How many Christian marriages today are steeped in the pain of secret abuse? Karen DeArmond Gardner is a survivor of domestic abuse that lasted over 30 years. She knows firsthand what women need to experience freedom from the lies of abuse. She is a pastoral trauma coach and advocate who provides crisis support for women seeking to break free from abusive relationships. Karen delivers insight and perspective on how spousal abuse can often lurk in the shadows, and how women often blame themselves for something that is not their fault. What does abuse look like? Does God really forbid Christians from getting divorced? Karen breaks down the well-meaning but sometimes damaging pieces of advice women often receive in the church about marriage - and how to think about it with a fresh perspective.
TAKEAWAYS
The Scripture does not forbid spouses from leaving an abusive marriage
Women cannot “influence” abusive spouses out of their behavior
Abusers often make their spouses feel like they’re the problem, when nothing could be further from the truth
Abused victims often begin to feel responsible for their spouse’s behavior
Tina Griffin and trauma coach Karen DeArmond Gardner discuss the complexities of domestic violence within Christian marriages. They examine coercive control, the weaponization of religious language to justify abuse, and the psychological traps that keep victims isolated. The conversation emphasizes that abuse is a choice, not a result of trauma, and encourages survivors to prioritize safety and healing.
October is Domestic Violence Awareness Month, and as we close out September, we want to spread hope
and encouragement to anyone trapped in an abusive relationship. When someone leaves an abusive
marriage, life isn't instantly fixed. Women who have experienced domestic violence feel shattered
because of the trauma they've been through a bond with their abuser has formed that keeps them tied
together long after they physically left. Karen DeArmond Gardner understands these difficulties
all too well. She tackled all the same struggles when she left her own abusive marriage. One of
the most courageous choices she could make was to leave. Only it would take her years after leaving
to know just how courageous it was. And she intimately knows what women in this situation
need in order to gain freedom from the lies of abuse to be reborn as the people God longs for
them to be. This is going to be a doozy. Thank you for tuning into the CounterCulture Mom Show. I'm
Tina Griffin. Domestic violence is the hot topic of the week. I'm with Karen DeArmond Gardner,
pastoral trauma coach, advocate, and crisis support. Karen, this is going to be a doozy
of an episode. How are you doing? Welcome. I am doing well. I am excited for this conversation.
I don't even know where to begin with what I just shared. There's a lot of people I know
that are in the situation you're probably going to be talking about today. You work with women
who want to know if what they are experiencing is abuse, women who are out of the horror and are
just trying to survive, and women who are ready to heal the trauma and pain caused by the one who
vowed to love them. I think I'm just going to hit you with a curveball right out of the gate.
Approximately how many marriages in America, Christian marriages, do you think are dealing
with some sort of abuse? That is really hard because all of the numbers are designed around
physical violence, and it's reported physical violence. And often in Christian marriages,
it goes unreported and often it's not physical violence, and so how do we know how many? I think
it could be as high as one in three, high as one in two. In different cultures, Native American,
it's one in two women, and that's reported cases. One in two in the Black community,
in the church, I think it's pretty close. The one place it shouldn't be is in Christianity.
Correct. Correct. And here's what's wild. I think a lot of people who are trapped in it,
which we're going to talk today about how do you know you've been trapped in it? Some people
justify it. They don't think it's that bad or they're used to it or they grew up in that type
of household, so they think it's normal. It's so corrupt. But a lot of people who are probably in
it think that they're one of the only people in the neighborhood, only person on the street,
only person in the family dealing with it, and chances are they are not. It might actually be
the opposite. Oh my gosh. Okay. So let's just nail out something you said that was critical.
Most people, when they hear domestic abuse, they picture physical violence. That's typically what
I would think, but we know it's a lot more than that. What does domestic abuse actually look like,
especially in a Christian marriage where everything may look good from the outside?
