Analyzing Remi Garrigue vs. Gyeongdong with Theron Sharp!

Sydney Sabre
2 followers
1 Video View·Sep 28, 2026
Analyzing Remi Garrigue vs Do Dyeongdong with my friend Theron Sharp!
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedCommentators Theron Sharp and Julian provide a technical breakdown of a high-level saber bout between world-ranked fencers Remy Gareg and Doe. They analyze Gareg's impressive comeback from a 4-9 deficit to a 15-13 victory, focusing on tactical execution, the psychological battle, and the nuances of international refereeing.
Alright, hello everybody. I am joined by a friend of mine who will introduce himself now.
What's your name and what's your background in fencing?
Hello, it's Theron Sharp. I've existed in this channel on one previous video.
That's right.
I believe it was the first balance analysis video, if not the second.
I am still a D-rated fencer from St. Louis, Missouri.
I've taken a bit of a break from my on-and-off 13-year fencing career
recently to go through basic military training.
And I'm now greatly enjoying the opportunity to film this video
on the Wi-Fi being paid for by your tax dollars.
So thank you very much for helping produce this video.
Perhaps Julian can give all of you back a little bit of the money he makes off of it.
And soon you're going to bike 13 miles to do fencing and 13 miles back.
That's correct.
When your kids eventually ask you, what was your childhood like,
you can say, I biked uphill both ways.
I biked uphill both ways from the military barracks just to go to fencing practice.
Get off the couch, son.
Exactly.
You linked this bout to me.
I haven't seen this yet.
So it's a bout between Remy Gareg, or I'm going to butcher the French name.
I have no idea.
Gareg, you maybe?
I'm too American to pronounce that correctly.
Should have looked it up ahead of time.
My apologies.
I know he's a really strong fencer.
I think he's top 10 in the world right now.
And he's fencing against Doe, who's currently the number two-ranked fencer in the world right now.
Both exceedingly strong fencers.
I watched this bout in the airport, actually, while reporting to this command out of boredom.
And I watched it and immediately thought that it was one of the most fun bouts I'd ever seen,
which is why I linked it to you.
So I'm excited for you to see it for the first time.
Oh, yeah.
All right.
Well, let's get right into it.
What does the first point look like?
The first point is very clear.
It's just attack and prep for Doe, right?
Maybe even attack, counterattack for Doe.
He's just ahead.
Yeah.
Attack right.
Nothing really to be said there.
Unless you want to say something.
Not particularly.
I mean, I'm impressed with the speed off the line.
But of course, they're top fencers in the world.
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
It's nice when the actions are very clear.
I don't have the sound on, which maybe is to my detriment,
because maybe he should be carded there.
Maybe not.
Yeah.
I guess the French fencer hit him in the leg.
Looks like it.
I wasn't actually sure why they stopped the bout
the first time through that I watched it.
Okay.
This is a nice, nice attack by Remy.
Okay.
Yeah, Doe just attack.
So far, Doe is winning the game in the box.
No.
Wait, does he actually get line?
Oh my god.
No, he did not get line.
Wait, I thought that Remy was like...
No, he had thumbs up for like, yeah.
So sometimes the referee calls something
and one of the fencers is arguing and he's like, no.
And the French fencer just had his hand up like thumbs up.
Like, yeah, no, that was my point.
I thought it was interesting because for a minute
before I saw both lights going off,
I thought he pulled off the line counter.
I thought he had the timing there
and I was about to get very excited.
Yeah.
That's not something you see as often.
It's something that you do.
Yeah, that's why you're rooting.
It is something that I do.
It's why I wanted to see it done at a high level
because my coach hates when I do it.
You're like, see, look, it works.
It works.
The best fencer in the world can make it work.
Clearly, I can do it too.
Right.
But sadly, it did not work.
It did not work.
Maybe your coach knows what she's talking about.
On to point four.
Yeah, on to point four, my bad.
I'm just kidding.
No, you're probably right.
Preparation.
Oh my god, he prepared so hard he got one lighted.
Dang.
Yeah, I thought that one was almost a little bit embarrassing.
