Logical fallacies are rampant in today’s society, and perhaps that will never change.
Also known as “junk cognition” or “flawed arguments,” logical fallacies have been relied upon across the ages by people who are intent on defending certain points of view.
Often, these logical fallacies are never actually disproven, causing entire populations to make decisions based on inherently flawed premises. Because of this, it’s very important to recognize logical fallacies when you see them.
Here are the ones we will discuss: 00:00 Intro 01:54 The Bandwagon Fallacy 04:01 The Sunk Cost Fallacy 05:32 The Straw Man Fallacy 07:03 The Ad Hominem Fallacy 09:00 The Mott-and-Bailey Fallacy 10:04 The Safe Space Fallacy 12:08 The Reductio Ad Hitlerum Fallacy 13:49 Final Thoughts
This video explores the prevalence of logical fallacies, also known as \"junk cognition,\" in modern society. It emphasizes the importance of recognizing these flawed arguments—especially in political discourse and discussions about paranormal events—to avoid being misled and to foster more honest, productive debates.
Logical fallacies are rampant in today's society, and perhaps that will never change.
Also known as junk cognition, or flawed arguments, logical fallacies have been relied upon across
the ages by people who are intent on defending certain points of view.
Often, these logical fallacies are never actually disproven, causing entire populations to make
Because of this, it's very important to recognize logical fallacies when you see them.
If possible, you should also call people out for adopting these logical fallacies.
Not only will this help you prove that your own point of view is correct, but it will
also show people that what they believe, or what they've been told, is false.
As you might expect, these flawed arguments often come up when paranormal events or conspiracy
theories are discussed.
Many people use this junk cognition to prove that these events could not have happened.
If you've ever spoken about paranormal events or conspiracy theories to your friends and
family, many of these logical fallacies might sound familiar.
But what are some examples of logical fallacies?
Well, we're glad you asked.
The bandwagon fallacy is perhaps one of the most common examples of this flawed reasoning,
and you've probably heard it before.
The basic premise is simple.
If everyone else agrees with something, then it must be true.
Alternatively, many people argue that if everyone else likes something, then it must be good.
You've probably experienced the bandwagon fallacy as a child or young adult, via peer
pressure.
For example, a teen might say to his friend,
Come on, everyone else is doing it, you should too.
In your adult life, you may experience the bandwagon fallacy in a more political context.
For example, a popular buzzword today is fringe.
Small fringe minority of people who are on their way to Ottawa or who are holding unacceptable
views that they're expressing, do not represent the views of Canadians who have been there
for each other, who know that following the science and stepping up to protect each other
is the best way to continue to ensure our freedoms, our rights, our values.
Having fringe views does not necessarily mean that those views are incorrect.
It simply means that these views are less popular and common.
But today, politicians often refer to fringe groups in a very derogatory manner, a clear
example of the bandwagon fallacy.
On the other hand, they may also point out that everyone agrees on a certain point or
90% of Americans want something to happen.
One of the greatest flaws of democracy is that the majority doesn't always act in
its best interests.
The sumpkin cost fallacy is something many of us are guilty of, perhaps without even
realizing it.
The premise is pretty simple.
If you've already invested a certain amount of time and money into something, it makes
sense to continue.
After all, if you stop now, you'll have wasted all that time and money for nothing,
right?
In truth, that logic is inherently flawed.
You will likely benefit more if you stop now to avoid future costs.
For example, you might buy an extremely expensive sports car that requires expensive gas, constant
repairs, and regular maintenance.
For some, these costs can be ruinous.
But a motorist might justify keeping this vehicle because they've already invested
tens of thousands of dollars into it.
Obviously, they would benefit more if they simply sold the vehicle and eliminated the
future costs.
With that said, there's nothing wrong with owning an expensive sports car.
Just don't justify it with the sumpkin cost fallacy.
Another example we're all probably familiar with involves a bad movie.
You might get halfway through a movie before you realize it's one of the worst films
you've ever seen.
Now, you'd probably benefit more if you simply turned off the TV and did something
more productive.
But you might justify watching the rest of the movie because, hey, you're already halfway
through, right?
You might as well finish it.
The straw man argument comes up a lot when discussing conspiracy theories and paranormal
events.
The concept is pretty straightforward.
Instead of responding to the actual argument, someone instead attacks a subject that was
never even raised in the first place.
They are attacking a straw man.
A false target.
A scarecrow that has nothing to do with the argument.
For example, you might discuss the concept of UFOs.
Perhaps you're simply pointing out that many UFOs have been sighted over the years,
and someone might say, come on, there's no evidence that aliens are real, but you
never actually raised the subject of aliens.
You were simply talking about UFOs.
And by definition, a UFO is an unidentified flying object.
We don't actually know what they are.
By automatically assuming that you believe in aliens, the other person is using a straw
man argument.
Many people continue to use straw man arguments even after you point it out.
This is because it was never their intention to actually respond to your points, and they
are intentionally steering the debate towards a subject that they feel more comfortable
in refuting.
Unfortunately, there is very little you can do if someone insists on using a straw man
argument.
