This Changes Everything We Thought About The Mets...
Sep 27, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedDespite a disappointing 2026 season, the New York Mets have developed what is described as the best rookie core in Major League Baseball. Centered around standout talents like Nolan McLean, Carson Benj, and A.J. Ewing, this young group provides a significant bright spot and a foundation for the team's ascent in 2027 and beyond.
This changes everything we thought about the New York Mets despite an underwhelming 2026
campaign that's coming to the close. The New York Mets have the best rookie core in all of
Major League Baseball. Noam McLean, Carson Benj, A.J. Ewing, and Zach Thornton all headlining
a class that is really hard to forget and will continue to lead the Mets as they look to ascend
in both 2027 and moving forward. What's going on guys? I'm Josh Byrne. You're tuned into Mets
Digest. Guys, thank you for all the support this season. With just one game remaining,
are the Mets going to finish 74-88 or 75-87? Everyone's itching to find out. But the fact
of the matter is, despite all the jokes and sarcasm that we can give ourselves to kind of
handle and cope with the fact that this season was a disaster, there is a legitimate bright spot.
The bright spot is that the Mets have one of, if not the best young cores in all of Major League
Baseball centered around Carson Benj, centered around A.J. Ewing, centered around Noam McLean
and Zach Thornton. When you look at what David Stearns has to do this offseason, we've heard
that he's going to get help in that front office. He has a lot to prove because these past two
offseasons have been a disaster. But one thing that has worked out well under the term of David
Stearns is the ascension of the young Mets. And the young Mets are as good as we've ever seen them
in their history. Because PLA Dinosaur tweeted this, this rookie class for the Mets is by F-worthy
greatest in franchise history. If you look at this year, the 10.7 fan graphs, wins above replacement
cumulatively between Carson Benj, A.J. Ewing and Noam McLean is at 10.7. That's the best. And that's
not even including Zach Thornton, who has been a really nice addition to the starting pitching
rotation as well. So that is something to behold. And of course, you see the year 2014 right under
it. We know what happened in 2015. So hopefully that's a good fortune teller of what's to come
for next season. And Sleeper Mets also tweeting basically along the same lines that insider Joel
Sherman says the Mets have the best rookie class in Major League Baseball. And when you look at
these names, you can totally see where he's coming from. Carson Benj, Nolan McLean, A.J. Ewing, Jonah
Tong, Zach Thornton, and then also guys that I haven't really mentioned yet in Nick Morabito and
Nate Lavender. Lavender has been sensational out of the bullpen and Nick Morabito, his total stats
aren't all that impressive, but he really got off to a slow start. Also hasn't gotten a ton of at
bats and has showed a couple things through September. Maybe he can be another contributor
as a fourth outfielder for the Mets moving forward. But when you look at the top of that
list, that's where it starts. And that's really why when you when you look at the future prospects
of the New York Mets, you have to feel good because there's been so much made of the farm
system, Jefferson Rojas, Billy Amick, Mitch Voight. And then sometimes we forget that the prospects
who have already graduated and who are here now have done really well. Let's start off with Nolan
McLean, who has somewhat quietly put together and completed one of the best rookie starting
pitching seasons in Mets history. Now, obviously, and we saw in that list, Doc Good in 1984.
Nolan McLean, nowhere close. OK, it's not even the same stratosphere, but that's not really
fair to compare against for any rookie pitcher. And Nolan McLean, to his credit, has been very
good. It looked a little shaky. And you also have to figure there was so much hype coming around
Nolan McLean going into this season because of what he did in 2025 when he was so dominant in
those few starts and also him getting that start in the World Baseball Classic for Team USA,
where I felt he held his own. And, you know, he he handled it, I believe, very well.
We remember in May he was struggling a lot. He righted the ship and he posted an ERA that's
just above three, twelve wins, three wins above replacement. And most importantly,
to me, he stayed healthy the entire season. This is what you love to see.
Not many starting pitchers are reliable in terms of their availability. So if the Mets
can continue to have the good fortune of health alongside their young pitchers,
that would go so well. And Nolan McLean, when you look under the hood at what he does,
what he did on baseball savant, he was really spearheaded by an elite fastball
ranking in the ninety nine percentile of overall value. But he didn't really have
a specific weakness. Now you look at the breaking run value and you look at the off speed value
and they're both below league average. And I don't think that's a stuff kind of complaint.
I think what that is stemming from is sometimes we've noticed Nolan McLean can lose the strike
zone. That's why his walk percentage is a little bit below 50 percent. So when I look at the
breaking ball and I look at the off speed, it's not that it doesn't have good movement. In fact,
Nolan McLean has been reported to have amongst the highest spin rates of any major league pitcher
with his off speed and breaking ball. It's that sometimes he can lose command. So if that's
something that he can continue to improve on, there is no reason why he cannot be if he is
not already one of the better pitchers in all of major league baseball. Now, do the Mets have a
finished product in the rotation? No, they probably need to add more. We've talked about
the possibility of them adding Tarek Scouble. But when you have Nolan McLean already linchpinned
at the top of the Mets rotation, that's a good place to start. And looking at the lineup,
you know, you would thought and this is why the whole definition of this team has changed.
