LIVE: NATO Secretary General Mark Rutte Speaks at Euronews Defence & Space Summit

Live News Network
1.4K followers
23 Video Views·Sep 30, 2026
NATO Secretary General Mark Rutte is interviewed at 9:15 a.m. ET on Sept. 30 at the Euronews Defence & Space Summit.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThe NATO Secretary General addresses Russian nuclear threats and hybrid tactics, dismissing them as attempts to divide the alliance. He emphasizes NATO's readiness to defend its territory, the urgent need for air defense support for Ukraine, and the necessity for Europe to increase defense spending to achieve greater strategic autonomy and reduce over-reliance on the United States.
Yes. Well, thank you very much. It's been a lot of questions and I'm sure
the room is full now. So thank you very much. It's a lot of interest and let's get straight into it,
Secretary General. Can you confirm that Russia sent a letter to NATO that said,
if the Russian Federation, its territory, including Kaliningrad comes under any threat,
they will resort to the full arsenal, which includes also nuclear weapons,
in a letter. They use the term nuclear weapons in a letter.
Well, I'm not at liberty to disclose what they sent us, but this is what they reported,
more or less, to the media. So let me just refer to what the Russians reported to the media and
leave it at that. What we did, we reacted. And basically what we said is, hey, listen,
we are a defensive alliance and stop the nuclear threats. This is absolutely not called for and
particularly stop the war in Ukraine, which is unprovoked war of aggression against Ukraine.
So we have been clear in our reaction, which was short and concise,
but what was exactly in a Russian letter, I think it's up to them to disclose.
To disclose it. But if you sent a response, it's because they sent you a letter in the first place.
If we assume the media does a good job, this letter did say, the Russian Federation said,
if any of our interests in the Russian Federation territory, which also includes Kaliningrad,
is threatened in any way, we will use all of our capabilities, including nuclear weapons.
Is there a threat, an escalation that implies the risk of nuclear weapons being employed
against the Baltics is now real? No, it's not. Putin knows that he can
never win from NATO. So I don't take this that serious. But of course, we had to reply and make
clear to him that NATO is a defensive alliance, as I said, and stop the war in Ukraine and stop
the nuclear threats, because it's not helpful. And NATO is so much stronger than Russia is,
so there's no way they can ever beat us. The Prime Minister of Bulgaria was here,
we did an interview just an hour ago, and he said, you have, and everyone here in this room
has to be clear that you are dealing with a country that has nuclear capabilities. It is
a nuclear armed country. I presume Bulgaria is a NATO country probably had seen that letter
and their response too. There's a lot of frenzy around the situation in the Baltics.
And a security scenario that has or seems to have deteriorated over the past three weeks.
What are the scenarios you're preparing for? Because something seems to have changed beyond
language. Listen, let's zoom out a little bit.
What's happening? 43,000 Russians killed or seriously wounded a month now in Ukraine.
Ukraine holding the front line doing much better than only a half year or a year ago,
striking deep inside Russia. Allies supporting Ukraine in terms of weapons delivery, etc.
So this is the picture. So Putin is not winning this. So let's assume that he is a bit worried
and a bit rattled. And I think the best way to deal with this is to have a little bit of calm
here. On the NATO side, we can allow a bit of calm, but also a bit of making sure we continue
with what we are doing. So the carry on part, which is investing in our defence and we're doing it.
I see the Chief of Defence of the Netherlands here, they are massively
stepping up defence spending in the Netherlands and the same for Germany and basically for the
whole of NATO territory. Equalising with the United States, not only because we have to
equalise with the United States, but because we need all these capabilities. Because Russia
clearly has a strong military and we want to stay ahead. But most important for now
is to keep the support for Ukraine going. What Putin tries to do, don't forget,
by these letters and these hybrid grey zone activities, is he tries to divide us
and lose the focus on Ukraine. We will not. So every hybrid, whatever happens in Europe,
will be met with more support for Ukraine, not less support for Ukraine. That's the message.
Calm, carry on, keep the support for Ukraine going. That's how we deal with this.
