#History#Ancient In October 1893, eleven hundred and forty feet inside the Anthracite mine above Crested Butte, Colorado, a Slovene miner named Tomaž Kastelic drove his pick into a swelling coal seam and struck iron. What the crew uncovered over the next three days was a tool no man could hold: a shaft sixty-four inches around, a round pommel pierced by a clean hole, and a double crescent head, one blade sharpened, the other cut into thirteen teeth. The company engineer measured it at seventeen feet, eight inches and wrote one line he underlined: the coal formed around it. Within three weeks the heading was sealed.
Forty-three years later, on the Uintah and Ouray Reservation in Utah, an Uncompahgre Ute elder described the same tool to the anthropologist Anne M. Smith. Two moons, back to back. One cuts. One bites. He counted the teeth on his fingers. The Ute already had a name for it: the moon with teeth.
This film follows six records: an engineer's field book, the tool itself, an unpublished notebook page from 1936, a geologist's return to the sealed heading in 1919, objects found in coal and worlds that ended in fire, and a state inspection form from 1986 that ends with three words: left in place. The mainstream explanations are set out in full.
This documentary examines historical records, archaeological research, and Indigenous oral traditions. It presents documented findings alongside long-standing questions that remain open. Where accounts differ, both are presented. Nothing here is offered as a settled conclusion.
In 1893, miners in Colorado discovered a massive, 17-foot iron tool embedded within 70-million-year-old anthracite coal. The object's placement suggests it existed before the coal formed, a claim supported by later geological surveys and Ute oral traditions describing a \"moon with teeth\" left by prehistoric giants. Despite technical documentation, the find was ignored by institutions and remains sealed.
In the autumn of 1893, in the Elk Mountains of Colorado, at an anthracite mine north of the town
of Crested Butte, a miner named Tomáš Kastelić drove his pick into a coal seam deep inside the
mountain, and the pick struck iron. It was not rock. It was not quartz. It was not the end of
an old rail, or a forgotten pick. Out of the coal ran a thick, round, ringed iron shaft,
and at the end of that shaft, buried deep in the seam, was not one crescent blade but two,
back to back. The larger one was taller than a man. The smaller one had teeth. A handle no man's
hand could close around. A tool no man could lift. And in those mountains, a people who had
never seen this tool already had a name for it. The ute. Forty-three years later, in Utah,
an old ute man would describe this tool to an anthropologist. A tool he had never seen.
Counting its teeth, the coal came from the age of the dinosaurs. The tool was inside it. And two
records, each unaware of the other, waited for more than forty years, in two different states,
in two different files. That is where this story begins.
But before we can understand what was found in that seam, we need to understand the mine itself.
Crested Butte today is a small mountain town in western Colorado, at the northern end of the
Gunnison Valley, ringed by peaks that rise past fourteen thousand feet. In winter, the snow piles
to the rooftops. In summer, the valleys fill with wildflowers. Just north of town, above the Slate
River, rises a forested ridge with a flat top. It is called Anthracite Mesa. There is a reason
for that name. Anthracite, the hardest, purest, densest coal there is, comes in America, almost
entirely from one place, eastern Pennsylvania. By the end of the nineteenth century, America's
factories, locomotives, and homes were heated by the black, glassy stone dug from beneath those
hills. West of the Mississippi, there was almost no coal like it. Almost. In the 1880s, prospectors
working the Elk Mountains found coal on the slopes north of Crested Butte that could not be told
apart from Pennsylvania's. Glossy. Hard. Breaking in the hand into edges as sharp as glass. Burning
with almost no smoke. The reason that coal is there lies deep underground. It formed in the
late Cretaceous, seventy-five, perhaps eighty million years ago. While dinosaurs still walked
the earth, these valleys were swamp, and the swamp's plants were pressed beneath the mud and
slowly turned to coal. Geologists call these layers the Mesa Verde Formation. Then, much later,
molten rock rose from far below. It spread into the mountains like a lens and baked the coal above
it. The heat turned ordinary coal into anthracite. What the collision of mountains had done in
Pennsylvania over millions of years, magma did here. The result was the same. A black,
glossy, hard stone. A stone in which, for millions of years, nothing had moved. But the story of
these valleys does not begin with coal. Before the prospectors came, the Gunnison Valley and
the mountains around it belonged to the Ute. Above all to the Tabaguch Band, the Ute who would later
be known as the Uncompagre. In summer they hunted deer and elk on these slopes. In autumn they came
down to the lower valleys. The Treaty of 1868 left western Colorado to them. On paper. Then silver
was found in the mountains. In 1873, the Brunaut Agreement took the San Juans. In 1879, after the
fighting at the White River Agency to the north, the Denver Papers began printing a single sentence,
In September of 1881, under the eyes of the army, the Uncompagre Ute were marched out of the land
they were born in, and into the deserts of Utah. That year, Crested Butte was a town of a thousand
people. The railroad arrived the same year. And one year later, in 1882, the first tunnel was
driven into the side of Anthracite Mesa. So the miners were entering a mountain the Ute had just
been forced to leave. And for the next ten years, no one knew what was inside it. By 1893, the Anthracite
mine belonged to the Colorado Fuel and Iron Company, CF&I. The mine's entrance sat high on
the mountainside. The coal went down an 1,800-foot tramway, pitched at 45 degrees, to the breaker
below. The seam was thin, three or four feet thick. The men worked bent double most of the day,
sometimes on their knees. Below the portal, a small company town had grown up, also called
Anthracite, a boarding house, cabins. A company store opened that very year, 1893, under a manager
named M. P. McDermott, where the miners bought their powder, their lamp oil, and their flour,
against the next pay. In summer, the company even ran a small school for the miners' children.
