The Historical Origins and Evolution of International Humanitarian Law: Prof. (Dr.) T.R. Subramanya

Global Affairs Academy
6 followers
1 Video View·Sep 27, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Good afternoon, everyone. Once we are seeing the present scenario of the war, we thought why not
have a session in respect of the historical origins and the evolution of international
humanitarian laws, an assessment up to the outbreak of the Second World War
by Professor T.R. Subramanian, Dean, CMR University's School of Legal Studies, Bangalore.
Those who have been connected with Beyond Laws CLC would have seen that Mr. Subramanian is an
authority under the international law and perspectives. Therefore, we had requested
keeping in view the present scenario, if he could share his knowledge. And he has been
happy to accept our invite. And this part will be, this session is into two parts,
that is up to the Second World War and thereafter. Today is the first session. Over to you, sir.
Thank you. Very good. Good afternoon to Mr. Vikas and your team. Today we'll be discussing
something relating to the development of international humanitarian law from the early
ages till the present day. Now, when we take up this matter, naturally many would feel,
was there a law in the ancient times known as humanitarian law? To be very frank with you,
there was no such law in the ancient times. So, war was fought with the populations of the states.
Because two states were entering into a war, naturally it was a fight between the whole
population. But then, in the evolution towards higher levels of learning, man developed a law,
which is popularly called as the humanitarian laws of warfare. Now, when we take up this matter,
I just intend to speak to you what exactly you mean by the definition of war. The definition
of war which is being given by Professor Oppenheim in his book on Law of Armed Conflict,
Volume 2, Law of War and Neutrality. He points out, war is a contention between two states.
So, this contention between two or more states is fought with through their armed forces.
So, naturally it is a contention between two or more states
fought with and fought through their armed forces and to impose such conditions as the victor
pleases. A person or a state may go to war because it has a huge army which has weapons of mass
destruction or whatever in the way. But then, the final conclusion of war may be totally different.
So, the conclusion may be the person who has gone to the war may get defeated
and may suffer from dismemberment. And that is why it is a contention between two or more states
through their armed forces and impose and the victor will impose such conditions as he pleases.
Now, this is the simplest definition and which can be applied to any situation under the present
international law as well. Now, if you examine the stories of the civilizations from the ancient
times to the present day, remember most of the dictators disliked the timid idea of human
warfare. So, they used to say, remember we do not want anything human there. The conduct for
purpose of winning the war must be inhuman. If you take the BC, there were only two emperors.
One happened to be Ashoka and the second one happened to be Augustus. These are the two
emperors, one from India and from the other continent, were speaking that we actually
dislike the timid idea of war and human suffering should not be there. Humans
might be protected at all costs. The resources which are earned with great difficulty must be
protected and cared for. Come what may. So, this was the approach which was given by a few rulers
like Ashoka and Augustus. But then most of them hated this kind of concept in the ancient times.
When we take the ancient times naturally, the civilization when it began, the Mesopotamians
were the first, remember in 3000 BC, who developed what we call as a military system of defense.
There was no such thing as the military defense system until 3000 BC. Prior to 3000 BC,
the Mesopotamians when they waged war, they said there should be something known as the
military defense system, which is very much essential for the running of a war, without
which war cannot be fought on regular terms. Now, after the Mesopotamians, you might be knowing,
the Romans came into the picture. The Romans when they came into the picture,
you might be knowing, they had traded with the rest of the world. Their trade relations
with Egypt or with other countries were very strong. And always they used to believe that
they are the best in the world. And there was no match to the Roman courts which were adopted by
them. There was one day, always used to speak and say. Now, when they traded or when they signed
treaties with the rest of the world, there might be or there could be some misunderstandings.
So, the event of a misunderstanding, remember for the first time, they said there should be
a declaration of war. Without a declaration of war, war cannot be fought. Then the Romans were
the ones who went to the extent of finding out what we call as the legions. And after establishing
the legions, they said, remember what kind of officers should be kept in the military?
And what power should be given to these people who are enjoying the higher post in the military?
And what type of employees? For example, today we say sergeant. And what powers the sergeant
should be given? No, he did not have any power for that matter. Only the higher-ups had the powers.
So, this was actually prepared by the Romans because they were very good in drafting legislations.
In the civil law system, remember, they had wonderful advisors and they were considered
as statesmen as well. Now, if I just go to the extent of pointing out, there were jurists like
Alpian, jurists like Pepinian, there is jurists like Gaius and Justinian. These are the ones who
made, remember, Rome a very strong state because of the laws which were enacted by way of courts.
