Behind the Scenes: Lone Star (Sayles, 1996) with Chris Cooper and Elizabeth Peña

Fantastic behind the scenes
10 followers
8 Video Views·Sep 26, 2026
When the skeleton of his murdered predecessor is found, Sheriff Sam Deeds unearths many other long-buried secrets in his Texas border town.
This audio-visual film commentary has been extensively edited, dubbed and transformed by Serious Feather in an original and thoughtful manner for historical, cultural and educational purposes.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedA filmmaker and interviewer discuss the philosophy of independent cinema and the creation of the film *Lone Star*. The conversation explores the use of authenticity in location, the symbolic nature of borders, and the tension between official history and lived experience, ultimately framing cinema as a tool for empathy and a means to transcend societal and racial divides.
You know, to me, you are the consummate independent filmmaker.
And when I think about the independent film movement of the late seventies and
eighties,
I always think of the return of the Secaucus seven is really the film that kind
of kicked the whole movement off.
And you were so inspiring to all of us young filmmakers who wanted to get our
own stories made and Hollywood wasn't making them.
And we had to find a way to do it by hook or by crook because you've maintained
it. You've never gone off and done the big Hollywood movie.
You've always been rigorous about doing your independent projects.
Yeah. I think it was a combination of what I could do good timing and that I
started as a novelist and as a novelist,
I got to write the first, second and third draft of the book without a whole lot
of interference, you know, and a little help from an editor.
That's what I thought storytelling should be. Also,
I went into making movies,
which I'd always thought would have been a cool thing to do.
A great form of storytelling thinking if it's going to be a movie,
I'm going to put my name on, I'm going to have that kind of control over.
The timing was good in that it was just before home video showed up,
but the independent theaters were realizing, you know,
I don't think we can just program 400 blows for the same two weeks in July every
year. Maybe we should look for some other movies.
And all of a sudden there were some American movies and some Australian movies
and some English movie and they liked that they were English language movies
because people to this day have a resistance in this country to reading
subtitles. And so our timing was very good. And then as it,
as it continued, you know, people asked me, so why don't you make Hollywood
movies? Well, it seems to be a mutual decision.
You know, it's, it's the kind of things that I want to, you know,
and what they think they can sell and want to make are not usually the same.
You know, the whole independent film movement that you were so centrally a part
of it, it was transformative in terms of all the filmmakers like yourself.
And of course me and Spike Lee and Wayne Wang and Joan Beckman silver.
And there's so many great filmmakers and making so many fantastic movies,
low budget. And they broke big. I mean,
they were box office successes and they were done outside of the Hollywood
system. Stories that needed to be told that weren't being told.
Like Lone Star. Yeah. I know that for you,
location is incredibly important.
Lone Star is very much a movie about borders.
Well, you know, because we had friends in Austin,
we did a nice little scout and went to some beautiful bars and cantinas.
And we just realized this doesn't look like the border and the Texas film
commission, they helped us out.
They actually flew us to the border one time and we got to check out various
places. And I just felt like, first of all, there's the real Bravo right there.
And we're going to be shooting on and around that.
We're going to be drawing our extras and even maybe some of our small speaking
parts from this community.
There's just a feeling to it when you go down there. Occasionally,
I have an idea for a movie and I go and I find the place first and then I write
the screenplay.
The vibe, the spirit of a place is essential.
For the people making the movie that in a way, if everybody's open,
the spirit of a place somehow inhabits you.
Yeah. I had a couple of Cubans and Puerto Ricans, you know,
playing Mexican Americans and Mexicans, you know,
actors love to absorb that stuff before they do a performance, you know,
so that they know this is grounded in this place.
Also we often will hand our script out to local people and occasionally you get
some, you know, you can't catch catfish in August or whatever it is.
And I've changed some major things in scripts because the local people said,
you know, that wouldn't happen.
It seems like the whole concept of borders is so essential to the movie,
not just the actual political border between the United States and Mexico,
but also between fathers and sons, you know, between different groups.
The big thematic concept for me is often when we say we,
how big a we is it? You know, look at the constitution.
You know,
it was not including a whole lot of people when it said we the people class can
be the line that people draw between people.
Race can be the things that people say, this is me, that's you.
And never the twain shall meet.
So I was interested in this idea that people tend to want to draw those lines to
identify as I'm this and I'm not that.
So you don't understand me and I don't probably understand you or I understand
you enough to know that I want to keep some distance from you.
And so what you realize is that the, yes, there are these lines,
there is this border, but there's always been people who crossed it.
And that's the unwritten history. And certainly the Texas Mexican border,
you know, how many times has it moved? You know, people in the Southwest will say,
you know, I'm Mexican, but the border came up and got me.
