In 1964, Burgundy Took Away This Vineyard’s Famous Name...But Why?

World of Grape Wine
21 followers
2 Video Views·Sep 28, 2026
Thierry Mortet Bourgogne Rouge Cote d'Or 2023
Link to Purchase Wine: https://www.winex.com/thierry-mortet-..
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video highlights a high-value Burgundy Pinot Noir from Thierry Mortay. The wine is labeled as Bourgogne Côte d'Or but originates from the Poissonnier vineyard, a site that was declassified from Gevrey-Chambertin in 1964. Despite its lower classification, the wine offers the complexity and pedigree of a premium Gevrey-Chambertin at a fraction of the cost.
We are back with another Insider Burgundy Secret Vineyard Selection.
One of our deals as Wine Exchange, Spectrum,
has always been sourcing the cool Pinot Noir
from the vineyard next door to the fancier Pinot Noir and Burgundy.
You know what I'm saying?
And usually it is like an actual vineyard, it's been classified as such,
and it's next door, like it's a Bourgogne vineyard next to Grand Cru or something like that,
and we tell you the story.
You know, this story is a little different though.
We, um...
This is interesting, because what we have here
is a vineyard that was Gervais-Chambertin,
and then one day, it was not.
And it's like, okay, well why?
And the reason given was balance.
Balance?
What does that mean, balance?
Well, see back in 64,
the governing wine bodies wanted to classify
a certain section of Gervais-Chambertin as village,
namely these parcels around Evocelles and a couple of really good sites.
And to do that, they had to declassify another part.
This is back in 1964.
So they were like, okay, what's getting declassified?
Well, you know, the Gervais over here is pretty good, very good.
But you know, if we have to give up something to get something,
then we'll declassify this section of Gervais down here.
And that section was Poissonnier.
And when you see it on the map, on our email offer,
which of course you're all going to open and look at our email offer, aren't you?
So when you do that, you'll see what we're talking about.
It's pretty amazing where it's like Gervais, Gervais.
Well, actually, going back to it,
the Arlo family, who's located outside the commune of Gervais-Chambertin,
back in the 60s bought a parcel of Roncesvilles,
which was another Gervais-Chambertin vineyard.
And then they did the reclassification.
And suddenly the people that didn't live in Gervais-Chambertin
and owned vineyards in Gervais-Chambertin no longer had Gervais-Chambertin.
Remember that story with the Arlo, Bourgogne Rouge, Roncesvilles?
Basically the same thing here.
The vineyard next door to Roncesvilles in Gervais-Chambertin,
which I'm perfectly okay saying it's in Gervais-Chambertin,
is Poissonnier.
And a portion of Poissonnier got to stick as Gervais,
but a portion didn't.
But the strange thing is, and again you'll see it on the map,
the portion that was taken out was like in the middle?
Like, I don't know.
Somebody got a raw deal.
What does that mean?
Look at that label.
Label that says Bourgogne Cote d'Or.
What's in the label?
Well, it should say Thierry Mortay, Gervais-Chambertin, Poissonnier.
But it can't, and it won't.
So even though they said in 1964 it's Bourgogne Rouge now,
they let them put Gervais on the label for 30 more years until 1994,
and then finally these guys had to put Bourgogne Rouge on it.
Now, the other famous producer in Poissonnier is Joseph Roti.
And you'll notice on Joseph Roti's Bourgogne Rouge,
he's got that little gold thing there that says Cuvée de Poissonnier,
because he wants you to know that his Bourgogne Rouge comes from,
well, not Bourgogne Rouge vineyards.
It's Gervais-Fragan-Chambertin.
Such is this wine.
Now, this is Thierry Mortay,
who, by the way, is one of the sons of Charles Mortay,
the famous Charles Mortay, who retired in the 1990s
and gave his estate over to his two sons Denis,
who tragically passed away some years ago, and Thierry.
And Thierry, they split the domain between the two.
So we're talking about top parcels in Gervais-Chambertin,
some of the greatest holdings,
including this wonderful little one hectare, technically 90 heirs.
It's not even a full hectare parcel of half young and half old vines in Poissonnier.
Okay.
And this is a wine that got our goat the minute we tasted it.
You know what I mean?
We're tasting, and look at the color.
Beautiful color.
And you stick your face in the glass, and you're like,
this is complex.
This is not throwaway Bourgogne Rouge.
This is real effing wine.
Huh?
And they're like, well.
You know, it's like, well.
And they're like, well.
It comes from this patch.
And we're like, can you confirm that?
And they said, yes, we can.
And then it all started to make sense.
This is a stunning bottle of Pinot Noir, Burgundy and Pinot Noir,
from 20- and 55-year-old vines in Poissonnier.
Thierry didn't quite get the run that his brother did.
You know, his brother shot to notoriety quickly
because the wines were a little more ostentatious in nature, shall we say.
And Thierry was always more classy, straight up, bit of culture school,
analogy bone, de-stems, 1 3rd New Oak.
Like, the classic Burgundy recipe with Thierry's wines has always been the case.
He's been organic for 20 years.
You know, he just doesn't make a big deal out of it.
And he just makes fabulous, tried-and-true, classic Burgundy wines.
Mmm.
Yum.
Sweet, tender, juicy, but with the proper kind of cooler frame.
Because even the Gevreys down in this section,
you know, you're at the lower part of the hill.
Even the Gevreys here, there's a little more clay coming in.
So there's limestone, it's clay limestone,
but the soil here is not as Vandegarde-y as it is further up the hill.
You know, this is, I mean, you're basically directly below the Grand Cruz,
but you just kind of find your way up the hill a little bit.
And this wine provides an ease and a deceptively casual drinkability
in spite of the wine's complexity.
That's a very good sentence right there.
Wow.
You know, I got up at 4 o'clock this morning, but you wouldn't know it.
Mmm.
Or maybe you would.
What else can we say about this wine?
The wine will speak for itself in your glass.
To get a wine of this pedigree from this level of vineyard at this price
is becoming rarer and rarer in Burgundy.
As a matter of fact, we're seeing price increases in Burgundy
at a time when we have tariffs, you know, when the dollar is in a weird place,
when not as many people are drinking wine.
And we're seeing price increases here
simply because the yields in a lot of the years now are so low
because of climate change and the impact of frost and hail
and weather conditions and sudden rains, et cetera, can have on these vineyards.
So a lot of these producers are kind of cropping at half their normal crop a lot of the times.
Accordingly, they do have to raise prices.
But in this case, we get a fabulous Bourgogne Rouge
from arguably the greatest Bourgogne Rouge vineyard,
that is not Bourgogne Rouge, in Gevrey-Chamberton
in a tasty year, and the wine hits you at $39.98.
That is some kind of value in the context of Burgundy nowadays.
And trust us, we know.
Click down below to buy this wine.
Absolutely phenomenal value.
And if you're a Burgundy fan or a pinophile or just love red wine in general,
this wine's an absolute must for the price charge.
Sign up for our daily email offers.
They're the best in the business, and it's where you'll see that cool map.
And then sign up for our YouTube videos.
Watch us daily.
Like us when you watch us.
What else?
Oh, and...
Oh, hi, Patrick.
Hi.