Up here, nearly 10,000 feet above the sea, the snow could close the road for weeks. The town
lived for the mine, and the mine lived for the seam. Mining in these mountains left no room for
error. On January 24, 1884, methane that had gathered in the Jokerville mine, just outside
Crested Butte, exploded. Fifty-nine men died. It was one of the deadliest mine disasters in
Colorado's history. A month earlier, the state's mine inspector had gone through Jokerville,
found the ventilation adequate, and still written in his book,
A Very Dangerous Mine. After the explosion, the state tightened its laws. Daily safety inspections
in every mine, every accident on the record, every working mapped. Which means that by 1893,
every heading, every turn, and every foot of advance in the anthracite mine was on a map,
in a ledger, under a signature. The mine is real. The seam is real. The laws, the maps,
and the ledgers are real. The unanswered questions begin only after that point.
No one in Colorado was comfortable that year. In June of 1893, the price of silver collapsed.
The state's silver mines closed one after another. Banks failed. The coal mines were
still working, but every miner knew that losing his place was one shift away.
Tomas Kastelic knew it too. He was twenty-nine. He had come from Ribnica, in the Carniola region
of Slovenia, and had been in Crested Butte since 1886. Among the town's Slovenes and Croats,
he was known as a quiet man who knew his work. He knew when the roof was about to talk.
When the seam was about to turn. When the gas was about to smell.
Tuesday, October 17, 1893. Kastelic was working on the second level of the mine,
at the far end of the north heading. He was eleven hundred and forty feet in from the portal.
Above him lay six hundred feet of rock. For several days, the seam had been behaving strangely.
Miners called it a roll, the seam suddenly thickening, bending. Four feet of coal had
become seven, then eight, then eleven, within a few paces. That happened. Coal remembered the
hollows and twists of the swamp it came from. But this swelling was round. The bands of the
coal were bending as if they turned around something. That afternoon, Kastelic's pick
came down at the centre of those bands. The sound was wrong. Not the dry, glassy
crack of anthracite splitting. A short, dull ring. Metal on metal.
The shock ran up the handle into his arms and shoulders. Kastelic brought his lamp closer.
In the crack, his pick had opened, there was a dark, dull surface, rough, crusted with rust,
curved. He called the man working beside him, Llewelyn Price, Welsh, the biggest man on the
crew, six foot three. Together they widened the crack. Then the pit boss came. Michael Tully,
County Mayo. Forty-two years old. Twenty of them underground. Tully had a habit.
At the end of every shift, he wrote a few short lines in the small, thick,
black-covered book he kept in his pocket. How many cars of coal came out? Which roof was sagging?
Who got hurt? On the evening of October 17, he wrote this,
For three days, three men cleared the coal away from it, first with picks,
then with hand tools, then almost with their fingers. Tully told them to go carefully,
as if something might break. Each day, more of it showed. First part of the shaft, then a ring,
then a square, bolted plate. Then, on either side of the plate, two broad, curved iron wings
bending away into the coal. On Friday, October 20, Tully sent word up to the office. The next day,
an engineer came down. His name was Walter H. Ashby, and the first record of this story is
his field book. Ashby was thirty-one. He was born in Pottsville, Pennsylvania, in the heart of the
anthracite country. He grew up in the very valleys that coal came from. He graduated from Lehigh
University as a mining engineer in 1884, and came to Colorado in 1888. At CF&I's anthracite mine,
the surveys, the maps, and the ventilation figures were his. In other words, there were very few men
in Colorado who knew better than he did what could and could not be inside that seam. For three days,
from October 22 to October 24, Ashby worked beside it. He brought his transit, a measuring tape,
two lamps, and his field book. Eleven pages of that book, and four pencil drawings, still exist.
On the first page, he wrote down where it lay. Level 2, north heading, eleven hundred and forty
feet from the portal, where the seam swells. He tied the spot to the nearest survey station on
the mine map, and carried a line back to the portal, bearing and distance, so that anyone
who came after him could find it again to within a foot. It was a routine thing for a mine surveyor
to do. It would matter twenty-six years later. On the second page, he described the coal. The
coal around the object was the same as the coal in the rest of the mine, same luster, same hardness,
and the bands, Ashby wrote, turned around it like the growth rings of a tree around a nail.