So, they are the ones who, for the first time, set up legions and the responsible offices
in the military. And afterwards, the responsible powers which were given to them or attached to
their office, all of them were made by the Romans. Now, after this, remember, after the advent of the
story of Mahabharata, when you read the story of Mahabharata or the story that is being given to
us by posterity, you find lots of law development which have taken place during the course of
Mahabharata. Most of you may be interested to know as well. We are not going to discuss everything
that is being spoken. We speak only the relevant portion which come into the picture of humanitarian
law. In the Mahabharata war, there was an understanding and this understanding was
followed in stricto sensu. And what is this understanding is all about? They said,
poisonous arrows must not be used during the course of war. The war lasted for 18 days and
during the course of these 18 days, they are not supposed to use poisonous, what we call as arrows
during the course of war. Then war was declared, remember, in the early morning. And at the time
of sunset, it will come to a close. See, they declared, they were most civilized. They said,
you cannot fight war during night time as it is being fought today. Today, only when everyone
sleeps, the aerial warfare takes place and the eventual damage that is being
committed on others, the innocent population. So, this was something relating to the Mahabharata.
After the Mahabharata, again we go to the city of Egypt. The Egyptian emperors
naturally entered into what we call as something like Sumerians and others. And Egypt happened to
be the most civilized states then. And the most civilized state of this time, remember, when it
entered with Sumerians, an agreement. And this agreement went to the extent of pointing out
prisoners of war must be protected, come what may. Prisoners of war must be protected, come what may.
But then, the Romans did not bother about it. The Romans always went to the extent of declaring
that it is a war between the whole populations. The elders, the youngsters, the aged, the wounded,
the sick, expectant mothers, remember, all of them were the targets. That is why the Romans were
fought with much brutality. And the brutality, remember, it is at times difficult to explain even
the horrors that is being perpetrated by them. And horrors that were perpetrated by them because
to create a fear amongst the enemy. Don't touch the Romans. If you touch the Romans, what will
happen? So, that was the attitude during the time of Romans. But then, the Egyptians, when they
entered into agreements with the Sumerians and others, they said prisoners of war must at all
times be treated, remember, humanly. Then actually, we come to the year 1590.
The state of Netherlands or the state of Holland, present Holland, drafted what we call as a
chapter. And this chapter is popularly called later as manual. And this manual, which was drafted in
1590, was ultimately, to a certain extent, was the first document which spoke about what we call
as the humanitarian law of warfare. And this document, remember, referred even today. And you
might be knowing the state of Netherlands and the state of Holland has produced wonderful
international law scholars, starting from Hugo Grotius. After Hugo Grotius, we have plenty of
them. And Cornelius Van Winkershock and many others came from the state of France. That is why
the Hague Academy, the International Court of Justice, all of them are placed, the Court of
Arbitration, all of them are placed at the Hague in Netherlands today. Because they are the ones
who are responsible in speaking first. And when this was done, the state of Great Britain did not
lag behind. In order to perpetuate sort of colonial tendency or acquire territories abroad,
they were, for the first time, they produced a manual. And they produced a manual somewhere
between 1600 to 1610. And this manual, for the first time, operational for the state of
Great Britain. Now, you might be knowing that afterwards, a famous 30 years war began in the
year 1618. The 13 years war, when it began in the year 1618, it was, remember, a religious war.
For the first time in the European theatre, a war broke out between the Protestants as well as the
Catholics. And a war, remember, when it broke out, the hardest cruelty was shown and demonstrated
during the course of war. And the 30 years war, remember, has four periods. One happened to be
the Bohemian-Palatine period. The second one is the Danish period. The third period happened to
be the Swedish period. And the fourth period happened to be the Franco-Swedish period.
Now, in the first two periods, Bohemian-Palatine period and the Danish period,
the Catholics won the war. But then, when we speak about the third and the fourth,
with the entry of Gustavus Adolphus of Sweden, victories smiled in favour of the Protestants.
And Gustavus Adolphus of Sweden was primarily responsible in concluding the Treaty of
along with the Cardinal Nazarene of the State of France. Now, remember, when the 30 years war came
in, during the course of the war, Gustavus Adolphus of Sweden in 1621 prepared a war manual.
And this war manual, remember, for the first time spoke about humanitarian law.