We didn't cross the border. The border crossed us.
When do people respect those borders that have been set up and when do you
cross them?
One of the beautiful images of the movie is when he talks about the bird flies
over the border back and forth without any problem.
And so it seems like people make choices to fly across borders in the course of
the film.
Yeah. When we shot, I think it's 96, uh,
the border was a more amorphous place than it is now.
And when we were there, you,
you carried a dime and you put it in the turnstile and you went through the
turnstile and the border patrol guy said,
we see somebody and we know they're not from here.
And all they did was they made sure you didn't have a want that you weren't
wanted for any crime. And then they drove you to the other side.
And sometimes they said, try again. If you want,
we'll probably catch you. But, and that was it.
This is before the wall. This is before a lot of those,
the stuff that's been thrown in there now to make people miserable.
I was born and raised on the border, you know, San Diego and Tijuana,
a lot of family on both sides of the border.
And we used to cross all the time.
You're just a five year old kid and you see the huge contrast between these
worlds, but how interconnected they are.
And it seems like from the personal that's really the seed from which everything
else grows. So in Lone Star,
it is out of how they resolve their personal issues.
And suddenly that's going to grow into a larger manner in which people can live
together and find a way to live in a multicultural society like we have.
You hope so. You know, and, and, and, and some people make that effort.
I mean, you have to conquer your inner demons. Yeah.
Before you can deal with the bigger world. Right.
But the bigger world will come and tell you you're on the wrong side of the
line. Every once in a while, it's like Pilar and Sam at the end of the movie,
find out that they're half brother and sister, but she can't have kids.
So this is okay. Yeah.
But they're not going to be able to live there. You know,
it's not like it's going to be a rosy future for them,
but these are people who fell in love before they knew that they were too
closely related. But it's kind of clear to me,
just in the vibe of the movie, these are people who should be together.
I believe William Goldman was saying about what the difference between an
independent movie and a Hollywood movie is, you know, we think of it as finance.
Yeah. Right. You have to find the money somewhere else, right. Whatever.
But his definition was more like, well,
a Hollywood movie makes you feel everything's copacetic and wonderful.
An independent movie always has something that disturbs you that gets under your
skin. And that really makes you think about it.
They do love each other, but it's there's incest and that is
people, what does all this mean? Yeah. And it stays with you.
And you think about it forever. Like, Oh my gosh, what's he trying to say?
You know, who's in a interracial relationship will tell you
it's not just the two of us. Everybody on the street has an opinion.
That relationship may be really good,
but that doesn't mean that the rest of the world is going to approve of it or
even leave them alone. Race is an illusion, but culture is so real. That's right.
And it starts the minute you wake up from being taken out of the womb.
It's your choice eventually,
if you're willing to do it to question the official version.
Is that really what happened in history?
One of the seeds of Lone Star,
I came down to do a cameo part in Piranha,
which I had written. The things we do to get movies made.
Oh, it was fun. It was fun. And it was my first sold screenplay.
And there was a drought in California.
There was no water in any of the rivers in Los Angeles or anywhere in
California. So he went to San Marcos, Texas, right near the LBJ ranch.
And I said, hell, I've never been to the Alamo.
So I took a bus up and in those days when you walked in,
the first thing you saw was an oil painting of the three
principles, you know, from the movie. So it's, you know,
Lawrence Harvey and Richard Widmark and John Wayne.
And there was a protest on the outside.
It was some Tejano power group saying, tell the real story. And I said,
Oh, this is interesting. You know, this, this,
this is people fighting about history.
You know, I'll tell you an Alamo story. When I was a boy,
you love Davy Crockett and then you see him killed by these evil Mexicans
at the Alamo. And I was weeping, crying. I was a little boy. Yeah.
And I remember my father came and of course he was Chicano and
he put his arm around me and he said, son,
you are a Mexican.
I was like, Oh no. Yeah. Figure that one out. Yeah.
I think that the whole concept of the Alamo is so ingrained.
It pervades the film in a deep way until at the very end,
Pilar played by Elizabeth Pena says, forget the Alamo.
What does she mean when she says that?
Look, there's this official story and there are these official rules
and they're just messing us up. That's not a useful legend.
So what she's basically saying is you and me,
we don't expect the world to forget the Alamo, but we are going to do it.
We're not going to let them run our lives anymore with their role,
with their legend. That seems to me to be a, you know,
a pretty destructive legend.
Again, it gets back to this point,
the personal as opposed to the society and they make these personal choices.
But as people make those personal choices,
that will eventually change society and that that's the right way to do that.
