The Catholic Church - Builder of Civilization, Episode 11: Origins of International Law

Global Affairs Academy
6 followers
2 Video Views·Sep 29, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis episode explores the Catholic Church's pivotal role in establishing universal human rights and international law. By championing the inherent dignity of all rational beings, the Church countered Machiavellian political realism, arguing that governments are subject to a higher moral law. This framework provided the ethical basis for protecting the rights of indigenous peoples in the New World.
We've heard a great deal over the years about the terrible demographic tragedy that struck
the peoples of the New World in the Age of Discovery. But who were the greatest and most
outspoken critics of the abuses of the natives? Catholic theologians. Let's talk about this
issue today on The Catholic Church, Builder of Civilization.
Welcome to The Catholic Church, Builder of Civilization. I'm Thomas Woods. Last week
we talked about the church and law. And for a good portion, we talked about the church's
role in developing the idea of natural rights. This is a central concept in Western civilization.
The idea that simply by virtue of being a human being, I possess certain rights that
inhere in my very nature as a rational creature. That I have the right not to be killed, not
to be expropriated, have my property taken away. I have these rights by virtue of being
human. And I even cited an encyclical that I consider to be sort of recent, 1891 encyclical
by Pope Leo XIII in which he specifically said that the right to property is sacred
and inviolable. So nobody can come up with some pretext for violating that. So these
are important liberating ideas in the best sense of the word. Today what we're going
to talk about is the extension of this idea of rights to the whole world. And the suggestion
that all the peoples of the world enjoy the same fundamental dignity because they're made
in the image and likeness of God and they have that rational nature. All of us identically
share in a dignity that demands the recognition of rights. This is a revolutionary idea. There
are not many peoples in the world who have looked around at all the diversity of people
in the world and said, let's bestow equal rights on everybody. This is not exactly the
most popular idea in the history of mankind, but it came right out of the heart of the
church. Now let's begin by looking at the exact opposite of what the church teaches.
And then we can better appreciate why the church's message is so revolutionary. And
when I look at the exact opposite of what the church teaches, I focus specifically on
one of the great villains of political philosophy. In the early 16th century, a fellow named
Machiavelli, who wrote an enormous amount, wrote a small book around 1513 called The
Prince. When we look at The Prince, we find a totally secular analysis of politics. God
is left out of the equation altogether. Morality is left out of the equation altogether. Sound
a little bit familiar? That's what modern political life in effect has been like. These
things are to be banished. Governments have to do what they have to do. And moral principles
will suffer in the process. Now think about how St. Thomas Aquinas would have answered
the question, what is political obligation? Or what is the nature of the state? Or what
is the function of the ruler? And he would have thought, well, God's intention in establishing
these institutions was, and then he would have gone on from there. Machiavelli has no
truck with any of this. He's not interested in God's intention. That has no relevance
to him whatsoever. Instead, Machiavelli looks at the state from the point of view of a cold
calculating theoretician. And in effect, what he wants to do is give advice to rulers. If
you want to stay in power, you should do these things. And don't be caught up in moral concerns.
Am I allowed to do these things? You have to do what you have to do. Because according
to Machiavelli, the worst thing that can happen is the collapse of a state. So the state has
to be able to do whatever it feels necessary to do to keep itself functioning. Because
were it not for the state, we would all revert to a condition of civil war, of all against
all, as in a later century, Thomas Hobbes suggested. So therefore, the end that we have
in mind, that is keeping the state functioning and preserving the peace, is very important.
So the means to that end become okay, whatever means necessary. So his advice to the prince
is do what you have to do to maintain yourself in power, even if that means lying and cheating
and stealing, and even worse. So for example, it was a typical piece of Machiavellian advice
to rulers that you should give the appearance of being generous, but don't be so foolish
as actually to be generous. Or it is good for you to be loved by your people, but much
more important, if you can't swing that, is to be feared by them. This is classic Machiavellian
advice, and part of the reason that Machiavelli despised the church and despised Christianity
was that these things taught that states were subject to moral restraints, they were subject
to the moral law. Machiavelli's state is subject to nothing other than necessity. And so Machiavelli
would have disdained what the Catholic church taught, that there are virtues that we ought
to cultivate. We ought to cultivate the cardinal virtues of prudence, temperance, fortitude,
and justice. We ought to pursue the three theological virtues of faith, hope, and charity.
