association.
Captain, we appreciate your time.
We appreciate you sharing your insights with us tonight.
Thank you.
Thank you for having me.