There was no crack. There was no void. There was no path by which anything could have fallen or
worked its way in from above. At the very bottom of the third page, he wrote a single sentence and
underlined it. The coal formed around it. Ashby knew what that sentence meant. He knew the age
of the coal, more than seventy million years, and so, from the fourth page on, he wrote no more
opinions. He only measured. But what he measured says everything he did not write. The second record
is not a story about the tool. It is the tool itself. Pages four through eleven of Ashby's
field book, read like an inventory, unemotional, numbered, the language of an engineer trying to
describe what is in front of him to someone else, someone who will never see it. Overall length,
seventeen feet, eight inches. The tool lay across the seam at an angle. The butt end of the shaft
had come free of the coal and sloped down toward the floor of the heading. The head was still
buried in the thickest part of the seam, at the very centre of the swelling. The shaft. Thirteen
feet from the pommel to the head. Round. Straight. Like a tree trunk. Ashby put his tape around it.
Five feet, four inches. That number deserves a moment. A grown man's hand closes comfortably
around a handle four to four and a half inches around. A pick handle. An axe handle. A hammer.
Every tool the human hand has held, from the Stone Age until now, has been shaped to the size
of that hand. This handle was not four inches around. It was sixty-four. Price, the biggest
man on the crew, wrapped both arms around the shaft. His fingertips did not meet on the other
side. Tully wrote in his book, Price can't reach round it. On the shaft, evenly spaced, sat two
raised collars. Thick, rounded rings, their faces lined with fine parallel grooves. Not cast,
forged. At the butt of the shaft, a heavy round pommel, twenty-six inches across. In his sketch,
Ashby compared it to a cannonball. Then the head. At the end of the shaft sat a square iron plate,
thirty inches on a side. At its four corners, four domed bolt-heads, each the size of a man's fist.
The plate joined the head to the shaft crosswise, the way an axe-head sits on its handle. But this
was not an axe. From the front of the plate swept a broad, deep, full crescent. Its two horns curved
back and ended in sharp points, horn-tip to horn-tip, seven feet, nine inches. The edge was
smooth, and along that edge, where Ashby went over it with a hand-lens, ran fine, regular,
parallel lines. The kind of lines are whetstone leaves. Ashby measured their angle. Along the
whole length of the edge, they ran at the same slant, about thirty degrees, the angle at which
a hand holds a stone against a blade. The blade had been sharpened. From the back of the plate
rose a second crescent, two-thirds the size of the first, five feet, two inches, the same deep curve,
the same horns sweeping back. But the edge of this crescent was not smooth. It had teeth.
Ashby counted them one by one. Thirteen, each about five inches long, triangular,
evenly spaced. Not one of them broken. A cutting edge in front. Behind it, an edge made to rake,
to scrape, perhaps to tear. Two faces for two different kinds of work. On a single shaft.
The surface, Ashby wrote, was covered in coal dust and a thick crust of rust.
Where the crust had fallen away, there was dark, dull metal beneath. Ashby tried a magnet. It held.
Iron. Or something very close to it. He made an estimate of the weight. He worked out the
volume of the shaft, and the head, and multiplied by the density of iron. The answer, roughly twenty
thousand pounds. Ten tons. He paid particular attention to the bolts. None of the four domed
heads had a wrench flat, a corner, or a thread. The heads looked as though they had been hammered
over while they were hot. Like rivets. This head was never meant to come off. It had been fitted
once, and left that way. There was something in the pommel, too. Straight through its centre,
from one side to the other, ran a clean round hole three inches across. For a rope. A chain.
Perhaps a strap. Ashby held his lamp to the hole. It was clean. There was no coal inside it. There
was rust. But no coal. And in the corner of his first drawing, beside the tool, Ashby drew a
small human figure. For scale. Five foot eight. His own height. The figure did not reach even
halfway from the pommel to the head. The men below could see that difference, too. Tully's
entry for October twenty-three is short. Two men won't go up the north heading. The old Cornish
miners talked about the Tommyknockers, the unseen things that worked inside the mountain,
and left their tools behind. The Slovenes crossed themselves. Kostelich kept going, every morning,
during the measurements he held the lamp. And then came what may be the quietest,
and most important detail in this story. On October twenty-five, Tully tried to move it,
with twelve men, a mule, and two jacks. They wanted to free the butt-end, the pommel,
from the coal completely. The jack handles bent. The mule pulled. The tool slid three feet. And
when the pommel came out of the coal, it left a hollow behind. The coal held the shape of the
A mould. Even the fine grooves on the collar showed in the face of the coal. An engineer
knows what that means. If an object had entered the coal later, through a crack, through a hole,
the coal would not have taken its shape. The coal would already have been hard. A mould like that
forms only when the object is already there, while the material that will become coal is still soft,
and is pressed around it. Ashby drew the mould. It was his fourth and last drawing.
The same day, another problem appeared. The heading was six feet high. The head of the tool,
from horn-tip to horn-tip, was seven feet nine. It could not come out of the mountain,
not without widening the heading, cutting the roof, and rebuilding the tramway. Weeks of work.
And in the autumn of 1893, no manager at CF&I wanted to spend weeks of money on a heading
that produced no coal. On the evening of October 25, the superintendent, H. C. Wheeler, stopped
the work. Here, we have to be fair. There is no need to look for a mystery behind that decision.