Going into point five.
Yeah, point five.
Oh, at the very end, he tried to close them out,
but it wasn't effective.
I like the doe.
That was a very nice pull.
Yeah, so doe pulls.
Actually, I'm gonna go back.
So I've been reading this action where they go to parry two
as an insurance parry on the pull as an attempted skyhook,
but that's just wrong.
He isn't intending the skyhook,
so it's just a good pulling action.
The reason not to skyhook here
is it's unlikely the skyhook is going to hit a hit,
and if your opponent notices,
then they can just take reprise and hard punish you.
Attack no, counterattack no, and then reprise, right?
Okay, anyway, on to the sixth point.
Oh, which is attack and preparation, parry, riposte.
You do that to me all the time.
I do, in fact, do this to you all the time,
anytime somebody tries to hit me with attack and prep
and goes for four is one of my favorite things
somebody can do to me,
because I love calling that line out
and smacking them on the head.
We've all been there.
It's more fun as the side parrying
than the side who's attacking in prep.
I think you'll like the next point
for the same reasons that you enjoy watching Colin Eavecock.
Yeah, sorry, I've been re-watching this point,
so yeah, it's just stop, stop, then go, yeah?
If I recall, down the line in this path
there's a point where I think Gary Ryu gets frustrated
and actually calls for a wall, watching the replay.
Oh, man.
Sorry, I just saw the next point.
Oh, man.
This gets closed out here?
Closed out, like, kind of?
I was not there yet, let me take a look.
Yeah, on point number eight,
so Gary, like, bluffs
and then pretends like he's gonna go
and set up a wall in defense,
and then instead he decides to close them out.
It's a really nice action.
It was a beautiful, what was that?
Counter and close?
Yeah, yeah.
Yeah, counter attack, close out.
It's gotta be one of the most frustrating things
to have done to you, especially on a long attack.
Okay, now that is something that I do all the time.
Yes, I know, I'm just talking about the frustration
from personal experience.
Oh, doh.
All the Korean fencers
know how to pull super effectively.
It's a common thing you'll see throughout their fencing.
Like, oh, Sanguk is really good at pulling people short.
Doh's really good at pulling people short.
Park is good at pulling people short.
They just like attacking and pulling you short.
I feel like I've watched a lot of Korean,
mostly, oh, Sanguk,
but I feel like I've watched a lot of the Korean fencers
going up against very high-level fencers,
and when you watch them, you know,
doing these pulls
and have it consistently work against monsters
like Heathcock, Adam Zalagi, Tarjani,
it's very impressive how they're able to make that work
against, you know, some of the biggest names
in fencing history.
Right.
It doesn't matter who you are.
Your attack will fall short.
Their legs are stronger,
and their body is faster, unfortunately.
It's like an opposition closeout point for Doh.
Ooh.
Yeah.
Oh, I see what you mean.
I love doing this to people,
especially in those highline attacks
where they put their blade up high.
Yeah.
It kind of feels like you just get to punch their hand out of the way.
Well, I don't necessarily enjoy causing people pain.
But I do enjoy winning the point for this reason.
I mean, I enjoy causing them psychic pain
when they go for an attack.
Yes.
Their wrist falls apart in the face of my counter.
Uh, psychic pain, yes.
Physical pain, no.
Um, all right.
Well, I'll move on.
I'll move on to the next point.
I've seen that.
I've seen that like 16 times by now.
So yeah, no point.
Apologies to the viewers.
Oh, seven.
Oh, no, I'm cutting like half of that out.
Don't worry about it.
Um, let's see.
Okay, so just attack, counterattack for Doe.
He's more committed to the attack.
They decided to take the time to review this one, though.
Uh, wait, they did?
No, no, no, they didn't review it.
They're just on break.
The one minute break.
Oh, never mind.
You're, I'm a fool.
I should know this.
All right, I'm skipping past the break.
We don't need to pay attention to the dead time.
Eating through double time.
All right, let's, let's check it out.
Oh, okay, just attack for Doe.
I actually thought he might, um, Garigou might have gotten, gotten,
Get the clothes out.
But he did not, yeah.
