Is Speaker Mike Johnson planning his own January 6th? Before diving into the explosive battle over the 2026 midterms, The Atlantic’s David Frum joins Jim Acosta to break down how a brewing foreign policy crisis with Iran and skyrocketing gas prices are rapidly draining the administration's political leverage.Frum warns that if economic fallout leaves the 2026 midterm elections razor-thin, Speaker Mike Johnson—not Donald Trump—holds the ultimate constitutional power to decide which House members get seated. Pointing to a shocking 1984 House fight precedent, Frum poses the ultimate question: Does Johnson want his own January 6th crisis, or would he rather take a quiet exit to a lucrative K Street lobbying career?
📌 TIMESTAMPS: 0:00 - Cold Open: Will Mike Johnson Trigger the Next January 6th? 0:20 - Trump's Secret Foreign Policy & The Looming Iran Crisis 04:56 - Surging Gas Prices: How the Economy is Draining Political Power 5:45 Are polls reliable? 07:30 - The 2026 Midterms: Parties have made bad choices How the Speaker Can Hand-Pick the House Majority 10:45 - The 1984 Precedent: Can a Speaker Overturn an Election? 13:00 - K Street or Chaos? Mike Johnson's Ultimate Choice
This discussion examines the political instability of the Trump administration, focusing on strategic failures regarding Iran, domestic economic fallout, and erratic claims about Greenland. It further analyzes the constitutional precedents for contested House elections, emphasizing the House's authority to seat its own members and the potential role of Speaker Mike Johnson in future disputes.
The question is, is this how Mike Johnson wants to go down?
Does he want to have his own January 6th?
Is that how he wants to be remembered?
And he gave the speech before the General Assembly.
He was not, I don't believe that they laughed at him as badly as they did that one time
during the first time, which was very unfortunate for him.
But he did threaten to annihilate Iran, which I'm not sure really anybody, does anybody
really put any stock in these threats anymore, David?
When he talks these days, I often think of a line from the play King Lear, where Lear,
as he begins to lose his power and lose his mind, begins to threaten revenge.
And he says at one pitiful, poignant point, I shall do such things, I know not what they
will be, but they shall be the terrors of the earth.
And Donald Trump sounds like that, that power is visibly ebbing from him.
He started the Iran war in the worst possible way, without mobilizing Congress, without
mobilizing the public.
And what was so crazy about this is the Trump administration, allied with Israel, struck
Iran successfully in the summer of 2025, and did a lot of damage to the Iranian nuclear
program.
And I know from talking to him, and you know, there are a lot of people in Congress who
think the United States has a debt from Iran, that Iran has been a very hostile force to
the United States for a very long time.
And there is a constituency in Congress, a bipartisan one potentially, under a different
kind of president, to do something.
Maybe not a full-fledged war, but to do something.
There are a lot of senators and House members in both parties who will say, if we see a
plan that makes sense, yeah, war.
If Iran had been goofing around during, let's say, Hillary Clinton administration after
Obama and not held up the JCPOA, you could foresee a scenario where maybe a Hillary Clinton
administration might have done something militarily.
And Obama threatened various kinds of action.
So it was there to be done by a different person using different kinds of politics.
But he went in without the public, without Congress, and if that's going to happen, it
better be fast, easy, and cheap.
And it's not fast, easy, and cheap.
And now he has to go back to do this far into the war, the work you should have done before
you went to war.
Do I have Congress?
Do I have the public?
I'm raising your gas prices.
I promise it'll be worth it because you'll be safer.
Well, maybe if you'd asked us in advance, we might even agree.
You didn't ask us in advance.
We got the high gas prices, and now there are all these promises, and we don't believe
you anymore, and you sound weak.
And he's at the mercy of the Iranians, it seems to me.
It does have some, you know, I won't say that Donald Trump is in Jimmy Carter territory
because that makes folks who love Jimmy Carter, and he is a beloved ex-president, late president.