It's patterns of behavior. Coercive control is defined as, in simplified terms, it is
the use of threat, the threat of violence to coerce, to control, to manipulate,
and that's in very, very simple terms. Often they don't hit you, they maybe hit you once,
but after that, it's just the threat. A look is enough. If they throw things, they may throw
something at the wall, they may punch the wall, they may pound the tables,
those are things they actually want to do to you but don't. And the abuse of verbal, emotional,
and psychological, we separate them, but yet they're so intertwined that they literally overlap,
and so we can use those terms, but what does that mean? It means she may have the freedom
to do the things that she wants, to go to the store, to take care of the kids, to homeschool,
to work, she has those choices, but when she makes those choices, if they're not in alignment
with his, then there will be consequences to those actions. So it looks like she can spend
all the money she wants, it looks like she's in a happy marriage, she looks like she has freedom,
when in reality, when you get behind closed doors, she has anything but freedom.
Yeah, anything but freedom. And then it strips the purpose, mission, vision that that woman has
that God gave her, and it's like you feel like you're in prison the whole time that you're,
it should be the complete opposite. And honestly, the abuser is missing out on a phenomenal life
as well because when you give your spouse the freedom of who God created them to be,
you receive the benefits of that by your spouse being free in Christ and being able to flourish.
Your love deeper, your love's closer. Do you think people who abuse others, let's just take
a marriage, let's just say it's the husband, and I'm going to ask you a crazy wild question after
that. If the husband is abusing in some way, emotionally, physically, his wife, does that
husband, have they typically been abused themselves in some way in the past? Not
justifying the current actions, but do you find that, or is it more just not the case?
Sometimes. My ex had not been. I think there was maybe some neglect there,
and neglect does have a big impact. Often it's an entitlement, and so abuse is not always
there. And I always do say, abuse is abuse is abuse. Trauma is trauma. So, an abusive situation
could happen one time, or it could happen a hundred times. The impact is the same,
however, the healing process may be longer. But then it really comes down to choice.
I've known people who grew up in horrifically abusive homes, who did not turn out to be
abusers. They chose something different. Different. And you think that most people
in that scenario, if not all, would say, I'm severing that generational curse. I know how
hellish it was to grow up in that domestic violent situation of a home, or abuse, or neglect,
or whatever it is. So, I'm going to make sure, darn well make sure, that when I get married,
I sever that, and it's going to be the complete opposite for my own kids, because I don't want
them to live through the hell that I lived through. And yet, you have these people, and yet you're
saying, who cares what their past was, how they grew up, that has nothing to do with them making
the choice today. So, can you explain that further? And I do agree, because otherwise,
if we use our past, we're justifying our current, woe is me, victim mentality. I'm doing the best I
can with the crap that I grew up in. Explain that it's all based on the decisions that people
are making today, regardless of their past. Yeah, and that's usually the hook. I had a rough
childhood. And so, we then, when you have empathy, because they do, abusers tend to go after women,
because we're talking about husbands and wives, women who are empathetic, who are kind,
especially Christian women. We're forgiving, we believe, we don't believe in divorce,
all of these things set us up, and then we're been taught as women that if we're better,
they'll be better. And so, they use all of that to ingratiate themselves to us, and eventually,
we begin to feel responsible for their behavior. This is all very subtle, you can't just pinpoint
it, but it is how they get us to feel bad for them and to want to help them and then they use a lot of
language around that. So, in Christianity, we're really good at using Christian ease
and Christian language to over-spiritualize, oh, I was just really wounded, and that
gives them a pass. And they are not bad all the time. The pattern is
using kindness, which I believe it's niceness, and nice is a counterfeit of kindness because
kindness is a character of God. But they give us moments of good times and happy times
to keep us in that, but their behavior is it just goes more covert, maybe more overt,
but yet we start saying, oh, daddy just had a really bad day, he had things going on at work,
and we blame outside sources, anything, but saying what your dad just did was really wrong,
that rarely happens in the beginning. And so, often we just think we're in a hard marriage.
