The Monty Show: Charlie Brewer Quits Utah Utes Football - Is Cam Rising the Answer?
Sep 30, 2026
The Utah youths are in shambles and this continues.
The only word that I can keep using is shocking.
Yeah.
This continues to be shocking
that Kyle Whittingham football teams
losing their starting quarterback,
Cam Rising wins the job.
No doubt about it.
We saw it against San Diego State.
Cam Rising is your best quarterback.
Well, Charlie Brewer doesn't agree
and Charlie Brewer quit.
And Jake, I guess the question is,
is Charlie Brewer a quitter
or is there massive dysfunction up on the hill?
No, so to me, I think it's definitely a combination of both
but I think it skews more towards Charlie Brewer
being a quitter.
And I don't like to say that about athletes.
I very rarely say it.
But at the end of the day, what have we seen?
We saw Charlie Brewer come to Utah from Baylor.
The Baylor situation was basically the same thing.
He couldn't win the starting job.
He was on the bench and he decided he wanted to transfer
because he felt like he could start at Utah.
So then you go through training camp
or whatever you wanna call it in college football.
You work up to everything and he's named the starter.
He comes out and they're off to a rough start.
And I'm tired of hearing people say that BYU did this.
BYU had nothing to do with this.
This is not a BYU thing.
They should not be included in this conversation.
San Diego State did this.
The performance that Charlie Brewer rolled out there
against San Diego State is why this happened.
It is a combination of a couple of things.
Number one, in terms of Charlie Brewer's accountability,
he does not have a strong enough arm
to play big time college football.
It's just that simple.
Yesterday, I was tweeting with some people and I said,
when your arm is weak, when you do not have a strong arm,
you have to compensate that in other areas of your game.
Pre-snap read.
You gotta understand what the defense is doing to you
and where the football naturally should go
based on what the defense is trying to do to you.
That's number one.
Number two, you gotta understand that the offensive line
you're playing behind at Utah is not very good right now,
which is why I say it's a little bit of Utah,
but mostly Charlie Brewer.
This offensive line is a problem,
which is why we've seen changes now on the offensive line.
So that's number two.
And then number three, mentally,
I can't get down with Charlie Brewer and what he's doing.
I can't get down with it.
I can't get down with the mentality that,
hey, I'm gonna transfer around
from school to school to school
until I find a nice landing spot
where I'm gonna be able to start no matter what.
That's not how sports work.
You don't get participation trophies in major D1,
you know, power five conference college football.
That's not how it works.
So when I saw, oh my God, Charlie Brewer left Utah,
I wasn't like, oh man,
Kyle Whittingham's program is burning to the ground.
No, what I saw is, hey,
Kyle Whittingham made the pragmatic decision last week
against San Diego State and brought Cam Rising in,
and Charlie Brewer couldn't handle that mentally.
And so he was like, all right, I'm gonna transfer,
and I'm gonna go and find another spot
where I can get another chance.
And I'm telling you right now,
when you transfer from program to program to program,
number one, guys don't respect you.
Number two, coaches don't respect you.
So wait, wait, wait, wait, wait.
You're putting this 100% on Charlie Brewer.
Yeah, 100%.
Wow, I don't think anything's ever that black and white.
I think that Charlie Brewer very clearly has issues,
and I think you're probably right,
there's frustration on Charlie Brewer's part
that he got beat by Cam Rising here,
because Charlie Brewer left that game,
and all of a sudden we were in overtime.
And a lot of that is on Cam Rising.
But I think it's awfully difficult for me anyways
to look at what is going on at Utah football.
And before we knew that Charlie Brewer quit yesterday,
I think we were on this show yesterday morning saying,
hey, there's a problem at Utah.
There are significant issues.
There are significant chemistry problems.
This is atypical of Kyle Whittingham football programs.
And then all of a sudden, the bombshell drops
that Charlie Brewer has quit the program
and essentially has said, I don't wanna be here anymore
after three games.
