What if King Charles did tell Earl Spencer that "we’ll forget [Diana] soon enough" in the days after her death? It's one word against another but the public discourse seems pretty settled - that Diana's brother is at best misremembering, at worst lying. How much has the Palace spin team forged that narrative? If you read the Palace statement closely, you'll notice that it never outright denies the claim, even if it does point out that "the pain of fraternal grief can cloud reason". "Never complain, never explain" is the motto associated with the Buckingham Palace media strategy. But they do complain. And they do explain - just not often publicly. Andrew Lownie's bombshell biography of Andrew Moutbatten-Windsor - 'Entitled: The Rise and Fall of the House of York' - shone a light on Andrew's relationship with Epstein before the release of the Epstein files. He has reported on and written about the Firm for years, but - unlike much of the Royal rota - they would much rather he didn't. In the week where the Royals find themselves dragged into yet another scandal, he sat down with Lewis to explore how the press operation around the King works, why he believes Spencer, and what Andrew thinks now.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
Journalist Andrew Lowney discusses the British monarchy's reputation management, focusing on Earl Spencer's allegations regarding King Charles's reaction to Princess Diana's death. The conversation examines the Palace's use of press patronage to suppress critics, the rehabilitation of controversial figures, and the systemic lack of accountability regarding Prince Andrew's scandals.
I think one has to put oneself back into the mindset of 1997, right, and the years leading
up to that, that she had been such a problem, such a thorn in the side, that she was constantly
getting attention, she was such a star, and ultimately we know that Charles had been utterly
tunnel vision about marrying Camilla. Yeah, well it brings back that time which they thought they
kind of done and dusted and Camilla was now queen and everyone's forgotten about her and no one was
throwing bread rolls at her, and this brings back that moment and people, you know, still feel very
strongly about how Diana was treated. Let's take this Earl Spencer quote which was on the record
in this case, looked like a denial, wasn't really a denial, was basically an attack on his character
or certainly an attack on his state of mind, but they do that quite a lot, don't they? I mean they
do that quite a lot on the record or off the record, I mean they did that to Virginia Guiffre.
I mean the fact is that the hush money which it was paid to basically shut up Virginia Guiffre,
everyone in the royal house talking about that, you know, which the hecklers are shouting,
what did you know, when did you know, what did you do about it? The News Agents podcast
is brought to you by HSBC UK, opening up a world of opportunity. This is a global production.
The House of Windsor has taken yet another battering this week. All over the world,
allegations from Princess Diana's own brother that the king himself was giddy at her death,
that he told Earl Spencer in the hours after her tragic car crash in Paris in 1997,
that her sons would forget her soon enough. On paper, pulped or otherwise, you might think that
that could be enough at least to wound a monarch whose own ascension was almost halted by the toxin
which flowed from the Diana marriage and her demise, and yet it hasn't really. The battering
has felt like toasting at best. Why? The passage of time, the peers dimension, isn't there always
one, or is it something else? The power of the media to still relentlessly mediate royal stories,
an alliance between palace and press which affects royal coverage in ways most of us
don't ever even see. Andrew Lowney has seen that process at the sharp end. He's one of the few
writers and journalists about royal affairs who can't be placed neatly into the category of courtier.
His book, Entitled, a biography of the former Duke and Duchess of York, became a bestseller because
it spared no royal blushes and applied scrutiny which we rarely see, exposing Andrew and Fergie
as well the entitled figures that they then were. So we thought what better week to invite Andrew
into the news agent studio, that's Andrew Lowney, to assess how damaging has this book been? What is
the state of the House of Windsor now, and how does the palace work with press to curate our monarchs
and princes? Welcome to the News Agents. The News Agents. Well Andrew Lowney, welcome back to the
News Agents. Let's just actually start very very clear, do you believe Earl Spencer? Yes I do, I
think broadly speaking, I've only read half the book, but I mean broadly speaking I think he's
telling the truth. It was a good opportunity to challenge the narrative that we've been fed for
the last 30 years, and I think that's what he wanted to do. I think the problem is he's been
let down by some sloppy editing and poor legal work, and so he has to take responsibility for
the mistakes he's made, but you know those should have been picked up. And so I think the sad thing
is that the message that he had is kind of being diluted, and indeed in some ways has been
destroyed by the fact that he has made some very silly mistakes in the book. I suppose the
natural thing to ask would be what's the point of it? I mean it's so long ago, I mean of course
he's got the right to write a book about his sister if he wishes, but what's the point of it all?