People have to literally, basically own their crap, own what is going on with them, and then
we have to see change. Change has to take place. When someone is doing the same thing over and over
again and not changing, it tells me they're doing exactly what you're doing. They're going covert,
overt, hiding behind the scenes, fake niceness, all that business. You got me started here,
got me rolling. We're going to take a commercial break, and we come back. I'm going to let you
tell me what you're thinking about what I just said, and then have a critical question about
if women don't realize that they're being abused, what does she think is actually happening in her
marriage? That is wild. More with Karen right after this. For over six years, I've been sounding
the alarm regarding the dangers of EMF exposure, primarily coming from the towers that were
implemented during the pandemic. I've interviewed countless experts on the show that confirmed my
research. Besides harmful 5G radiation, we are constantly bombarded with EMF exposure from Wi-Fi
routers, smartphones, laptops, smart appliances, all contributing to massive sleep issues,
headaches, fatigue, nausea, dizziness, brain fog, heart palpitations, and even increased
cancer risk. I've been using two Waveguard devices for over six years. I have the key home,
which gives me whole home protection, and the key shield when I'm on the go. Waveguard uses
depolarization technology to significantly reduce EMF radiation without blocking your Wi-Fi or cell
signal. Protect your family now. Use CODETINA at checkout to save 20% off all devices at
waveguard.com. That's waveguard.com CODETINA. You drink water every single day, but what if
your water could do more than simply quench your thirst? Meet Echo Water, the technology that
transforms ordinary water into hydrogen-rich water designed to support your body at the cellular
level. Why is that important? Because every day your body deals with oxidative stress,
from toxins in the environment, exercise, to normal living and aging. Research is exploring
how hydrogen water has the potential to reduce inflammation, boost your energy, improve focus,
sleep, and overall gut health. And here's the beauty of it. You don't have to add another
complicated supplement to your routine. You're already drinking water, so let's upgrade it.
With an outstanding warranty, 60-day money-back guarantee, and free shipping, it's a no-brainer.
Whether you want hydrogen water on the go or a home unit in your kitchen, the Echo Water product
line has it all. Go to echowater.com and get 10% off with CODETINA at checkout. That's CODETINA
at echowater.com. Echo Water provides better health, vitality, and longevity.
The Counterculture Ministries team put our heads together and created the Pop Culture Purge Tour.
This event can be a half a day, full day, or two-day event loaded with eye-opening,
life-changing speakers who have survived or experienced some of the most wild situations in
life and are on fire to share their stories. We have people on our speaking team talking about
public school pipeline to Planned Parenthood. That one's a showstopper. A gifted singer-songwriter
who has a workshop entitled From Me, Me, Me to Christ in Me. A former news anchor reporter
talking about mainstream media madness. Another woman who's a mother of nine and business owner
talking about the education indoctrination. An ex-alcoholic and people pleaser, My Dear Husband,
who's talking about identity crisis. A former homosexual now pastor. A pro-life activist
giving her abortion reversal success story. And so much more. If you want more info on this
life-saving tour, text the word tour to the number 55444. Once again, tour to the number 55444
to get info on all the different speakers that are available and contact Christy on our team
to book an event in your city, town, or backwoods. We've been all over the place,
from schools to prisons to cruise ships. Let's do this.
But religious abusers love using that. I'm in control. I get to make all the final decisions,
and yet that is not how Jesus works. He sacrificed. He loved. He gave himself up,
and it doesn't mean that he makes all the final decisions because God gave us free will. So
why would that, the mindset, that thought process just doesn't hold because of that.
And so, what we think should normally happen is we're going on the assumption that this person
believes that they need to change, and they don't. They do not believe that they are the problem,
that's why they make her the problem, because they do not do anything wrong. When they use
apologies, they only do that to appease us. Oh, and our brain says, oh, they're really sorry,
they didn't mean to do that, and then the pattern begins again, and it happens again.
