The Unconventional Engineering Of The X-59

Warship And Aircraft
72 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThe X-59 Quest is a NASA X-plane designed by Lockheed Martin to minimize sonic booms. By utilizing advanced aerodynamics to replace the disruptive \"double boom\" with a soft thump, the aircraft aims to overturn bans on supersonic flight over land, potentially reviving commercial supersonic travel.
This is the X-59, NASA's latest X-plane and the newest creation from Lockheed Martin's
secretive Skunk Works in Palmdale, California. The same facility that produced the SR-71,
F-117 Nighthawk, P-38, F-35 and F-22. This plane is designed to do one thing, make supersonic
booms so quiet that a supersonic transport could fly over a city and barely disturb a mouse.
With the insane experience in house at Skunk Works, this plane became a Frankenstein monster.
Pieced together with parts and lessons from F-16s, T-38s and even an old F-117 Nighthawk.
Resulting in one of the most aerodynamically interesting X-planes in recent memory,
but can it really accomplish it's mission? This is the insane engineering of the X-59 Quest.
The X-59 is littered with interesting design choices, but it's key feature is right here.
This weird nose. From tip to nose wheel it takes up over half the plane. The pilot can't even see
out of the cockpit, and the centre of gravity is three quarters down the plane, where the wings
curve deep into the slim waisted fuselage. All these sharp twisting features are the result of
a decade of aerospace research on how to slice through the air in an entirely new way. One that
the X-59 hopes will bring back supersonic flight. Because ever since the Concorde last flew,
commercial air travel has been subsonic and actually slowing down year by year. Part of the
reason for that, arguably the main reason, is the lack of suitable routes for supersonic passenger
planes. The Concorde flew only a few select flights over the Atlantic, where it's sonic boom
couldn't bother anyone. If we can quieten the booms, more routes would open and drive money
into the development of supersonic passenger planes. The X-59's unique design choices
are all in pursuit of this goal, but let's start by explaining why it's impossible to be both
supersonic and silent. This is a plane flying at 200 meters per second, the speed of a regular
airliner. Like any object pushing through the air, it generates pressure waves. These spread
out in all directions at the speed of sound. Most forces transmit this way, you just don't
notice the delay between pushing a table and seeing it move, because the speed of sound in
a solid is so high. Aircraft just fly fast enough that it starts to matter.
Now watch as the plane speeds up. The pressure waves travelling ahead of it don't get very far
before the plane catches up with them, causing them to stack up and increase in pressure.
And that's how a shockwave is born. This causes a sudden disruption of the air flowing over the
plane and sharply increases the drag it experiences. In fact, the drag coefficient of a regular
airliner will double or triple at this airspeed, with a corresponding increase in the forces
acting on it's airframe too. These were enough to tear apart the first aircraft travelling at
these speeds and it was so difficult to get past them that pilots coined the term sound barrier to
describe it. And it's even worse when not all parts of the plane go supersonic at the same time.
Here's the profile of a regular wing. Air flowing over the leading edge speeds up as it follows the
curve. That can push it past Mach 1, even if the rest of the plane is slightly subsonic.
Air transitioning from subsonic to supersonic and back to subsonic again doesn't follow the
wings surface smoothly, causing it to separate into turbulent flow that violently shakes the wing.
This is called Mach Buffeting. The aerodynamic centre of the plane,
the average point where lift is generated, also shifts to the rear.
This effect, called Mach Tuck, tends to pull the rear up, causing the whole plane to pitch down.
If you're already in a dive, this deepens it. Something that affected the P-38 and required
the addition of a dive flap to save pilots who found themselves in high speed dives.
The X-59 of course is built to handle this. It has delta wings that can survive aerodynamic
forces without much structural support, but they are highly swept, effectively reducing
the velocity of the air perpendicular to the leading edge. In fact, the sweep angle is
chosen to be steep enough that the entire wing can hide inside the shock cone generated at the nose.
Inside the cone, the wings act as if they were in regular subsonic airflow,
avoiding the formation of shockwaves over their surfaces and becoming dramatically more efficient.
The wing profile is different too. Compared to a regular wing,
it is very thin and symmetrical from top to bottom. Air flowing over the wing doesn't
accelerate as much, so it's harder to form shockwaves and separate into turbulent flow.
The shockwaves above and below the wing are balanced too, reducing Mach buffeting.