Um, maybe I'll make a video at some point explaining how I think counters work, um,
because I, I don't think that this was the right time, um, to, well, actually, I don't know.
Maybe it was the right time.
He just got unlucky with his timing, because Doe was going pretty fast.
And with counterattack closeout, um, maybe counterintuitively, you want your opponent
to go fast, um, so that they don't complete.
With exit counters, you want your opponent to, like, prepare slow, but with closeout
counters, you want them to go fast so you can catch their blade, because you don't really
care where, where they are or you are, um, because you don't intend on, I mean, you don't,
you don't care where you are in relationship to them, you just care where their blade is.
In any case, it unfortunately did not work for the, for the French fencer here.
Yeah.
All right, 9-4.
It's, uh, it's starting to become a real lead.
Huh.
Well, you say that now.
Maybe, maybe there'll be some plot twists, I don't know, but.
They're all gonna watch 9-4, but it's a pretty brutal counter.
Well, it's now 9-5, so.
It is now 9-5, with a brutal counter to the wrist.
All right, oh boy.
I think this is just attack for Doh unless there's something that wasn't caught on camera.
I might have missed something the first time around, but to me, I think that this, that
Doh just won the point.
Wait, wait, wait, what?
Oh no, they awarded the point for Garyu.
Garyu?
What, what happened?
Did he?
I believe it was Parry or Post.
Oh, he actually caught, caught the blade?
It didn't look like that to me on camera, but.
I, I believe it.
It did not look the most like that to me on camera, but I feel like I heard it.
I also think it's very funny to point out that in the beginning of the point, on Doh's
pull, after Garyu misses, he, like, throws his hand up in the middle of the bout in,
like, exasperation at getting pulled again.
And I thought that was very funny when I watched this the first time.
I did not see that at all.
Oh, he totally does.
He gets so frustrated in the middle of a live point and just actually makes a physical
gesture towards it, which could have been a cardable offense as well, if I understand
correctly.
He's, uh, he's stemming.
I don't think you can actually card him for that, but yeah.
They certainly, I certainly don't see a reason why any referee would, but I just think it's
funny how frustrated he gets when he gets pulled again.
Yeah, he's just.
Even if he, even if Garyu won the point in the actual strip, I think that Doh forever
won that point psychically with that one.
Yeah.
Um, okay, well, onto the next action.
Okay, I think preparation attack for Doh.
That's what the.
Correct.
Yeah, that's what was ruled.
Okay, I don't really feel like talking about that point, so let's move on to the next one.
Oh, he did not get pulled short.
Oh man, let's see.
He tried to sky hook and it did not work.
Didn't even get to touch him.
Yeah, just gets through.
Needed to, needed to pull faster.
And the next one is just the classic saber point that you, that you hear about from every
stereotype.
Uh oh.
So I'm going to hate it.
Okay, let's see.
Maybe.
And they both argue.
I actually think this is, so I haven't played it back on first watch.
I think this is Garrygu's point.
I think he's ahead, but I will replay it to see what I actually think.
The referee did agree with that, I will note.
It, uh, maybe there's some argument.
So honestly, if I went to video review here, um, I would probably rule this as simul.
Like I've watched the point twice now.
I don't like that referees are splitting points like this so thin.
Like they're basically doing the same thing, have the same intention.
And it's just, it's just bad for the game that these points are split, right?
Like you need somebody to be very, I, I prefer more decisive actions.
Um, I'm anti this.
I can understand that.
That being said, I, my reference in the beginning was mostly to the fact that you had both fencers
rushing each other off the line and hitting each other and then practically falling over
and screaming.
Yep.
Which is what every epee fencer will tell you Saber is.
Yeah.
That is what every epee fencer says.
But you know, every epee fencer dreams of winning their bouts via black card.
So I don't, I don't know if I.
This is why every epee fencer is banned from watching your videos.
Yeah.
If you say you're an epee fencer, I will block you from this channel.
Go and leave a comment talking about being an epee fencer.
I'd love to make fun of you in the comments before you get banned.
Yeah.
Don't even try it.
All right.