In Colorado, in 1893, a mine superintendent's job was coal. The state's economy was falling apart.
Miners were waiting for work. The anthracite mine was already working a thin seam,
in hard conditions, on a narrow margin. And throughout history, most of the strange
things found in mines have turned out, in the end, to have ordinary explanations.
Tools abandoned from older workings. Machine parts buried under an old roof fall.
Mineral nodules, iron sulfide and the like, that really did form inside the coal,
and happened to look as if hands had shaped them. Stories that grew among miners and leaked into
the papers. The anthracite mine had been working for 11 years. In that time, a great many things
could have been lost underground. A great many things could have been buried. That explanation
may be right, but it does not explain this. Since 1882, everyone who opened and worked
the anthracite mine had mapped every entry and every heading inside that mountain.
In October of 1893, the north heading was advancing into fresh coal that no one had ever entered.
There were no old workings there. There was no roof fall. There was no abandoned machinery.
Nobody leaves a 10-ton, 17-foot, double-crescent iron tool, sharpened and toothed, lying forgotten
in a heading. And no mineral nodule carries 13 even teeth, four domed bolts and the marks of
a whetstone. There was one more reason, and it was not a sinister one. Word of a huge iron relic
in the anthracite mine would have brought the curious up the mountain. Reporters. Collectors.
Men who had never been underground, wanting to walk 1,100 feet into a working with open lamps.
Crested Butte had buried 59 men from Jokerville only nine years before. No superintendent in
that valley wanted visitors in his headings. For a coal company, Wheeler's decision was the right
one, but it did not answer the question. It only put it off. Ashby did not want to put it off.
Six days later, on Tuesday, October 31, 1893, he sat down at his desk and wrote a letter to Denver.
We will come back to who that letter went to, and what happened to it when it arrived.
Because first, we need to hear from this mountain's other witnesses,
the ones who never saw the tool at all. The third record is not a measurement,
it is not a drawing made by lamplight, it is a voice. It begins in Utah, 300 miles west of Crested
Butte. Forty-three years later, in the summer of 1936, a 36-year-old anthropologist from Yale,
Anne M. Smith, came to the Uintah and Oray Reservation in northeastern Utah. She was a
student of Edward Sapir. She was writing her thesis on the material culture of the northern
Ute—in other words, on tools, arrow points, scrapers, hide knives, baskets, grinding stones,
everything the Ute made and used with their own hands. That summer, and the next, Smith sat with
the oldest people on the reservation, Uintah Ute, White River Ute, and Uncompahgre, the ones
who had been marched here from Colorado in 1881, and their children. They were the last generation
who remembered Colorado. Smith's notebooks are held today in Salt Lake City, in the special
collections of the University of Utah's J. Willard Marriott Library. Her papers run from 1936 to 1980,
and in one of those notebooks is a page that has never been published. It is dated Tuesday, July
21, 1936. The name of the man speaking on that page is written in the notebook, but we will call
him, as Smith often did in her own notes, only by his role—an Uncompahgre elder, 78 years old,
living in a small house near Randlett, born in the Gunnison country,
23 years old in 1881, when the march began. His interpreter was his granddaughter, a young woman
who taught at the school in Randlett. Smith's first notes from that day are not about tools,
they are about the march. The old man described September of 1881 how the soldiers closed around
the camps in the Uncompahgre Valley, how horses, blankets, and lodge poles were loaded onto wagons,
the days of walking west, down the Gunnison, across the Grand River, into the dry flats of Utah.
The old people who died on the way, the graves left behind. And one detail. On the first morning
of the march, his grandfather turned to the northeast, toward the shadow of the Elk Mountains,
and looked for a long time. Then he said something. Fifty-five years later, the old man still remembered
the sentence. His granddaughter put it into English like this. Now nobody will be there to
leave it alone. Smith wrote the sentence down, but she did not ask then what it meant. Its meaning
would reveal itself further down the same page. That day, Smith asked him what she asked the elders
every day. What tools did your people use? What did you scrape with? What did you cut with?
The old man began with ordinary things. Scrapers of elk antler. Stone knives. Bone auls. Smith wrote
them all down. Then he was quiet for a while, and, according to Smith's notebook, he said to his
granddaughter, I have to tell about the other thing. What he told is in the notebook, in quotation marks,
in his granddaughter's English. His grandfather had told him something he had heard from his own
grandfather. In the Elk Mountains, north of the place where two streams meet, there was a slope
where the black stone comes out of the mountain. The ute knew that black stone. In some places,
it burned on its own. The tabaguach did not camp there. Hunters slowed down as they passed beneath
that slope, and went by without a word. Because inside that mountain, there was a tool. His
grandfather told it this way, and the old man said it, Smith wrote, slowly and evenly, as if reading
from a list. There was another world before this one, they said. In that world, there were others
who worked the ground, they said, before people, bigger than people. When the sun came too close,
that world burned, they said. Before it burned, the ones who worked the ground laid their tools
inside the mountain, they said. They did not lose them, they laid them down. They put them to sleep,
and the black stone grew over them, the way skin grows over a wound, they said.