Now, you cannot ask the prisoners, you know, by way of asking for ransom. Prisoners should
be released forthwith, come what may. Don't attach anything to the prisoners with the ransom.
Now, you might be knowing, when the Battle of Mangalore took place between Tipu Sultan
and the British, along with the Lord Wellesley. Remember, this was by Cornwall. And soon after
the battle was over, two children, two of Tipu Sultan's children were kept ransom by the British.
So, here is a case wherein the authorities in the 30 years war were championing,
under no circumstances ransom be given and a prisoner should be released forthwith.
That was the attitude which was prevalent in 1648. Now, war happened to be a great document
because in the 30 years war, when the Treaty of Westphalia was concluded, most of the scholars
in the area of international law pointed out, remember, modern international law began with
the signing of the Treaty of Westphalia. Now, the Treaty of Westphalia happened to be a major
multilateral treaty. Most of the issues were negotiated between the Protestants and the
Catholics. And these negotiations once, remember, discussed and there afterwards negotiated,
they came to a particular conclusion and many principles of international law,
including the laws of war, were there along with the principles of humanitarian law.
Now, there afterwards we come to what we call as the fight between the United States,
what we call the sectional conflict. Before the sectional conflict, the fight between
what we call as the State of United States as well as England. See, America happened to be a
colony of the State of England and the way the British were treating the Americans was not liked
and with the result, the War of Independence began in the State of United States.
And in the battle that has taken place, the American army was able to vanquish the British
army. At that time, George III happened to be the King of England. George III happened to be a
Hanoverian who was from Germany but still ruling. He did not know proper English at all.
And he went to the extent of saying, I am the King, in fact, as well as in name.
For having said, remember, he lost an important colony that is the present American States.
Then later after the sectional conflict, it became what we call as the United States of America,
sectional conflict between the South Americans and the North Americans.
And when the North Americans wanted to, remember, give up and abandon the institution of slavery,
South Americans wanted to keep the institution of slavery because it was largely an agricultural
class. Agricultural class wanted laborers and these laborers had to serve 365 days
like bonded labor, which was opposed by the North Americans. So, the war began,
which is called the sectional conflict. And at that time, Abraham Lincoln was in charge of it.
And ultimately, the South Americans, 13 of them elected Jefferson Davis as the president and the
battle was launched. And thereafter, ultimately, the Americans won the war and the British again
just kept out. I just wanted to speak to you. During the course of the sectional conflict
that took place between South Americans and North Americans, the state of Great Britain
expressed its neutrality. And having expressed its neutrality, that means he said, we are not
interested in your war. It is a war between the South Americans and North Americans within the
United States. We are not interested in war. Now, having declared its neutrality, remember,
it supported the South Americans. In the British Liverpool shipyard in London,
they were constructing ships. The British would construct ships and afterwards they would release
it to, remember, South Americans to fight a war against North Americans. And remember,
at that time, the American ambassador in London warned the state of Great Britain,
Her Majesty, we are telling you for sure that you are constructing ships.
And once it is constructed, you are fitting it with the ammunitions and armaments.
And then you are releasing for South Americans to fight against North Americans. This is not
expected. And once you have declared the principle of neutrality, you cannot do that.
But the British did not care. In the meanwhile, there was a ship that was getting constructed
in the British shipyard. And this ship happened to be Alabama, a huge ship.
The American ambassador in London warned and the president wrote a letter to Her Majesty.
And they were all just ignored. And the ship construction was complete. And then it was fitted
with the arms and ammunitions. After getting fitted with the arms and ammunitions, the ship
was released in the dread of a night. And it goes to South America, assists the South Americans
against North Americans. And one Alabama destroyed, remember, 103 British vessels.
103, I'm sorry, 103 American vessels, sorry, 103 American vessels belonging to the North Americans.
Then the war came to an end. When the war came to an end, remember,
America became United States of America. When it became United States of America,
the Americans together demanded compensation from the state of Great Britain for violating
the principle of neutrality. You have expressed your neutrality and having expressed your neutrality,
you have supported the South Americans against us. Now, all of us are one, pay compensation.
In the initial stages, the state of Great Britain refused to arbitrate. But the pressure that was
brought by the state of United States was such it had to agree for arbitration. And the arbitration
court gave, remember, more than 500 million pounds of compensation. And the greatness of
the state of Great Britain was it paid the compensation. That is where the law of neutrality
and the concept of neutrality got strengthened because of the Alabama arbitration.