Well, on, on to the next point.
Okay.
Attack was awarded for Garegu.
Remy Garegu.
You know what I bet?
I bet his name is pronounced Gareg and they just ignore the U and E because it's French.
That is very possible, but for me to actually not call him Garegu would require me to like
the French language and I don't.
Yeah.
Oh, this next point is very obvious.
Just preparation for Garegu.
I'm an A10.
Yeah.
I mean, just very, very clear, clear preparation.
So going in the middle, still preparation.
So Garegu attacks his preparation.
I mean, yeah, I don't have much to add to that.
It's kind of a boring, boring action.
Going into 910 at the moment.
Okay.
And, oh, and Garegu gets past this defense.
Yeah.
If you see your opponent swinging their blade like around a lot, that's a good moment to
be like pretty patient.
You'll notice that Garegu is taking these like steps back on the attack.
And technically that does give a priority if Do can attack at the exact moment when
Garegu steps back.
But it does, I mean, realistically, he's just not going to find that timing.
So it doesn't matter.
So, and the reason to do this on the attack, to take these like tiny steps back is so that
you can accelerate into your opponent, which is exactly what happens.
And I'll also point out that now it's 1010 again.
I think credit should be given to Garegu for being able to catch up like he has.
Was it 410 or was it 410?
It was 49.
49.
Dang.
So you're telling me out of the last seven points, Garegu scored six of them.
He did.
That's something.
All right.
Going into 1010.
And 1010's a hell of a point.
Oh my god.
I love points like this.
So Garegu exposes preparation as a trap.
Anticipates preparation comes and then goes parry four and gets the point.
Just like hard outplayed.
Beautiful.
You'll love to see it.
I would love to pull a move like this someday, but I'm not sure I'm good enough to make that
trap convincing.
Yeah, I mean, I don't know.
It's just it just it just takes it just takes practice.
And so I don't I think you could do it, honestly, like pretty fast.
I think you just need to have the right people to try this against.
I like you.
Yeah.
Although we're like far away from each other now.
Further away than normal in Texas.
Yeah.
Ridiculous.
We've driven farther than that to go fence before.
I'm going to storm the army base with my sword.
He's going to walk up to the gate at Fort San Houston and say, hello, I'm here to visit
one of the Navy people with a sword.
Don't mind me.
Yeah, yeah.
I'm here for a sword fight.
They're like, we have guns here.
Like, yeah, but I challenge somebody to a duel.
You're approximately 250 years too late.
All right.
On going into 1110.
Yeah, 1110.
And we see the same thing as before.
Once again, Joe attempts a sky hook and Gary was too fast for them.
So I'm actually not sure that he's attempting a sky hook here.
It's he could be like very well.
It's I would need to see this like in real life.
He's either trying to have like this insurance, Perry, too, and then gets caught on the arm,
which is why insurance Perry's are maybe not the best idea when pulling or he's trying to sky hook.
On this one, I actually kind of lean towards insurance, Perry,
because he doesn't like attempt to hit him, right?
Insurance Perry is a term that I've never heard before, and I love it.
I just make up a bunch of stuff.
I will be I will be using this term in the future.
You could be right.
I've just never seen somebody rainbow their arm like that for any purpose other than a sky hook.
But I've also never fenced at this level.
So it's very possible.
I would also never intentionally use Perry to for anything other than to protect the bottom of my arm.
That that is that is fair.
OK, well, on to on to 1210 and quite, quite the quite the turnaround.
Garigou having a two point lead for the first time in the in the match
and a meaningful two point lead.
Three away from winning.
What?
What happened?
1210's a bit of a goof.
1210.
So I like how Doe is like, all right, I'm going.
And he's like, and then he lunges and hits him anyway.
Garigou's not even moving.
I mean, he never heard halt.
The point was not awarded, right?
OK, it was not awarded.
Unfortunately, it would have been funny.
You show this to two.
You showed this video to a student.
Best defense ever.
Best defense ever is don't move.
Pretend like you didn't hear the call.
Oh, the opponent has attacked.
Just say, just say you didn't hear it.