Some abusers never apologize. Mine never apologized and never admit he did wrong.
Some abusers will admit I did XYZ. They take partial ownership, but they still put it back
on us. They will never, let me say, they will rarely take ownership of their behavior.
They rarely want to change because they don't believe they need to change. They
don't believe that they are the problem.
There's so much I want to say right now. So, I hear what you're saying, and you're rewiring my
brain on this program about the roles, and what I meant about the roles is a little bit different
than what you're saying, but we don't have to go in there, but I hear exactly what you're saying.
I absolutely hear what you're saying. It takes two to parent children, two to make mutual decisions.
In fact, when people come together, husband and wife, to make decisions, and they are the
same decision that the Holy Spirit is leading them to do, it will be the same decision.
They won't be button heads because the Lord will tell both of them the same thing,
Holy Spirit guidance, where it'll be the confirmation with your spouse on a certain
decision you're trying to make. If there's an issue there, then someone's not walking with
the Lord is how I see it. I'm going to have you come back. It depends on what the decision is
that we're trying to make. If they're both biblical, then talk it through.
Often when Tom and I made decisions together, my current husband,
if one of us doesn't feel comfortable, we don't move forward with it.
Correct. I have the same view on that. Then if you wait on God's timing, or if you never do it,
you'll find out why that didn't happen. It's exactly it. You're going with each other,
unified before the Lord, waiting for the green light on both sides. I completely agree.
I'm going to backtrack about two minutes here. When you said
when the abuser thinks that they're not the problem, why do you think that is? What is the
underlying problem with that? Because you can have all these different things and fill in the blank.
They could be a narcissist. They could be strong-willed. What's the reason? Why do people
do that? I don't use the word narcissist or sociopath or psychopath. I just use abuser
because that's what they're doing. We can't diagnose. That's why I use that general term.
But from everything that I have read, they do not want to carry their own pain
and so they are so opposed to carrying their own pain that they offload it onto us.
And as women, we tend to take that on and we don't even know we're doing it.
You can't look back at a day and go, oh, on October 23rd, this is the day that I started
carrying his pain. You can't do that. It happened so slowly. And yet that is such a simple answer
because it's a little more complicated than that, but that in a nutshell is what they do.
If a woman doesn't realize she's being abused and she's in the midst of an abusive relationship,
what does she think is happening in her marriage instead?
She often thinks it's just hard because marriage is hard, but it's not. Marriage shouldn't be hard.
However you can go, we go through hard things in our marriage. But it's toxic,
but if what she does then, or that you're not communicating well, so she goes and gets
some marriage books. She reads all the books, she listens to all the podcasts,
she's trying to find the answer, and all of our Christian marriage books put the burden on
her to be better. If you respect him more, then he'll love you. There was a whole big book on that.
Other books, some written by men, some written by women, that if she just tries harder,
that she can influence her husband to be a better man. And I did that for 30 years and it didn't
work. He actually got worse and worse because he knew that he could. And so, that belief keeps
them trapped thinking, oh, it's just hard, God hates divorce, and in reality, that is not what
the scripture says, and even if he does, he loves us way more than he hates divorce.
There are so many more scriptures about abuse where God says he hates, he detests when someone
violates their family, when they destroy their family. Paul tells us to stay away from these
people who love themselves, who just create conflict and slander and lie and do all of
these things, Paul says, stay away from them. And one of the scriptures in Titus,
Paul said to Titus, everything is pure to those whose hearts are pure, but nothing is pure to
those who are corrupt and unbelieving. Because their minds and consciences are corrupted,
such people claim they know God, but they deny him by the way they live. They are detestable
and disobedient, worthless for doing anything good. We think because they talk about him,
because they go to church and they pray and go to deliverance, do all the things,
that they're just someone that needs to be fixed. They need to be delivered from whatever is going
on, and the opposite is entirely, it's true. And we women keep trying. Like, what kind of God
expects a woman to stay in a marriage where she is being harmed, destroyed, her identity is being
destroyed, where she's expected to bow down and to put up with all this trauma and abuse?
