The United States announced it had completed its withdrawal from Iraq on Wednesday, more than 20 years after invading the country to topple Saddam Hussein, in a move that was celebrated by the Iraqi government and the Pentagon – as well as Iran and its allies, who claim years of pressure forced the American departure.
In 2024, the Iraqi government and the Biden administration agreed to a phased withdrawal of US troops, a plan the Trump administration has honored. The pullout, however, leaves a new Iraqi government with the daunting task of loosening Iran’s grip on its neighbor, which has long been trapped in a cycle of sectarianism, foreign meddling and civil conflict.
0:00 Trump announces last US forces are leaving Iraq 2:22 Former ambassador to Iraq reacts 4:54 What were the remaining troops doing there? 7:45 What this means for Iran 9:19 How will history look at the Iraq war?
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
The video discusses the final withdrawal of American forces from Iraq, analyzing the geopolitical ramifications and the long-term legacy of the U.S. presence. Experts debate whether this move empowers Iranian-backed militias and weakens U.S. regional influence, while reflecting on the failure of the original mission to establish a stable, prosperous democracy.
But I wanted to announce something
that I'm also very proud of today.
I'm pleased to announce that the last American forces
are leaving Iraq.
It's been a long time with very bad decision-making
that got us involved in this quagmire.
In the first place, it was a quagmire.
Many, many years it lasted.
But soon that part of history will be over.
Part of this mission, obviously, has been an anti-ISIS mission.
There have been issues, of course,
recently with Iranian-backed militias in Iraq
launching waves of strike on US and allied interests.
There have been problems with militias.
I guess I wonder what you think about his announcement,
but also just if Iraqi leadership can
keep militias under control without US assistance
or presence in the region.
Well, again, I worry about this kind of decision
when we're still in the middle of a war with Iran.
And the fact is that these militias have conducted,
I think, something like 600 attacks on US military.
They're supported by Iran.
They're armed by Iran.
And what I worry about with this decision
is that we are handing Iraq over to Iran at a time
when we're still trying to figure out
what's going to happen with this war with Iran.
I just don't see the reasoning behind withdrawing our forces
at a time when we need to defend a lot of our forces
throughout that region who have been under serious attack.
We've had almost something like $4 billion
worth of damage to our bases throughout that area.
And now if you allow these militant groups supported
by Iran not to have to be in any way checked by the US forces
that were there as they were, I think
you're just going to add that much more to a forever war
that we seem to be stuck in.
As the former ambassador to Iraq,
somebody who was there at the height of this war,
did you ever think it would end like this?
Yeah, you know, this has been a problem.
It's always easier to go into a country than go out.
And the Iraqis have been ambivalent about US troops
for a long time.
On the one hand, they need the protection.
On the other hand, the protection
is coming from troops who originally invaded Iraq.
So there are a lot of concerns.
At one point, of course, President Obama
withdrew all the US forces only to bring them back
a couple of years later when the ISIS threat came.
So now after some years, there is an agreement
within the last year to withdraw them all.
But of course, in the meantime, we have an Iranian threat.
And the problem right now is it appears
that the US is retreating in the face of the Iranian threat.
And of course, it's happening in the Kurdish area of Iraq.
And these people have been beleaguered for, frankly,
centuries.
And US forces have been very welcomed in the Kurdish areas.
You mentioned the Iranian threat.
Obviously, we're in the middle of a war with Iran right now.
How does the US troops leaving Iraq
impact the current war with Iran?
Yeah, we're in the middle.
We're really in the muddle because we
don't know where we're going with this, obviously.
But I think a big issue, of course,
is as US troops leave, those Iranian sympathizers in Iraq,
the militia groups that have been funded by Iran
will say things like, well, the US
is retreating in the face of our successes.
And therefore, the US doesn't seem
to have the courage to face us, et cetera.
So all this kind of negativity, obviously, that's
not bought by everybody.
And I think, overall, the Kurds are very concerned that they
could be left as a target.
On the other hand, of course, part of the targeting
that the Iranian militia had done in Kurdistan
is targeting against the US.
So there may be fewer drones and bombs
because there are fewer US forces to hit.
But overall, one always gets the sense,
I'm sorry to put it, at least with this administration,
that it does things before it thinks about things.
And one gets the sense that it's not really
thought all the ramifications of this.
I think the first reaction that maybe some Americans and even
people around the world might have when they see today's
headline is, wasn't America already out of Iraq?
So can we really start there?
What American presence remained in Iraq
that is withdrawing today?
