China and Japan traded sharp accusations during right-of-reply exchanges at the UN General Assembly. Beijing accused Tokyo of “remilitarization,” expanding long-range strike capabilities and failing to fully confront its wartime past. Japan rejected those claims, defended its security policy as strictly defensive, reaffirmed its non-nuclear principles and argued that the UN Charter’s “enemy state” clauses are obsolete.
China and Japan Clash at UNGA Over Militarism, Security Policy and Wartime History “Japan’s Remilitarization Is a Real Threat”: China Fires Warning, Tokyo Hits Back Japan Rejects China’s Militarism Charge in Fiery UNGA Right of Reply Exchange
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
China responds to statements from Japan and the Philippines, accusing Japan of re-militarization and rejecting the South China Sea arbitration award. Separately, Burundi denies allegations of aligning with the FDLR in the DRC, asserting its military presence is based on a legal bilateral agreement. Japan maintains its commitment to a defense-oriented policy and its history of remorse.
I now call on the representative of China.
President, China would like to exercise its right of reply in response to the
statements by Japan and the Philippines. In his statement on September 22,
second, Japan stated that as a peace-loving nation, it is committed to its exclusively
defense-oriented policy and calls for the deletion of the enemy state clauses from the UN Charter.
China firmly opposes this. Rather than what Japan says,
the international community should care more about what Japan does.
In the course of history, Japanese militarists brazenly launched wars of aggression
and committed numerous heinous crimes, including the illegal occupation of China's islands and
reefs in the South China Sea, inflicting immense suffering on the people of China and the region.
Back then, Japan joined the UN after recognizing its militarist crimes and accepting the UN
Charter in its entirety. The post-war country for peace image that Japan seeks to establish
can only be realized by repenting its history and making a clear break from militarism.
However, more than 80 years later, the Takeuchi government turns a blind eye to Japan's historical
crimes. Instead of self-reflection, it has spared no effort to glorify and whitewash them.
By fabricating narratives about threats from neighboring countries, among others,
it attempts to cover up its ongoing expansion of military capacities.
In recent years, Japan has been drastically increasing military spending, relaxing restrictions
on export of lethal weapons, advancing the deployment of intermediate and long-range
missiles, strengthening offensive military capacities, stockpiling large amounts of
pushing for amending its pacifist constitution, attempting to break free from the three
non-nuclear principles, and even clamoring for becoming a war-capable nation.
All these facts are proof that Japan's re-militarization has become a real threat
to regional and global peace and stability. Upholding the post-war international order,
defending the outcomes of the victory of World War II, and maintaining regional peace and stability
are the shared responsibilities of the international community.
The enemy state clauses in the UN Charter are a vital institutional arrangement aimed at preventing
fascism and militarism from threatening international peace and security ever again.
They provide important institutional safeguards for defending the post-war international order
and remain extremely relevant today. Any attempt to deny or glorify the history of aggression,
revive militarism, or challenge the post-war international order
runs counter to peace and justice and will be firmly rejected by all peace-loving nations and
people. This year marks the 81st anniversary of the founding of the UN and the 80th anniversary
of the beginning of the Tokyo Trials. China hereby issues its stern warning to Japan's
right-wing forces that Japan's only correct path is to strictly abide by its international
obligations, make a clean break from militarism, and stick to peaceful development.
Those running the Japanese government should face history squarely, conduct deep reflections,
and earn the trust of its Asian neighbors and the international community through concrete actions.
China will work with all the peace-loving nations in the world to resolutely contain
Japan's neo-militarism under the cloak of becoming a normal country and prevent it
from getting rampant and from destabilizing and disrupting the region and the world.
Regarding the statement by the Philippines on September 26, China has consistently maintained
that the UN is not the appropriate forum to discuss the South China Sea issue.
