Debating Don Mattingly's Key 7th Inning Decision in Game 1

SportsGrid
3 followers
Sep 29, 2026
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThe discussion centers on the controversial decision by manager Donnie Baseball to bring in pitcher Duran early in a game against the Braves. While the move ultimately led to a three-run home run by Austin Riley, the speakers argue that the decision was likely a calculated risk based on the Phillies' struggling bullpen and predetermined game planning.
I'm starting to see a lot of chatter here, Craig, about this decision by Donnie Baseball
there to bring in Johan early in the game.
And I guess he's having to answer questions now about bringing him in, in what, the seventh
inning and in that kind of spot there.
You can't worry about the ninth in the ninth.
Exactly.
The Phillies, statistically, were the worst bullpen in baseball in September.
They sent Perkering down to the minor league.
They have not been doing well at all.
Duran has been the only one to count on.
So I don't doubt that that's happening because we micromanage this more than anything else.
And this is not defending Donnie with a friend.
It's just the reality of what are you supposed to do?
Are you supposed to have Alvarado, Joe, the lefty face him?
Like who are you going to bring in?
Yes.
Riley now with that home run, I think I just saw that he has the most go-ahead home runs
in postseason Braves history.
Javi Lopez and Tipper Jones have two.
He now has three.
So the only, the only downside to something like that, Joe, is if disaster strikes.
Disaster struck.
Right.
And so, and so now I just don't know how Philadelphia gets up off the turn.
I understand that the Braves pitching is going to be more challenged tomorrow with Molly
pitching.
For sale.
I, I do understand that, but I would be concerned in any kind of close game that the Phillies
would have it in the back of their heads without, then if that was the case, I mean, I hate
to say it, but Donnie is probably managing right now for his potential job for next season.
And there are some people who think that Alex Cora already has the job.
Crazy.
I think Donnie did such a good job.
It's also complicated because his, his father is the GM, but, but I, the way I went into
the series, Joe, is the same thing with pretty much every postseason is yes, it is dominated
by pitching.
Yes.
Christopher Sanchez, probably the better pitcher, but I go with the hot teams and I spade the
I just, I, I don't, I don't think you could just be ice cold going into September and
October and win anything.
And that's why San Diego has to be really concerning for some of these other teams.
They have just been so hot with San Diego beat the Dodgers, maybe, you know, maybe they,
would they play each other?
I'm the, I didn't look at the bracket.
Maybe you should show me the bracket.
I don't speak out, but I think, isn't it?
If I'm not mistaken, uh, yeah, it's, uh, so is it San Diego LA, right?
That's what that says here, Joe.
Okay.
So yeah.
So if San Diego beats the Cubs LA, I wouldn't be shocked.
I would not be shocked to see San Diego beat LA.
The, uh, the only shocking thing for me, Joe would be in this entire thing would be if
White Sox or Astros even got, that, that would be shocking.
Yeah.
I think it's going to play pretty close to the, the vest here across the board.
Uh, but listen, Durant threw 11 pitches in the seventh inning and then he got two outs
in the bottom of the eighth before the cheesy Michael Harris infield single.
Uh, and then he hit Ozzie Albies and then Austin Riley comes up, hits the three run
home run.
It wasn't like they were going right through the order.
Not to mention it would have been the bottom of the order coming up in the ninth inning.
They would have had an opportunity, uh, there to do it.
So I don't think he, he did that off the cuff.
Uh, I would imagine it was probably discussed before, uh, the game there in that usually
how that works.
Correct.
Always.
Right.
Almost nothing is in the moment.
No, I don't.
I can't speak for every team.
I know.
I can speak honestly that Miami, that they have it all mapped out, have the whole game
mapped out.
I've had, I had, I had one conversation when I was on the sideline this season, Joe Clayton
McCullough, the manager of the Marlins.
And we didn't, I didn't know exactly how it was going to play out, but he did like he
was like, and hopefully we have this and we'll do this in the fifth and then we'll win the
game.
I was like, wow.
How do we even know this?
The game hasn't even started yet.
And it played out exactly the way that he thought it would.
So yeah, the, they have these meetings with the pitching coach and the bullpen coach and
the managers and they go over, okay, what if in the fifth inning we have a guy on and
this guy comes up, who are we using?
Him.
Okay.
So make sure you get him up in the fourth.
If the lineup turns around a hundred percent, they, 99% of this stuff is predetermined.
It's that 1% that always is interesting.
And that's the debatable stuff at the end of the game.
You never know.
What if it goes sideways?
Okay.
Now all of a sudden you have to, have to react, but look, the, the question that Donnie will
get asked the most about here is that Duran coming back out again, right?
And it's for, to get more out because he's generally a one inning pitcher, but I got
news for you.
Duran's going to pitch tomorrow if they need him tomorrow and if they win, Duran's going
to pitch again on Thursday, if they need him again, like every, everybody, it's all hands
on deck here.
I think now to the end.
