The commercial real estate (CRE) market is facing severe pressure as delinquency rates climb past post-2008 levels. In this video, we break down why rising default rates on commercial mortgage-backed securities (CMBS) and dropping property valuations could trigger a major wave of stress across regional and commercial banks.
We explore the impact on bond markets (TLT), the banking sector (XLF), yield curve movements, and what these macro signals mean for your portfolio and broader financial markets
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
The commercial real estate (CRE) market is facing a severe crash as rising interest rates turn paper losses into realized losses. With office delinquency rates exceeding 2008 levels and valuations plummeting, the instability threatens regional banks and CMBS holders, signaling a potential systemic financial crisis and a broader economic downturn.
Many small and mid-sized regional banks will not survive as the commercial real estate crash is
moving from paper losses to realized losses. And the problem is, it's worse than it was during the
financial crisis. And check this out, because office delinquency rates have now surpassed
their post 2008 crisis levels. And I want you to look back to 2008. We didn't hit peak until some
four years later. And office delinquencies, they were over 10%. Today, they're touching just shy of
12%. And what about those commercial mortgage-backed securities? These are things that
are hiding in your 401k and your IRA that you think, I probably don't own them. But you actually
do. They're buried in there. And you can see the delinquency rate on those is up over 10% in 2012.
Today, again, just shy of 8%. And the proof this is going to impact banks, and in a big way,
look at this. Commercial banks and thrifts, commercial mortgage-backed securities,
life insurance companies, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, together, these investors hold more than
80% of commercial mortgage debt outstanding. Meaning, if we see these delinquencies break
out even higher, and we see the economy start to crumble like we did back in 2008,
it means we're going to see banks fail once again, and massive government bailouts. Because for years
after COVID, loans were modified, maturities were pushed out, and buildings were given more
time to recover. Because interest rates, at least the hope was they were going to come down.
And you may remember, years ago, we talked about how this was going to be at the epicenter of the
next crisis. And yet, it didn't happen. And it was all because banks were doing something called
extend and pretend, and hope things were going to get better. The problem is, they're not.
Because many owners are reaching the end of the runway with rates still elevated,
and buildings now worth dramatically less than the debt that's sitting against them.
And their only option is to walk away, turn the keys back over to the banks,
and leave them holding the bank. And here's some evidence.
Chicago's Aon Center, it was worth $712 million back in 2015. Well, its latest appraisal came in
at $195 million. That's a decline of roughly 73% from its 2015 purchase price. And think about
this. It's all about comps, just like with residential real estate. As more of these
buildings get marked down and sold, next thing you know, everybody's valuation is going to drop.
And the problem is for the banks. They're keeping the valuation back at peak level saying,
we think this is worth it. Because if they had to write them down,
these banks would become insolvent overnight. But the problem is, we can see as we look around
the country, values in US central business districts, they've already tumbled almost
50% since 2022. So this is a real issue for the banks. And again, they're hiding it,
they're covering up. The problem is, they can't do it much longer. And the situation for them,
it's about to get a whole lot worse. Because what we're seeing are situations like this are
beginning to pile up across the country. Office loads packaged into commercial mortgage-backed
securities. And again, these are the things that get sold out to your 401k and IRAs,
all in these little bond funds that you're investing in. You think they can't have any
of this garbage. Well, I promise you it's in there somewhere. We're now seeing delinquency
rates sitting at 12% according to TREP. And when we look at the bigger picture,
64 billion of office commercial mortgage-backed loans come due this year and next. With nearly
40 billion that pile already delinquent in default or flagged as potentially troubled.
And now you're thinking, well, Steve, well, you know, 64 billion, that isn't really that much.
The problem is that's what we see today. And that's at the current state. If the economy
gets worse, and I'm going to show you why. For the banks and these office buildings,
things are about to get a whole lot worse. That number is going to jump. And again,
this is only beginning. Remember back in 2008, it started, it wasn't some four years later,
after the crisis even ended, that things got out of control. And as Polpo Capital's Dan McNamara
put it, one of the scariest headlines is that office commercial mortgage-backed securities
delinquencies are higher than after 2008. And it's going to go higher, he says, as we face
more maturities. Because it's really simple math here. All of these office owners thought they're
going to be able to refi at lower and lower interest rates. That was what's going to save
them. Today, they're facing substantially higher rates. And we can already see this flowing into
many of the funds you own. Because if you got something with PIMCO, well, check this out.
But before we get to what's going on with PIMCO, if you're asking Steve,
how do we take what you're talking about and put real money in my pocket? Let's take a look at this
recent trade we put on with our subscribers. Now we got stopped out of this for a nice gain,
but this was SEF. We were actually short the large banks here on that move down that we're
talking about right now. So if you're looking for our next big trade, or maybe you're saying,
Steve, I don't have time to trade. I just need to know what to do with my portfolio before this
unwinds. Well, we've taken all of our signals from both of our trade reports. We've got tactical
sectoral momentum and risk style models embedded in both of our reports. We make this so easy for
you. We give you the exact trade. We tell you exactly when to buy it. And we give you all the
risk control levels you need. Now, what do you have to do? Well, all you've got to do is grab
those links in the description below, use a coupon code. So you get a free 30 day trial. That's right.