I have trouble believing that a kid
who competed at the highest levels at Baylor
and did pretty darn well, by the way,
all of a sudden just flipped the script, Jake,
and quit and said, nah, I give up, I'm out.
Well, here's why I think that is the case.
I think that's the case because if we,
whose side are we gonna take?
Are we gonna take, how long has Whittingham at Utah now?
What has it been, like 10 plus years now?
Oh, way more than that, yeah.
Way more than that.
So like, typically the issue at Utah
is you don't have quarterback talent.
You don't have anybody back there.
Travis Wilson, like all these people
who have come in and played the position at Utah
have been mediocre and not gotten the job done.
The problem is is that's been okay at Utah
because Utah's a defensive school.
Utah's a handed off to the running back school, right?
So this time around, when I see a guy in Charlie Brewer
who was hyped, and I love Charlie Brewer,
admittedly, I've been on the show saying,
hey, this guy, like I thought he had a much better arm
than he did, mainly because he made some throws early
in the year that I was like, yeah, this guy's got an arm.
This guy can get the job done.
And all of a sudden, you roll out against San Diego State
and all of your throws are like three, four yards short.
All of your throws are just well under thrown.
Like, how does that work?
Now, I understand that the offensive line has not been good.
I 100% agree with that.
And that definitely contributed to Charlie Brewer's
departure from this program.
There's no question about that,
but I'm just a firm believer,
whether it's at the pro level or in college football,
as a quarterback, you are a leader of the football team.
It's not good enough to go out there and not play well
because, well, my offensive line sucks
or this or that, my arm hurts.
It's not good enough.
You're a leader on this team.
You're the starting quarterback at Utah.
The mentality has to be, yeah,
is my offensive line not the best?
Absolutely, it's not the best.
It's not the best.
I'm gonna be running around.
That's part of the gig here.
I get it.
Secondly, hey, I don't have the strongest arm
in all of college football.
I have a below average arm.
That doesn't mean I'm a bad quarterback.
But what it does mean is that I have to be on point
with understanding what the defense is doing to me
and what I'm trying to do on any given play.
Am I throwing the ball into the flat?
Let me lead my receiver.
Am I throwing, am I on the right hash
trying to throw to the left sideline?
Well, look, I don't think anybody's arguing
that Charlie Brewer has a noodle.
I don't think anybody's arguing that.
Like his arm strength was a question
before he ever left Waco.
And I think once he was a Ute, I think we saw that.
But there are ways to compensate for that.
Are we really just going to overlook the issues
on the offensive line?
Are we really going to just overlook the issues
of a straight up lack of talent in the wide receiver room?
I don't think you can do that.
And I think the issue is that you have a guy
in Charlie Brewer who's used to winning
at a very high level.
And when you bring a guy like that in
and all of a sudden he's not winning,
that's a hell of a transition for him to make.
It is very difficult to say to a kid
who's used to dominating on the football field,
yeah, you're gonna be mediocre
and we're gonna take your job from you
and now we expect you to support Cam Rising.
That's a lot for a kid who's probably never failed
in his football career to do.
So did Charlie Brewer handle this well?
Well, very clearly not.
He quit the football team yesterday
or whenever that happened.
But I think we have significant issues
at the University of Utah and I don't know
what it's gonna take to fix those issues.
My guess is winning is what it's going to take
because I hope you kick the crap
out of Washington State this weekend.
Nick unvaccinated Rolevich and his Cougars
coming to town, good luck with that.
And in my opinion, this is the make or break game
because if you go one and three,
now it's almost a foregone conclusion
that Kyle Whittingham's on a farewell tour
because that's the other 10,000 pound gorilla
in the room that nobody's talking about
is that we continue to hear whispers and rumors
that this is it for Kyle Whittingham at Utah.
And I'm curious how true those rumors are
because I'm telling you now,
whether you appreciate all the best
and all the worst of Kyle Whittingham,
replacing Witt is not going to be an easy task
because it's not as simple as elevating an assistant coach.