We'll talk about Ukraine in a second. But just to understand this clearly, because over the
past three weeks, ever since the CIA boss went over to Moscow and that was reported,
there has been this real frenzy around whether or not something is in the making, could happen,
not imminently, but that now moves away from Ukraine into a NATO country. I was in Riga two
weeks ago. You could feel there's a sort of nervousness that I had not detected previously
in your own assessment. And you have one of the best intelligence in the world. Is the risk
assessment really truly the same it was three weeks, three months ago, a year ago?
Yes. And let's not forget, if the Russians want to do something against Finland or one of the
Baltic nations or Poland or whichever country in NATO, we will see a buildup. And let me,
if you don't believe me, let's listen to the Latvian and Estonian politicians. They are saying,
hey, we will be the first to call you if we think there is a serious threat against,
for example, Estonia or Latvia. But their message is, please stop being so worried.
We have prepared for this. We have planned for this. And this is true for the whole of NATO.
We will defend every inch of NATO territory, every square kilometre, square mile. There's no doubt
Putin knows this. So that threat is not there. And if anything happens, we are ready to counter it.
We will always be defensive. But if necessary, of course, we will defend ourselves. But
the most important thing is this is all happening because it's not going well for him in Ukraine.
He wants to divide us. He wants us to lose the attention when it comes to Ukraine,
keep the support going. And let me also quote Radek Sikorski, the foreign minister of Poland,
who said for every hybrid threat to Poland, we will do more for Ukraine instead of less for Ukraine.
That's the best reaction, by the way, when it comes to how to counter hybrid grey zone
threats to NATO territory. You say, if you don't believe me,
let's just listen to the Baltic politicians. They are politicians. They have to say there
is no imminent risk. It is politics. And it's also damaging the business environment. I was
told that clearly in Riga by a number of officials. This conversation is not good for investment.
But the question, and this is why I want to insist to you, is because the word of NATO
really matters. Should we just take away from this conversation that regardless of the letters,
the trip of a CIA top officer or not, nothing has changed. And even if Russia was planning
to do something, you are prepared for it. And this is NATO territory. We'll be protected.
There is no imminent threat to NATO territory. If there is a buildup, we will see it and we will
deal with it. If anything happens otherwise, we will also deal with it because we have prepared
and trained for this. We have a single command structure. We have 32 allies working together.
We have a fantastic Supreme Allied Commander in Alexis Grinkevich, the American general.
So we are in perfect shape, both when it comes to the hybrid and when it comes to whatever might
happen more. And we have to be clear-eyed. Russia is not doing well in Ukraine. And this is all
about that. And every minute we spend on this is exactly what Putin loves us to do, being rattled
and talking about what's happening here, what's happening there. Calm. We are stronger. Carry on.
Keep on investing. And most of us, most of all, make sure that Ukraine has what it needs to stay
in the fight. They need the support, particularly air defense, but also all the other stuff they can
get. Let's talk about Ukraine now. How do you see things evolving in the next few months? We
had a report this morning from our correspondent there. She said, and she's been there now four
or five days straight, it is worse than at any other point this year so far. There's a real
concern that the air defense is, I don't want to say depleted, but close to. Is it as bad as it
sounds? No, it's much better. Do we get to winter in a better shape? No, it's much better. The
pummeling of cities by the Russians, that's true. So they are hitting hard at the infrastructure,
critical energy infrastructure at cities. So that's taking place. And there is a lack of
interceptors. And that means that the Europeans and the Americans, we are all working in conjunction
to get as much as possible to Ukraine to make sure that they can defend themselves. But when
it comes to the frontline, as I said, look at Donetsk, Slovyansk, Kramatorsk, these key cities,
the Ukrainians are doing much better now than only a half a year or a year ago.
Look at what they are doing in striking deep inside Russia and taking out some of the key
logistical systems in Russia when it comes to the energy infrastructure, when it comes to
their systems of warehouses, et cetera. So Ukraine is doing fine, but it is absolutely
true an issue when it comes to big cities and energy infrastructure and logistics under threat.
