SmileDirectClub was everywhere. The purple boxes, the YouTube ads, the promise of straighter teeth for half the price without constantly visiting an orthodontist. For a while, it looked like one of the biggest direct-to-consumer success stories ever. Revenue exploded, the company expanded across the country, and by the time it went public in 2019, it was valued at nearly $9 billion. Four years later, it was bankrupt. This video looks at how SmileDirectClub tried to turn orthodontics into a product, why it spent hundreds of millions of dollars acquiring customers, and how its cheap, convenient model put it at war with dentists, regulators, and even some of its own customers. There were lawsuits across multiple states, customers allegedly pushed into NDAs to get refunds, complaints about injuries, a $2.8 billion lawsuit against NBC, and a mountain of debt backed by payments customers hadn’t even made yet. Then SmileDirectClub shut down almost overnight, leaving thousands of people mid-treatment while some were still expected to keep paying. It’s a strange story about what happens when a genuinely disruptive idea grows faster than the business underneath it.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
Smile Direct Club (SDC) attempted to disrupt orthodontics with a direct-to-consumer model, offering low-cost aligners without in-person visits. Despite rapid growth and a massive IPO, the company collapsed due to unsustainable marketing costs, medical negligence, legal battles with dental boards, and a precarious financial structure, eventually leading to bankruptcy and liquidation.
You may have seen this purple box, small direct club, straighter teeth for half the price
without seeing a specialist.
It was everywhere, in YouTube ads, sponsorships, the news, with one of the most aggressive
advertising funnels ever.
So how did they go from this, to this, an even stranger still charging customers for
a service that no longer exists?
What happened?
It turns out this is one of the strangest companies ever.
Lawsuits with the entire dental industry, US states, and paying to silence critics
and even their own customers.
I think a pain everyone can relate to is dental, especially realigning teeth and braces.
It's extremely costly, but what if it didn't have to be?
This was a pitch of Jordan Katzman and Alex Fekel, founders of small direct club, which
I'll often shorten to SDC.
A single dental visit can quickly become months of travel, repeated appointments with an orthodontist,
x-rays, and thousands of dollars out of pocket.
But with SDC, you can access dental care from the comforts of your own home with a $79 kit
and an $80 monthly fee.
That's pretty radical.
How did they do this?
Invisalign charged orthodontists $1,000 to $1,500 per case for the aligners.
And once the orthodontist added consultation and treatment fees, patients could end up
paying $4,000 to $5,000 for the full treatment.
So SDC cut out the orthodontist and brought the aligners directly to the customer.
Their pitch was 50-60% less than traditional treatment.
To get in, they mail you a DIY dental kit that you simply buy into and mail back, or
you could simply walk into a small shop for a quick 3D intraoral scan.
These shops were everywhere, going from 121 shops in 34 states to over 300.
The scanned result or mold is reviewed remotely by a licensed dentist or orthodontist who
will create a treatment plan.
Once approved, the full set of aligners will be produced and shipped back to you.
To sign up, you don't need a credit card, making this easier for those who can't afford
traditional dental care to get treatment.
We're not trying to replace orthodontists, we're trying to reach the 85% of people
who need treatment but can't afford it or won't go through the hassle.
Fast and easy, right?
Well, both of those aren't always the best, especially in healthcare.
They also had to convince a lot of people to trust a website and a stranger they'd
never met with their dental health.
So SDC operated one of the most aggressive customer acquisition funnels in DTC history.
And boy were they spending a lot.
For example, in 2019, SDC spent a staggering $481.5 million on sales and marketing to generate
roughly 453,000 unique aligner orders.
That's an estimated $1,060 to acquire each converted customer.
That would cause some problems down the line, but for now, they were growing fast.
SDC went from making just $20.6 million revenue in 2016 to making $750 million by 2019.
And within that same stretch, they grew to 6,300 employees.
Even Align Technology, the company behind Invisalign, took a 19% stake in SDC.
By 2017, SDC was already valued at roughly $640 million.
With this success, SDC went public on September 12th, 2019.
The company raised $1.35 billion, and on paper, it looked like a massive success.
Its founders, Jordan Katzmann and Alex Fenkel, became billionaires almost overnight, with
the company reaching an $8.9 billion valuation.
But there was a problem.
SDC initially priced its shares at $19 to $22, but strong investor demand pushed the
company and its bankers to settle at $23 per share.
The higher price meant more cash for SDC.
Then investors got their first look at what they were actually buying, sending the stock
down 27.5% on its first day and closing at $16.67.
This was the worst first day performance for an American IPO that raised more than a billion
dollars since the financial crisis.
And within five weeks, the founders were no longer billionaires, but they were definitely
multi-millionaires.
Four years later, SDC would file for Chapter 11 bankruptcy, carrying roughly $900 million
in debt.