Now, the second important development that has taken place happened to be a battle
that took place in the year 1859. And this battle happened to be a battle which has taken place in
South Arena. The state of Austria had declared a war against the state of Piedmont and the state
of France. Piedmont was nothing but the sovereign state of Sardinia, which is part of Italy now.
When war was declared with the state of Austria against Piedmont, the present state of Sardinia,
as well as the state of France, inhuman atrocities were perpetrated. All customs of war which were
developed through the centuries were violated. Remember, the target of attack was everyone.
No one was spared. Now, you may ask me, how you came to know about this? Now, there was a witness
and this witness was none but Henry Dunant. Henry Dunant happened to be a businessman and what we
call as a big philosopher. And this person, Henry Dunant, happened to be a Swedish man.
And this Swedish man was a witness to the battle of Salfarino, which has taken, remember, almost
six months from March to almost up to September in the year 1859. And afterwards, remember, he
started describing the atrocities which are perpetrated. And when he described, remember,
this has to come to an end, come what may. When the war came to an end in the year 1864,
he requested the Red Cross because since he being a Swiss man, he had no difficulty in
approaching the Swiss people. And immediately, he approved the Red Cross and a conference was
convened. And in the conference, there were as many as 16 independent and sovereign states
came together. And having come together, they said something has to be done.
This has to come to an end. Cruelty imposed with, remember, ruthlessness, come what may,
has to be stopped. Now, one instance is being given. I will give you two instances in the
battle of Salfarino, which is worth mentioning here. Now, there were soldiers, remember,
the state of France did not have one doctor even to take care of thousand patients.
If thousand, remember, soldiers suffered injury, there was not even a doctor. And for thousand
people, they sent one doctor. And in another instance, a doctor gave a message, remember,
this doctor had to amputate the leg or the hand or fingers of somebody. And he did not have
the proper instruments to do that. And this person was a witness. And being a witness,
remember, being a philanthropist, he went to the extent of providing these equipments.
He is the one he assisted by way of providing medicines. And that actually helped in getting
the Red Cross strengthened for the first time. Today, we say Red Cross is just like just the
great nightingale, like the great nightingale who helps everybody. And it will go to the place
where you find prisoners. And it will take care of them. It will assist them. It will assist the
captured soldiers to write letters to their regiment. It will allow them to write letters
to their home. And the invitation, the letters when it is written, comes back by a reply from
their wives and children or grandchildren or parents, it will go and give back to the soldier.
Who will do? This is done by the Red Cross. That is why Red Cross emblem at all times
are to be protected. This is done by law, humanitarian law. Now thereafter, what has
happened was in the year 1868, this is the one which I mentioned in 1864, in the year 1868,
they signed what we call as the St. Peter's Declaration, St. Petersburg Declaration.
And what is this St. Petersburg Declaration is all about? The St. Petersburg Declaration happened to
be in the event of a war, parties must not use what we call as the exasperating gases.
Later, it was used as the bacteriological elements in a war. Exasperating gases to harm
the enemy soldiers or to harm the concerned area. That was done for the first time in 1868.
Now in addition to this, in the year 1872, they went to the extent of pointing out in the event
of a war, the soldiers are not supposed to use the dum-dum bullets. Now you may ask me, what is
this dum-dum bullets? Dum-dum bullets are bullets, remember, when it is put to a gun and when it
pierces the stomach or body of an enemy, naturally, remember, the whole body gets expanded
and the death by way of poison is instantaneous. For this purpose, they went to the extent of
saying that in the event of a war, there is a prohibition of using dum-dum bullets because
it is humanitarian law not to use such harmful substances to pierce into the body by way of
bullets and harm somebody. That was, remember, for the first time came to be established in the year
1868, 1872. Then they went to the extent of pointing out under the Hague Declaration came
to be established and in the Hague Declaration there were as many as, remember, the Hague
Declaration was adopted in the years 1799, 1899. So, in the 1899 Hague Declaration, for the first
time it was adopted by 28 states. 28 states participated in the discussion. In the discussion
that was followed, they were able to point out under no circumstances in the event of a war,
civilian populations should be targeted. So, civilian populations are not the subject of
attack in the event of a war. The second one important thing that is being used is during
the course of a war, projectiles less than 400 grams and these projectiles less than 400 grams
must not be used in the course of a war by way of balloons and rockets.
