Working with Comfrey Safely

Herb Wisdom
2 followers
1 Video View·Sep 30, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video provides an objective analysis of the safety debate surrounding comfrey. It examines the risks associated with pyrrolizidine alkaloids (PAs), which can cause severe liver damage, and evaluates how plant species, preparation methods, and individual health factors influence the safety of using comfrey for medicinal purposes.
Mention comfrey in a room full of herbalists and you'll most likely be front row seat to a heated
discussion. Everyone's got an opinion regarding the safety of comfrey and most herbalists aren't
shy about expressing it. For years I've watched the comfrey debate from afar and noted that many
people will refer to someone else when justifying their opinions. They'll say, well so-and-so says
or they'll say, well this other person says it's not safe so that must be true. While I have no
doubt the comfrey debate will continue on for a long time, I want to address this issue as
objectively as possible by looking at what evidence we have both for safety and what
evidence we have of its potential harm. My hope is that people will have a better understanding
of the complexities of this herb rather than simply relying on who says what. In the end,
my goal is that you can feel confident about using the roots and leaves safely. There are
three main considerations when looking at the safety of comfrey. Number one, the level and type
of alkaloids in the comfrey plant that you're working with. Two, the type of medicine you're
going to be making with comfrey. And three, the health of the person using the comfrey. Okay,
let's look at each one of these more in depth. The first consideration is what exactly is in
the comfrey plant that you're working with. Here's what I mean by that. Comfrey contains
pyrilozidine alkaloids or PAs for short. These pyrilozidine alkaloids are substances that we
know are potentially toxic to humans by causing liver damage. There are over 600 different PAs
that have been identified in over 6,000 plants. Many PAs are harmless, but those that are harmful
take quite a toll on the liver, causing veno-occlusive liver disease and or liver cancer.
PAs are found in the borage, aster, orchid, and pea families. The main concern regarding humans
and comfrey is veno-occlusive disease or VOD. This condition happens when the very small veins
of the liver are obstructed, preventing normal liver function and causing a backup of blood in
the liver, leading to engorgement, portal vein pressure, fluid buildup in the abdomen, enlarged
spleen and liver, scarring or cirrhosis. Symptoms occur very quickly and about one-fourth of people
diagnosed with hepatic VOD die. Here's a hard fact for you. We know without a doubt that all
species of comfrey contain varying levels of different types of PAs. The two most often used
species of comfrey are Symphytum officinale, which is a common comfrey, and Symphytum x ablandicum,
which is a hybrid. We know that in general Symphytum x ablandicum contains more PAs than
Symphytum officinale. However, because these plants can easily hybridize within the genus,
it's hard to say whether a given plant has a certain level of PAs unless that exact plant
has been tested. One set of tests done show that there were significantly lower levels of PAs in
Symphytum officinale leaves after the plant had matured and gone to flower. Studies also show that
the leaves have less PAs than the roots. Okay, to sum all this up, all comfrey plants have some
level of PAs. Those levels can differ dramatically between various plants and hybrids, the maturity
of the plant and even the plant part. The second consideration is what kind of medicine is being
prepared with the comfrey plant. When it comes to comfrey, internal medicines like teas and tinctures
are always going to carry a greater risk than using external medicines like poultices, salves,
and soaks. And I'll be showing you my favorite poultice preparation in just a bit. Teas or
water-based extractions are going to have less alkaloids in them because water is a weak extractor
of alkaloids. Tinctures or alcohol-based extractions are going to have more alkaloids because alcohol
is a stronger extractor of alkaloids. Sometimes you'll hear claims that water extractions like
teas do not contain pyralozidine alkaloids. However, in one analysis of herbal teas made
from the leaves of comfrey, Symphytum officinale, there were PAs present in the tea. If you know me
at all, then you know I love it when we can make food or medicine. Comfrey leaves are high in
vitamins, minerals, and even protein. The leaves of this plant were also once widely eaten as a
wild green food. While there is an historical tradition of eating comfrey, what we know now
about PAs makes this a bit problematic. As a rule, I avoid citing unethical animal studies in my work.
There have, unfortunately, been a number of studies of comfrey involving rats. I will not
cite them here, but only acknowledge they exist and that when you feed rats large amounts of comfrey,
like ridiculous amounts of comfrey, they will get a liver tumor. I've heard herbalists point out the
flaws of using these studies. For example, rats aren't humans, the dosage was insanely high, and then
claim that since these studies are flawed, comfrey must be safe. The reality is, even if you completely
disregard these animal studies, there is still evidence that comfrey is potentially harmful to
humans. In the same light, using only these flawed studies to proclaim that comfrey is dangerous
is also misleading. To date, there have been no human clinical trials regarding comfrey ingestion.
Since there are concerns about comfrey toxicity, you can imagine the ethical considerations a human
clinical trial would raise. Which brings us to our third consideration, the health of the person
working with comfrey. There are some people today who love comfrey, and they regularly drink the tea
seemingly without issues. Before the potential for toxicity was known, comfrey root was used
internally for many hot conditions, such as dry, irritated lungs. It was also used for internal
bleeding of the lungs and digestive tract, such as ulcers and hemorrhoids. There are also some cautious
human case studies regarding comfrey consumption. In all of these case studies, comfrey does appear
to have caused problems, but there are also multiple confounding factors, such as using
hepatotoxic drugs, as well as malnutrition. If you're interested in reading those case studies
yourself, I'll leave citations for them in the show notes on the herbswithrosaliepodcast.com
page. Okay, let's sum this up. All comfrey plants contain some level of PAs, but it's hard to know
exactly how much unless you get that actual plant tested. The method that you use to prepare comfrey
matters. External use of comfrey leaf and root is far safer than internal use. Teas are going to be
safer than alcohol extractions. Mature leaves will be safer than roots or even young leaves.
And lastly, a big unknown is how individuals might respond to PAs, as there can be a lot of
individual circumstances that make one person more susceptible than another. Without a doubt,
and this is very important, neither comfrey root nor leaf should be used during pregnancy,
breastfeeding, or in small children with developing lovers. So after all that summary, I'll just say
my personal take is that I don't feel like it's ethical to recommend this plant internally until
we know more about how to use it safely for everyone. Do you love herbs? Are you dreaming
of becoming an herbalist? Join us at herbswithrosalie.com or click the link in the description
to be a part of our vibrant herbal community. Let's keep the love for herbs growing. See you
in the next snippet.