And eventually, the company would be liquidated.
So what went wrong?
Well, SDC had a lot of opposition ahead of them, and some of it very warranted.
Not only that, the direct-to-customer brand got caught up in some rather strange controversies
that would follow them forever.
As we'll soon learn, Small Direct Club spent an absurd amount acquiring customers.
And for every business, one of the biggest yet least spoken about challenges is go-to-market,
aka launching and reaching the right buyers.
But getting to the perfect customers who might love and need what you sell, how do you do
it?
Hire an agency?
Spend hundreds of millions a year on ads?
If you don't want that to be your story, you should really consider today's sponsor,
Clay.
Clay is how you find customers without a 9-figure ad budget.
What makes it different is the data.
Clay has relationships with more than 250 data providers, the best business data in
the world.
And the only way to access all of it is through Clay.
You tell it what kind of customer you want.
Say, every orthodontist in Texas, or every clinic that just opened a second location.
Clay builds a list, finds the owner or the decision maker, pulls their contact information,
and can research each one to tell you whether they're worth reaching out to.
Once it's set up, you point it to a new city or a new type of customer, and it runs
again.
It's the most powerful tool for any new or growing business.
You can try Clay completely free using the link below.
Just type in what you saw and who you want to sell to, and it will build you a list of
And, when you use my link, you'll also get 2,000 free credits.
Thank you to Clay for sponsoring this video.
Let's take a step back to what it actually cost SDC to acquire those customers.
Because there were three big problems.
On paper, SDC's revenue was increasing by over 190% in just one year.
But on closer look, something was eating into the company's gross profit.
So what was it?
In 2017, the company pulled in $146 million in revenue, but spent $64.2 million on sales
and marketing alone.
That's roughly 44% of everything it made.
Revenue jumped to $423.2 million in 2018, but sales and marketing spending exploded
to $213.1 million, eating up more than 50% of the company's total revenue.
But it gets worse.
Unlike SaaS, or even other direct-to-consumer subscription businesses like shaving clubs
or contact lens companies, clear aligners aren't something customers keep buying every month.
So, SDC had to keep spending heavily to find a new wave of customers every year.
Remember those monthly payments?
Instead of paying the full cost up front, customers could pay just $250
and spread the rest over two years.
And about 60% of customers chose that option.
But that came with a price.
By the end of 2021, customers owed SDC about $243.8 million.
And that year, missed payments added up to about 9% of SDC's revenue.
By September 2022, that had dropped to about $202 million.
And by the end of 2022, missed payments had climbed to 11% of revenue.
Basically, more and more customers were falling behind.
Things like expected discounts, cancellations, refunds, and customers failing to pay could
all reduce the amount the company expected to collect.
For example, in the first nine months of 2022,
SDC recorded about $73.2 million in these reductions against $384.2 million in revenue.
That's roughly 19% of the revenue figure.
SDC claimed that only 1% of its customers complained after treatment.
But 1% of 1 million is still 10,000 people.
And some of those customers were never told to see a dentist at all.
A hidden camera investigation by NBC Nightly News exposed SDC.
Employees at small shops in Ohio, New Jersey, and Alabama told prospective customers they
didn't need to see a dentist beforehand.
The damage that not seeing a dentist could cause goes even deeper.
Dr. Chung Kao, chair of orthodontists at UAB,
told NBC that moving teeth without in-person supervision could cause permanent harm.
And the FDA's own database contains some disturbing accounts from SDC's customers.
After a visit with the orthodontic and periodontic dept at the Univa B6,
it was determined that due to my Smile Direct Club treatment,
that the aligners pushed my bottom teeth out of the bone,
causing them to be mobile and causing severe gum recession on all front teeth top and bottom.
Ouch.
So how did SDC respond?
That may be a smile guide who didn't actually have or remember the proper training.
That's not all.
On May 18th, 2020, SDC sued NBCUniversal and reporter Vicky Nguyen for approximately $2.8
billion, accusing them of making more than 40 false and misleading statements.
Their main concern was that the report had wiped $950 million off its market value.
But NBC didn't back down.
Eventually, this lawsuit was dismissed in December 2021.
But it gets way, way worse.
CBC found that some customers couldn't even complain
because they'd signed agreements that prevented them from talking publicly about their experience.
And this eventually became the subject of a lawsuit from Washington DC's attorney general,
who revealed that customers who wanted refunds after 30 days were sometimes required to sign
an NDA.
And to sign said NDA, they had to delete negative reviews they'd already posted.
They could face $10,000 penalties for each violation.
And it didn't stop there.
The agreements allegedly prevented customers from even filing complaints with government
regulators, including when those complaints involved people who had suffered
painful and sometimes permanent injuries.
Then, on June 22nd, 2023, SDC settled the case,
paying $500,000 and releasing more than 17,000 customers from the gag provisions.