That's exactly the sort of slimy fencing we would like to encourage.
You know what would have been so sick?
It would have been so sick as as Doe was lunging and Garigou pulled him short.
I think at that point, it would be more comedy than fencing.
Yeah, but OK, let's let's move on to the next point.
The actual 1210.
Yeah, the actual 1210.
Oh, attack, no.
And then attack from Doe.
Or a parry repost was given by the ref.
I didn't see the parry, but I'm sure it was there.
Hard to see the blades.
Yeah, no, I actually I do see it on the replay.
Yeah, standard, standard fencing in the box.
Nice moves, next point.
Yep.
Oh, beautiful.
Yeah, I like this way of reposting.
Like you draw your opponent short and then you wait and flunge.
It's so hard to get away from that.
It makes it makes it seem like if your attack falls short,
you just lose and you want to give your opponent that that illusion, right?
I certainly would like to try it.
It's not something I've ever incorporated into my style,
but I can't deny its clear effectiveness in this bout.
All right.
Well, it's 13, 13, 13, 11, closing in on the end of the bout
with Garrigou in the lead after quite the nice comeback.
Yeah.
And this one I find a little confusing.
If you're the if I educated one of the two of us,
so clearly, you know, leaps and bounds more about fencing than me.
If you want to exclude happens.
Okay, so I wouldn't say leaps and bounds.
But I have attended an FIE seminar and I am like a rated ref.
Well, let's let's let's let's see.
My I haven't seen what this what this FIE ref called,
but my instinct tells me it should be Do's point.
So the first thing that happens is Do gets drawn short.
The second thing that happens is is Do goes for a counter attack.
And the reason why I don't think that Garrigou should be awarded the point
is that he attacks while jumping backwards,
which had he just attacked, it's obviously his point.
But the thing is, he's he's attacking while moving backwards.
So that's a counter attack.
And Do is preparing really hard.
But what he's doing is an attack.
So this is an attack counter attack for Do, in my opinion.
I was right, yes.
Okay, it is 1311 that I was confused about.
Yeah, so the way that I see this is attack no from Do.
Then Garrigou has priority, right?
But the problem, the problem with the point is that when he hits Do,
he he's jumping backwards while hitting him, which makes it a counter attack.
It appears the ref did not see it that way.
The ref did not see it that way, and that's fine.
I mean, if you I'm being like pretty harsh here,
like, because I I don't think you can actually attack like this.
Like, that's a counter attack.
Um, but, uh, yeah.
Let me see if I'm being like too harsh.
I think he's jumping backwards, man.
That jump backwards is not going to deny that he's jumping backwards.
I also feel like Do has already begun his, what is that a counter?
Yeah, by the time he's actually moving backwards out of the way, at which point.
No, but his counter is counter become an attack in the middle of him finishing it.
Uh, yes, because, um, Garrigou is.
So what's happening?
Well, Do is counterattacking is, um, is is Garrigou has priority, right?
So if he hits him, then that's his point.
No question.
Yeah.
So let's say Garrigou like attack knows, which is my argument.
My argument is that him jumping backwards is attack.
No.
Then Do's counterattack takes priority over what is essentially Garrigou's release.
I see your argument.
I see no flaw in your argument, but the FIU international ref disagreed.
Yeah.
Oh, that's that's I'm going to reserve my opinion.
Sure.
I'm sure that when I say that everybody in the comments is going to be like,
oh, you don't understand the rules and whatever.
And that's that's fine.
That's just the way that that's the way that I see it.
That's not an attack.
Um, attack.
No, by Garrigou.
I hold my opinion.
We'll move on to the next point.
We'll be eager to read the comments.
Technically.
Okay.
I'm going to nitpick the ref.
Gary has been doing this a lot.
Your foot.
I I've I've been educated.
Your foot cannot be on the line.
It must be behind the line.
So he shouldn't be starting any of these bouts.
He any of these touches he should be saying,
Garigou, get your foot behind the line.
That being said,
Doe has a nice attack and prep at 1411 becoming 1412.
Yeah, that's yeah, very clear.
Uh, Garigou actually attempted to parry at the end and didn't actually get it.