What gap do they leave behind?
And what was their role during this last period?
Well, specifically, this mission, Operation Inherent
Resolve, was the mission to combat ISIS.
In 2014, when the Islamic State rose and took over
a third of Iraq's territory, the US military
re-engaged in Iraq to help fight ISIS.
And keep in mind that the Iraqi government declared victory
over ISIS at the end of 2017.
So here we are in 2026, where the levels of ISIS,
in terms of the attacks, in terms of numbers,
in terms of their finances, are at an all-time low.
So a few years ago, the Iraqi government
and the American government came together and said,
this mission is clearly sort of finished.
I mean, there's no reason to keep this true presence there
to be fighting ISIS.
And so that's where they moved towards this word
normalization.
Can Iraq and the US have normalized relations
that doesn't include a US troop presence in the country,
but could still include bilateral security arrangements,
economic arrangements, and such?
Of course, these negotiations began before the region
was at the war that it's currently in.
And so there is some anxieties in Iraq
that Iraq is becoming a battleground for this war
between the US and Israel and Iran.
But specifically, I think, Iraqis are in the bigger picture
marking this day, because Iraq was one of the biggest
US foreign policy moves in a generation.
And the promise of regime change,
the promise of democracy, of a better future,
many Iraqis now struggle.
The country is one of the most corrupt
when it comes to several indexes that you see.
Human development is still not that high.
And there are many challenges ahead.
So people are looking back at what is now a history.
And wondering what was worth it.
Let me pick up there with this idea of normalization
that you mentioned.
I think we have to discuss the third party in the room.
You've already mentioned them, which is Iran.
How will Iran perceive this,
especially when you think about how tightly wrapped
Tehran's tentacles are around Baghdad?
Are they gonna see this as a victory for Tehran?
Does this weaken America's position
when it comes to that ongoing conflict with Iran?
Well, I think there's two ways you can answer this.
First, certainly Iraq is a battleground
where the US and Iran continue to fight for influence.
I mean, keep in mind that the US have struck across Iraq
over the last year at targets,
at militias and armed groups that are linked to Iran.
And at the same time,
Iran's IRGC is actively operational in Iraq.
I mean, the fact that you have armed groups
that are able to strike Saudi Arabia
and other countries in the Gulf from Iraqi territory,
shows you the extent to which Iran
and its acts of resistance are operational inside Iraq.
And the Iraqi government doesn't have the sovereignty
to be able to control this.
So certainly Iraq will continue to be a battleground
between this war, between the US and Iran.
But at the same time,
I think it's also important to note that not too long ago,
this Operation Inherent Resolve to fight ISIS,
Iran and the US were on the same page.
They shared a common enemy
and they didn't fight together per se,
but they were fighting on the same side.
And it just feels like such a long time ago
that that was the case,
as of course now their guns have turned against each other.
And that's such an important point to make
when you're talking about
a more than 20 year history of conflict here.
And so when you take that step back,
and I know you're beginning to touch on that,
but I wanna give you an opportunity
to sort of delve into this idea of legacy separately
for Americans and for Iraqis,
what will each remember
and how do you think history will look at
this more than two decade long conflict here in Iraq?
You know, when the Americans first came in to Iraq
to remove Saddam Hussein,
they were greeted with joy.
I mean, people were struggling to live under sanctions
and under the Saddam Hussein regime.
And, you know, and there was this hope
that is this American sort of unipolar world
where the Americans are so powerful?
Are they actually gonna be able to bring us a better life?
And in many regards,
we've seen that the Americans and their allies
broke too much.
They broke the state.
So much of the state is unable today
to provide sufficient water, electricity, basic needs.
As I mentioned, Iraq is one of the worst
when it comes to corruption in the world.
It's a country where the government
doesn't have sovereignty over its territory.
The fact that you have these armed groups
that could operate at free will.
You know, so the legacy from the Iraqi perspective,
and keep in mind that many link the rise of ISIS
and these other terrorist networks to the invasion.
So it's a legacy that's been very violent, very bloody,
and it's still hard to see the light at the end of the tunnel
of where this could go.
Now, from the other part of that, of course,
the Americans invested heavily in Iraq.
I mean, the embassy in Baghdad
was the biggest U.S. embassy in the world.
So much was invested financially,
and so many, you know, U.S. troops went.
I mean, so from both sides,
I think it's not regarded as a success.
And even though President Bush
declared mission accomplished
a few weeks after the initial invasion,
many are waiting to see what that mission accomplishment
actually looks like.