So, if it is less than 400 grams, balloons and rockets containing a poisonous substances must
not be used in the event of a war. For the first time it was done and this was renewed for a period
of five years. Although this document is not ratified, remember, they went on, there is nobody
opposed to it. That means for the first time a customary law of warfare, humanitarian law
began and began to develop and it got developed by 1949. Now, in addition to this, they went to
the extent of pointing out poisonous substances by way of rockets and balloons for putting on
the upper strata of atmosphere for purpose of causing the danger to the enemy must not be
allowed to be done. That was another major development. Now, another development which
has taken place in the year 1899 happened to be the use of what we call as the exasperating gases
which are deadly and dangerous to the health of a, what we call as a soldier, must not be used
during the course of war. It has to be prevented. So, these are all started, remember, after the
battle of Sulphurino of 1859. Then we have, remember, what we call the hate codification
conference of 1907. The 1907 hate codification conference for the first time
went to the extent of pointing out that all the rules and regulations which are done
in the 1799 regulations must be respected. In addition to it, depending upon the development
of science and technology, certain things are absolutely prohibited. So, they said,
no use of dum-dum bullets are prohibited during the course of war which spurns the human body
when it pierces into the body. Then exasperating and natural gases which are considered as deadly
and poisonous must not be used. Then projectiles, now earlier it was less than 400 grams, now it is
more than 400 grams, but a half kilo or more must not be used in the course of war. So, you see,
sincere effort began in the hate codification conference of 1899 as well as 1907.
Thereafterwards, remember, in the year 1911, the Institute of International Law met.
Having met, they wanted to discuss something relating to what we call as the release of
poisonous and bacteriological weapons. And at that time, bacteriological weapons were not that
developed. But then still they had the apprehension of fear because, remember, most of them in the
Institute of International Law happened to be jurists in the area of law. They had apprehended
and in the year 1911, they pointed out bacteriological weapons as well as poisonous gases
of any type is not allowed to be used during the course of war between the parties.
Then we come to what we call as the League of Nations. Now, the League of Nations came in after
the conclusion of the First World War. The First World War broke out in the year 1914 and it came
to an end in the year 1917. Now, remember, thereafter, due to the efforts of the State of
United States, what we call the Treaty of Versailles was signed. The Treaty of Versailles, remember,
was signed between the parties who are the war and other parties who are not part of it.
And for the first time in the history, an international institution came to be established.
But right from the beginning, this institution had one defect and this defect is the State
of United States was not a party to the League of Nations. The entire League, League Charter,
that is the Treaty of Versailles, was drafted at the behest of President Wilson of the State
of United States. But the State of United States, when it wanted to become a party to
the League of Nations Treaty, that is the Treaty of Versailles, the American Senate just rejected
by saying, we don't want to become parties to entangling alliances. See their approach then
and see the approach now, the differences between the presidents. Now, when such things were there,
the League of Nations provided one article, Article 171. So, the Treaty of Versailles in
Article 171 pointed out the use of bacteriological weapons as well as investigating gases must not be
used during the course of war between parties to the war. So, whoever ratified this treaty is
supposed to remember not to use bacteriological weapons as well as investigating gases during the
course of war. So, a multilateral treaty expressly pointed out this matter for the public in the
course of war. Then we come to what we call as the year 1922. In the year 1922 and 1923,
lot of discussion has taken place related to aerial warfare. Because for the first time,
remember, in the Second World War, they have used aeroplanes. And these aeroplanes to fight the war
used in limited quantity, not like the quantity as being used now. Now, for example, these days,
you don't have, remember, war that is taking place in a confined area. Earlier days, remember,
all of them used to take place in a confined area. Take the Battle of Kurukshetra.
Battle of Kurukshetra used to take place in a confined area. Or you take the Battle of Plassey,
took place in one area where it was confined. Take the Battle of Haldighat Pass in 1576,
wherein Akbar was able to defeat Rana Pratap, confined to the Haldighat hills.
And the Battle of Panipat, confined to a particular area. Now, these days, it is not
like that. Remember, all are being involved. And since you have a classification of army, navy,
as well as air force, all the forces will try to protect each other and see that the enemy is
destroyed. In circumstances such as this, you can't say and give the dictum which was given
earlier, the war is fought in a fixed place. No, that's not possible. And it is fought everywhere.
Now, you might be knowing yesterday's development that has taken place.