All this falls out in Machiavelli's system, for there is only one virtue for Machiavelli,
and that is the ability to survive. And that trumps everything, and that extends to states
in particular. States have to survive, so they need to be able to do what they need
to do. And it is unjust for a state to be held up to moral scrutiny. It won't work,
it's impractical, and that in effect is Machiavelli's message. Now the church condemned Machiavelli's
work in no uncertain terms. They condemned it because they believed that there are such
things as moral standards when it comes to government. Now it's one thing for a teenager
to go around saying this. This is the typical teenage morality, isn't it? I'm not going
to get my moral teaching from any of you people, I'll just live by my own code. Every teenager
has this view, you know, during the teenage years, and then most of them grow up and realize
how stupid they're being. But the typical teenage mentality is, I don't need to read
your Bible, or listen to your preaching, or even listen to my parents, I'll make up my
own rules, blah, blah, blah. Now that's bad enough when a teenager teaches that, but when
a government believes that, then you're getting into something very dangerous. So what the
church teaches is that states can not only be held up for moral accountability, but they
can also be held up to moral scrutiny in how they interact with other states. There are
moral rules that govern how they interact with other states. They can't just do whatever
they want, or whatever they think is to their passing advantage. They have to be subject
to the moral law. Machiavelli would be absolutely livid at this suggestion. But the church teaches
that an absolute, unchanging standard of justice applies to all peoples alike. This, in effect,
is what international law is. The idea that all states are subject to certain rules and
restraints. Now let me anticipate an objection here. The fact that you believe that there
is such a thing as international law does not mean you have to be the world's greatest
cheerleader for the United Nations. Because you may be saying, isn't the United Nations
made up in large part of a bunch of bozos and dangerous and weird people? Don't they
say a lot of strange things and we would never want to be governed by these people? I couldn't
agree more. In fact, some of you may remember Bill Buckley's old statement that he would
rather be governed by the first 2,000 names in the Boston telephone directory than by
the faculty of Harvard. I sort of feel that way about the United Nations General Assembly.
So I don't mean to suggest that you have to be a big cheerleader for the United Nations.
The question is the principle. As long as we recognize the principle that governments
are subject to some kind of moral rules, then we can leave aside, for our purposes anyway,
how would you enforce those rules? Because, of course, as soon as you establish a United
Nations to govern the interaction of states, the question then becomes, well, who's going
to govern the United Nations? You haven't really solved the problem. Who's going to
make sure the United Nations is doing the right thing? So that's another matter. How
do you enforce international law? Perhaps you could try to do it through moral suasion
or threatening to make the offending state an international pariah with whom no one will
trade. These are possibilities. Right now, I simply want to look at the principles the
Church upheld. Now, in the 16th century, from the 15th into the 16th centuries, Spanish
theologians and individuals began to get reports coming back from the New World of Spanish
mistreatment of the natives there. And this provoked a severe crisis of conscience among
Spain's philosophers and theologians, because they began to ask themselves, how should we
interact with these new peoples? Is our own government upholding the moral standards in
which we claim to believe? So what it did was it provoked a lot of reflection about
the nature of moral obligation, and in particular, the nature of moral obligation on the international
sphere. So that is to say, they began asking themselves crucial questions. How should different
peoples interact with each other? How should governments interact with each other? Are
there absolute rules that should be observed? Well, this interaction between Spaniards and
the peoples of the New World provided an unprecedented opportunity for theologians suddenly to entertain
these questions. And this is where the idea of international law comes from, as these
Spanish theologians are critically evaluating the behavior of their own government. They
are deciding that, yes, there are moral rules, and in fact, in some cases, our own government
is not obeying them. Now, the very fact that there was a crisis of conscience among Spanish
theologians is itself significant, because think, did Attila the Hun ever stop and say,
you know, I shouldn't be looting and raping and pillaging like this. I mean, how dare
I do these things? These people have rights just as I do. Well, of course, it never even
occurred to him to ask questions like that. Or the Aztecs, for example, who engaged in
human sacrifice. We have absolutely no record of any soul-searching that occurred in Aztec
civilization of people stepping back and impartially evaluating their own society and saying, you
know what, maybe we shouldn't be ripping the hearts out of people. You know, maybe this
is the wrong thing to do. Maybe this is a barbaric custom. We have absolutely no indication
of any such critical tradition there. And yet, within the Catholic Church, when Spanish
theologians look at the behavior of their government in the New World, that's exactly
what they do, is they begin asking these questions and they begin saying, should we behave this
way? And are there, in fact, general rules we should observe that apply to all peoples?
Attila the Hun didn't believe in rules that apply to all peoples. There were rules that
applied to him and rules that applied to everybody else. And that has been the typical way peoples
have understood their interaction with the world. We are the good people, everybody else
is a barbarian, and we treat them accordingly. So this is an advance of no small significance.
Now we're coming up to the break, but when we come back, we're going to meet a figure
of extraordinary importance, Fr. Francisco de Vitoria, who was a professor at the University
of Salamanca, to which I have referred many a time. And it was Fr. Francisco de Vitoria
who gave us the very first treatise in history on international law, setting out these principles.