Well his argument is there's going to be a lot coming out next year for the anniversary. I mean
I know dozens of books lined up, television programs, and you know everyone wants to kind
of shape the historical record. He wants to get his version of events out before,
I think as he honestly said, before the TV programs and the books in which he has no control
bring out a slightly different version. That seems to me a perfectly genuine reason. I mean
after all it's why politicians and generals write their memoirs. The thing I have to say, Andrew,
I mean we've talked before about Prince Andrew, or formerly known as Prince Andrew, Andrew Mountbatten
Windsor, and you know as scandals go in the royal family, how does this compare? Oh how does it
compare? Well what, the Charles Spencer with the Andrew one? Let me rephrase it. I mean how,
obviously the royal family have been going through plenty of turbulence in recent years,
it always feels as they are in one way or another. Even in the king's short reign
there have been lots of scandals, lots of problems. How does this compare to all of those
would you say, or will it just disappear? No I think this is just another nick in the whole
institution and it's going to begin to snowball depending on how they respond. You know I think
the Andrew thing is very serious because it was about endemic corruption within the institution
itself, not just two rogue apples there. But I think people sense a vulnerability with the monarchy,
I think people are more emboldened, I think people are much less deferential. We've had
many more programs questioning their finances for example, and I think you know even members of the
royal family sense an opportunity here. I don't think it's a coincidence that Harry has popped
back and we've got now Sarah Ferguson back in town. So it's, and I think the problem is the
monarchy always reacts too little too late and just misjudges the mood, and instead of addressing
all these issues they kind of try and cover them up. And I think once people realise the cover-up
that's gone on over Andrew over the last 40 years, I think they really will be in trouble.
We'll come back to Andrew, but just on this question around the sort of he said,
with Earl Spencer and the King, one of the things I've been most interested in really is not so much
the substance of it, which after all we can probably never really prove, but the reaction
to it. I mean I have been amazed, I don't know about you, at the number of people, you know,
senior media people, commentators, whatever, who all have been talking about this idea that the
palace has vehemently denied everything that Earl Spencer said, but their statement didn't deny it.
No, I mean and this is always what happens, it's some sort of woolly statement which they think
discredits him, but it doesn't address the issue, absolutely. I think what's very interesting is
we've seen very coordinated attacks on him, it's all about him as a father and a husband.
And they basically called him mad, or, you know, not mad, they basically said that he was just,
you know, disturbed and he couldn't really remember things at the time.
Yeah, I mean they always play the man rather than the ball, I mean I've had experience with this
and the messenger gets blamed. So yeah, I mean I think what's interesting is that they responded
so vehemently and quickly, when in fact a dignified silence might have been cleverer. I mean I think
the problem with Charles Spencer, as with Harry, is they kind of host themselves with their own
petard. Why do you think it, because you know it was atypical wasn't it, why do you think they did
respond at all and then so personally, so viscerally? Well there's a lot of personal animus
between the royal family and Spencer, I mean we saw it even in the eulogy.
But I think that the sense of someone as an insider always sounds more authoritative than
someone like me writing. I mean it's true of intelligence books, when I wrote intelligence
books, they would come down hard on a Peter Wright, but they would let things by people like
me get through, even though it came from often the same source. So I think also maybe a new,
more aggressive approach to these things, because they realise never explain, never complain doesn't
work. Who knows what the thinking is, but there's, I think they're always trying to change
the narrative, I mean to suit their own purposes and you know we often find them
briefing against other members of the royal family to take attention away from the principles etc.
I mean it's what Harry complained about and it's what Diana complained about.
Is it reflective perhaps of you know all these years on, as you say nearly 30 years on now from
her death in 1997, that she still touches such a nerve, that they're still afraid of her in one
way, and afraid of her legacy, that she's so untouchable and become so iconic that
she made them afraid when she was alive and she still is in death.