They're not the same person, but he is in the territory where he is at the mercy of
events that are out of his control, and even more so this time around, events of his own
making.
I mean, he's made his bed, as my mother would say.
He's now lying in it.
That is how it, that's what is happening.
Here's where the Carter parallel, I think, really holds, that Jimmy Carter, a lot of
the options that American presidents have for Iran, a lot of the options that every
president has had for the past 50 years, started being planned during the Jimmy Carter administration.
When the Iranians took those 50-plus Americans hostage, Carter called for options including
military options, and every option was studied.
And including the occupation of Karg Island, a lot of the things that Trump talks about.
And what the conclusion, and you can, Ed Luce, I think, is a friend of yours.
He's written this extraordinary book on Zbigniew Brzezinski.
And what we learn from Ed Luce's reporting, or are reminded by his reporting and his research,
is the problem Carter had was the United States, absolutely, the United States could win a
war with Iran.
If Iran were the most important single problem the United States had in the world, and the
United States were to devote all its resources to solving the Iran problem, of course it
would win.
Yes.
Iran is never the most important problem.
And so-
That's right.
So Carter says, I could do it if I gave up on Russia, China, everything else we have
in the world, but I can't, because it's problem number six, I'm making that up.
Yeah.
Problem number six, I can't make it problem number one.
And where Trump is when he says these things is, yeah, the United States could win the
war.
It could do all of these things.
It could say if it sent every resource, but is it really worth it?
And is it worth abandoning Taiwan, abandoning Ukraine, abandoning every other strategic
priority the United States has in order to focus on this one problem?
And that's the reason, in a way, that Iran has always gotten away with it in the past,
which is while they're really, really annoying to the United States and vicious to their
own murdered and oppressed people, they've never been important enough to the United
States to call for the kind of display of muscle that it would take to actually succeed.
Please remember to subscribe.
It's so important to support independent journalism.
It matters.
It matters when you subscribe.
It matters when you like.
It matters when you share.
It matters.
And it matters when you watch.
So thanks for tuning in.
Right.
And when Americans are paying as much as they're paying at the pump right now, I mean, Trump
can institute every press ban that he wants and rail against fake news and negative news.
When people go to the gas pump and they put their credit card in the slot, that's not
fake news.
People are feeling it.
And he is in deep political trouble.
I think it's one of the reasons why he's doing this press ban right now.
He's in deep political trouble.
You look at these poll numbers.
They are devastating.
And I'm sure, David, they're beyond what you would contemplate it might be the case six
months ago that you might have, you know.
I heard you talking about the poll numbers with Joyce and Manny together.
I want to issue an important caution.
Sure.
There are two things are going on with polling that people who absorb polls a lot need to
keep in mind.
The first is generally there was a crisis in the accuracy of polling.
That's true.
And it's a general problem.
And the problem is essentially that for a lot of reasons, it's much more time consuming
to put together a statistically valid sample of which ideally should be a thousand people
in the 2020s than it was in the 1990s.
Well, that's true.
And because of that, a lot of polls just cut down to samples of 500.
But the samples just aren't as good as they used to be.
And so the polls in general are less accurate.
And then there's a special problem, which is since Donald Trump came on the scene, there's
a lot of indications that not just occasionally, but as a regular matter, people who lean Republican
are less likely to reply to polls than people who lean against the Republicans.
So my advice to everybody is if you're trying to just add a point or two, whatever the Republican
number is in any race, I'd add a point or two.
And I would also be careful about just relying on polls too much as a source of information.
They're just not as good as they were in the 1990s.
And maybe there are other barometers, for example, of Byron Donalds, who's running for
governor of Florida, apparently is so freaked out that he is scrubbing Trump references
from his campaign website.
That's according to the Miami Herald.
So some of these campaigns, as you know, David, they do their own internal polling.
And some of the internal polling, from my understanding, is starting to freak out a
lot of these Republican campaigns and what were supposedly safe races.
Yeah.
Look, I don't doubt that this is going to be a big Democratic year.