So let's come on back and look at that, here on The Catholic Church, Builder of Civilization.
Welcome back to The Catholic Church, Builder of Civilization. I'm Thomas Woods. We're looking
today at international law. It sounds like kind of a dry subject, but as you can see,
it actually isn't at all, because the idea of international law simply means that there
are certain fixed rules that everybody has to observe, and that you can't say that this
people is more backward than we are, or they haven't achieved what we have, so we can just
trample them and this and that. There's nothing like that in what the Catholic Church teaches.
Now just before the break, we were talking about what happened when people in Spain began
to hear about some of the abuses toward the natives of the New World at the hands of some
Spaniards. And so in fact, Spanish theologians began thinking about all the implications
and consequences of this. They began thinking about the questions they needed to ask. Are
there rules that should govern the interaction of peoples? What are those rules? Is our own
government living up to those rules? Well, Father Francisco de Vitoria, whom I mentioned
immediately before the break, was a professor at the University of Salamanca, and he has
sometimes been called, along with the Dutch Protestant Hugo Grotius, who came much later,
the father of international law. In fact, a man named James Brown Scott, writing in
the 1920s in a book called The Spanish Origin of International Law, tells us that Vitoria
furnished the world of his day with its first masterpiece on the law of nations, in peace
as well as in war. Now in a separate episode, we've discussed a little bit of the ins and
outs of the just war theory. Now, what Vitoria was interested in was determining the treatment
to which all human beings were entitled by right, by natural right, because they were
human beings. And he insisted that these rights that people possessed came from their status
as human beings rather than because they were Catholics or anything else, Europeans, Spaniards,
so the right not to be killed or not to be robbed. This comes to you not because, well,
you're Catholic or you're of my race. It comes to you because you're a human being with a
rational nature. And the exercise of these rights is the way in which you can live out
your rational nature. You need to have a right to life. You need to have a right to own property
in order to function in the world. So these things are natural rights, and they are rights
that apply to everybody. So what this means in principle, in practice as well, is that
no Catholic would argue that it's a less serious crime to kill somebody who's not baptized
and a more serious crime to kill a baptized person because the baptized person is more
important or something like that. Absolutely not. That is not what the Church teaches.
And to the contrary, Father Domingo de Soto, who is Vitoria's colleague at the University
of Salamanca, said this. He said, those who are in the grace of God, that is good, faithful
Catholics, are not a whit better off than the sinner or the pagan in what concerns natural
rights. Now again, isn't that kind of the opposite of the impression I think people
have about the Church over the years? I think people have this impression that the Church
would be inclined to give certain favor to those who belong to the household of faith.
But to the contrary, as we see here, some of her finest thinkers in the 16th century
say, if not the opposite, then they state something that is true for everybody. That
all these rights are to be enjoyed equally by everybody because we all share a common
human nature. And we aren't, incidentally, just a clump of cells. We are human beings
with dignity, and that dignity demands these rights. Now what does Vitoria conclude looking
at the situation of his government and the peoples of the New World? He said that the
peoples of the New World, because they were human, they were human beings, just as we
Spaniards are human beings, they were equal to us. They were equal to us in matters pertaining
to natural rights. They owned their lands by the same principles that we Spaniards own
our own. And he also argued that, and incidentally his fellow scholastics agreed with him, Domingo
de Soto, Molina, and others, that pagan princes ruled legitimately. That is to say, if a pagan
king has committed no other crime, he can't simply be thrown out and deposed because he's
a pagan. Now that too, I think, is the opposite of what people think. People would think that
the Church believes that if a ruler is non-Catholic, they can just go in and throw him out and
put a Catholic there. Well, in a certain way, I mean, I bet in the United States we wish
we could do that sometimes. But that's not what the Church teaches. What the Church teaches
and what Vitoria teaches here is that each state has the same rights as any other, the
same rights to self-government, and is under an obligation to respect the rights of others.
So regardless of the religion of the ruler, if that ruler has committed no other crime,
nobody has a right to just topple him for no reason other than he's a non-Catholic.