And there we can help as Europeans and Americans and Canadians to make sure that they have what
they need. How can we accelerate or how can that process be accelerated? Because the Ukrainians
would say we want it. And the NATO summit in theory should have brought that to fruition
to get the licenses to be able to do the Patriots on the licenses. That is not really
going on, but that won't help them in the short term because it takes quite some time
if you have the licenses to to build these missiles. So that's for the U.S. and Ukraine
to discuss. Is that moving along? I think that's moving along, but I'm not involved in that. We
track that, we trace that, but that is particularly between the U.S., which has these companies
on this territory, which is building the Patriot systems. We know that in Germany,
when it comes to PEC 2s, we now see massive production sites being built between MBDA and
RTX to build the PEC 2 interceptors in Germany. So all of this is happening,
but this will not help Ukraine in the short term. For next winter and for the next coming
weeks and months, they simply need more interceptors. Please honor whatever you can still
give them. It's saving lives. And also our Supreme Allied Commander is saying to those
European countries still having these Patriots interceptors, whatever you can give, please do,
because it is crucial now to keep Ukraine strong. But Ukraine is not doing worse than
some time ago. They are doing better because the front line and striking deep inside Russia,
they are doing much better than only half a year ago. You mentioned, certainly when it comes to
the Europeans, that if you have any in stock, you should send them now. You didn't name the
countries, but we've seen clearly in Brussels, there's been ongoing pressure on Spain and Greece
in particular. Is this now the time to say whatever you have, really send it now? There
is no imminent threat on the southern flank? That's not how it works, because we have to make
sure, of course, that we have enough also to protect ourselves. But that's not up to me.
That's the Chief of Defence, the Supreme Allied Commander assessing what are the stockpiles we
need in NATO territory. And based on that assessment, what can we still give to Ukraine?
There's still room for that. But hey, that's not up to me to say, hey, send everything. That's
not my message. How much of a drag is the war in Iran on Ukraine? Because you could argue they feel
collateral damage out of the situation. It's a war that in theory, as we understood, the President
of the US said over the summer was done. Clearly it's not done. The oil is not coming out. And now
there's also energy pressure feeding into this conversation. How much of a problem is a war in
Iran when it comes to the situation in Ukraine? But let's also assess, and here we might not all
of us agree, that it was only the United States which was capable of taking out the nuclear
capability of Iran, which was a threat potentially soon, not only for Israel and the Middle East,
but also for us here. You really believe that? In Brussels, I absolutely believe that, yes.
So the American President taking out that threat, degrading that capability is crucial. And of
course, every war also has its downsides, that's clear. But I'm looking at the upsides here. And
by the way, with all the extra investments European countries are making in their defense,
this 3.5% leading to the 5% overall defense spending, this will lead to a situation where
in the future there's stronger Europe and a stronger NATO, where the Europeans will be able
to take care of their backyard themselves. It should be us doing this, not the Americans.
Why are the Americans doing it, taking out the Iranian nuclear capability? Because we can't.
But in the future, we have to make sure that as Europeans, we can do this ourselves.
It is anyway a bit strange that to protect ourselves here in Europe from 140 million
Russians, 600 million people living in NATO territory in Europe, that we need a country
which is six to eight hours flight from here with 340 million people to defend ourselves
against the Russians. We should be able to do that ourselves. That's exactly what we are working on.
Still the U.S. being involved, not only in the nuclear sense, but also in the conventional sense,
but the Europeans taking much, much more responsibility for the defense of this part of
NATO. The flip side, some would argue, and again, going back to the knock-on effect on Ukraine,
it's not clear how this ends or whether there's a strategy to do it. And it is having
an impact on Ukraine directly, because the president of the U.S. is now saying,
do not hit the refineries, because I don't want to see oil prices going up.
It is having a knock-on effect. So how can you undo this, this dynamic?
I'm not going to comment on everything which is said by...
But do you worry about the ramifications and the energy market?
I mean, there are always downsides. There are always downsides when war breaks out. That's
clear. But hey, let's face it, Europe was not able to take out the nuclear capability of Iran.
We couldn't. We didn't have the capabilities. In 10 years, we can and we should. It should not be
the Americans doing it. It should us be doing it. It should also us be taking care of the hooties
in the Red Sea and not the Americans. But hey, of course, there are always ramifications,
but the ramifications start from a premise that it is good that the Americans did this. And I'm
one believing that it was absolutely essential for the Americans to take on Iran.
