10 Most OVERRATED And UNDERRATED NBA Players At The Moment
2 Video Views·Sep 29, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
With the new NBA season right around the corner, we're starting to see every major media outlet
publish their player rankings, myself included as I just published my video ranking the top 50 NBA
players going into the new year, so go check that out after you watch this video. ESPN's player
ranking list is always the one that draws the most attention, and they just released their iteration
for this year, so today's video will be based off of that. More specifically, today we will be
picking out the 5 most overrated and 5 most underrated NBA players based on where they are
ranked on ESPN's rankings. With these lists, nobody will ever agree on everything, so in order to truly
be a pick for today's video, we're focusing on the most egregious ranks where the player in either
direction just does not actually provide the value nor put up the production worthy of where they
landed. Now with that being said, let's dive right in.
Starting with one of the most overrated players in ESPN's rankings, we have Derek White of the
Boston Celtics who was ranked 47th overall. Derek White is consistently a player that I see get
forced into conversations that he doesn't belong in, and last season he had the chance to prove me
wrong, but he floundered it. With Jason Tatum out most of the year, he was thrust into more of a go
role in Boston where he faced more intentional attention from defenses, and as a result of that,
his efficiency tanked. Derek White averaged the same amount of points last season as he did in
2025, 16 points per game, but he shot just 39% from the field and 32% from three. Just because
someone is a great role player does not mean they are better players than the guys who are lower end
star players, and Derek White showed he did not have what it took to be a star. In the playoffs
against the Philadelphia 76ers, he also stunk up the joint and could be looked at as the biggest
reason that they blew that series. Yes, Derek White is an outstanding defender. Yes, he is a
great connector in a lineup and does the dirty work and keeps things flowing to help those around
him. But no, that doesn't mean that he's a top 50 player in the NBA when several all-star caliber
players were ranked behind him. Now for the first underrated player from the list we'll be
discussing, we have Dylan Brooks of the Phoenix Suns, who was ranked 76th. Dylan Brooks suffers
from a fate where he just doesn't come off as a very likable person in the eyes of quite a bit of
people, which I do believe hurts him in these polls and rankings where people inflict their personal
feelings about him into it. He's a very polarizing figure, he's had a lot of ups and downs in his
career, but he is undoubtedly coming off of the best season of his career and is still being
treated like he was back in 2023. Dylan Brooks provides undeniable impact on the defensive side
of the ball, as evidenced by both the Houston Rockets and now the Phoenix Suns, becoming top
10 defenses after his arrival, when previously they ranked near the bottom of the league before
he got there. Plus, last season Dylan Brooks averaged over 20 points per game, displaying a
improved level of on-ball creation and shot-making that make him more of a reliable source of
offense. The Suns were completely counted out last season and yet they ended up making the playoffs,
with Brooks being at the heart of a lot of that success. For reference, here are the players
ranked directly ahead of him on the list, Kayson Wallace, Isaiah Hartenstein, Walker Kessler,
Vijay Edgecombe, Tyler Hero, and Peyton Pritchard. I legitimately believe that Dylan Brooks, at least
right now, is better than every single one of those players with better individual production
and more clear-cut impact on winning basketball games. And if he didn't rub so many people the
wrong way with his antics, I believe he would have been ranked possibly 20 spots higher,
which is around where I personally had him in my rankings. Now for the next overrated player from
the list, we have Kayson Wallace of the Oklahoma City Thunder, who was ranked 75th. As I just
discussed with Dylan Brooks, there are quite a few questionable names ranked ahead of him,
with Kayson Wallace having been one of the most noticeable being directly ahead of him. Now I want
to be very clear, being quote-unquote overrated does not mean that I view any of these players as
bad, nor am I intending to slander them by any means. It just means that they are ranked way
higher than they deserve, and Kayson Wallace just does not do enough to justify this kind of spot.
Again, Kayson Wallace is the ultimate role player, and all 30 NBA teams would love to have him in
their lineup. He knows his role, he doesn't try to do too much, he's an elite perimeter defender,
and he's a nice connector on offense. However, we also have to be real with ourselves. He only
averages 8 points and 2 assists per game, with very mediocre shooting splits. He's a smart
decision maker, but he doesn't do nearly enough on the offensive side of the ball to warrant this
kind of placement. Taking defense into consideration obviously matters, but we cannot simply overlook
completely pedestrian offensive output, and the middle of the ground is definitely not ranking
him ahead of high-level scorers and creators with all-star nominations on their resume.
Now for the next underrated player on the list, we have Norman Powell of the Chicago Bulls, who was
ranked 86th. Guys, Norman Powell was literally just an all-star, like yes, in the year 2026.