Another very common argument when discussing paranormal events or conspiracy theories is
the ad hominem attack.
You don't have it in your blood.
You could have never done that job.
I know how to do the job.
I know how to get the job done.
Well, you didn't do very well in swine flu.
H1N1, you were a disaster.
Your own chief of staff said you were a disaster.
14,000 people died, not 200,000.
There was no economic recession.
This is Latin for, to the person.
In other words, an individual directs their argument not at the actual subject matter
being discussed, but rather, at the person who is speaking.
Obviously, this has no place in a debate, since the speaker's attributes are irrelevant.
But you might be surprised at how common this argument is, even in the highest levels of
political discourse.
For example, someone might point out that your friends and associates engage in crime,
and therefore, your opinion should be dismissed.
Or perhaps they focused on how you're speaking.
Maybe you stuttered or mispronounced a word.
Maybe they bring up an embarrassing detail about your personal past in an attempt to
discredit you.
Another very common type of this argument is circumstantial ad hominem.
This is when someone points out that you stand to benefit from advancing a certain conclusion,
so therefore, that conclusion is wrong.
For example, you might argue that switching from plastic bags to paper bags could reduce
pollution.
Someone might point out that you own a company that makes paper bags, and therefore, you
stand to profit from people buying more paper bags.
However, just because you stand to benefit from it, doesn't mean that it won't still
help.
The Mott and Bailey fallacy is one of the lesser known examples of flawed reasoning.
There are two elements to this argument, an easy-to-defend premise, known as the Mott,
and a more controversial claim, known as the Bailey.
First, the controversial idea is presented.
When challenged, the individual reverts to the easier-to-defend premise.
For example, someone might argue that property ownership is wrong, and that all wealth should
be distributed among the people.
You might then say that people should have the chance to rise out of poverty, and accumulate
a considerable fortune.
Next, the person might say, I'm just saying that Americans are dealing with economic conditions
that are more challenging than ever before.
The second argument is a Mott, and it's easy to defend, because it's true.
But this individual has conflated two completely different arguments, and the initial point,
the Bailey, doesn't really have anything to do with the second point.
Today, we have to watch what we say.
This has led to the creation of a safe space fallacy.
In these safe spaces, people are prevented from voicing certain points of view because
they may trigger negative emotional reactions in certain people.
This is also known as the free speech fallacy.
None of that.
And if a university isn't a home, that's not what it is.
It's a place to be confronted by, I would say, often horrible ideas.
You want to learn about history?
You think that's going to be safe?
Do you know what human history is like?
It's an endless bloodbath, with a certain amount of hopeful progress underlying it.
It's a horror show, and great literature is like that.
And biology is terrifying, and physics is terrifying.
You want to be safe?
It's stay home.
Stay home with your mom.
Stay home with your dad.
Don't come to university if you want to be safe.
Some pills are hard to swallow, but that doesn't make them any less correct.
For example, someone might point out that certain subgroups of the population commit
crimes at a higher rate than others.
This point of view might be seen as racist or politically incorrect.
But it doesn't mean it's not true.
And while there may be tons of other factors controlling these statistics, unless we can
openly discuss them, it will be difficult to deal with the root cause of the problem.
The safe space fallacy also means that many people today are never actually exposed to
differing points of view.
This is very dangerous, and it leads to echo chambers in which wrongspeak is highly discouraged.
In addition, these people never actually learn how to debate and argue certain points of view.
There's a strong chance you've heard the reductio and hitlerum argument before.
These days, it seems like almost everyone we disagree with is quickly labeled as the
new Hitler.
To be facing this invasion, this is a unilateral decision of Putin who basically gone full
There are many problems with this.
First of all, it completely fails to address the actual opinions or motives of the person.
We simply demonize these individuals, label them as Hitler, and move on without ever actually
considering why they are taking certain actions.
The very similar logical fallacy includes calling people Nazis, without ever addressing
their arguments.
I think it was disgraceful, disgraceful, that the intelligence agencies allowed any information
that turned out to be so false and fake.
I think it's a disgrace.
And I say that, and I say that, and that's something that Nazi Germany would have done
and did do.
I think it's a disgrace.
We've seen this before with Trump, Putin, and many others.
You may not agree with these people, but calling them Hitler doesn't really achieve anything.
There is of course only one real Hitler, and that is the German dictator who is now dead.
The truth is that each person has unique motives that should be explored in depth.
Unfortunately, the fact that you now understand these logical fallacies may not make much
of a difference.
If someone else doesn't understand why these arguments are flawed, they will continue to
use them.
For example, you might point out that someone is using an ad hominem attack, but they may
have no idea why that is flawed, and they may believe that they are scoring points when
they take this approach.
In addition, you might unwittingly use some of these flawed arguments without actually
realizing it, even though you know they make no sense.
It's easy to split into old habits, especially when you're debating a subject that you feel
strongly about.
The truth is that logical fallacies are essentially built into our DNA.
The human mind is inherently flawed, and the only thing we can really do is try to be aware
of these flaws.
And even that is not enough.