And do you believe the vast majority of the alliance agrees with your assessment?
I don't think so, but that doesn't care. I don't care. You asked me on my opinion.
To that point, at this stage, do you see a NATO that is together in its collective decision
making? Or actually you would argue there are real tensions because the interests are moving
in different ways. Meaning for the Europeans, they believe Iran has had a negative implication
on Ukraine. And we've seen it this morning. A lot of these companies present here, they say
NATO pushes forward American contracts and we want to build our own industry. European companies
should go first. No, we are talking about Iran, but Iran last time. I'm saying two points of
tension. There are both. No, no, no. Iran is outside NATO territory. So let's be honest,
NATO is focused on the Euro-Atlantic. And when it comes to the Euro-Atlantic and defending
ourselves against Russia, which is our long-term threat, we are totally on one page. The US,
Canada, the 30 NATO allies in Europe, there's no poll. No, we were discussing Iran. And hey,
you're allowed to have your differences of opinion when it comes to Iran. By the way,
the Europeans are also totally in agreement that the freedom of navigation has to be restored,
both in the Strait of Hormuz and in the Red Sea. And we see now increasingly European countries
being active there. Lithuania, Latvia, Estonia helping out with demining in the Strait of Hormuz.
This is even before this so-called permissive environment will emerge, hopefully in the future.
So already they are there. Some other European countries are active there more discreetly,
helping out with demining. Why? Because the US is great, but the US lacks two capabilities. One
is icebreakers. You don't need them in the Strait of Hormuz. And demining capacity,
which the Europeans have an ample supply. So it's very good that Europeans are more and more helping.
And also 5,000 American planes took off from European bases since the end of February in
support of epic fury. So again, Europe being one big power projection platform for the United
States. So you're saying, because publicly, let's be honest, the war is not popular in Europe.
We've seen a number of European leaders who come out of it very openly saying it was a bad idea,
and my population doesn't support it. Would you say there's an element of performative?
Well, they're just politicians. There's an element of I disagree, but actually I'm providing much
more support than I say in public. No, no, I take all those comments very seriously. But
what I'm telling you is that the nuclear capability of Iran, in my assessment, is a
direct threat, not only to the Middle East, but also to Europe, that it was only the United States
which was able to degrade it. Yes, when you have a war like this, that will have also negative
consequences, but you have to take them into account. And Europe is now stepping up when it
comes to the Strait of Hormuz, was already stepping up when it came to making sure that
the US could make use of its infrastructure and facilities in Europe in support of epic fury.
And this is allies. This is not NATO, because NATO is not active in Iran. I mean,
it's outside NATO territory. But this is allies working together, making sure that
we have great atmospherics within the alliance, but also making sure that we are there for each
other when necessary. How is the atmosphere in the alliance at this point? It's great. It's
the best it has ever been, because you have now a Europe which is taking responsibility
for its own defense. President Trump loves NATO. He only hated one element, which was
the fact that we were not spending enough. And multiple other things. He also said he
had been at the NATO summit. He was not very happy going into the NATO summit,
then came out happy out of it. But he said he was not happy at his NATO summit and his NATO
allies, because of Iran. When I speak with President Trump, he's totally clear-eyed
where NATO is crucial also for the United States. Jonas Tøren, the Norwegian prime minister,
showing him the map of these nuclear submarines of Russia, which are a threat not to Norway.
They are a threat to the United States. They might end up at the shores of the United States
if we as NATO would not block them. So NATO, and this is just one example,
is not only there to protect Europe. It is also there to protect Canada. It's there to protect
the United States. I was just last week with Matt Whitaker. He was just here also presenting.