He just got ranked below Nas Reed for example, who wasn't even one of the top canvades for 6th
man of the year last season. There is of course context that goes into it, he definitely benefited
from a lot of other top players in the Eastern Conference being injured during last season, but
he was absolutely deserving of being in the mix in the first place, and it's an honor that does
hold weight when literally ranking how good a player is at the moment compared to his peers.
He is not without flaws, he's not much of a playmaker and his defensive work on the perimeter
is hit or miss, but he is a lights out shooter and a real weapon on the offensive side of the ball,
which is ultimately what basketball is about. He just averaged 22 points per game with
very efficient shooting splits, with the Miami Heat where he stepped into their lead role on offense
when Tyler Hero was out for most of the season, and Powell thrived in that role, which as we
discussed earlier with Derek White, not everybody can actually handle when a heavier workload is
thrust onto their shoulders, so this does count for something. Next on the list of overrated players
from the list, we have Tyrese Maxey of the Philadelphia 76ers, who was ranked 11th overall.
I've got a lot of love for Maxey, so it hurts to have to include him in this category,
but placing him right outside of the top 10 is probably premature. When you get to this tier
of the list, the whole body of work is very important, and this being where the superstar
level talents find themselves is very nitpicky between each player. Maxey is ranked directly
ahead of Steph Curry, Kevin Durant, new teammate Jalen Brown, and Kawhi Leonard for example,
a bunch of future hall of famers and champions who are all coming off of pretty elite seasons
in their own rights. Maxey's production has increased every year of his career,
and he is absolutely approaching this top, top tier of guard talent, but he hasn't actually
proven to be able to lead in a meaningful capacity like the others that I mentioned
in the playoffs. Last season the Sixers missed the playoffs with him thrust into the number one
role, and this past season the Sixers were on the verge of elimination in the playoffs against the
Celtics until Joel Embiid returned to the court, only for them to get smoked by the Knicks in the
round where Maxey struggled mightily in that series. Maxey is a phenomenal, explosive scorer,
and elite speed is at the key of his game where in transition he's a blur, but he's a pretty poor
defender. He struggles when the game slows down, and hasn't been the driving force of a top seeded
team yet, which may sound like nitpicks, but at the top of a list like this, the other players
check more boxes than he has at the moment. The next underrated player from the list is
actually his teammate Joel Embiid of the Philadelphia 76ers, who was ranked 41st overall.
Joel Embiid is a player that gets crucified every year for his health struggles, and I'm by no means
here to say that those aren't valid concerns, but stuff like this is just taking it way too far.
When Joel Embiid is right, you can count on your fingers the amount of players that can match his
impact, and we saw it firsthand in the playoffs. The Sixers went down in their series without him
against the Boston Celtics. He rushed back early from getting surgery on his appendix,
as his recovery process was still expected to be two more weeks, and he completely flipped that
series on its head against Boston, leading them back from being down 3-1. He may not have that
MVP caliber level in him anymore, but he still sleepwalks to scoring at least 27 points per game.
His impact metrics and on-off swings have always demonstrated how much better his team is with him
and now with more help around him than he's ever previously had. He's not going to have to exert
himself nearly as much night after night this upcoming season, which should help him be able
to preserve his health better. To even further demonstrate this point, the application of injury
concerns isn't even consistent on this list, because the two people ranked directly ahead
of him at 40 and 39 are Anthony Davis and Kyrie Irving. Davis is equally as injury prone as Embiid,
but he's also not been as good of a player as Joel Embiid since like 2018. Then Kyrie Irving
just missed the entirety of last season injured too, while also never having been an MVP caliber
player like Joel Embiid. Not to mention the countless others ranked ahead that will never
come close to Embiid's level of impact, so there's just not much rational explanation for him being
this low on the list. Now for the next overrated player on their list, we have Jalen Dern of maybe
the Detroit Pistons, who was ranked 33rd. I say maybe because he hasn't technically
re-signed with Detroit yet, but that is the most likely outcome there. Unfortunately,
I just don't have any trust in Jalen Dern at all to this meaningful of a degree,
and being named an all-star last season doesn't save him in my eyes. For one, last year was Jalen
Dern's first year truly playing at that high of a level, so he doesn't have the longevity of a star
caliber performer in the regular season. It's still to be determined on whether he's a one-hit
wonder or if this is his new norm. Second and most importantly, he had one of the most shameful
playoff showings that an all-star has had in quite some time. In the regular season, Dern was averaging
about 19 points and 10 rebounds per game. In the playoffs, the most amount of points he scored in
any game was 15. No, he didn't average 15, that was his best playoff performance.