A cargo plane of the state of Iran was supposed to come here to take up medicines
and other necessities from India to the state of Iran to give it to the wounded and the sick.
Now, what has happened? The concerned plane itself was, remember, destroyed.
Now, these are all, remember, today under the present-day international law are related to what
we call as offences against warfare. And there will be penalty in the event of establishing
what we call as a commission for this purpose. Now, thereafterwards, the same 1923, I will speak to you.
This conference of 1923 is related to what we call as general rules of air warfare.
Now, what are the general rules which are being taken under these conventions? I shall just put
to you Article 1 as well as Article 2. Article 1 of the 1923 declaration points out aerial
bombardment of civilian population, aerial bombing of thickly populated places, aerial
bombing of what we call as schools, colleges, and infrastructure-built areas are absolutely
prohibited. It is not possible. Remember, when I speak about thickly populated areas,
you have residential areas thickly populated, and you have other necessities which are being
established in these areas, which is not allowed to be destroyed. Then,
another article, Article 2 of Principle 23, Declaration of 23, which points out, remember,
bombing of military establishment is permitted. And what we call as the armament factories are
permitted. And anything concerned with military is allowed. Cantonment,
then establishments done by the military, their stationing forces where the soldiers are made to,
all of them related to the military are permitted. Otherwise, it is not allowed. It cannot be done.
No person, remember, is supposed to kill the enemy by bombarding thickly populated areas,
schools, colleges, and homes wherein elders only reside. This is not allowed. Only targets is
weakening the enemy by targeting the military establishments, the military armaments hardware,
the places where it is manufactured, only that much. Now, remember, this document is applicable
even today. And for this, there were as many as 25 plus states attended and participated and
agreed with this. Now, then we come to the year 1928. When we come to the year 1928,
for the first time in the history of international law, two brainy chaps, one happened to be Mr.
Kellogg, who happened to be the Secretary of the State of the United States, and Brienne,
who happened to be the Foreign Minister of the State of France, remember, convened a conference.
And this conference, when it was convened, there were 63 states,
63 states participated. And all the 63 states who participated, remember, ultimately agreed
to decide that war as an instrument of national policy was prohibited. In the history of
international law, for the first time, the Brienne-Kellogg Pact or the Kellogg-Brienne
Pact, whatever it is, adopted in 1928, in which 63 members were participants, remember,
just rejected war as an instrument of national policy. No state cannot adopt a formula saying
that war is an instrument of its national policy. It is not possible, whichever state, all of them.
Now, 63 states adopted it. Remember, it is still a rule of international law. Now, you may say,
how it is a rule of international law? Because the Pact of Paris of 1928,
remember, does not have an expiry date. When I speak of it does not have an expiry date,
means that the agreement was not signed for five years or 10 years or 15 years.
They said, from now on, we oppose any state adopting war as an instrument of national policy.
And that is forbidden. It is not allowed to be done. And that is the reason it does not have
an expiry date. And it is only a statement for which 63 states participated and decided.
And it is still in force, still in force. Now, see, for the work which was done
by Briand as well as Kellogg, they were honored with what we call as Nobel Prize.
Both of them were given Nobel Prize. Remember, under the circumstances, their activities are
praised forever. I remember, as a student of international law in the early 70s, 80s,
now we used to study these things. And we used to get so much of appreciation,
because it was taught in such a way in the classroom, everyone appreciated.
Then there afterwards, remember, the League was the one for the first time
opposed the institution of slavery. And there afterwards, remember, it called a convention,
a conference to oppose the institution of slavery in 1926. Having called, remember,
it adopted a convention against the institution of slavery. And in the year 1931-32, it adopted
what we call as a commission and set up an office to oppose the institution of slavery.
Now, many people have a wrong impression saying that the League has done nothing.
But then the League has done many things, many things, many good things.
Only because of the attitude of the state of France, as well as the state
attitude of the state of United Kingdom, it could not, remember, gel together. Both of
them were not in a position to get together. That is why problems came up and it dissolved.