Well I mean she's mortalised by her early death and of course you know people project onto her
what they want, but yes I mean she was a sort of star and that was the problem,
that she kind of eclipsed the other members of the royal family, they didn't like that,
and that was part of the sort of background to these discussions with Charles Spencer.
I mean I don't believe that the king was quite as callous as he says, but again these things can be
in the heat of rather angry exchanges, things can be misinterpreted, can be misheard,
so you know there could be some truth on both sides. But yes I think she still has this power,
I mean the fact that 30 years after her death there are going to be so many programmes,
new people are still coming forward, we're getting new information.
I mean next year will be quite uncomfortable for them, won't it, because you know inevitably as
you say there will be so much recollection and reflection on her life and her death,
and let's be honest I mean I'm still amazed to some extent that there isn't
more thinking about reflection on how they behaved towards her in those years.
Well I mean this was the opportunity to do that, and I mean there have been,
there was a very good documentary that Phil Craig made with Patrick Jefferson which kind of
raised this years ago, but I think the problem is that yeah I mean there is a lot of support
for her still, there's a sense that she was badly treated. I mean my own view of her has changed the
more I learn, in that I think you know there was clearly a lot of briefing against her,
they talked to tame journalists to present her as mentally unbalanced,
we clearly had the panoramas thing. You begin to see why she may have felt paranoid,
and you see how they use tame journalists to feed a narrative, and they try and silence others,
and I mean we saw that, I mean I saw that with the Andrew book, I mean the fact that
ABC television put pressure, sorry the palace put pressure on ABC television not to run their
programme on Giffrey, threatening not to give them access in future to members of the royal family,
and that's how they operate, I mean they deny, they then send legal letters,
they then either use pressure or patronage to kind of keep everyone in line.
Do you think that's happening with this story, with the Spencer story?
Yes, I think there's been a very consistent response from all the usual suspects get
trotted out to defend the monarchy, and it's very hard to find independent commentators,
you know, who are prepared to stand with the heads of other parapet. Ayn Wilson is one,
I thought it was very interesting that Richard Kaye came out and said that Charles Spencer had
said similar things to him at the time, but I had an interesting experience the other day,
this woman called Janet Jenkins, who was one of Charles's lovers in the 70s and 80s,
she wrote, they exchanged letters, some of those letters she sold, had been published,
she said that Charles had said very similar things to her in letters written after Diana's death.
Now I raised this in a podcast last week, within hours the palace had been in touch
with Janet Jenkins, saying that she shouldn't talk to anyone, she shouldn't show the letters
to anyone, and I've seen the text messages from her to my source, because I was very keen to
interview her and encourage her to come forward, because this was of course backing up Charles
Spencer. So that's the sort of pressure that's going on behind the scenes, and people do feel
scared. What was Charles saying to her? Well, I mean, I think the tenure of it was, you know,
thank goodness this makes my life a lot easier. Really? And I suppose you have to, and this is
why I can at least imagine a world in which Spencer's case is credible, because I think
one has to put oneself back into the mindset of 1997, right, and the years leading up to that,
that she had been such a problem, such a thorn in the side, that she was constantly getting
attention, she was such a star, and ultimately we know that Charles had been utterly tunnel vision
about marrying Camilla. Yeah, well it brings back that time, which they thought they'd kind of done
and dusted, and Camilla was now Queen, and everyone had forgotten about her, and no one was throwing
bread rolls at her, and this brings back that moment, and people, you know, still feel very
strongly about how Diana was treated. I mean, I think one thing that's interesting is you say,
why now? All the key players who could disprove Charles Spencer are now dead, so Robert Fellows,
perhaps the Queen and Prince Philip, his own mother, people who might have been some sort of
restraint on him are no longer there. He feels free to talk about this. So that's, you know,
one argument for waiting, but, you know, I think he's clearly felt this very strong sense of
resentment, the sense that his sister has been reduced by the royal family, and he's using this
as an opportunity to settle all scores. This is the War of the Waleses, you know, just going on
for another, you know, 30 years on. Is it also, I mean, just from a media point of view, something
that's always, one has to marvel at, in a sense, and you've got to hand it to the palace, the
rehabilitation of the Queen, Queen Camilla, someone who was perhaps unfairly, at the time,
loathed by much of the public, who was treated very badly by the press in some ways.