Here Smith asked the granddaughter a question. What did the tool look like? The old man raised
both hands. He held them with the palms turned outward and the fingers curled. Then he brought
them together until the backs of his hands touched. Two moons, he said, back to back.
One is big, it cuts. One is small, it bites. The small one has teeth, he said,
and he counted them. First he opened the fingers of one hand, then the fingers of the other,
then three fingers more. Two hands of fingers, and three more. Thirteen. Smith wrote it as a
number beside the words. Thirteen, and underlined it. The handle, the old man said, was too thick
for a man to put his arms around. At its end was a round head, and through that head ran a hole,
the hole for the rope that pulled it. In the margin of the notebook Smith made a small drawing,
in pencil, quickly, perhaps a little uncertainly, a stick, at one end two crescents, back to back,
the smaller one edged with short dense strokes, at the other end a circle with a dot in it.
Then she asked the granddaughter whether the tool had a name in the Ute language.
It did. According to Smith's page, the granddaughter first said the name in her own language,
then put it into English. Smith tried to write down the Ute word, crossed it out, wrote it again,
and crossed it out once more. But the translation is clear. The moon with teeth. The old man was
careful to say that the tool did not belong to the Ute. The Ute had not made it. The Ute had not
used it. The Ute only knew that it was there, and knew to leave that place alone. Last of all,
he said this, and Smith wrote it at the very bottom of the page, on its own. It is not lost.
It was put to sleep. The miners woke it. Smith meant to go back to him. In the summer of 1937
she returned to the reservation for a second season, and her notebook from that year has a
short entry near the front. The old man from Randlett had died in February. Smith finished
her thesis at Yale that same year. Its title was The Material Culture of the Northern Ute.
Its pages list scrapers, awls, cradleboards and hide knives. The moon with teeth is not among them.
She did not record the cause. She did not record whether anyone else in the family had heard the
story. Smith never published that page. There is no trace of the conversation in her Ethnography
of the Northern Utes, printed in 1974. The reason is probably simple and honest. The old
man himself had said that the tool was not part of Ute material culture. Smith's subject was Ute
tools. This was not a Ute tool. In the margin, in her own hand, she added a short note.
Not Ute. Mine story? That question matters. We will come back to it. But first, let us lay the
pages side by side. On one side, a tool drawn by lamplight in October of 1893 by a mining engineer,
six hundred feet inside a mountain in Colorado, seventeen feet, eight inches long, a shaft five
feet, four inches around, a round pommel at the butt, a three-inch hole straight through the
pommel, a square plate. In front of the plate, a great crescent, smooth and sharpened. Behind it,
a tooth crescent two-thirds its size, thirteen teeth. On the other side, a tool drawn in July
of 1936, in Utah, in a hot room, by an anthropologist who had never seen the mine,
from the words of a man who had never seen the tool. Two moons, back to back, one big, it cuts,
one small, it bites, two hands of fingers and three more, a handle no man can put his arms around,
a round head at the end, a hole through the head. Ashby's field book had sat in Colorado since 1893
inside a company's papers. It was never published, it was never given to any newspaper.
Smith's notebook had sat in Utah since 1936. That page was never published either. Between the two
records lie three hundred miles, forty-three years and a state line. Ashby knew nothing of
Ute language. The old man knew nothing of an engineer's field book. Smith had never heard
the name Ashby. And the two drawings show the same tool, with the same number of teeth.
Remember Tully's note of October 17, iron in the coal, not ours. Remember the old man's words,
the Ute did not make it. Both records say the same thing. The tool did not belong to the people who
found it. It did not belong to the people who knew about it either. And both of them, each in
its own language, leave the same question open. Then whose was it? When Castellic's pick touched
the crust of that shaft on the afternoon of October 17, was he breaking seventy million
years of silence inside the mountain, or, as the old man said, was he waking something?
None of the records answers that. But the records do not end here. Because twenty-six years later,
someone else went down into the heading Wheeler had sealed, and that day, beside the tool,
he found something no one had seen in 1893. The fourth record is not a rumour, and it is not a
memory. It is a second set of measurements, and it belongs to the summer of 1919. By then,
the anthracite mine had been closed for eleven years. CF&I took out its last coal in 1907,
and abandoned the mine in 1908. The tram rails were pulled up, the breaker was torn down,
the company store was emptied. On the mountainside there was nothing left but the portal,
rotting timbers, and a scar running down the slope at forty-five degrees.
In 1912, for the U.S. Geological Survey, Willis T., Lee had published a bulletin of 237 pages on
the coal fields of the Grand Mesa and the West Elk Mountains. Bulletin 510,
The Anthracite Mine, appears in it. Briefly, as an abandoned anthracite working,
the north heading is not mentioned. But a story can outlast paper.