His scoring was cut in half on average in the playoffs this year, and he had the same amount
of games scoring in single digits as he had scoring in double figures. Scoring alone doesn't
make a player, but it was literally Dern's most useful trait because, quite frankly, he's not
very good at other important parts of being a center. He's not a great interior defender,
he's not much of a shot blocker, and then on offense, he also doesn't have a reliable jumper,
so he's not spacing the floor either. He was in the paint clogging it up, getting shut down,
leaving Cade Cunningham out to dry, and it is indicative of his playstyle being fairly
predictable when defenses tighten up, which makes it a lot harder to write off as a fluke.
Ranking him 33rd overall over a lot of established multiple-time all-stars,
playoff risers, and guys that simply outproduce him to a significant degree is just not something
that I agree with at all, and honestly, I don't even have him in my top 50 of the rankings.
The next underrated player on the list is Anthony Davis of the Washington Wizards,
who was ranked 40th. Earlier, we discussed Joel Embiid being severely punished for his
injury struggles, and the same thing happened to Anthony Davis. Again, I'm not here to downplay
the effect that injuries have, but we all know Anthony Davis provides more impact than almost
half of the names above him. Even in a down year riddled with injuries, he was averaging 20 points
and 11 rebounds per game, which we know he's also capable of way more than that when he's right.
He's still one of the best defensive talents in the league on his day, and now playing next to
Trey Young on the Wizards, who may be the best pick and roll partner he's ever had, he's about
to feast on easy looks around the basket. The Wizards traded for him for a reason, he's someone
who can elevate a team on both ends of the floor, and one down year doesn't change that.
He's playoff proven, he's a star on offense and defense, he's a high level scorer, and he's far
more well-rounded than a lot of the players ranked above him who have fairly empty resumes comparatively.
Next, the final overrated player from the list that we'll be discussing today is Nikhil Alexander
Walker of the Atlanta Hawks, who was ranked 55th. Alexander Walker exploded last season having what
was far and away his best year in the league. He averaged about 21 points per game, shooting 46%
from the field and 40% from three, which is great for a score first sharp shooting two guard. I'm
not here to say otherwise. This is another example of someone with just one season of high level play
being credited more than longtime performers, with more of a proven track record when it matters
though. Nikhil Alexander Walker also had a really poor showing in the playoffs, where he averaged
13 points per game, shooting 38% from the field in the Hawks first round series against the Knicks.
And quite frankly, that's not good enough for someone who's being ranked here labeled as a
borderline star. He's not really a playmaker on the ball, and his defense is decent but not elite,
so the entire basis of this ranking is from his strong regular season and nothing else.
And if that's the case, then Trey Murphy, who was ranked two spots behind him,
has outproduced him for two years in a row now, and even someone like Michael Porter Jr.,
who just had one good regular season too, is ranked behind him when Porter's production
has far exceeded Alexander Walker's as a scorer. Brendan Ingram was even ranked behind him,
and he was an all-star last year. This list has a lot of rules that get applied to some,
but not others, and this is an example of that. And finally, the last underrated player on the
list we'll be discussing is RJ Barrett of the Toronto Raptors, who was ranked 99th.
Barrett's reputation has sunk over the last few years due to the fact that he was never
able to become the star many hoped he could be when he was drafted third overall in 2019.
His inefficiency as a scorer has been the main point of contention, and in the past,
that was a big problem plaguing him, but him still being ranked 99th on the list this year
is indicative of people not paying attention to the real growth he saw in his game last season.
Previously, Barrett was frustrating because he was a great driver of the ball and could get to
rim at will, but his finishing skills left a lot to be desired, and he would miss way more shots
around the basket than you would like. Last season, though, he improved his rim field goal
percentage by 11 percentage points, and was genuinely a dangerous driver of the ball who
was converting way better. He's been consistently averaging about 19-20 points per game for the last
few years, and last year it translated to actual winning impact, helping the Raptors get back to
playoffs. The team was 3.6 points better per 100 possessions, with him on the court last season too,
further illustrating that he was becoming much more of a consistent positive than in the past.
RJ Barrett was ranked behind all of the top rookie draft picks that haven't even played a game yet,
he's behind Jalen Suggs who just shot the ball historically terribly in his playoff series and
doesn't have close to the same production, and he was ranked behind one-hit wonder roleplayers like
Peyton Watson, which all feels disrespectful. And with that being said, that's all I have for you
today. If you want to go check out the list, that will be linked down in the description,
but make sure to like the video, subscribe to the channel, and comment down below what
you think about the players and their rankings. Thanks for watching, and I'll see you all next time.