Now, this almost adored figure by the press, I mean, I can't think, apart from the King himself,
almost no one gets a better press, the way that she's written up, her work, all of these sorts
of things. Is it also because that any time Diana is invoked and is talked about, and that time is
dredged up, that it almost invites the public to remember the other Camilla, the Camilla of
the 1990s, rather than the 1920s? Yes, well, that's their worry. I mean, you're absolutely
right. I mean, I think Camilla has kind of earned her spurs. She's just quietly gone on, done her
duty, never complained. And I think there is a respect for that in the public. And, you know,
people do change their minds. You know, you can still, you know, feel that clearly Diana was
wronged, but Camilla has kind of worked her passage back. And I think one of the interesting
things is so many of the royals could work their passage back. I mean, we think how unpopular
Anne was, and now, of course, she's now seen as, you know, a national treasure. But how,
actually, with good reputation management, even Prince Andrew, I think, could be rehabilitated.
Really? Well, maybe a little bit. I hope you know some pretty good PR people,
because it's an uphill struggle, I'd say, right? I think Andrew might be tough. But I mean,
Sarah Ferguson is back. She's hoping that she's going to play the victimhood again,
and she'll be back. And she's done it twice before. So it's possible to change public perceptions.
When you talk about the people and the journalists as a favoured journalist that exists,
how does that work? Because it's not a world that most people would understand or see.
How does the palace, how does it conduct its work and its PR?
Well, I mean, I'm not privy to it. But I mean, clearly, they are very good at employing
very good members of the pack to come and work as royal press people. We've just had
someone from Sky go across. We clearly took in Andre, who's the press secretary, was the male.
And this helps, I mean, with their own personal contacts to kind of suppress stories. And Piers
Morgan, even yesterday, I think, on the program was talking about how he killed stories for Diana
by being close to her. So there is a sort of deal that goes on. In return for access,
they will kind of help control the narrative. And I mean, there's some people like the principals
that are kind of, you can't touch. But, you know, it's a bit like how Max Clifford worked.
You give them a bone to kind of stop them knowing another bone. I think there's some people,
Tom Sykes is a good example, who didn't play ball with them, was thrown out of the royal rota,
is now working at the Daily Beast, who has good connections. And the way I work as a biographer
is to kind of come out the outside. Generally, I work off records if they're available. But when
they're not with a contemporary figure, you have to talk to people. But there are plenty of people
you can talk to who are not, shall we say, in the centre. And I think so many of the royal writers
just depend on a few courtiers, tame people who will help brief them, because they can't be bothered
to go and look at the forums, to go and look at the sort of, trace people through the electoral
roll, find them on LinkedIn, etc. But what do you think, I mean, I don't particularly remember
the sort of period of the War of the Wales and so on, and all the sort of tabloid stories there
were at that time. But my understanding of that era is that the royal family generally, perhaps
the Queen accepted, but generally speaking, much of the royal family was being battered constantly
by the press, negative stories by the press. I can barely think of an institution in Britain now
that I feel gets a better press. You know, very often, pretty much across the piece,
a sort of unscrutinised kind of, you know, rose-tinted glasses kind of approach. So what's
changed? Because it feels to me that there is so much, it feels to me as if there's potentially
more deference now in the press, and there wasn't, say, the 1990s.
Well, I think the hacking, all the hacking scandal, I think, you know, the tabloid,
the end of the News of the World, people like that, you know, the people haven't got the money
to do investigative journalism, so it's easy to do the soft journalism, just get fed the PR spin.