What kind of God would expect that?
You fight every single day for your kids, for what they eat, what they learn, what they watch.
So why would you settle for healthcare that doesn't fight for your family too?
I'm Tina Griffin, and for over 15 years, MediShare has been one of the best decisions
I've ever made for my family. I've had all four of my children with MediShare,
gone through two major surgeries, and every eligible bill has been shared by this outstanding
community of believers. Here's what makes MediShare stand out. Members can save up to
50% compared to other healthcare options. You get 24-7 telehealth access for those late night
sick kid moments, nationwide provider access, and no annual caps or lifetime limits. In addition,
your dollars only go towards supporting other families who share your values.
Over 320,000 members have trusted MediShare since 1993. And the best part? You can join at any time.
Visit MediShare.com forward slash Tina. That's MediShare.com forward slash Tina to get your
personalized pricing today. Or call 1-866-88-BIBLE. Keep standing strong.
I just learned that at birth, we have peak levels of IGF-1, insulin-like growth factor 1,
which assists in muscle development, tissue repair, and recovery.
Over time, IGF-1 levels naturally decline, contributing to the aging process.
Women who want to stay young usually take the synthetic HDH, human growth hormone,
but it's expensive, not safe, and there's a much better natural option.
Through scientific research, deer antler velvet has been identified as a top method of increasing
and maintaining IGF-1 levels. Neutronix Labs developed IGF-1 supplements made from premium
deer antler velvet. Get a powerful immune system, support regular heart and joint function,
build lean muscle, burn fat, grow great hair, skin, and nails, and sleep like a baby. Use
code TINA to get half off with auto shipping at GetIGF1.com. A free bottle of Sleep Miracle,
$95 value, and a free bottle of 300k IGF-1 Plus, a $350 value, is included.
Just use code TINA at GetIGF1, the number one, dot com.
Karen, your website, I know people are going to be flooding there right now. Everybody out there,
don't worry. We have three more, if not more, critical questions we're going to be asking
Karen in part two for tomorrow's episode. We have to do a part two on the fly here.
I can't rush through these questions and we can't skip any of them. Karen, your website is
entitled AnotherOneFree.com. Unreal URL, I love it. AnotherOneFree.com,
what can we find on this fantastic site? Well, it has a few blogs. It's just laying out
abuse, the access to coaching services about my book, Hope for Healing from Domestic Abuse.
Most of where you can find me is on Facebook or Instagram. On Facebook under Another One Free,
I am posting about domestic abuse. Matter of fact, right before we got on this call,
I had someone I didn't know send me a message thanking me for speaking out and saying the
things that need to be said. It was just the timing of her sending me that text.
I get those randomly, like, keep doing what you're doing. I've been out for 21 years
and I did not know I could heal. I did not know at all. I really didn't start healing.
Most of my healings happened since 2019. Unreal, wow, like way after. You have a five-star book
on Amazon. Everybody has to get their hands on it immediately. It's called Hope for Healing from
Domestic Abuse, Reaching for God's Promise of Real Freedom. Grab a copy of this today. Grab
some for your friends. You can buy it with one click on Amazon. Hope for Healing from Domestic
Abuse, Reaching for God's Promise of Real Freedom. Karen, I know it's going to share a lot about your
story, what you went through, how you got out of it. Hope and Healing for Today, all in that book.
We're going to talk more about it in tomorrow's episode. Thank you for saying yes to part two on
the fly. Domestic abuse, domestic violence is the theme and the message for the month of October.
We want to make sure we covered that hot topic. So share this episode. Karen, I'll talk to you
here in two seconds. Don't go anywhere. Thanks for everything that you do.