Every Massachusetts Kid Knows This Donut — Here's How to Make It

So tasty
169 followers
10 Video Views·Sep 28, 2026
Watch more "My State, My Plate" 🍽️ → • Does Florida Make The Best Pie In America?...
00:00 - Why Old-Fashioned Donuts are the Best
00:11 - The History of Dunkin' Donuts in Massachusetts …
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedDavid shares his passion for the old-fashioned donut, arguing it is the superior choice from Dunkin' because it is perfect for dunking in coffee. After briefly discussing the history and rebranding of the Massachusetts-born chain, he provides a comprehensive step-by-step guide to recreating these classic, nutmeg-scented donuts at home.
The old-fashioned donut is the best donut from Dunkin' Donuts, and here's why.
Hi, I'm David. I grew up in Needham, Massachusetts, a suburb of Boston,
Massachusetts. And you know what is also a suburb of Boston, Massachusetts?
Quincy, Massachusetts. And you know what came from Quincy, Massachusetts? Dunkin' Donuts.
I know you all probably are thinking jelly donut supremacy, glazed donut, munchkin.
The old-fashioned donut is the best donut you can get from Dunkin', and the reason is because
it's the best one to dunk in a cup of coffee. Dunkin' Donuts first opened in Quincy,
Massachusetts under the name Open Kettle. Thank God they changed it to Dunkin', far more fitting.
And this was back in the year 1948. By the 70s, they became more known for their munchkins.
In the 2000s, it became well known that America runs on Dunkin'. And then finally in 2018,
it rebranded to just Dunkin'. They dropped the donuts, but the donuts have not dropped
from my heart. And that's why I'm making old-fashioned donuts today.
So first, you're gonna whisk together the flour, the baking powder, and the baking soda,
salt, and nutmeg in a medium bowl until evenly distributed. And then you're gonna set that
aside. Next, you're gonna beat the sugar and the butter in the bowl of a stand mixer fitted
with a paddle attachment on medium speed until just combined. And that should look like about
a sandy texture, and that should take about one minute. Next, you're gonna add in the egg
and the egg yolk, and you're gonna beat that until smooth, which should take about three minutes.
Make sure you scrape down the sides of the bowl. And then after that, you're gonna add the
buttermilk and the vanilla, and you're gonna beat that on low speed for about three minutes.
Once that's done, you're gonna add the flour mixture to the sugar mixture, and two additions,
beating on low speed until no dry streaks remain. That's about one minute per addition.
Once you have your dough together, you're gonna wrap it tightly in plastic, and you're gonna put
it in the fridge so it gets firmed up, which should take about two hours, or you can leave
overnight for up to 12 hours. Once your dough is chilled, you're gonna unwrap it and put it on a
well-floured work surface. You're gonna dust the top with flour and roll it to about a half-inch
thick. Using a three-inch donut cutter, you're going to cut out your donut shapes. Make sure
you gather the scraps gently and re-roll once so that you have about 12 donuts total. Make sure
you pour the oil into a heavy pot or Dutch oven and heat it over medium-high until about 350
degrees Fahrenheit. Make sure that you adjust the heat as necessary to maintain that temperature so
that you don't get uneven cooking. Working in batches, you're gonna gently add two to three
donuts at a time to the hot oil, and make sure you fry them for about 60 to 75 seconds. They should
look pale golden, not deep brown, before you then flip and fry the other side for just about one
minute longer. You're really looking for an even, light, golden color, and you're making sure to
pull them out before they get too dark. You're gonna transfer your fried donuts to a wire rack
set over paper towels and let them cool completely, which should take about 20 minutes.
And there we go, 12 old-fashioned donuts in the style of a Dunkin' Donut old-fashioned donut.
They smell like nutmeg and sugar and almost like fried dough, and they're really actually quite
easy to make. Without the chill time, you can probably get this done in an hour. All right,
let's give this a bite. It's pillowy perfection, classic, it's got a crunch. I could probably eat
all 12 of these if I'm being honest. The most important thing is... hold on. All right, if we
really want to do it the right way, we're doing it with a cup of coffee. I mean, it really doesn't
get more blissful than that. Honestly, like, I'm good to go for the day now. Like, I can,
I feel like I can conquer the world after such a perfect bite. Okay, that's it. We've made
old-fashioned donuts in the style of Dunkin' Donuts, and thanks for watching. Last thing,
shout out to all my Massachusetts-ins or Massachusettsites. Just call them assholes.