You can try out my systems completely for free and join us because when this hits,
there's gonna be huge opportunity. And I want you to be right there with us. Because now PIMCO
is facing a triple A debt loss after an 85% write down of office complex. And I want you to be
thinking about this triple A paper. Remember what else was triple A? Well, home mortgages. And what
happened? People insured against them. And they said, again, these can never fail. This is a risk
free trade. Just buy insurance against these. You're going to make a fortune. And next thing
you know, they all started to fall apart. And now for PIMCO, they're facing severe losses. Look at
this. A 368 million commercial mortgage backed security backed by the center square building
was appraised for 471 million back in 2019. A judge last month approved the sale of the complex
for a mere $70 million. And that 85% decline in value means even the bonds safest slices. So I
want you to understand what happened here. They took this and they packaged it in bonds, just like
they did with mortgages. And then they sliced it up again. Remember all those tranches you heard
about during the financial crisis? Again, triple A all the way down. They're doing the exact same
thing with office complexes. And here you can see it was once rated triple A and that is going to
get hit. While the holders of the seven lower ranking tranches are going to be completely wiped
out. And again, this is just the beginning of something I warned about three years ago. And
that extended, pretend it's all coming to an end. And even Bank of America is jumping on this as we
now look to Alan Todd, who's the head of their commercial mortgage backed security strategy.
He ran his own recovery analysis. And he says, you're definitely going to see more of this over
the next year or two. More of these loans will come due and borrowers are going to run out of
options. And the problem is, as we saw back looking at the financial crisis, it peaked
four years after 2008. So if he's saying, look, this is just the beginning, where are we going
to be four years from now? Particularly if we start to see a lot of layoffs, we see the economy
slow down, or even interest rates stay elevated. So a loss at the triple A level would mark just
the third time since the financial crisis that investors in a top rated commercial mortgage
backed security have gotten hit, meaning this whole thing is not supposed to happen. And it's
going to get a whole lot worse. Let's take a look at some evidence. This first chart, we've got
commercial real estate prices for the US, it's on a year over year rate of change in blue against
the unemployment rate in red. So why did we see four years after things get pretty ugly? Well,
you can see as a financial crisis took off, and the unemployment rate rose into 2010,
what happened? Commercial real estate prices completely crashed. Now they didn't recover
till 2012. But by then, it was too late, the delinquency rate was out of control.
Because if you've got office space, and you don't need it, because you've been laying people off,
well, who's holding the bank? That's right, the building owner. But the problem is, the Fed right
now is completely in denial. It's not just about the labor market. It's about interest rate policy
as well. But yet, Fed's hammock says yields reflect growth, US debt and rate path, meaning
everything's okay. But what she can't see here is let's now take that same chart and overlay gross
domestic product in red. And we go back to 2008. What happened? The economy was doing just fine.
But what did we see? Commercial real estate prices were dropping. They entered a contraction
right there in 2008 as it dropped below that horizontal black line. And what happened? The
economy followed. And look at where we are today. The same setup. Everybody's saying, look, the
economy is booming. We need higher interest rates. Can't you see all the growth and the inflation
expectations rising? Commercial real estate saying, you've no idea what's about to hit.
And higher interest rates, they're only making it worse. And hammock said that adding that
investors are pricing and more rate hikes from the Fed saying, look, we need more hikes.
Interest rates have to go up. And the commercial real estate center saying, no.
And the small and mid-sized regional banks that are holding this paper are saying, we don't want
this. Because if these things go into actual default, we're going insolvent. And the next
financial crisis is going to hit. And it all has to do right now with the fact that it's interesting.
It's not the labor market that hasn't broken yet. But now as we look at 30-year yields,
5.5% sitting in a vacuum, what we're facing here, technical analysis are saying, hey, look,
this thing's going to get a whole lot worse. Rates are going to go to 6%, 7%, maybe even 8%.
The problem is if they were to, it's unlikely that's even going to happen.
What you're going to see first is commercial real estate and the banks are going to implode.
Because there's no real technical levels for people to hang on to here. And it leaves things
in a bit of a vacuum. And that allows yields just to keep drifting higher and higher,
suggesting that the only path for rates is to go up. And that's why we're seeing now the 30-year
yield topping 5.5%. Because everybody's betting on higher interest rates. But something has changed
here. Now let's dive into the charts because I really want you to see there's opportunities here
all over the place. Let's start out by looking at TLT over the last six months. And of course,
we know price dropped really big on Wednesday and Thursday. And then again, something changed here
on Friday. But I want you to focus on the volume here. Those are those cayenne bars. And look at
where volume was going up to the last two months. You can see it started to actually rise. And what
this is suggesting is as bond prices fell, more and more people were looking to sell, but people
were looking to buy. And as we got into September, what happened, the volume here really picked up.