The downside to this profile is that it doesn't produce lift unless it enters the air at an angle,
unlike a regular wing, but you can see that the X-59's wings are installed with a natural angle
already. To maintain control, the X-59 uses all moving stabilators instead of elevons in the tail.
If the whole control surface tilts into the airflow, there's nothing behind the turbulent
wake, so control is retained at supersonic speeds. It adds a supersonic trim, that is,
it tilts the nose up to counter the rearward shift in it's centre of lift caused by Mach tuck.
Normally doing so adds drag, but the canards in the nose are angled in a way to passively move
the centre of lift back to the front, so the amount of trim the X-59 needs is cleverly reduced.
Now, the X-59 accelerates past Mach 1. It is going supersonic, outrunning it's own pressure
waves as they get dragged behind it in a narrowing shock cone. The X-59's design speed is
Mach 1.4, which is 413 meters per second in the cold air at 15 kilometers altitude. At this speed
it's pressure waves are pressed into a 45 degree cone, an unavoidable aspect of breaking the sound
barrier that makes it impossible to fly silently. If you were standing on the ground with one of
these planes speeding overhead, you'd see it move past silently, then after delay you'd hear a
bang bang. This double boom sweeps over the landscape and it can be strong enough to shake
buildings or break windows. The reason it's so powerful is because the shock waves from a
supersonic aircraft merge as they spread away from the aircraft, adding up their energy until
there's two peaks in an N-shaped wave. This N-wave weakens as it travels down, but enough energy is
gathered in each peak to produce a loud double boom at ground level. Quest's goal is not to
eliminate supersonic booms, but to alter them in a way that they are no longer disruptive to the
people on the ground. There's two parts to it, weakening the shock waves so they become quieter
and then shaping them so they don't become a powerful N-wave. The first part relies heavily
on the Whitcomb Area Rule, discovered by Richard Whitcomb in 1952 while experimenting with wind
tunnels. It basically states that abrupt changes in the cross-sectional area of a plane from nose
to tail are what create the strongest shock waves. A fuselage like a straight cylinder would
have a constant cross-section until the airflow reaches the wings, which suddenly adds a lot of
cross-sectional area. In the earliest supersonic planes, this was the source of a very strong
shock wave, which resulted in immense drag. If instead the fuselage narrowed at the point where
the wings were attached, the change in cross-sectional area would be less abrupt and the
shock waves would be weakened. Planes which follow the Whitcomb Area Rule typically have
a coke bottle fuselage, with a narrow waist and smooth curves. Modern aircraft analyse every
change in cross-sectional area to follow the Whitcomb Rule, from the cockpit bubble to the
rudder placement, but the X-59 applies the Area Rule differently. It is trying to generate the
weakest shock waves by having the smoothest transitions possible between its thick and
thin sections. That's why the nose is so long and why the cockpit blends seamlessly with the
fuselage, and because of this the pilot has to rely entirely on the cameras and screens of its
external vision system to fly the plane. At the point where the wings are the widest,
the fuselage is also the narrowest. The engine looks like it sticks out, but the airflow sees
it as a hollow tube rather than an obstacle, so it doesn't actually change the cross-sectional area
as much as you'd expect. In the rear the tail is short, with the rudder bridging the gap between
the wings and the stabilators. Thanks to these features the only strong shock waves that are
generated are near the canards and the engine intake. The intake has a special bump called a
divertless supersonic inlet that solves two problems with high speed flight. You can see
these on the most advanced fighter jet, the F-35. As air travels along the length of the body,
air begins to form a layer of slow moving turbulent air called a boundary layer. If
this air is allowed to enter the engine, it not only lowers performance, it can also damage the
engine. As the turbine rotates it will pass through the slow boundary air on one side and then the
fast free stream air on the other. This means the force on the turbine blade changes for each and
every rotation, causing cyclical bending. A recipe for fatigue failure. Planes like the F-16 feature
a boundary layer diverter that separates the inlet from the fuselage with a small gap,
but this design increases drag. Later variants of the F-16 tested the DSI, a divertless supersonic
inlet. Essentially a large bump that creates a region of compression that pushes the boundary
layer away from the inlet while lowering drag. The test flight demonstrated it could meet
performance requirements, ushering in it's introduction to the F-35. The final product
reduces weight by 30% and lowers production and maintenance costs. The X-59 takes it to the next
level by moving it onto it's back, so the shockwave it produces is directed up and away from the
ground. The next step in quest design is to shape the sonic boom. If the main wings did all of the
lifting there'd be a single strong shockwave centred on them. With the canards, large
stabilators and fins on the rudder, the sources of lift are distributed along the plane's length,
resulting in multiple smaller shockwaves precisely spaced out from each other.