In 1919, Everett J. Sayre was 26 years old. He was born in Boulder, and had studied geology at
the University of Colorado. That summer he was working for the Colorado Geological Survey,
under the state geologist R.D. George, on a small field party, remeasuring the coal seams
of Gunnison County. In Crested Butte, in the hall of the Slovene Benefit Society,
someone told him about the Iron Crescent at Anthracite. It seemed that everyone in town
knew the story, but for 26 years no one had gone down into that heading. One of the men who told
it was Tomasz Kastelic. He was now fifty-five. Tuesday, August 12, 1919. Sayre, Kastelic,
and two young miners from Crested Butte went in at the Anthracite portal with carbide lamps.
In places the roof had come down. The way to the second level was half-caved. It took them four
hours to reach the north heading. On the last stretch there was black damp in the air, carbon
dioxide, no smell. It takes the oxygen out of a working. The flames of the carbide lamps shrank
and turned yellow. One of the young miners turned back. Kastelic, walking ahead of Sayre,
kept going, his eyes on the flame. At the mouth of the heading, the timber and stone stopping that
Wheeler had ordered built on November 4, 1893, was still standing. For an hour, the four men
worked the top of it loose. The first sentence in Sayre's field book reads, It is here. The tool lay
where it had been left in 1893, the pommel three feet from the hollow it had been pulled out of,
the head still inside the seam, the crust of rust was thicker, the coal still held the mould the
pommel had left behind. Sayre took the measurements again. He took them without ever having seen
Ashby's figures. At that time Ashby's field book was somewhere in C.F. and I's papers,
and Sayre did not know it existed. Overall length, 17 feet 9 inches. Circumference of the shaft,
5 feet 4 1⁄2 inches. Teeth on the rear crescent, 13. Differences of half an inch, exactly the
difference to be expected between two men, with two different tapes, 26 years apart,
measuring over the same crust of rust. Sayre looked into the hole through the pommel,
three inches, clean edged. After 26 years in the dust of a sealed heading, with every surface
around it coated in coal dust, the inside of the hole was still clean. Sayre noted it,
he did not try to explain it. Kastelic, meanwhile, stood by the shaft. According to Sayre's notes,
he pulled off his glove, laid his bare hand on the rust, and said something short in Slovene.
Sayre did not ask what, in his book he wrote only, T.K. spoke to it. But Sayre's day did not
end there. Behind the head, in the part of the seam that had never been mined in 1893,
the coal face was still standing. Sayre held his lamp to it, and in the coal he saw parallel
grooves running away from the back of the head. The grooves came in groups, 13 grooves to a group,
evenly spaced. Sayre measured the spacing, 5 1⁄8 inches. He measured the spacing between the teeth
of the rear crescent, 5 1⁄8 inches. The grooves were inside the bands of the coal. The coal had
formed over them, which means that toothed edge had passed through the material of this seam
while it was still soft. Not once. Sayre counted four separate sets, each one a little farther on
than the last. Someone had already been there. Someone had worked this seam long before anyone
had a word for coal. Sayre cut out a block of coal carrying part of the grooves, labeled it,
and took it back to Boulder. Specimen number 1919-47. And that day, in his field book, he added
just one opinion. It was used here. In September, Sayre turned his report in to the state geologist.
It listed the thickness, the quality, and the economic value of the Gunnison coals. At the
very end, under the heading Other Observations, half a page, iron object, dimensions, grooves,
Specimen 1919-47. The report was never printed. In those years, on a tight budget, the survey could
publish only findings of economic importance. In the margin, someone had written two words in pencil,
no economic value. Sayre left the survey in 1921 for the oil fields of Wyoming and spent the rest
of his working life there. He did not write about anthracite again. His report, with its half page,
went into the survey's files. When the Colorado Geological Survey moved to the Colorado School
of Mines in Golden in 2013, the files went with it. There is a record showing that Specimen 1919-47
entered the collections at Boulder. There is no record of it ever leaving. It is not on the shelf
where it should be today. Nobody hid it. Nobody destroyed it. The next person simply never went
looking for it. The fifth record takes us out of this mountain, because this tool was not the only
thing ever found inside coal, and the Ute were not the only people who remembered a time when the sun
burned and a world ended. Two years before anthracite, in June of 1891, in the town of
Morrisonville, Illinois, a woman named Mrs. S. W. Culp broke up a lump of coal for her stove.
Out of it came a gold chain, ten inches long, finely made, with both ends still set in the coal.
The local paper printed the story on June 11th. The chain passed down through the family,
and then its trail was lost. Nineteen years after anthracite, in 1912, in Thomas, Oklahoma,
a worker at the municipal power plant broke apart a large lump of coal bound for the boiler.
An iron pot dropped out of it, a clear rim, a clear base, and in both halves of the coal a perfect
mould of the pot's outer surface remained. The coal had come from the mines at Wilberton,
a mould, like the one the pommel left at anthracite. In the same era, among the Ute's
western neighbours, the southern Paiute, John Wesley Powell recorded a story in 1873,
the story of Tarv Watts, the little rabbit. The sun came too close to him and burned his back.
Tarv Watts went after the sun, struck it, and broke it to pieces. The pieces fell and the world
burned. Powell published it in the first annual report of the Bureau of Ethnology, printed in 1881.