I think that's one thing. I think what's very interesting is, as you say, we've had this period,
actually, of reasonable calm until perhaps the beginning of Charles's reign, and yet support
for the monarchy has gradually diminished. It's not shaped by the scandals. It seems to be just
either growing indifference or whatever. But you're absolutely right, you know,
I was looking at some stuff this morning, and the commentators are saying, you know,
ignore Charles Spencer, that's not important. The really important thing is that David Beckham was
there with Catherine in a lovely frock opening something. And I think that in some ways is what
the audience wants. And I just know, again, from podcasts that will sometimes have me on or won't
have me on, is they're rather shaped by their listeners. And they don't want people, for
example, to be critical of Catherine and William, because all their supporters like them. It's safe
to attack Meghan and Harry. And I think a lot of these broadcasters are shaped by their audience
and are feeding their audience what they want to hear. When your book came out on Andrew and
Sarah Fergus, did you experience in terms of how the press covered your book? Could you feel the
hand of the palace? Oh, absolutely. I've discovered a story the other day about a journalist who was
told not to do anything with me that he would lose access if he talked to me. I mean, there
were some pretty critical reviews put out. I mean, even before the book was published,
there was stuff on Wikipedia, for example, which is all negative, even though the book has had very
good reviews elsewhere. Yeah, I had invitations rescinded. I had interviews that I did that were
never run. I had certain papers that never covered me. The Sun, for example, have hardly covered my
book. And you would have thought it was manna from heaven for them. When I appeared once on a podcast
a year before the book came out and was critical of Andrew and Sarah Ferguson, she complained to
them. They took down the piece based on what I'd said and did an interview with her. And I think
what's very interesting is all the stories on Sarah Ferguson now are coming out from The Sun.
They're the ones who found her in Austria, a picture taken by one of her favourite photographers.
They're the ones saying that she's writing a book now, when I suspect this is all part of
a negotiation with the palace to get them to pay her bills. And wasn't their briefing
suggest you were a Republican or Marxist? Yes, you can see I'm a Marxist. I'm a Republican.
Red Lowney. I'm well known. It is, it's very difficult. But I mean, also, you know, this stuff,
I use prostitutes. I'm always taking people's numbers and wanting to ring them up.
You didn't know it was the palace briefing that you were a Marxist?
No, I think there's a lot. No, I think there's a lot of stuff from people who just are very,
very strong royalists and feel that I'm going to bring the edifice down and I need to be brought
down. I think there has been some, shall we say, coordinated response. I mean, it's quite well
delineated that I mean, Fergie was talking to private detectives to try and smear Virginia
Giuffre. We see in the Epstein files, Epstein, Ghislaine and Andrew getting together to bring
a PR firm to try and undermine Virginia's testimony. We've got clearly all these people
like Jay Beecher and Victoria Harvey who are trying to create an alternative narrative.
I mean, you mentioned Virginia Giuffre. Is it right you think that in a way, I mean,
one of the things I think doesn't get enough attention is the way, let's take this Earl
Spencer quote, which to be fair was on the record in this case, looked like a denial,
wasn't really a denial, was basically an attack on his character or certainly an attack on his
state of mind. But they do that quite a lot, don't they? I mean, they do that quite a lot
on the record or off the record. I mean, they did that to Virginia Giuffre.
Absolutely. Absolutely. And I've seen it. I mean, just when my books came out, when I did the book
on Traitor King on Edward VIII, I had no broadsheet reviews for six months. And the briefing was going
out, there's nothing new in this. He's just got an agenda. This is ridiculous. He's misread history,
etc. So, and that was coming.
Has someone listening to this said you were paranoid, Andrew?
Well, I mean, I began as a literary biographer. I then moved into intelligence. And I moved into
royal books kind of just by chance. And I certainly didn't believe in conspiracy theories. I mean,
I have a PhD. But increasingly, I do feel, yes, that there is, well, as I say, there is an attempt
to create a narrative and news management. And that's probably true of anything, any good PR
company.
All institutions do that.
Is do that. Exactly. That's their job to put a spin on things. But I think it's a little,
it's a difference between putting a spin and telling lies. And I think increasingly,
we've seen a lot of lies being told and denials. And that's not true just of the royal family.
It's true, for example, comments that were made about Prince Andrew. I mean, I got denials from
former foreign secretary saying they had no dealings with Andrew, which is clearly not true.
And certainly talking to sensitivity reviewers who look at,
who basically decide what goes in the archives, the line they're given is basically anything on
the royals, take out, this doesn't go to the archives, and this goes to Buckingham Palace.