The X-59's unconventional layout helps it move all of these shockwaves far enough apart
that they don't merge as they travel down to the ground. Instead of adding up into a single
n-wave, they stay separate and weak all the way to the ground, where they're heard as a longer,
softer thump rather than a short boom. The objective here is to reduce the volume of a
sonic boom down to 75 decibels. That's like a door slamming shut across the street or a small
truck passing you on the highway. To get to this point, the X-59 was put through a rigorous regime
of computer simulations and wind tunnel tests. Every bump and curve was mapped out and it's
effects on the airflow calculated by the Advanced Supercomputing Division at the
Ames Research Centre. Scale models of the X-59 were placed into wind tunnels at NASA's Langley,
Lockheed Skunk Works and even JAXA's test facility in Tokyo.
All of this makes the X-59 a unique design, but it's not the first plane to try to shape
it's own sonic booms. The most recent is this NASA F-15B that collaborated with Gulfstream
Aerospace on the Quiet Spike project. A multi-stage, 7.3 meter extendable spike
was installed on it's nose, adding 38% to the jets length. That helped split the shock cone
at the front of the plane into three smaller shock waves. Before that, the same F-15B tail
number A-36 was used to trial an ugly duckling F-5E fitted with a much longer nose and modified
fuselage. To measure whether it could reduce the intensity of it's sonic boom in flight,
it did so by one third. The X-59 program is the most serious
attempt at designing a plane purpose built for reducing sonic booms. Lockheed Martin Skunk
Works got a quarter of a billion dollar contract to build it. Parts from existing planes were used
wherever possible to save time and reduce costs. Which is why it got the landing gear of a Falcon,
the engine of a Hornet, the cockpit canopy of a T-38 Talon, the control stick of a Nighthawk,
and even components from a U-2 spy plane. After 5 years in the workshop, the X-59 rolled out
in 2023. The X-59 was unveiled to the public on the 12th of January 2024, but it's first cautious
flight only happened on October 2025. In 2026 it is still being put through it's paces. It reached
an altitude of 6 kilometers in April, then went supersonic for the first time in June 2026.
A week later it reached it's design speed of Mach 1.4 at an altitude of 15 kilometers.
The next step is to fly over Edwards Air Force Base while surrounded by sensors and microphones,
both on the ground and flying alongside it at all altitudes, to demonstrate that the low
boom concept will work in the real world. Wind tunnel testing doesn't say what weather, winds,
clouds and terrain do to the impact of sonic booms on the ground, so the data can only be
gathered live. Then the big test. The X-59 will be flown over several US cities to measure how
residents will react to it's sonic booms. This community response testing is the most important
step in changing flight regulations from a straight up supersonic ban to a 5.3 pascal ground
pressure restriction. If it succeeds the door may open to a new generation of supersonic passenger
flights. But a quieter supersonic boom doesn't solve all the problems. Technology may have
progressed, but it's arguably more difficult economically to pull off today. Mostly on fuel
costs. Supersonic jets need smaller fuselages to cut down on drag and thus can't spread the
cost of fuel across as many passengers. With fuel costs higher than ever, the next big challenge is
getting fuel demands lower, but that's no easy task. The engineers of the X-59 chose to use a
reliable off the shelf military engine. The General Electric F-414, the same engine the
Super Hornet uses. This was primarily a cost of development choice, but these engines will just
not cut it for a commercial application. The Concorde was excellent in supercruise.
It's four Olympus engines turned out to be the most thermodynamically efficient motors of their
time, thanks to a complex arrangement of intake ramps that could compress the incoming air.
Slowing it down while recovering it's kinetic energy as pressure rather than wasting it.
That way it could supercruise at Mach 2, but getting up to supercruise required costly
afterburners. The Soviets actually beat the Concorde into service with the Tupolev Tu-144.
It was heavier, faster, with 42% more powerful engines and canards to help it lift off,
but it's tragically unlucky career was terminated after three years.