In 1936 and 1937, Ann Smith recorded the White River Ute's own version of the same story,
Cottontail Shoots the Sun. It was printed in 1992, eleven years after her death, in the book
Ute Tales. The sun comes too close, the world burns, and before it there was another world,
the same skeleton as the sentence the uncompagre elder heard from his grandfather.
And that skeleton reaches beyond North America. On December 17th, 1790, in the Zocalo,
the great square of Mexico City, workers relaying the paving found a carved stone disc beneath the
ground, about 12 feet across and weighing some 24 tons. Today it is called the Sun Stone.
The four panels around the face at its centre show, in the Aztec account, the four worlds,
the four suns, that came before this one. Each one ended in catastrophe, one by jaguars,
one by wind, one by a rain of fire, one by flood. Ours is the fifth. The idea that one world ends,
and the next begins on top of what remains of the last. 1500 miles south of Ute country,
with no connection to them, carved in stone. The crescent itself does not belong to the Ute
alone either. In 1999, on the Mittelberg Hill in the German state of Saxony-Anhalt,
illegal treasure hunters dug up a bronze disc about a foot across, the Nebra Sky Disc,
some 3,600 years old. On it, in gold, a sun or a full moon, stars, and a thick, deep crescent.
Whoever made it thought that shape in the sky was important enough to set in metal.
The sixth record is the last, and perhaps the heaviest, because this record tells us where the
First, let us follow Ashby's letter. The man he wrote to in Denver on October 31st,
1893, was Samuel Franklin Emmons, head of the Rocky Mountain Division of the U.S. Geological
Survey, founding president of the Colorado Scientific Society, and, at that very moment,
one of the three authors of the Geological Atlas of the Anthracite and Crested Butte District.
The Atlas came out a year later, in 1894, as Folio 9, the Anthracite-Crested Butte Folio.
It describes the anthracite, the lacoliths, and the elk mountains in detail. It says nothing about
an iron tool. But in the minutes of the Colorado Scientific Society's meeting of December 1893,
there is a single line. In the list of communications presented that evening,
an iron object in the anthracite coal, Gunnison County, W. H. Ashby, read by title.
Only the title was read. No discussion is recorded. No paper followed in the next volume.
At the bottom of the eleventh page of Ashby's field book, in a different ink,
two words were added later. The date, March 3rd, 1894. No reply. Ashby left CF&I in 1897,
opened his own engineering office in Denver, and died in 1931. His obituary in the Denver
Papers lists his career, his mines, his bridges. It does not mention anthracite. The letter itself
has never been found among Emmons' papers. Emmons died in 1911. The survey's Denver files
were shipped to Washington. Somewhere along the way, the letter was lost.
Ashby's field book, on the other hand, was never lost. It was only filed in the wrong place.
CF&I's archive is kept today in Pueblo, at the Steelworks Center of the West. Six thousand
cubic feet of records. The papers of more than sixty mines. Over thirty thousand maps and
drawings. Thousands of ledgers. And even now, much of the collection has only been processed
at the level of the box. In 2009, a man retired from the Pueblo steel mill, volunteering at the
archive, began opening the boxes from the anthracite mine, one at a time, and listing
what was inside. We will call him only by his role. The list he left survives today as one line
in the archive's finding aid. Field notes, WH Ashby, October 1, 1893, include sketches of
unidentified iron object. Ashby's eleven pages and four drawings were in one of those boxes,
in a folder labelled, Anthracite, Ventilation, 1893. Ventilation, among exactly the kind of notes
an engineer kept most, that year, at that mine. The last record dates from 1986. That year,
Colorado's Inactive Mine Reclamation Program sent a crew to close the old portal on Anthracite Mesa.
Since 1980, the program had been backfilling, fencing and sealing dangerous old mine openings
across the state. Before sealing the portal, as standard procedure required, the crew made
an inspection walk inside. The inspection form is in the state's files. Under Observations typed,
a single paragraph, Level 2 North Heading, Partial Collapse at Entry, Beyond Collapse,
Large Iron Object, Approximately 18 Feet, Partially Embedded in Coal Face, Condition
Stable, Left in Place, Left in Place. At the bottom of the form are the crew chief's initials
and a date, and in the lower right corner, a pre-printed box, Photographs Attached. The box
is checked. There are no photographs in the file. Three weeks later, the portal of the Anthracite
mine was filled with rubble and concrete. None of this is proof, not the field book, not the notebook,
not the form. There is a version of this story in which everything resolves into comfortable
categories, and that version deserves to be heard at its strongest. First, mining camps make stories.
In the Colorado camps of the 19th century, the Cornishman's Tommyknockers, the Irishman's Ghosts
and the Slovene's Mountain Spirits were told again on every shift. An odd piece of iron found
in a heading can grow into a ten-ton legend in a few years. Tully's pit book no longer exists.
We know the three lines quoted from it only because Ashby copied them onto the second page
of his own field book. The pit boss's voice reaches us only through the engineer's pencil.