You can't simply do that. Now Vitoria and his supporters also believe that the idea
of natural law existed not just among Christians, but among all peoples. Now natural law, of
course, is the idea that there are laws that are in effect written in our human heart that
we simply know. When you're a child, you know. You know these laws. You know when little
children are running around, they're saying, hey, that's mine, give it back. They understand
certain aspects of what it means to be just and fair, that I had this property first,
and it's unjust for someone to confiscate it from me. And they understand perfectly
well that if they take something from somebody else, they cry when you punish them, but typically
they understand the punishment. They don't say, Mom, Dad, I have a whole philosophical
argument against why you're punishing me. They know. They know in their heart they've
done something wrong. Well, we have these senses of what is right and wrong. We also
have the Ten Commandments in our own tradition, but according to Vitoria, the Ten Commandments
are really spelling out principles that practically any people, really, if they reflect long enough,
will understand and appreciate. And because we all possess this kind of sense of right
and wrong, a basic sense, then this basic sense can become the basis for international
rules of conduct. And these rules of conduct can morally bind even those who've never heard
the Gospel, or never heard of the Ten Commandments, or had even rejected the Gospel, because we're
basing ourselves on the idea that we all ultimately know that sheer conquest is wrong, and looting
and pillaging is wrong. We know this because God has imprinted it on our hearts, and this
becomes the basis for a common understanding of international obligation. Now, that is
to say that peoples such as the peoples of the New World were thought to possess this
basic sense of right and wrong, summed up in the Ten Commandments and in the Golden
Rule, and so we could interact with them on the understanding that they understand these
principles, but we have to understand and live according to them too. So what this means
is that in the 16th century, Spanish theologians looked at the behavior of their own civilization.
They held it up to critical scrutiny, and they found it wanting. They looked and said,
we have failed to live up to the absolute moral standard that binds all people. They
proposed that in matters of natural right, the other peoples of the world were their
equals, and that the commonwealths, even of pagan peoples, were entitled to the same treatment
that the nations of Christian Europe accorded to one another. Now, that is something extraordinary
in the history of the world, and we in no way wish to make light of what happened to
the peoples in the New World, because many of them perished, sometimes in terrible circumstances,
oftentimes due to disease, a non-volitional source, sometimes due to overwork, and it
was something terrible in some ways, what happened to a great many of these people.
But the very fact that the Spaniards could step back and say, my people have failed to
live up to an absolute standard, is something new in the world. A historian named Louis
Hankey wrote a book called, The Spanish Struggle for Justice in the Conquest of America. Now,
that's a strange title, isn't it? But what he's talking about is precisely what we've
seen here. The Spanish theologians attempt to devise rules that would bind everybody
and that would establish justice in the world, and their ability, the Spaniards' ability
to look objectively at these foreign peoples and recognize their common humanity was no
small achievement. In fact, this type of impartiality, this ability to look at the peoples of the
world and be willing to apply the same rules to other peoples that you apply to your own,
and that you would abide by the same rules that you expect others to abide by, this impartiality
is not exactly embedded in every civilization. In fact, we need look no further, for example,
than the American Indian cultures, which, for whatever their merits, did not possess
the ability to look impartially at the world and hold themselves up to a common moral standard.
The Harvard historian Samuel Elliott Morrison said that the Indians of the same region or
language group did not even have a common name for themselves, and that each tribe called
itself something like, we the people, and referred to its neighbors by a word that meant
the barbarians, or sons of she-dog, or something equally insulting. Well, if that's your view,
that you are the people and everybody else are the barbarians or sons of the she-dog,
how are you going to be able to come up with impartial rules governing both you and the
barbarians? It's not going to happen. So the idea of an international order of states,
some large, some small, of varying levels of civilization and refinement, operating
on a principle of equality, one toward the other, this could not have found fertile ground
amid that kind of narrow chauvinism, a kind of chauvinism that has been all too prevalent
in the history of the world. So it's thanks to the Catholic conception of the fundamental
unity of the human race that we're able to think in terms of universal principles governing
all peoples. So when we criticize Spanish excesses in the new world, therefore, it's
largely thanks to the moral tools provided by the Catholic theologians of Spain itself
that we're able to do so. The Peruvian poet Mario Vargas Llosa, when he spoke about these
Spanish critics of their own government's policy, he said this, they fought against
their fellow men and against the policies of their own country in the name of a moral
principle that to them was higher than any principle of nation or state. This self-determination,
this capacity for criticism of your own civilization could not have been possible among the Incas
or any of the other pre-Hispanic cultures. In these cultures, as in the other great civilizations
of history foreign to the West, the individual could not morally question the social organism
of which he was a part. Well, let's conclude now by saying that we have seen that, in theory,
the Catholic Church has set up and established and defended these universal moral principles.
Perhaps they have been observed in the breach at times, but these are the principles. The
additional principle, of course, is that there's to be no forced conversion. That's in canon
law. All these things are Catholic principles. What we're going to see next time is an aspect
of modern history that's often been forgotten, when anti-Catholic or atheistic states in
effect establish the opposite principle, that people have the opposite of rights because
they're Catholic. Because they're Catholic, they can be imprisoned or tortured or killed.
And we are once again going to see this glorious witness of Catholics in the face of devastation.
Join me for The Catholic Church, Builder of Civilization.
