Aaron Judge OUT! Yankees roster moves for Red Sox series | Pinstripe Post

New York Post - Sports
11 followers
8 Video Views·Sep 29, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
The rosters were announced for the wildcard series, the best of three, Yankees, Red Sox,
and I would say the Yankees in the end were tactical, practical, but also emotional.
Aaron Judge didn't make the roster. I think it was practical and I'm sure it was emotional.
He's the captain of the team. He's the best player on the team. He badly wanted a play.
He understands. He talked about it in the day before the series was to begin.
He's played for 10 years. The team hasn't won a championship while he's there.
How precious it is to play this time of year, but the reality is he took batting practice
in front of the world in a little simulated situation on Monday, and it was telling that
after that round, Trent Grisham and Giancarlo Stanton, who were also on the injured list and
trying to get back in time, ran on the field. The player who did not run on the field
was Aaron Judge, who had said before the workout the only running he had done
was on an anti-gravity machining, and the Yankees have to protect Aaron Judge from Aaron Judge.
He has a strained calf. I've covered baseball for a long time. I've never seen anyone come
back from a strained calf in less than three weeks. The Yankees did not describe this as
the mildest. Everyone agreed it was in his soleus, which is the lower part that attaches
to the Achilles. To try to do this in under three weeks, there's a delusion players need to play
great, and I think Aaron Judge has that, and I'm not saying that pejoratively. To be able to do
something like he does in front of 50,000 people live and millions more and folks caring this much
and the other teams as talented as they are, you have to have a certain delusion that you can do
what people say you can't do, and I think Aaron Judge has it at the highest level, but ultimately
the Yankees just can't put a compromised player on the field. It's not good for them, and it's
not good for him if he were to do some serious damage there, and suddenly you're talking about
not just missing the rest of these playoffs, but maybe a part of next year. Now, maybe do you
gamble because who knows how much baseball we're playing next year with a lockout due
on December 1st and some real concerns about when the season might start or if it will be played at
all, but ultimately Judge didn't make it back to this roster. I even say it's a big question if he
can make it back. If the Yankees advance for a division series, the first two games and possibly
three and five games would be played on the turf in St. Petersburg against the Rays, and that is
not a forgiving surface, and it still is not the typical healing period. You could hope, you could
pray, you could wish, but the body is the body. It is the body of a 6'7", 270-plus pound man
who does things with great force, and as much as he wants to play, as much as the fan base wants
him to play, and I'm sure as much as the Yankees want him to play, the body is saying certain
things here. Conversely, the Yankees did put Grisham and Stanton on the roster. They didn't
put Ryan Weathers on. I think, again, we got to tell on Monday during this simulated period.
Weathers faced Stanton and Judge, and my thought was if he's pitching on Monday, it means he can't
pitch on Tuesday, probably not on Wednesday. The series maximum goes to Thursday if a game three
is needed, but I think by being on the mound and pitching, if the Yankees advance, I think
Weathers becomes a part of the roster for the next round without any setbacks. What I would
look at in this series is the Yankees put Stanton on, who hasn't played since April 24th. The Red
Sox put Garrett Crochet on, who hasn't pitched since April 25th. You'd like to know how long
ago that was. April 25th was game four of the first round of the NBA playoffs. The Knicks beat
the Hawks to tie the series, went on a 13-game winning streak that would take them towards an
NBA championship. The Knicks opened camp yesterday for a new season. That's how long it's been since
Stanton and Crochet played. Why are they on this roster? Well, they're incredibly talented. Crochet
finished second for the AL Cy Young last year, but he's left-handed. The Red Sox are taking
six lefties on their staff. Two of them will start games if it goes three games.
Peyton Tolley is starting the opener, and Ranger Suarez would start game three.
They're going to throw a ton of lefty pitching against the Yankees. The Yankees lean lefty.
They did decide to go with 16-position players. I think at the end, that came down to taking an 11th
pitcher, Ahmad Rosario. I think they decided Rosario's right-hand bat to pinch hit or maybe
even open at third base against a guy like Tolley was more valuable than the 11th pitcher. Stanton,
sitting on the bench, it's a roll of the dice. He's a high-strikeout, high-swing-and-miss guy
in the best of times. Here he is. He hasn't taken a competitive at-bat since late April.
But he's Giancarlo Stanton. You look down the bench. When they bring in one of these lefties,
I think he's going to get two or three targeted plate appearances in this series where Aaron Boone
knows for sure it will be against the lefty, and he'll try to do it. Grisham is on the roster
because, again, there is some value to the left-handed bat when righties come in. Also,
at the moment, to end the season, Jose Caballero was their fourth outfielder.
As problematic as Grisham might be in center field, I think you'll see him,
if the Yankees are leading late, Grisham in center and Spencer Jones in right and
Elio Ramos off the field because Ramos is still the worst defender of that trio,
and they'll try to play defense that way. But I would just concentrate a lot on who's here
for both teams. This is going to be a lot of Boone trying to get favorable righty-lefty matchups,
but the Yankee lefty hitters, you know, Rice is not going to be pinch hit for,
and Bellinger is not going to be pinch hit for, and so they're going to have to do some damage.
He's not going to want to pinch hit for Austin Wells because the downgrade is to Ali Sanchez
being in the game, and so some of their lefty hitters are going to have to do left-on-left
damage in this series. I think it's a big part of this series, but where he can,
he will try to get the right-on-lefted bat for Stanton. Obviously, he would love to have some
right-on-lefted bats for the guy who, you know, who has built a career around hitting a lot of
people, including lefties, really well, and that's Aaron Judge. But Judge isn't going to be part of
this series, and let's see if the Yankees advance and ever could get to the point where they could
get Judge onto a roster.