I suppose as well, I mean, just thinking about it, of all public institutions,
of all institutions, generally, I mean, I suppose the monarchy, how it knows that it
relies on consent, and that consent cannot be readily expressed, right? It can't be
expressed in the ballot box, so on. It can't really do very much. It's in a sort of state
of sort of permanent grace. And I suppose because it knows that it needs that consent,
more than almost any other institution, it zealously guards its PR and its reputation.
And so it doesn't surprise me in a sense, the phenomenon that you're describing,
because it must exist in a permanent state of paranoia.
But surely the way to earn trust and respect is to be accountable, to be transparent,
and to be honest, rather than to do cover-ups,
because cover-ups are always worse than often the original crime.
I want to talk a little bit more about Andrew, which is obviously your speciality, but before we
do, the Earl Spencer affair now, I suppose we can call it, do you think that he is being
fatally undermined by the Piers Morgan mistake?
Yes, I do think that that is what people remember and they will use.
Do you think Piers has been speaking to the palace about it?
No, I think Piers, you know, understandably feels pretty upset by it. I mean, it's a very,
it's a harsh thing to say, and when it's not true, and when, as he pointed out,
he actually was very friendly with Diana, he's quite entitled to make a fuss.
Do you think they'll end up pulping the book?
Well, I think they should.
You do?
Yeah. I mean, what tends to happen in these things is they say they're going to pulp it and,
you know, quietly nothing happens. But yeah, and I think what's interesting is this is the
publisher that published The Salt Path, shown to be, you know, not accurate. I mean, we went
through, on my book, 18 different legal reads. So this is the stuff that should be picked up
by the lawyers and a sub-editor apart from Charles Spencer. So it's very, very sloppy
publishing as well.
Where are we on the Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor story? Because in a sense, I mean, I don't
think there could be any doubt it is easily the most serious scandal, institutionally,
to rock the palace, I think, for decades. It isn't just about personal impropriety or, like,
sexual affairs or anything like that. We're talking, you know, very, very serious,
the most serious allegations. And yet it sort of seems to have disappeared rather.
Well, it's interesting that the briefing that's going on is poor old Prince Andrew's in limbo,
he doesn't know what's happening, etc., which actually is not true. I mean, he's been able
to travel freely, his passport wasn't taken away, he's been going, I understand, to the
Middle East, he's been going to France, he's been visiting his, I mean, he's been going
to Gatcombe Park and seen Princess Anne. So he's not under house arrest in Sandringham.
Because a lot of the briefing has been that he's sort of holed up,
barely able to leave the house and so on in Sandringham.
Exactly. We're trying to, you know, create a sense of sympathy for him. I mean, there
was briefing when my book came out that he was suicidal. And again, I think that's one
of the things that's been put out there. But we are in limbo. We're in limbo because we
don't know what's happening about this investigation. You know, the police, I think,
understandably are keeping the whole thing quiet. They're saying it's going to take a long time.
But there is a suspicion that they're kicking it into the long grass, that it's just one of
those things not to deal with. And I've seen this time and time again, when I talk to people,
the National Crime Agency, who had things brought to them about Andrew,
they shuffle the papers around, this was years ago, and, you know, too difficult to deal with.
And I think that's possibly the problem now. I think even if the police do their job,
the Crown Prosecution Service will probably say, sorry, we can't make the charges stick.
I think you're absolutely right. It's pretty evident to me that he shared information with
unauthorized people in return for paying off his wife's debts. It's a pretty clear case of
breach of the Official Secrets Act. The encouraging sign is there seem to be women who are prepared
to come forward and speak to the police. There's a woman who was trafficked to him in 2010,
who is now talking. And I hope others will come forward. So I think there's a very strong case
that could be brought. But it's clearly that they're playing the long game in the hope somehow
something will change and they haven't got to bite the bullet.
Andrew, I still find it genuinely astounding. Two things I find astounding. One, tell me if
I'm wrong, but as far as I know, there has been no institutional attempt officially within the
palace to try and make account of and to find out what may or may not have been known institutionally
by people working in the royal household in and around Andrew. They consistently put out
statements saying that our thoughts are with victims of violence against women and girls
and so on. And yet institutionally...