You would have thought we'd be talking about the influx of talent, be it Jorge Polanco or Carson
or not Carson Benja, Jorge Polanco and Bo Bichette after this season. But no, it is Carson Benja and
A.J. Ewing who have provided that real stark addition to this lineup. And while the veteran
guys have struggled either due to injury or underperformance, Carson Benja really made the
most of his rookie season. And he started off so slow. But the final numbers with one game to play
still are extremely impressive. A 280 batting average. We've been seeing that batting average
just climb and climb all year. He has officially hit the 20 home run mark, over 20 stolen bases.
He he has four wins above replacement, according to baseball reference.
Just a fantastic season. And these baseball reference numbers don't even account.
Actually, they do account what he did today. But, you know, he has been fantastic. And
correct me. I'm sorry. They don't include what happened today. But nonetheless, he has been
great. And you look at what he's done. Look, again, not a finished product.
Walk percentage on the under 50 percent. But if he can continue to grow, he is still 23 years old.
He has the potential to be one of the best outfielders in the game. And Anthony Decomo
tweeted that only six major league baseball players rank in the 70th percentile or higher
in all three of stat cast values, metrics of batting, base running and fielding.
We obviously are a little hurt still over the Pete Crow Armstrong tree, but Carson Bench on
that list with guys like Crow Armstrong, Bobby Witt, Corbin Carroll, L.A. De La Cruz, Otto Lopez,
all great players. So it's impressive company. And then it's not just him. We all know about
A.J. Ewing, too. A.J. Ewing's had a very successful rookie campaign. And unlike Bench,
he actually made his debut later in the season in May. And he has dealt with some deep struggles
at times. And when you look at what he's done, holistically speaking, three wins above replacement,
it's been a bit of a roller coaster ride. You see May, June, July, specifically that August,
really, really deep slump. But he's finished strong. And this has been a very positive
season for A.J. Ewing, who looks like he can easily be one of the best defensive centerfielders
in major league baseball and probably an above average offensive player already.
So that is great to see. But going back to the holistic viewpoint here, if you look at
just the starting pitchers that the Mets have developed, it's wildly impressive. McLean,
Scott, Thornton and Tong, all varying levels of sample size here. But the fact is all of them
under four ERAs. And when you slot all of them into the rotation and you add in the veteran
Shamanaya, it's a good starting point. You don't feel like this team is miles away from contention
when you are assessing the talent level specifically in that rotation. And more
specifically regarding Zach Thornton, this is a guy who, unlike Ewing and unlike Bench,
wasn't listed amongst the Mets top prospects. But he has been very, very successful this season.
And what he's done is basically just come out and attack hitters and elite.
He's getting a lot of hard hit balls against him, but he is not walking batters. He has an
effective fastball. And according to SMY Mets, who they retweeted what he said after the game,
he's hoping to get his fastball velocity up to 95 miles per hour next season. And it's really
great to see. So if you look at this rotation that the Mets have and you rate it against all
the rotation areas of all other teams, they'd rank third behind only the Yankees and Dodgers,
who are arguably the favorites to go to the World Series this season. Again, the Mets have more work
to do in their roster to get to that point. But when you combine McLean, Thornton, and then
Christian Scott, who technically isn't a rookie, but had a really successful season coming off of
Tommy John, it's a lot of positives here. And Jonah Tong, who really only got to start this
September, finished off his season in a really encouraging way with five innings of one run ball
and nine strikeouts. Despite having a disappointing season at AAA for most of the year, he vastly
improved over the course of late July through August, came up and mostly showed that he is
continuing to develop into the pitcher that we believed a year ago was about to be the Mets ace.
Now, he still has work to do on his end, but this is really promising. And when you look at the
contractual situation of the Mets, you're essentially seeing the salary being bottled
up by the guys like Shawn Minaya, Kodai Senge, Marcus Simeon, and Bo Bichette, all guys who have
been disappointing. But when you look at Minaya, he has gotten better as the season has gone on.
I would feel comfortable with him at least at the back of a rotation in that role. Kodai Senge,
really like what I've seen of him in the bullpen. And then this is the biggest thing. In addition to
David Stearns making the necessary moves this year, they need to get more out of Juan Soto
next year. They need him to stay healthy and they need him to get that OPS up closer to a thousand.
Not that you can complain about the 9-19 it's at right now,
but he's getting paid $50 million, doesn't play good defense. Really need the best version of him
next year. And same thing with Lindor. Now, Lindor, I've been a bit of a defender on, but the fact is
this is easily his worst season as a Met. Easily his worst season of his Major League Baseball
career. And it's been a bit start and stop. I think offensively he hit into some bad luck this
year, but he also, he got hurt too. But what's most concerning is his defense, which has gone
downhill significantly. And with the Mets having a lot of middle infield prospects, it's going to
see over the next year or two if Lindor's defense can improve. And if it does, whether he will stay
at shortstop or not. But the fact is what we thought of this Mets team, what was going to
guide them for success has changed. They have a strong young core and one of the better rookie
classes in all of Major League Baseball. So let me know what you guys think about these young
Mets and how they can impact the outlook of the Mets in 2027 and beyond. Comment below,
let me know. And as always, guys, let's go Mets.