Just wasn't fast enough.
Headed into 1412 at this point.
Wait, Garigou asked once again,
Why is he asking for video review?
He's arguing for attack.
Are you at 1412 or 1413?
No, I was at 1411.
And then after 1411, when it becomes 1412.
Um, Garigou is asking for video review.
Oh, that's right.
I mentioned this earlier that he does this.
But why?
This is a fantastic question.
Uh, I assume this was not overturned.
It was not overturned.
It was not.
Okay.
I don't know.
Somebody's going to have to point out the argument.
I don't I don't see it.
I think it's just does all the way.
Um, okay.
1412 is an even more beautiful attack and prep.
Yeah, it's it's it's the kind of attack and prep that you could consider to be embarrassing,
right?
Like you just attack and prep so hard.
He gets one lighted.
Yeah, that's tough, man.
Going into 1413 with a very close bout that has been very back and forth so far.
Oh, yeah.
Okay, that's attack and prep for Garigou for sure.
What what is what is the argument?
No, he's he's he's I mean, I understand it's a close bout.
And when you're fencing in the moment, it becomes tough.
But, um, from the side, very, very clear, very clean fencing from Garigou.
And I mean, what can you say?
Like the the mental fortitude that he he had to have to survive?
The ball is a score nine to four for nine to four.
And he finds his way back to 1513.
Oh, my God.
Well, I mean, both of these dudes are world class fencers.
Do does like rank number two in the world right now.
Garigou, I think, like number six or five or something like or no.
Yeah, probably like number six in the world.
So they're both top ten fencers.
And I feel like once you're in the top ten, who's better than who,
you know, is kind of becomes a who's your favorite game?
Because, yeah, the skill gaps there are marginal enough
that you could pick any one of them and say that they're arguably the best.
But I do think that it's awesome to see that Garigou can say,
I I was fencing the number two fencer in the world.
I was down four to nine and came back and won.
Yeah, that's a that's a hell of a statement to be able to make.
Yeah, just put he puts that on his resume.
Well, he put that on his resume, right?
Survive.
I certainly would.
Four to nine against the number two ranked fencer in the world.
I don't know if that was true at the time.
Probably it wasn't.
But at least Do became number two at some at some point.
This is true.
This this is a video from twenty twenty four.
Oh, yeah, yeah.
Well, I think the fencing was was really nice.
I mean, I knew that this was going to be a good bout when when you told me who was fencing.
I was like, yeah, I know these dudes.
Actually, Do is one of my favorite fencers.
He's just so fast and athletic.
It's really fun watching him work his magic.
He's beautiful to watch from an from an athletic perspective on the strip.
Yeah, I think Garigou kind of
outplayed him in the box.
And in the later later half of this this match, like he kind of just started to read, read him.
He figured out what wasn't working and change tactics
and seemed to have figured out what did work.
Yeah, which is such a simple thing to say.
It seems obvious, but fencing on the strip, figuring out what isn't working
be a lot harder than than a lot of people realize,
especially people who haven't had as much experience fencing,
because things, especially when something works in the beginning of the bout
and you just want to keep doing it when your opponent,
like especially after halftime, it happens to me so often
that my opponent will start reading into me thinking a certain trick works
and they'll start baiting me into doing this thing
that I know works specifically to counter it.
Like that happened to me a lot at
games you and I fenced at not that long ago.
Where I was having a very easy time hitting parry for a post
on one of the Kansas City fencers in the bronze medal bout
and going into the second half, he started painting four and hitting me in three
and it worked on me like four times.
It was really frustrating.
Yeah, if somebody just figures out some tendency,
that's when that's when you can get and get into trouble.
And whatever, whatever, um, um, whatever Garagoo, uh, figured out,
I mean, it clearly, clearly was effective, right?
Anyway, I think he made the comeback.
Yeah, I think we're gonna, uh, we're gonna end it, uh, end it there.
Um, thank you as always, uh, Theron for joining me on this channel.
Um, uh, yeah, uh, I'll catch you, um, catch you guys next time.
Thank you for the opportunity to be here.