However, China finds it necessary to issue a solemn response to the relevant erroneous
claims by the Philippines. China's position on the South China Sea arbitration is consistent and
clear. The Philippines, in a natural initiation of the so-called arbitration, violated such basic
principles of international law as state consent and pacta sunt servanda, and violated international
law, including UNCLOS. In rendering the award, the arbitration tribunal exceeded its authority
and abused its jurisdiction. The award is illegal now and void. It has seriously undermined the
principles and spirit of the Convention and substantially impaired the authority and
integrity of the international law of the sea. China neither accepts nor recognizes the so-called
award and opposes and will never accept any claim or action arising from it. This is both
to safeguard China's own territorial maritime rights and interests and to uphold the international
law of the sea and a fair and equitable international maritime order. The Philippines'
attempt to play up the fact that a decade has passed since the so-called award is utterly
meaningless. The fact is that the award not only cannot solve maritime issues between China and
the Philippines, but has increasingly become a tool for the Philippines to expand its territorial
maritime claims, aggravating regional tension, and becoming a stumbling block to China-Philippines'
relations and to peace and stability in the South China Sea. On territorial issues and maritime
delimitation disputes, China does not accept any dispute settlement solution imposed upon it,
and has consistently advocated resolving disputes through negotiation and consultation with the
countries directly concerned. China will continue to work with ASEAN countries to jointly safeguard
peace and stability in the South China Sea. Thank you, President.
Burundi firmly repudiates the allegation issued by the delegation of Rwanda, according to which
the national defence forces of Burundi operating in the DRC have supposedly been aligned to the
FLDR. This information has no legal foundation whatsoever. The presence of Burundian forces in
the DRC has a clear legal underpinning. That is the bilateral cooperation agreement for defence
signed on 6 March 2023 in Burundi between the Government of Burundi and the Government of the
DRC. This agreement also authorises, as appropriate, the conduct of joint operations.
The deployment of the FDNB in the DRC is thus being conducted at the request of,
with the explicit consent of the Congolese authorities, in accordance with the provisions
of this agreement. It is important to underscore that this legal and consent-based presence cannot
be likened to that of the LDF, whose military engagement in the DRC is being conducted without
the authorisation of the Congolese states and, in other terms, is in a violation of its sovereignty
and the notion of the inviolability of its borders. Any attempt to establish a parallel
cooperation between Burundi and the DRC in activities conducted by armed groups,
such as the FDLR, is an act of defamation and a distortion of reality.
Burundi is not in line with any armed group operating against a neighbouring state. Burundi
remains committed to regional stability, to the fight against armed groups and to
stringent compliance with the principle of the sovereignty of states. Its cooperation with the
state-to-state cooperation is based on formal agreements made between two sovereign governments.
Burundi reaffirms that its military presence in the DRC falls within the exclusive purview
of a bilateral framework and has no direct or indirect link to the FDLR. Faithful to the
principles of the United Nations Charter, Burundi remains committed to dialogue,
regional cooperation and the peaceful resolution of conflicts.
to the minimum necessary to ensure Japan's security in the face of the most
severe and complex security environment since the end of World War II.
Under the constitution, Japan adheres to the basic policy of exclusively maintaining
national defence-oriented policy without becoming a military power that poses a threat to other
countries. Also, Japan firmly maintains the three non-nuclear principles. Japan will never
change the course it has taken as a peace-loving nation. Regarding so-called enemy state clauses
in the UN Charters, UN General Resolution 50-52, adopted with overwhelming support,
including that of China in 1995, recognised these clauses as obsolete. Furthermore,
UNGA Resolution 60-1, adopted by consensus including the leaders of China in 2005,
resolved to defeat differences to enemy states from the UN Charter. Regarding the issues relating
to history, I must make it clear. All nations must be humble about their history, and Japan has
squarely faced its history. As former Prime Minister Shinzo Abe clearly stated in his statement
on 14 August 2015, that Japan has repeatedly expressed the feelings of deep remorse and
heartfelt apologies for its actions during the war, and that such positions articulated by
previous cabinets will remain unshakable into the future. The current administration has upheld in
its entirety the positions of previous cabinets in history, including their Prime Minister's
and will continue to do so. Reflecting upon the past eight decades, Japan has consistently walked
the path of a peace-loving nation and has consistently contributed to peace and prosperity
in the international community since the end of World War II. This is widely and accurately
recognized and highly appreciated by the international community. Freedom,
democracy, and fundamental human rights remain unshakable foundations of Japan's
every decision and action. Guided by these principles, Japan has made assiduous efforts
to promote the rule of law in international society, stressing the importance of compliance
with international law, including the UN Charter. I thank you.