Now, what has happened was, in the year 1936, two incidents took place. I shall explain before I
wind up. The 1936 incident happened to be, one happened to be a fight in the state of Spain
between the nationalist government, as well as the rebellious government who are called the
insurgents. Now, the fight when it started in the state of Spain between the nationalist government,
the ruling party, as well as the insurgent revolutionary party, the revolutionary party,
day by day, became strong. Now, the state of Great Britain, in order to keep trade with the
state of Spain, recognized that part of area which was with the ruling party as the de jure
government. Then simultaneously, it recognized those areas which are captured from the de jure
government or the legal government by the insurgent forces were recognized as the de facto
government. Now, one fine morning what has happened was, the revolutionary government was in a
position to capture the entire state of Spain. At that time, they derecognized the nationalist
government and recognized the revolutionary government as the de jure government. This is
one. Then what has happened was, in the year 1936, Italy invaded Ethiopia. When Italy invaded
Ethiopia, an aggression, open aggression, which was prohibited in international law. Remember,
the state of Great Britain under Clement Attlee went to the extent of recognizing,
first it recognized as de facto recognition. When the Italian rule was established in Ethiopia or
they gave de jure recognition. In the British Parliament, there was so much of hue and cry.
What is happening? The rules of international law which are established over the years with
great difficulty are being flouted and violated by a country which calls herself as the mother
of all democracies. And then the parliamentarian shouted against Clement Attlee and asked him to
get down. And he got down. And in his place, remember, the great Winston Churchill was brought
in as the prime minister. By then, it was 1938, 39. And Adolf Hitler wanted to acquire most states
in Europe. And for his aggrandizement and thirst, there was nobody to quench it. And the state of
Great Britain under Winston Churchill decided ultimately to declare a war. And that war started
in the year 1939. And then the humanitarian law development took place after 1939, one by one,
which I will speak to you in the next edition, which may take about one and a half hours.
Thank you very much. Any questions? I can take a few questions, but I think you are running short
of time. Yeah. We will take it in the next session. Yeah. Any questions you can take now?
I will tell you. No. Should I take it up or you are going? No, no. I can take another five minutes.
I can be with you. Just hold on. Yeah. It says, did the atrocities in the World War I contribute
to the codification of the humanitarian norms before World War II? It is true that the atrocities
perpetrated by the Germans during the course of the First World War was a lesson to everybody.
And there afterwards, remember, they have convinced several things during the course
of the war and subsequently. And they decided to have an international institution.
Now, for the first time, remember, the League of Nations, to be very frank, was more powerful than
the United Nations. The League of Nations had the power to impose sanctions, but the United
Nations will have to consult the Security Council. And these were certain things, which I shall tell
you in the next class, because if I start taking up both the issues, because the League of Nations
was dominated by two states only. That is the state of France, as well as the state of England.
The United States was not a party to it. Oh, remember, they had their own agenda,
their own programs, and their own fight in a series of continents, in India and elsewhere,
all of them were fighting. Then when the Charter of United Nations came in, everything settled.
And thereafter, they had to believe what we call the principle of racial discrimination,
the principle of equality, the principle of equal rights, the principle of equal opportunity.
All of them became part of the Charter of United Nations. For example, under Article 1,
Paragraph 3 of the Charter of United Nations, the United Nations is not supposed to show any
discrimination based on race, sex, religion, and place of birth. So, these were all, remember,
had to be accepted by all of them ultimately, because most of them happened to be states
from the developing countries and the least developed countries. And ultimately, they
decided to help these countries as well. In one of the videos, I have spoken enough,
there is UNIDO as well as UNCTAD, United Nations Conference on Trade and Development,
as well as United Nations International Development Organizations are the two organs
which were established by the United Nations exclusively for the economic development of
the poorer states. Do customary international law contribute in the international human laws
before formal codifications? Naturally. See, for example, most of the laws relating to the
warfare started with the customary rule of international law. And the task of the International
Law Commission, which came to be established in 1945, with 34 members, naturally, earlier it had
25 members, today it has 34 members, only to see that international law, the customary rule of
international law is converted or changed into the conventional rule of international law.
For example, for the first time, you have a convention on the privileges and immunities
of the diplomatic intercourse. Earlier, it was based on the customary rule of international law.
And then we have a law of the treaties. Earlier, there was a treaty that was signed based on the
customary rule of international law. We have a codified document today, law of the treaties,
1969. Then you have, remember, the entire law of the sea was dependent upon the customary rule of
international law. You have a conventional law of the sea. I can speak hours together,
it doesn't require preparation, because for the time being, just give it a glimpse.
Yes, sir. We can take this time or next time. What is the distinction between
Hague law and Geneva law and how do they evolve historically? We'll take it next time.
Yeah, yeah. Okay. Okay. Thank you.