But SDC still pushed back.
For too long, there has been a misinformation campaign
claiming SDC stifles negative customer feedback through the use of non-disclosure agreements.
But there was another big problem.
And you might have thought about it during the video.
What about the dental industry?
You know, all the thousands of orthodontists, practices, associations?
There's no way they would've rolled over and let SDC dominate.
Right?
And you're right.
Which brings us to SDC's biggest battle yet.
Which, ironically, would persist beyond the company's own lifespan.
If you've watched this far, consider subscribing.
It helps the channel and means you won't miss future videos.
There is a reason why people are meant to visit an orthodontist with years of postgraduate training
or take x-rays, physical exams, follow-ups.
Even for the small to moderate cases which SDC operated in.
But SDC took a complex medical service and turned much of it into a product.
And many were not happy about this.
While SDC reported growth into multiple states,
patients started showing up in orthodontist offices with SDC treatment that needed to be fixed.
So the American Association of Orthodontists, or AAO, launched a campaign against Small Direct Club.
This included filing complaints with more than 35 state dental boards and authorities,
alleging that the company's practices could put the public at risk.
In Alaska, the dental board unanimously sent SDC a cease and desist.
In response, SDC prepared its lawyers.
In October 2017, it sent its own cease and desist letters to dentists over YouTube reviews,
sued orthodontists in New York and New Jersey,
and even sued the Michigan Dental Association over four paragraphs it had published.
And this was all before SDC even went public.
Then, the states started pushing back.
In 2018, Georgia passed a rule requiring dental assistants taking orthodontic scans
to have a licensed dentist immediately supervising them,
effectively blocking SDC's small shop model.
So SDC sued Georgia, arguing that taking digital scans wasn't the practice of dentistry.
But Georgia wasn't the only state SDC was fighting.
The company filed similar lawsuits in Alabama and later California.
It even took the fight across the border, going after dental associations in Manitoba.
Then, the fight reached the federal level.
The American Dental Association petitioned the FDA,
arguing that Small Direct Club was providing prescription-only medical devices
without requiring customers to undergo an in-person examination.
The ADA and AAO later took their complaints to the FDC.
And in May 2019, a federal judge in Georgia ruled that taking digital scans for treatment planning
falls squarely within the definition of the practice of dentistry.
Yet, SDC was going public while all of this was happening.
Then, on January 6th, 2020, nine members of Congress, five of them dentists,
asked the FDA and FDC to investigate Small Direct Club.
With lawsuits, regulators, and Congress closing in, how long could SDC hold up?
With all these legal fights and rapid expansions are pretty expensive,
but SmallPay wasn't bringing in cash fast enough.
So in 2022, SDC borrowed up to $255 million from a private lender called HBS.
And to get it, they used SmallPay payments as security.
Over 60% of customers were paying through SmallPay, which is SDC's monthly payment plan.
Basically, SDC borrowed against money their own customers still owed them.
But it meant SDC was waiting to collect much of its revenue over time.
Then inflation and interest rates went through the roof.
Customers started falling behind on payments, making those receivables harder to collect.
By late 2023, SDC was carrying around $891 million in debt liabilities.
But somehow, it gets worse.
In 2023, an arbiter ordered SDC to pay Align Technologies roughly $63 million over a patent
dispute.
Then on September 29th, SDC filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy to restructure and find a buyer,
but they found none.
Just over two months later, SDC abruptly shut down.
But the story, unfortunately, didn't end there.
Thousands of customers were left with unfinished treatments, but their bills didn't disappear.
SDC's shutdown FAQ told SmallPay customers they were still expected to make their monthly
payments until the balance was paid in full.
Yeah.
And regulators eventually stepped in.
In late 2024, the New York Attorney General finalized a $4.8 million restitution agreement
covering more than 28,000 customers nationwide.
But even then, many customers, who had already received their aligners,
remained obligated to pay their financing contracts.
SmallDirectClub was a strange direct-to-consumer experiment,
innovative and disruptive, but maybe not in a good way.
During the lawsuits, 77% of orthodontists surveyed by the AEO said that they had seen
new patients needing retreatment after using mail-order aligners without an in-person exam.
I think that's the irony at the heart of SmallDirectClub,
the low price came from removing the dentist.
That put SDC at war with an entire profession.
They won some battles in court but lost the cash to keep going
because their product was essentially a one-time purchase.
And even then, I wouldn't call SmallDirectClub the good guys.
SmallDirectClub is one of the many gigantic brands that used a direct-to-consumer model.
A lot of these started exploding in the 2010s, and one of the biggest was Dollar Shave Club,
a box of razors every month that single-handedly topped the razor industry,
only to collapse several years later.
So, why do direct-to-consumer brands keep collapsing?
Watch this video next to learn the rest of the story.
But until next time, I'm Shree.