No, they've done nothing. Absolutely.
And there seems to be no pressure for them to do anything,
which is the second thing that astounds me.
It's still this huge deference. I mean, we still don't have, you know,
parliamentary accountability. You can't ask questions in parliament. I mean, I've tried
to raise all sorts of questions. Who was accompanying Andrew on these trips? He was
taking his daughters at huge public expense in order to build their filofax of contacts.
But I mean, I think, you know, the shocking thing is we had these 33,000 emails that were
hacked from Jonathan Rowland's communications with where they were basically, you know,
with Andrew, given to the palace six years ago. We don't know what they did with those 33,000 emails,
if they were given to the police, if they've even been given to the police at this stage.
I mean, even Pizza Hut, or Pizza Hut, wasn't it?
Pizza Express.
I don't think he'd have gone to Pizza Hut.
No, probably not.
Even, yeah, that would have been a step too far for him.
But, you know, they had an internal investigation.
But, you know, there was no investigation after Sarah was caught selling access to Andrew in 2010.
There was nothing happening in 2022 when the High Court and a High Court case with Selman
Turk showed that money was being paid to the Yorks they couldn't account for.
Nothing happened after my book came out.
The policy is always to just hope the problem will go away.
But I mean, I just can't think, and I thought this so many times. I mean, you know, when we
the Epstein files coming out in Congress, when there's all that focus on Peter Mandelson,
rightly, all sorts of things.
And I just can't think of any other public institution in the glare of a story like that,
where everyone would just sort of accept that there would be no internal investigation,
even internal one, let alone an external one, that there would be no public statement.
And as far as I know, apart from these pretty kind of saccharine statements they put out,
they don't really answer any questions that anyone puts to them about any of this stuff.
I just cannot imagine any other institution in Britain,
private or public, that would get away with it.
It is the last unprotected institution. I mean,
they have the exemptions under the Freedom of Information Act, which they use very,
very liberally. You know, all the problems of, you know, royal wills being sealed,
no proper royal register, which was being debated 20 years ago, never got through.
I mean, the key is parliamentary accountability.
There should be someone responsible for speaking up for the royal family,
let's say the Cabinet Office, and questions could be asked about,
for example, their finances or some of this behavior.
One of the questions I put in was how many cars are given to the royal family for their use for
free and on what basis? And they wouldn't allow that question to be asked. I wrote to Land Rover,
Bentley and Audi, who are the three companies who do provide cars,
and two of them didn't answer. The other told me to get lost.
So I think people give up because there is just this constant sort of bat coming back
deflecting it.
It's one of the reasons why people don't even put these questions, partly because ultimately,
if those questions are going to be put institutionally about what the institution
did during those years, well, there is such squeamishness about doing that because of the
person who was head of the institution at the time, which was the late Queen Elizabeth II.
And so to ask questions which in some way, you know, scrutinizes her and brings her probity
into question is just almost verboten.
Well, it's interesting how things have changed. When my book came out,
I was vilified for suggesting the Queen had protected Andrew.
She was Mother Teresa and I was just a Republican.
And now the palace's line is actually don't blame the king.
It all happened on someone else's watch and they're kind of trying to shift the blame.
I mean, the fact is that the hush money, which it was paid for to basically shut up Virginia
Giffray, everyone in the royal household knew about that, the Queen, King Charles, etc.
And this is the real sort of Damocles over their head, you know, which the hecklers are shouting,
what did you know?
When did you know?
What did you do about it?
And if, as I believe, they've known about this problem for 20, 30, 40 years,
then they're going to be... and they've covered it up.
But I mean, I've talked to two heads of the permanent heads of the foreign office.
They said we knew from day one that Andrew was a problem,
but because the Queen wanted it, there's nothing we could do.
If he wanted a jet, we allowed it.
If he wanted to put his massage expenses on general accounting, we allowed it.
As much as they may now be trying to deflect to the late Queen,
do you think there are questions for Charles in terms of whether he has
acted on his brother's behalf in some way?
Absolutely.
I mean, I think Charles has given an undertaking to his mother that they would protect Andrew
and take care of him.
Are they close?