He is the ambassador, fantastic ambassador of the U.S. to NATO. We were both visiting
his home state, Iowa. So I brought this message to the American Midwest. I will continue doing that
also to discuss with the American people that NATO is not only there for historical reasons for
the U.S. to stay involved in Europe after the Second World War, but also to make sure that
the U.S. mainland stays safe and therefore NATO is crucial. And finally, in the U.S.,
in all the senior circles, in the Pentagon, in state and in the White House, there is widespread
agreement that if China would move against the first island chain, that there is no doubt that
at the same moment Putin will keep us busy here. And then we need a stronger European element
in NATO. This is NATO 3.0, a stronger Europe and a stronger NATO to make sure that the U.S. doesn't
have to spread its resources too thinly. And just a final point on this. The reason why I
ask how is the mood is because right now we see competing priorities. The U.S. is sending this
message, do not hit the refineries because it's affecting the energy market. What I detect from
the European leadership is that they are okay with Ukraine hitting deeply into Russia because
that is the moneymaker for Russia. As a NATO Secretary General, when you look at both scenarios,
do you say at this point I'd rather they continue just hitting Russia deeply, even if it comes with
the energy market? I look at another scenario. It's a best balance. I look at another fact.
And the fact is that when it comes to war in Ukraine, there is only one person who can bring
it to an end. And that person is not living in Europe. That person is living in the White House.
And the American president is the only one. You really believe that? Yes, I really believe this.
He was the only one who could break the deadlock with Putin. He did. He started a dialogue.
He sent some of his senior advisors to work diligently with the Russians and the Ukrainians
to bring this war to an end. So far, it has not been successful, but they are working on this.
I commend them for that. And that's what we need to do. But for Ukraine to enter into peace talks,
we collectively with the United States and Canada and the Europeans have to make sure
they are as strong as possible. And we need to bring this war to an outcome where Ukraine is
sovereign, can defend itself, is viable and can continue as a independent nation.
And in the right politic, I'm pretty sure 99.9% of everyone here would say President Trump will
have to be if there's any sort of peace at that table. But I want to ask you, the ceasefire,
he promised, did not happen. The energy ceasefire is not happening either. In your mind, is there
really now any path in which we see from now until the winter, any sort of mediated ceasefire
of any way, or actually this is just war? Of course, we all hope for it. I know, and I spoke
with some of the senior American people involved in this last week in New York. They are working
day in, day out to get it done. I support them wherever I can. I know that the whole European
leadership is behind this effort because we all want this war to end. But hey, you need two
to tango. So far, it doesn't seem that Vladimir Vladimirovich Putin is willing to tango when it
comes to a peace deal. And as long as he is not making himself available for that, it is a bit
difficult. But hey, we always know that these wars end with a peace deal. And we always know you need
negotiators and you need somebody with clout who can do that. And the American President
breaking the deadlock with Putin when he came into office, I think was essential.
And we can then criticize that it has not been done. No, I mean, this is very difficult. It
takes time. But over time, I'm sure that will be successful. I don't know whether it will be
before winter. At the moment, we don't see Putin willing, it seems, to engage.
When you look at NATO, you also accomplish the 5%. And then, of course, there's the famous
Trump trillion. Some dispute that it's an effective trillion, but the President doesn't
say we will get to the one trillion. What we've seen this morning here is there is a lot of cash
and money to be put forward. But there are differences in terms of what do we buy. And
the European industry would say there needs to be a clear European preference. This is taxpayer money.
The U.S. ambassador today said it is clear the Europeans are creating instruments that will limit
U.S. abilities to play in these contracts. In your mind,
do you go, as long as you're a NATO member, you buy what you want?
First of all, it's more than one trillion. But then on the question you ask, the problem is not
is it do you buy in Europe or do you buy in the United States? The problem is can you buy?
The money is there, but the defense industrial base in Europe is underdeveloped. It is not
producing enough. Too many factories are still not working full time, are not churning out their
products 24-7. But there is no bias for manufacturers. No, no, the same is true for the United States.
Also the United States needs to ramp up its output. This is exactly what Trump tries to
do with the quadrupling of the five big primes in the U.S., et cetera. So the problem is not
if only we had the luxury of this discussing buy European or buy American. No, I would say buy.
