BREAKING: Trump's voter database gets a Supreme Court victory

Important News
7 followers
19 Video Views·Sep 28, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThe Supreme Court has lifted restrictions on the SAVE database, allowing the Trump administration to use Social Security records to police state voter rolls ahead of the November midterms. The 6-3 ruling sparked a sharp dissent from liberal justices. Additionally, the Court is reviewing an emergency appeal regarding the deportation of migrants with criminal records to third-party countries.
Breaking news, the Supreme Court lifting restrictions on a controversial federal
voter database. It gives President Trump a temporary win in his campaign against
non-citizen voting just weeks ahead of the November midterm elections.
Here to break it all down is The Hill's legal affairs editor, Zach Schoenfeld.
Zach, thank you so much for joining us on this busy morning. The Supreme Court says
these changes can go into effect ahead of the midterms. What does this mean for state voter
Hey, Judy, this is a case all about a database called SAVE that historically has been used to
ensure that someone is their immigration status makes them eligible to participate in federal
benefit programs. But the Trump administration's Department of Homeland Security has looked to
expand that to increasingly use it to police state voter rolls. This overhaul, the key change
to know about is this clearinghouse is now hooked up to social security records. So that was really
what this lawsuit was all about. But now that they have the green light, it means that these
changes are going to be able to go into effect. And now states are going to be able to use those
social security records in this database to individually police voter rolls in the lead
up to those big November contests. Zach, what's the plaintiff's argument here? And how did the
Supreme Court rule? They argued that, first of all, this violated the Social Security Act,
and then it also violated more generic federal privacy laws. They had won in the lower courts,
as in so many of these cases where these trial judges have ruled against President Trump.
But once again, here we are. This case gets up to the Supreme Court on its emergency docket
and in the parent ruling along at six to three ideological lines. The court is now siding with
the president. I'll just read you a little bit here from the majority unsigned opinion,
saying that under federal law, the federal government has an obligation to respond to
requests from state and local election officials, and saying that the order below prevented the
federal government from using the program it believes is best suited to the task.
So essentially here, president and DHS now have the green light to move forward ahead of November.
And those three liberal justices dissenting, as you mentioned, what do they say?
Yeah, this was a dissent authored by Justice Katonji Brown-Jackson, joined by the other two
liberal justices, Sonia Sotomayor and Elena Kagan. I'll just read you a bit here from Justice
Jackson's dissent, because she is saying that in her view, the harm that is caused by burdening
or disenfranchising even a few lawful voters outweighs, she says, the non-existent harm that
experiencing when it is prevented from taking an action that Justice Jackson says the government
likely lacks the authority to do. She says that that imbalance, along with the government's
improbable merits arguments, should have compelled the court to deny the stay and rule against the
president. So the liberal justices making clear that they disagree with the president, both on
the law here, saying that the challengers were likely to succeed, but also on the balance of
equity. Zach, you sat in just last night as Justice Jackson was delivering a lecture rebuking
her colleagues' recent emergency rulings. What do you make of her remarks now after seeing this
decision come down? Yeah, Judy, I was at the University of the District of Columbia last
night where Justice Jackson was talking to a group of law students and specifically focused this
lecture about these recent emergency cases. Now, I was sat in for this. There were no cameras allowed
inside, but she did allow reporters in there with pen and pad. I'll say she never mentioned
President Trump by name, but certainly he was the elephant in the room for her talk, repeatedly
imploring her colleagues to stop stepping into these hot button issues on their emergency docket
so quickly. At one point, she said that it's having a potentially corrosive effect on how the judiciary
normally handles cases. And so, Judy, it is interesting now knowing that she was saying
those comments. As we now know, behind the scenes, she was working on penning that dissent that came
out today. So, not necessarily anything new from Justice Jackson. She has been criticizing her
colleagues for quite some time now, but still some more pretty searing criticism this week from her.
Okay, Zach, so one more election case handled at the Supreme Court, but there's still more to come.
What can you tell us about this new emergency appeal the Trump administration filed last night?
This one also is related to immigration. That's right. This one is related to what is called the
Trump administration has increasingly relied on this practice in which it sends migrants
to countries where they have no ties. They say that they are specifically here targeting migrants
who have criminal records, often violent criminal records. And they say this is part of their
immigration, aggressive immigration crackdown, where they want to send these individuals
to countries all across the globe, even ones they're not from. Oftentimes, the Trump administration has
been signing agreements with lots of countries in Africa, for example, among other regions.
But now what has happened is there has been a lower court that has stepped in and placed
restrictions on those flights, saying that the administration needs to do more to ensure that
these individuals have an opportunity to raise claims that they might face torture or persecution
if they're deported to these countries. So, with that block in place, it's meant that some of these
flights can't continue. We've learned that there was a flight supposedly was going to go to three
different countries carrying 70 individuals with criminal records. We've been told that flight is
now on hold. But once again, this case now at the Supreme Court, the Trump administration trying to
get the green light. What's the timeline on that case? When can we expect a ruling? Not a ruling
quite yet. There is a briefing schedule that is going to go into early next week. It's actually
Justice Jackson who receives this case by default. She set a response deadline for the other side
Monday afternoon. So we'll get that, then a final reply brief from the government.
And then after that, we could get a ruling there too. So potentially,
we could get that decision as soon as next week.
Busy days ahead for you, Zach. Thank you so much for joining us.
Thank you.