Republican margin in the House anyway, so narrow that even for a small Democratic year,
you'd expect the House to flip.
But the Senate map, I'm not going to pretend to understand.
And it's a strange year too, where on both parties, parties have made bad, bad choices.
Ken Paxton, Abdullah Saeed, the parties have not gone with their best nominees.
And so, I mean, you really, you could have a situation where the Democrats lose Michigan
and win Texas.
Which is-
That's true.
You could.
And then not get the majority somehow because of that.
Yeah.
And all because of candidate quality.
The Republicans have a weak candidate in Texas, the Democrats have a bad candidate in Michigan.
Yeah.
But I do think that the public is tiring of Trump's act.
I mean, even while he's doing this press ban, he's trying to launch something called Trump
TV.
Yeah.
Which, I mean, he already has Trump State TV.
It's much of the sycophantic networks that exist out there.
Abdullah Saeed retweeted that and said, we want cheaper gas, man.
But, you know, some of this feels like, you know, ninth, tenth season of The Apprentice
type stuff.
When he was-
We have a video of Trump threatening Greenland today again and saying, we now have absolute
power over Greenland.
He was basically saying, we now control Greenland, which is horse crap, but we should play this
video because-
And just get your response, David, because I just wonder that we're starting to see the
wizard behind the curtain.
You know, I just think that now people see it.
Days ago, the United States has also reached an unprecedented agreement regarding the northern
frontier of North America, the large and strategically vital piece of land known as Greenland.
This agreement made with the kingdom of Denmark, an incredible, beautiful country.
And the Greenland people itself gives the United States permanent control over security
and all other needs on that territory.
Permanent control over security.
David, this is nutty stuff and the Danes are having to sit there and just take it.
I think the Danes can smile quietly to themselves because somebody had a wonderful analogy.
What's happened here is the spoiled child is in the playroom screaming and yelling and
kicking and throwing a tantrum because it wants a new toy and its behavior is so bad
that it's not getting a new toy.
And finally, what the parents do to mollify this terrible child is they go into the child's
room, take a toy the child already has, and wrap it in gift wrap and say, here's a present,
here's a new toy.
And the child rips up the wrapping paper and grabs the toy and say, this is the best toy
I've got.
The United States has been in Greenland since before it entered World War II.
It's been there since 1941.
There's a treaty written in 1951 and the treaty says, you want bases in Greenland?
We're delighted to let you have bases in Greenland.
Have all you want.
At one point, there were 17 American bases in Greenland.
I think there's now one or two.
The Danes always said, you want more bases in Greenland or you want to send more troops
to Greenland?
That's part of the security of Denmark.
NATO member protects Britain, it protects other NATO countries, but be our guest.
The constraint on the American presence in Greenland has always been American defense
budgets, not Danish refusal.
And if you want to mine in Greenland, and if you figure out a way to get under a mile
of ice to get at where the minerals are, a lot of people think it makes more sense to
mine in Colorado or in Indonesia where there isn't a mile of ice, but if you have figured
out a technique, it's an EU country, it welcomes foreign investment, the rule of laws, there's
been no obstacle to any of these things.
So what has happened here is that Trump has been persuaded he got a big win when he got
the status quo.
And the status quo was always good, so I don't know what this commotion was all about, but
the damage left behind in the US-EU relationship, that's not going to be fixed so fast.
And I guess not to bounce around too much, but just finally, David, I mean, I was talking
to Joyce a few moments ago and she was sounding, I thought, somewhat optimistic that we're
going to get through these midterms and it's going to work out okay and count the votes
some attempts to throw a monkey wrench in there, but it's not going to succeed.
I am not as optimistic when I see Donald Trump musing about, and I don't think he's going
to get an arch with snipers on top.
But I think that the fact that he muses about this, the fact that he's hellbent on putting
his name on the Kennedy Center, he's becoming more and more unstable, it seems to me, in
a way that we can't calculate or imagine what he might do that could just destabilize
and throw everything up in flames.