And generally speaking, being a free market politician, I think it's always better if you
have these free markets functioning as open and independent as possible. But at the moment,
I think it is a discussion of luxury whether you buy European or American. Because we cannot
buy on both sides. There is not enough production, not in Europe, not in the United States,
to fulfill all the demand signals. So this is my message to industry. Invest. You know there is a
long term demand, there is a long term commitment to spend so much more. You know that 30%
approximately of all the defense spending is spent in the industrial base. So develop the
industrial base. Make sure we have the latest innovations there. And we know that European
companies, Thales, investing in the U.S., U.S. companies investing in Europe, it is a transatlantic
defense industrial base. It is working as one. And that's exactly what it should be. The only
problem is it has to produce much more than it is doing at the moment. The good news is
industry is ramping up. And we had that in Ankara with the 50 billion extra defense industrial
contracts being closed there and the 40 billion when it comes to the drone edge. So these were
huge announcements which will also help to accelerate the investments in the defense
industrial base. So meaning Europe is a Brussels debate. It exists in the Brussels circles.
If only we had the luxury to have that debate. At the moment the problem is we do not produce
enough. Look now at Ukraine. So we have the S-30, the 70s from Italy and France, fantastic systems.
We have the Patriot system from the U.S. Both of them do not produce enough. This is just one
example. If only France and Italy would be able to really ramp up the production of 70s and S-30s,
if only Russia and Lockheed Martin would be able to quadruple as the president has requested
as soon as possible the production of PAC-3 interceptors for Patriot systems,
then we would be in good shape and then we can have a debate do you buy European or American.
But at the moment I would say more generally speaking let's look at this as one big
transatlantic defense industrial market. And there is enough money for everybody.
And there will be a piece defense dividend coming from this because all these investments will also
lead to societal returns not only in the defense output from the defense industrial base but also
innovation and everything else. And Secretary General, just a final question. What do you
think NATO 3.0 means? Because I see two different schools. One says it means an alliance in which we
pay. We both commit. So it will equalize the relationship. It will be stronger because we
all commit more. There are some in Europe who would say ultimately NATO 3.0 means they will
pull back the troops. We will have to pay more. We will have to pay for their weapons. And in
exchange what we get is the nuclear umbrella. That is it. That is NATO 3.0. Which one is it?
Well, it's more like the first and the second. It's too negative the second one.
I mean it's a bit of a crazy assumption that it will be the second one. You don't mean this.
Because if the U.S. What do we think? If the U.S. would only be here with the nuclear umbrella,
of course from a strategic and tactical point of view that would not be very wise.
Because you want also to be there then if you have a nuclear umbrella in a conventional sense.
For all kinds of tactical strategic reasons the military people can explain to you why that is
important. So the U.S. will stay involved in Europe also in the conventional domain. No,
the problem was that NATO was not sustainable. It is not sustainable that you have a country
being overly responsible for the defense of 600 million Europeans. We are the richest part of the
world. There is no part of the world which is richer than Europe. And then we are totally
over dependent on a country so far away, 340 million people to defend against 140 million
Russians. That's not sustainable. That's what we are changing now. That means that,
and this is the paradox, the United States, thanks to the fact that Europe is stepping up,
will be much more committed to Europe. Because they need Europe and a secure Atlantic and a
secure Arctic. Look at the Greenland debate we were able to bring to a successful outcome last
week. The Danes and the Greenlanders and the Americans very successfully. A case in point
that we need a secure Arctic, secure Atlantic, secure Europe to keep Europe, the Arctic and the
United States safe. The problem was there was a total lack of equality in terms of spending.
That's now being redressed, not only because Trump wants this, but also because we have to
spend much more in Europe to be able to defend ourselves against the Russians.
Your team says you have to go and you have to leave on time,
so I don't want to have any problems with NATO at this point. But just as a final question,
would you say ultimately all of this is chitchat because the big problem in Europe will be China?
No, China is extremely relevant. And as I said, if something happens in the, China would move
against Taiwan or somewhere else in the first island chain, that will have a huge impact on
the US first of all, because they will try to do everything to stabilise the situation in the
Pacific. But they will need Europe to take responsibility much more than we do at this
moment for our own defence, because you cannot require from the US to spread its resources too
thinly. And yes, of course, China is extremely relevant. And we assess that for the moment,
Russia is the long term threat against NATO. We will see how China develops. We know they are
sitting by 2030 on 1000 nuclear warheads. They have massive investments in their military and
it's not only to organise parades in Beijing. Well, on that note, Secretary General,
thank you very much for joining us. Thank you very much.