Second, machinery lost underground. In the 1890s, Colorado mines used coal-cutting machines,
pumps, hoist parts and cast-iron wheels. Some were buried under roof falls, some were simply
abandoned. A rusted piece of machinery, caked in coal dust, can look to tired eyes, in lamplight,
like something none of them recognize. Third, the coal itself. Geologists know that under the weight
of hundreds of feet of rock, over very long spans of time, coal can creep. It can squeeze and bend
around a hard object inside it. Coal wrapping around an object does not, on its own, prove the
object is older than the coal. And the grooves have a natural explanation, too. Slickensides.
Where rock surfaces grind past each other along a fault, they can leave parallel regular scratches
in coal as well. They are common in Colorado's folded coal fields.
Fourth, and perhaps most serious, is Anne Smith's own question. Not Ute, mine story.
After the 1890s, some of Crested Butte's Slovene and Croatian miners moved on to the coal camps
of Utah. Carbon County. Castle Gate. Sunnyside. Those camps were only a few days' travel from
the Uinta and Ore reservation. Over forty-three years, a miner's story could pass from mouth to
home and be remembered there as a grandfather's words.
And fifth, we do not have the tool. We do not have a photograph. We do not have Specimen 1919-47.
We do not have the photographs attached in 1986. Every piece of this story stands on paper.
Each of these explanations is reasonable. Several of them together may even be true.
But they do not explain why Ashby, a mining engineer born in Pottsville
who had known anthracite since childhood, underlined the words,
the coal formed around it. They do not explain why Sayre, who never saw Ashby's figures,
came within half an inch of every one of them. Why the spacing of the grooves matched the spacing
of the teeth. Or why the old man's grandfather, on the first morning of the march, before the
mine had even opened, looked back at the Elk Mountains and said, now nobody will be there
to leave it alone. No institution suppressed these questions. No one in this story acted in
bad faith. Wheeler had coal to mine. Emmons had an atlas to finish. The state geologist had to
spend his budget on economic findings. Smith had a thesis to write on ute tools. The reclamation
crew had a portal to seal. None of them did anything wrong. None of them followed up.
That is not the weakness in this story. It is the story. Anthracite Mesa today is not a ruin,
and it is not a monument. It is a quiet, wooded rise inside the Gunnison National Forest,
within walking distance of Crested Butte. In summer, mountain bikers ride down the trails
on its flanks. In winter, snowmobiles cross its flats. For anyone who looks carefully,
the line of the old 45-degree tramway still shows among the trees,
straight as a ruler. The portal has been full of rubble and concrete since 1986.
Opening it again would take permits from both the Forest Service and the state's Mine Safety Agency.
According to the records, no one has applied for one since.
West of town stands Mount Emmons. The locals call it the Red Lady. For nearly fifty years,
the people of Crested Butte fought to keep a molybdenum mine out of that mountain.
In 2024, a land exchange closed off its mining claims for good. The town celebrated keeping
the inside of a mountain shut. A few miles to the north, the inside of another mountain is
shut as well. No one celebrates it. Almost no one knows. On Elk Avenue, Crested Butte's main street,
the town's Mountain Heritage Museum, tells the story of the Jokerville explosion,
the Slovene Benefit Societies, and daily life in the coal camps.
There is no case that mentions the north heading at anthracite.
Tomas Kastelic died in 1937, at 73. He lies in the town cemetery, under a stone inscribed
in Slovene. In the top corner of the stone, a small pick is carved, a mark often found
on miners' graves of that time. After 1893, Kastelic went on working at anthracite until
the mine closed. Apart from what he told Sayer, he left no record of the north heading.
Ashby's field book is in Pueblo, in a reading room opened by appointment. Anne Smith's page
is in Salt Lake City, in a special collections box. Sayer's report is in Golden. The Colorado
Scientific Society's minutes are in Boulder. The 1986 form is in the state's files.
Five records, four cities. Two states, not one of them refers to another. And the descendants
of the Uncompahgre live today in Utah, as part of the Ute Indian tribe of the Uinta and Ouray
Reservation, headquartered at Fort Duchesne, on a reservation of more than four million acres,
the second largest in the United States. Every spring, when the bears are said to wake,
the bear dance is still held, as it was in the Gunnison country before 1881. The mountains
their grandparents left on foot are six hours away by car. In the autumn of 1893, Tomáš Kastelic's
pick came down into the coal, and it was not coal that rang. It was iron. More than 130 years later,
that iron is still there. Ashby gave it a measurement. 17 feet, 8 inches. Sayer gave
it evidence. Sets of 13 grooves, 5 and 1 eighth inches apart. The reclamation crew gave it a
condition. Stable. And an Uncompahgre elder gave it a name. The moon with teeth. None of them gave
it an answer. A tool is made to be used. And the grooves Sayer found in the coal say this tool was
used inside that mountain. Not once. Four times. Each time a little farther on. If you know the
stories of the coal camps of Crested Butte, of Gunnison, or of Utah, if someone in your family
once worked at Anthracite, or if you have heard a Ute elder speak of something sleeping inside a
mountain, tell it in the comments. Half the records of this story still live in the memory of people
alive today. And one question remains. The old man said the tool was not lost. It was put to sleep.
Who would want to wake something that was put to sleep, and why?