I thought your line of questioning about the elections was very astute because if the networks
report on election night that the Democrats have picked up 38 or 42 seats, then I think
there's not a lot Mike Johnson can do.
And he may quibble at the margin, but it's just a hope.
Why cause so much commotion, it won't make any difference.
But if it's tighter, if we're right, if this polling is overstating things, if it's tighter,
and I came in late so I don't know if you discussed the race in 1984 in Indiana, which
is the ultimate precedent here, so in Indiana, I think the 7th district, there was a very
close contest separated by a couple of hundred votes as to who won, the Republican, the Democrat.
I'm now going to forget who's on which side of who was up and who was down, but it went
to the Supreme Court and the Supreme Court said, the Constitution says that Congress,
the House of Representatives, is the judge of the qualifications of its own members.
So if there's a real controversy over whom to seat, the courts say, we won't bail you
out.
This is a matter for the House of Representatives.
And what happened in 1984 was the Democrats ultimately prevailed because they were then
the majority of the House and they said, our guy won, not your guy.
And they did that as an act of the House of Representatives, not as the court.
And that's a precedent that Mike Johnson, if it's real close, if it's eight seats that
are at stake, not 38, he's got the 1994 precedent.
I would encourage people to go back and read that case because it's going to be heard from
a lot if the outcome is close in 2026.
Interesting.
And you think, so we just don't know.
We're on the dark side of it now.
Where do we get to the other side of this?
Well, Trump will need, the one, the big question is Trump will need Mike Johnson actively to
cooperate with this project because it doesn't say the president, the courts have not said
the president is the judge.
It says the House of Representatives, and that means the people who have the majority
at the time the decision is made.
So in November, the Republicans will have the majority.
And the question is, is this how Mike Johnson wants to go down?
Does he want to have his own January 6th?
Is that how he wants to be remembered?
Or does Mike Johnson say, you know, this is a pretty tough job I've had, I haven't enjoyed
it.
There's a beautiful lobbying office waiting for me on K street.
Now you're talking.
I'm actually, I'm going to do my, I'll say what Donald Trump wants me to say, but I'm
out of here for my life of golf and high fees.
And so a lot will turn on him because it will be his call, not the president's, whether
to sabotage the seating of representatives after the vote.
Yeah.
We'll see what kind of a true believer Mike Johnson is at that point when he's got your,
and you're absolutely right.
That, that is Washington.
That's how it works in hashtag this town, but David from the Atlantic, David, always
great to see you really appreciate the insights.
I always learn something every time we sit down together.
Thank you.
Thank all of you who are a part of this independent media movement, like you subscribe, share.
You are supporting, you are lifting up independent media.
Make sure you support independent media so we can continue to bring stories like this.
Hit that subscribe button, like a share.
It all matters.
It all supports what we do.
And if you are a paid subscriber, you get access to our daily newsletter, the Jim Acosta
morning memo.
You're getting the daily video updates that are coming out every day, which give you a
great synopsis of the news with a little, little tongue in cheek, little, we're having
a little fun here and there.
That's okay.
As long as we're not, we don't want to be too serious.
So we can help some folks get through this moment that we're all going through together.
We're all going through a moment.
We're having a moment right now, aren't we?
But in the meantime, still reporting from Washington, I'm Jim Acosta.
I'll see you next time.
Broadcasting live from the heart of New York City.
This has been a Jim Acosta show special report.
Okay.
So if you really like this program, make sure you hit the subscribe button.
But also if you want to watch a full clip of the show, you can just click up on this
thing right up here.
Look at that right over there.
Just click on that.
You can watch the full show.
Or if you want to watch a shorter clip, click this thing over here.
And don't forget, of course, to hit that subscribe button.
That subscribe button is right there.
It's just, it's so easy.
Even I can do it.
Somebody who passes a cognitive test like myself can do it.
Right there.
Hit that subscribe button.
Do it now.