And it really picked up on those two down days as people were unloading, but there were eager buyers
standing right by. And then what happened on Friday? The expectations was this thing was
going to go down even more. And if you own any of this stuff, you better get rid of it and fast.
But what keeps happening? Buyers are showing up. And who are some of these buyers? The people that
realize that these banks and these loans are toast. And they want to hold on to some good paper
because they know the government's far more solid than commercial real estate. And you can see what
happened on Friday with TLT. It dropped just like it did the first two days at the open. And next
buyers continue to step in, throw prices back up on very strong volume. So what we're seeing here
is while Wall Street is telling you, don't touch interest rates, they're only going higher. Can't
you see the tiger bulls here? Nobody wants to buy it. What you can actually see is evidence
that people do want to buy it for good reason. Because when you zoom back and look at commercial
real estate prices, what is a big impact on that is rising interest rates. And you can see going
financial crisis. Same thing as now. Everybody wanted higher interest rates as 30-year yields
were rising. But the commercial real estate market said no. And as it started to decline and contract,
what happened? Rates came crashing down. Today, everybody once again wants higher interest rates.
Commercial real estate and the banks are saying, no, we don't. But next thing you know,
this is all likely to come unglued and fast. Because when we look at delinquency rates,
now this of commercial real estate loans, what you can see is you have these periods,
again, going back to 1999. Where do you see? Rising interest rates. There's a 30-year going up. And
what happens? The delinquency rate starts to rise. Next thing you know, everybody that was shorting
the bond market finds out they're on the wrong side of the trade. Same thing going into the
financial crisis and soon to be what we're seeing right now. Because again, Trump is saying, look,
the government data is not reflecting this yet. Problem is everybody who's short is looking at a
potential massive squeeze. It's all due to the yield curve. Because Friday's yield moves widen
the gaps between short and long-term yields with key segments such as a two to 10-year and five to
30-year rebounding from the lowest level in more than a year. So let's look at the yield curve here.
And I want you to understand what you're looking at. Because what the issue at hand is, if you
believe the Fed's got to raise rates here, that means what has to have to go up, the long rates.
Because in a normal healthy bond market, you have short-term rates that are lower than
intermediate-term rates that are lower than long-term rates. The problem is we're starting
to see that dynamic shift. And you can see going back into the 1970s and the 1980s and again in
early 2000s, what do you have? The yield curve is rolling over and heading down where it's actually
touching that horizontal black line. And what does that mean? The 2's and 10's are at the same
level. That's not supposed to happen. And what the issue is now is we're seeing it roll over now.
So what it's telling you is yields across the curve are compressing. So the market's saying,
look, that's not normal. And if we think rates are going to go up, that means we have to aggressively
short the longer the curve at every opportunity. Because every time the yield curve, still shown
in blue, gets near that horizontal black line, what happens? The Fed starts to cut rates. Because
the only way to fix that inversion or near-term inversion is to cut policy rates. Because at this
point, the Fed is realizing that the longer the curve is clearly staying, the growth and inflation
expectations are coming down. And the Fed's on the wrong side of the trade. And as with that,
we see market participants as well. Let's take a look, because when we look at net shorts on the
10-year futures, we see they're pretty deep here. And they've been pretty deep. But the question is,
after we see the last couple of days of the week, which aren't reflected in these charts,
how bad is it going to look? Because we see again, large spec net shorts on the 30-year.
They pulled back, but this was up until Tuesday. So the question is, are they pressing their shorts
here at a time when commercial real estate is starting to tell them a big unwind is coming?
And you can see this in the market. Let's take a look at XLF. This is the large bank ETF. Let's go
back to the financial crisis. And you can see, going into that, as early as 2007, it broke its
200-week moving average. This is being a weekly chart here, and continued to decline. Now look
at where we're at now. It's coming right down to the 200-day moving average. Nobody's looking at
the bank stocks. So if rates were going higher, and all this demand to some of these experts
were saying were there, then what should that mean for bank profits? They should be going up,
and the market should be rewarding them with higher stock prices. But the market's saying,
wait a minute, we already know that higher rates are going to break the market, because they're
looking at commercial real estate here. So what we're expecting is XLF to continue to go down.
And that's a red flag, because when we overlay the broad stock market, the S&P 500 in purple,
and we go all the way back to that weekly chart, we can see that XLF led the broad market lower.
And we're seeing the same setup now. What it's telling us is while everybody thinks the stock
market should go higher, XLF is saying, maybe it's time to actually think about taking off some risk
here, or putting on some short positions. Because when you look at the charts here, again, let's
come back to that TLT chart, and what we see is periods where TLT typically is rising, bank stocks
are falling. So while everyone is piling into the short side, dumping the bond market, what we're
seeing a setup here is suggesting that we're about to see a massive squeeze, and it's nothing to do
with what most people are looking at. And what we're seeing here is a lot of people are looking
at commercial real estate, and seeing just the beginning of what's going to be a massive unwind
that could take down many small and mid-sized regional banks. And with that, I'm Steve Van
Viener. Thanks for watching. Thanks for being fans. Bye now.