The X-59 inherits features from both. It's delta wings are actually double deltas,
similar to the Concorde, with the inner portion at 76 degrees and the outer portion at 68.6 degrees.
It's canards also help by generating vortices that spill over onto the main wing at low speed.
The next piece of the puzzle is creating an engine that can run efficiently at both subsonic
and supersonic speeds. Astromechanic is designing and testing hybrid engines with an electric fan
mode at low speed, an efficient turbo fan mode for transonic to supersonic flight and a ramjet
mode to keep it pushing up to Mach 3. A design this advanced is only made possible by recent
progress in high power to weight ratio electric motors, dense batteries and heat resistant
ceramic turbine blades. And just a little side note, my other company Throttle actually created
these animations for Astromechanica. If you run an engineering company and need help making
animations we can help you out. With engines like these a supersonic plane could enter a
virtuous cycle of needing less fuel to make a trip, which means smaller wings to take off,
which leads to less drag and smaller engines, which in turn reduce the fuel needed further,
which would also potentially open up options for longer range trans-pacific routes,
which could prove extremely valuable. But it's not a done deal, private companies have attempted
to bring back supersonic flight since the Concorde ended in 2003. The Arian Corporation spent between
500 million and a billion dollars on its AS-2 design, a sort of supersonic business jet,
but failed after declaring the effort would take closer to 10 billion dollars.
Exosonic, Virgin Galactic and Spike Aerospace have all tried and failed.
Boom Aerospace is the current contender. They plan to deliver an 80 seat supersonic jet called
the Overture, which would supercruise at Mach 1.7. It has raised about 600 million dollars to do it
and has been working on it for the past decade, when it isn't busy designing gas turbines to power
AI data centres that is. Instead of a painstakingly designed airframe with a shaped sonic boom like
the X-59, they are relying on Mach Cut-Off. A phenomenon where sonic booms don't reach the
ground if they start out between Mach 1.1 and Mach 1.3 at around 10km altitude. A phenomenon
they have tested once and claimed success. Simply put, sonic booms are sound waves that refract
when travelling through air of different densities and they can bend enough to make a u-turn in the
air and never reach the ground under specific weather conditions. This means Boom Aerospace
would be constantly adjusting it's speed, altitude and flight path while navigating through
the atmosphere, looking for those perfect conditions. There's still no guarantee that
Boom Aerospace or some other company will succeed. Supersonic jets will always be more expensive than
subsonic airliners, just because they take more fuel and make more sacrifices to carry each
passenger. Rising fuel costs and businesses relying on video calls rather than physical
meetings in other countries are also making them less likely, but there are a lot of people who
will pay thousands of dollars to save themselves a few hours. And with 5,500 new millionaires being
printed every single day around the world, finding a market for these faster planes might not be so
difficult. Just to demonstrate how far technology has come since the Concorde made it's first flight
in 1969. This was how big state of the art calculators were at the time.
This is the AL-1000 Commodore manufactured by Casio in Japan in 1968. It's a beautiful piece
of computer history. It has just 448 bits of memory from it's core memory array, which stores
data on tiny iron rings. And these high voltage nixie tubes demanded a fairly complex power supply.
I bought this as part of a Nebula series where I put cool objects like the Nokia 3310 and the
first generation iPod into a CT scanner and then used the volumetric models to make mesmerizing
animations. Well, this calculator is both too big and too heavy to fit in the CT scanners we are
using, so I messed up there, but it did kickstart a new obsession for me, the history of old
calculators. So instead the first episode is about the Curta Mechanical Calculator,
which is an absolutely fascinating little portable calculator that uses gears and rotating levers for
calculations. You can watch that episode when it releases on Nebula next month. With the help of
Nebula we hired a new animator with a background in electronic engineering to take the animation
technique we developed to make one of these episodes a month. Next month we'll be going
further down this new calculator collecting hobby with the Sharp EL8, which launched just 4 years
after this gigantic thing and benefited from the new arms race in microchip development.
So subscribe to Nebula if you want to watch me obsess over old calculators for the next few
months. A monthly subscription to Nebula is usually $6, but with my link or the QR code
on screen right now you can get an entire year's membership for just $30. Or if you are sick of
up to new subscription services like I am, we've created a lifetime membership if you'd rather just
pay it and forget it. With YouTube policies changing more and more in favor of slop scrolling,
every subscriber over on Nebula counts, where we can focus on the things that really get us excited.