It's not as simple as going out and hiring some other guy.
This is an iconic figure.
This is a guy that will forever be
part of Utah football history in the very best of ways.
And to think that Morgan Scali's gonna get elevated
and just simply step in and replace Kyle Whittingham,
I don't think it's that simple.
And frankly, I don't know that Morgan Scali
would be the guy that they would wanna turn to
after what happened with that texting scandal.
So I think there is a lot of complex issues at play
and you better appreciate Kyle Whittingham
while he's here,
because I don't think he's gonna be here long.
Yeah, well, and I genuinely felt like
when the news came out that Charlie Brewer left
and then we heard that there were changes
on the offensive line
and there was basically a lot of change
happening in the program.
I felt like, hey, this is a great sign.
This shows me that Kyle Whittingham
is still committed to winning at the highest levels.
He changed his quarterback last week.
He had no way to know that Charlie was gonna leave.
So in my opinion, the Charlie Brewer thing
isn't even on Kyle Whittingham
or really anybody except for Charlie Brewer.
Then secondly, again, you're making changes
and holding people accountable
for their lack of performance on the line.
But I do agree with you.
It is a fair point that, hey,
when you don't have good talent in your wide receiver room
and you don't have good talent at the skill position,
that's not helping your case.
So obviously for accountability purposes,
yeah, Kyle hasn't done a great job recruiting
for this year's team.
So they're just in an interesting time.
If they go to one and three, yeah.
Is he on the hot seat?
Absolutely.
But based on his actions and his choices
and what's going down in the program right now,
I don't think that the guy wants to retire.
I don't think that he's done coaching football yet.
I think that he is putting fires out.
I think that he is making changes
to up the level of this team.
And that's all you can ask your head coach to do.
And the question that I think you have to answer now
is what's wrong with QBs at Utah?
Because you have a situation with Jake Bentley.
Jake Bentley's a guy, and I'll look up his numbers,
but Jake Bentley's another interesting guy.
Jake Bentley, come on, sorry.
Of course, when I need it to be fast, it's not.
Jake Bentley threw for 3,000 yards,
27 touchdowns in a season, and that's in the SEC.
He comes to Utah and is an absolute bust.
You look at Charlie Brewer.
What does a guy have, 50, 60 touchdowns
in 9,000 yards at Baylor, and all of a sudden,
the guy can't play football anymore at Utah?
You know, I think what's interesting to me
is that if you are not in the program at Utah,
transferring into the Utes to be their starting quarterback
is probably not what's best for your career.
I don't know, is that a system thing?
Clearly it is, because again, I think we all know
that BYU and every other school in the Pac-12
recruits against Utah by saying,
hey, if you wanna be a quarterback,
you're not going to Utah.
They don't throw the ball, they're a run-first team.
Look at their wide receiver production.
They don't put wide receivers in the NFL.
Yeah, I mean, for Charlie, if you look at his 2019 stats
at Baylor, the guy put out, I mean,
you're talking about playing 14 games,
251 completions on 389 attempts.
That's gonna be a 64 and a half completion percentage.
Really good, you know, 31-61 for yards,
8.1 yards per attempt, like 21 touchdowns,
seven interceptions, that's a little high,
but you know, it's doable.
So I mean, this guy can throw the football.
So yes, I agree, it does beg the question,
what's the deal with Utah and quarterback?
Because they never can seem to keep one.
They never can seem to get that dynamic talent
to put out for them in an entire season, so.
How do you throw for 3,171 yards at South Carolina
and 27 touchdowns, and then you come to Utah
and throw for 882 yards, six scores, six interceptions?
I don't know.
How does that, well, it's gotta be
a coaching and talent gap.
Well, that's definitely what it is.
How else do you explain?
It's a crappy offensive line,
it's a lack of wide receiver talent,
and those combinations paired with a weak arm are not good.