No, but it's again about protecting the institution.
I mean, it's exactly what happened with when the German files came out about
Edward VIII after the war, the mob group files,
showing he'd colluded with the Nazis or at least talked to them.
And, you know, Churchill was no fan of the Duke of Windsor,
but he realised that the only way to kind of protect the institution
was to make sure these documents were destroyed or never released.
Does the King think his brother's an idiot?
Well, I asked someone who's very close in the royal household,
how did the Queen treat Andrew?
And they said she treated him like a special needs child.
And I said, how did Charles treat him?
And he said he just totally ignored him.
I mean, they're two very different characters.
They're 10, 12 years apart.
You know, Charles is intellectually curious.
He's sensitive.
He has a strong sense of duty.
He has no illusions about his brother.
There's a lot of jealousy between them.
There's a lot of arrogance.
Andrew thinks he could do a better job than Charles.
So there's no love lost there.
But I think Charles feels a responsibility.
And you just never know in these things,
is it better to have a containment policy,
keep them inside the tent or cut them loose
and risk all the damage they might do?
And you, in your book, when you exhaustively show
the sort of personality, the sort of person that Andrew
and indeed Sarah Ferguson have,
given that you know his mind, I think, pretty much better than anybody,
certainly on the outside of the palace anyway,
what do you think, what do you think he thinks about his future?
Do you think he, do you think he's deluded enough
that he thinks he could come back?
I don't know if he thinks he's going to come back.
I think he plays very much, it feels the victim.
He feels betrayed by people who he felt should have stood by him.
He's kind of obsessed with small, from what I'm told,
he's obsessed with small details,
where he's going to park his car,
where can he stable his horses, etc.
Rather than, there's no sense of remorse, exactly.
But I think there's any strong sense of empathy for the victims.
I mean, just the casual way he dealt with Giffray,
the way he kind of pretended he didn't even remember her.
You've got to remember that, you know,
this is someone who ordered Giffray out of a catalogue of pictures.
I mean, as if you might have gone to Pizza Express for a takeaway.
And, you know, this is someone who has very little sense of feelings
about people.
And it's all about him.
And it remains all about him, even now.
Do you think he's still got connections with talking to other members of the family?
Yes, I mean, he's visiting.
I know he sees Anne and Edward.
I think some people clearly are keeping their distance.
I mean, clearly, William and Catherine, I think,
will have nothing to do with them.
But absolutely.
And, you know, we've got to remember that we're dealing with,
as you say, the institution and the family.
And there may be some family loyalties there,
even though they can see the reputational damage to the institution.
Just finally, we always knew that the King was going to have a short reign,
by definition, really.
Sort of Edward VII type figure.
Do you have a sense yet of how the reign of Charles III,
who, of course, is still an ill man?
We don't know many details about it, but he's an ill man.
How do you think his reign will be remembered?
Well, it depends how long he reigns.
I mean, if he has 10 years, like Edward,
then I think, you know, clearly we just don't know.
I mean, he's got six years to go.
At the moment, I think it's been about firefighting.
It's about the crisis of Andrew and Harry.
I think he had an opportunity to reform the monarchy,
make it fit for purpose for the 21st century.
The Queen wasn't going to do that.
She passed the baton to him.
And I'm afraid he's dropped that baton.
He's kind of hoping that William will do it.
And I think he will be seen probably as someone who had an opportunity
to take the monarchy to basically restore trust and respect
and fail to do so because he was so hidebound by tradition.
Came too late.
Andrew Lowney, thanks so much for joining us.
Pleasure.
Thanks as ever to our very own Court Jesters,
our production team, Shane Fennelly, Michaela Walters,
Natalie Inge, Anna Georgievich, Jess Williamson,
Mikey Baggs, Martin Crozer and Lizzie Ward.
Our executive producer is Louis Dagenhart.
Our editor, our very own King is Tom Hughes.
The News Agents is presented by me, Louis Goodall, John Sopel and Emily Maitlis.
We'll be back from the Labour Party conference in Liverpool on Monday.
Have a lovely weekend.
The News Agents podcast is brought to you by HSBC UK,
opening up a world of opportunity.
This has been a global production.