I mean, again, his arm, it would be great,
because here's the thing, when you have,
let's say he had a plus-plus arm,
like an over-the-top strong arm.
You can overcome a bad offensive line with that.
You can throw guys open with that.
You can do something to give you some options.
But when you don't have a strong arm,
when you can't power the ball down the field
or into tight windows, it makes your life really difficult,
because if your guys are not getting open
and you don't have 4,340 speed outside,
you're not gonna be able to get the football to guys.
And that's why I say, I just think,
that San Diego State game, it's not even
that San Diego State is some world-beating team.
They're a great program.
They put out a tough football team every year,
but it's not like San Diego State is gonna compete
for a national championship or anything.
So when you went to San Diego State
and you got your ass kicked in the first half,
and then you roll out and you come right back
with a guy who admittedly has a pretty strong arm
and cam rising, it just, I almost feel
like Charlie was embarrassed about it.
I almost feel like Charlie took it personally
and was like, you know what, F this, F that.
I have a crappy offensive line,
nobody to throw the ball to, let me get a new start.
And my biggest thing with that mentality
is just that in sports, quitting is not an option.
When it gets hard, quitting's not an option.
That's my biggest problem with Charlie Brewer.
Yeah, and I go back to, I don't know,
Travis Wilson and Kendall Thompson.
I go back to, Travis Wilson, I think,
is the only four-year starter
in the history of Utah football.
That should tell you something.
You know, and you look at, who's the truly elite quarterback
that's come out of Utah?
I mean, Alex Smith is the guy that comes to mind.
I mean, I just don't know how you change this
with Kyle Whittingham as your head coach.
And for better or for worse, this is who it is.
My biggest concern is that there are significant issues
there, and we are watching the flaming pile of turd
that is gonna be the last season of Kyle Whittingham football.
I don't want it to end like this.
And as you can see, there's not much hope for you left.
Seriously, like I want better for, he deserves better.
He does.
But I feel like a lot of the responsibility
for this situation has to be on Kyle Whittingham.
I mean, the buck stops with wit,
and I just think that Kyle Whittingham
has never valued offense as much as he's valued defense.
He never has, he never will.
And I think that this is where it comes back to get you.
Because I think when you look around the Pac-12,
man, it's not going to be easy to replace him.
It isn't.
And I think it's very difficult to win in this league
just based on the built-in circumstances.
And then trying to recruit to Utah
is not the easiest thing in the world to do.
And trying to change the face of Utah football
and the reputation with high school coaches
is not going to be the easiest thing to do.
I mean, it's going to be an interesting five months.
It is going to be an interesting five months.
I mean, when we get to spring football,
is Kyle Whittingham still the head coach at Utah?
Yeah, and if he's not,
is Utah still a respectable program?
You know, is Utah still a program that you're like,
yeah, this team could win the Pac-12?
You can't answer that question until you know.
You know what?
Maybe I'm a masochist, I don't know.
But yeah, I think they can still win the conference.
I do.
I think they can still win the conference.
I just mean that it's like they move on from Witt
and you have all that change and everything like that.
No, you're going to have a three-year fall-off,
would be my guess.
Because Kyle Whittingham and his coaching staff,
they have a pipeline in place.
You know, like, and that's the,
this is the who replaces Kyle Whittingham conversation
that I don't think is justified or fair
and we probably shouldn't have it.
But if you go outside the program,
are you going to get a,
compare the Utah job to the SC job.
You're not even in the same conversation as USC.
You're probably going to get either Morgan Scali
or a premier assistant from around football.
But you're not calling Josh McDaniels.
You're not calling James Franklin.
You're not calling Urban Meyer.
I mean, those guys are not,
those guys are not coming home.
You know, like there was some talk on Twitter yesterday
about offer Urban the job, he'll come home.
Stop.
Like, is Urban Meyer leaving the NFL?
Are you kidding me?
Come on, guy.
For what has been a lower tier Pac-12 team,
I don't think he is.
Sorry, man.
Like, I don't know where Utah goes.
I don't know, let's see.
Let's get some of your comments
because there's a lot of them here.
Utah is just fine.
Y'all worry too much, Taylor Kearney says.
Well, we'll see.
We'll see about that.
I mean, the truth of the matter is,
in all reality right here today,
that they're at a crossroads.
They're at a fork in the road,
which is, hey, if you go left,
you know, you're looking at a four win season,
WIC gets fired, program burns to the ground,
and you start the whole thing over.
Or, you can go right,
and you're making a bunch of changes
on your offensive line.
The offensive line play picks up.
Cam Rising is a, by the way,
it should be said, Cam Rising is a teammate favorite
on that team.
Like, Covey loves him.
You know, Keithie loves him.
Like, there are a lot of guys on that team.
Yeah, I don't think there's any doubt, yeah.
That really respect him.
And so, I think from a camaraderie standpoint
and a culture standpoint,
having Cam back there is definitely gonna be
an upgrade mentally.
And so, you know, if you go right,
as opposed to going left,
you have an opportunity to still go out
and win the South.
There's no question about that,
but that starts this week.
Like, there is no more room for a crappy quarter
or a crappy half, not executing to end a half.
Like, you can't keep making these mistakes.
This team has to come together.
So, when you say, hey, you worry too much,
no, I don't worry too much.
I'm looking at this situation,
and I'm saying, hey, there's a lot of smoke here,
and that flame's about to get lit
if they lose to Washington State.
You know what I worry about?
What happens if Cam Rising gets hurt.
Because, with all due respect,
Jaquindon Jackson is a freshman,
and if Jaquindon Jackson is taking snaps for Utah,
you're screwed.
I mean.
I'm screwed.
Yeah, I mean, you're in trouble.
But that's the situation that you've been left with now.
I mean, if you think about that,
and so many youth fans devalued Charlie Brewer.
I'd rather have Charlie Brewer as a backup
than not have Charlie Brewer at all.
I mean, I think this is a historically dire situation
at the quarterback for Utah.
I mean, it makes, again, look at Huntley.
Look at, it makes you miss any of the guys
that you counted on, who were pretty mediocre quarterbacks,
but what do you do now?
And the answer is, I don't know,
because the depth chart at Utah
is not stocked with quarterbacks.
I can tell you that.
BYU fan CJ says, Baylor traded Brewer
in the rivalry win for Grimes.
Sorry, guys.
Wow.
I don't, again, BYU has nothing to do
with Charlie Brewer leaving.
Yeah.
Nothing.
Not a thing.
That game was lost on the line, not by the quarterback.
Cody Strickland says, will there be more to talk about
other than BYU for over an hour?
Lol, Utah State is undefeated.
Like to see some love for them, too.
Well, the fact is, is they're not relevant.
What is, what's, I mean, sure, we can talk about them.
I can do two hours on any topic you wanna talk about.
That doesn't mean we should be talking about them, though.
That's cool that they're undefeated.
How about you get into a conference
that you can actually make noise in?
Well, but, I mean, think about,
BYU has the largest fan base in the state.
Easily.
Utah has the second largest fan base in the state.
Why would I talk about Utah State
before I talk about Utah or BYU?
Like, why would I do that?
Graham Ormey says, Brewer quitting is probably
the best thing that could've happened to Utah right now.
Hope they can finally make our win
look good for the Cougs.
Well, there is that.
Spencer Morgan says, hey, Daryl says, Jake heaps anybody?
Oh my goodness, why bring up that name?
Yeah, so like you have, and that's the thing with Utah.
You have all these names, all these guys,
all these dudes who came through the program
with the exception of Alex Smith.
You have all these guys who came through the program
and have just been average.
And if you're a Utah hater,
this is what you hang your hat on.
Wit does not recruit offensive talent.