Yeah. It's a wonderful thing that movies can do.
People in the audience met people from not their group
who they rooted for. All of a sudden there's Sidney Poitier,
this black guy from the Caribbean, you know, how,
how come I'm rooting for him when I don't like black people?
Well, that's what Roger Ebert used to say.
The most powerful thing that movies can be is they're a machine for empathy.
That you walk in somebody else's shoes, another race, another gender,
another culture.
So maybe when you encounter somebody from that world in real life,
that wall between you isn't quite as high as it used to be.
Well, so much about the film is fathers and sons. Yeah.
Now obviously you have with the pain, Otis Payne and his son,
playing by Joe Morton, but then in a sense, in a larger sense,
Buddy Deeds becomes like the dad of the whole community.
Yeah. And what you realize is that he's probably a useful legend.
There's some positive change there because this guy had better
antenna and better intentions than his predecessor did.
You have these personal father, son relationships,
and then this sheriff who's a patriarchal figure.
So there is this societal view of what the well run society
is with a white guy, always at the top running things.
And you seem to be equating those two together.
For me, the father is also, this is the official story.
Well, the Charlie Wade official story is a black and white one.
White people get a break. Mexicans and black people don't.
You know, they get shot. Buddy Deeds, you know, takes over.
He has this secret affair with Pilar's mother, right?
He has a secret kid who she doesn't even know he's her father.
Well, we're going to wink at this,
but we're not going to, you know, let these people stand in the sun
right next to us.
But finally, Sam Deeds, he's ahead of his community.
He's probably, you know, the sheriff who's not going to stay sheriff.
And who becomes the sheriff?
Well, Tony Pilar becomes the sheriff.
And he's a Latino.
And he's probably going to be a pretty good one.
All these themes.
I mean, because the film deals with all of these different communities.
It was very bold and very courageous of you to get in deep
with the Latino community, the African-American community, the Anglo,
the racist sheriff.
But also the seeker is a guy who's taken that same job.
But he's changed it.
Well, you know, he's reacting against his father who had that job.
He wants to find out worse news about his father than he eventually does.
And then he just leaves them where it is.
You know, at the end, he says, well, buddy's a goddamn legend.
He can handle it.
I love that line.
Yeah, that's one of my favorite lines.
I think that's just in your movie, but in all cinema, he now knows,
oh, my father was was a less hard ass, less racist,
a more complicated human being than I thought he was.
The most unusual thing, if you look at the structure of the film,
is that Joe Morton's character and Chris Cooper's character
who are, you know, kind of co-leads in a way.
They never are on screen at the same time.
They never meet all kinds of people who they come into contact with crisscross.
But there's no showdown between these guys.
They don't even really know the other guy exists.
He's just talking about film structure.
I personally am not a three act structure guy,
because to me, the structure is like a river.
It all moves.
One of the things that is brilliant about Lone Star
is the time structure where you're going back through memory
and the past and the present become interconnected in a very powerful way.
When I designed those scenes, I said, well, it's 1957 and 1996.
But these people are still carrying that past around.
Right. It's still affecting.
Even if like Chris Cooper's character, he doesn't know what the story is yet.
And it was really fun for the camera crew and the grips to work out these scenes.
How are we going to just pan away?
And we're back in 1957.
It's one of the big images in the movie.
They find that cruddy old badge at the gravesite.
Yeah. And that image pervades the film.
That's the iconic part of it.
We've seen so many Westerns.
It really is structured more like a detective film than a Western.
But the guys are wearing cowboy hats and badges and boots,
bringing together different genres because it's on one level.
It's like a whodunit.
It's like a film noir.
On another level, it's like a Western.
And in a sense, culturally, you're combining all these things
because they are all part of what we think of as the American experience.
I think Coppola said that a movie is made three times.
Once when you write it, once when you shoot it and once when you edit it.
And you do all three.
Yeah. A couple of times, you know, I've worked with editors who were,
you know, people I really liked working with and I was in the room the whole time.
And finally, it was just too much fun to let somebody else do it.
I know the footage.
I know where it wants to be.
I'm editing while I'm writing for budget.
I'm editing while I'm shooting for we got to make the day, you know,
and I'm working with my script supervisor about, OK,
we're only going to get 12 of the 18 shots I wanted today.
What's the shot that's going to connect these things, you know,
and let's start working on that while I'm shooting this scene.
And then the final editing is about rhythm and you're improving the performance.
You're still working with the actors.
They're not there, but you're still working with the actors.
That's right.
And when I come into the editing room, this is my new universe.
I know what the script was.
I'm not going to look at the script anymore.
I'm going to look at this footage and make a movie out of this footage
as if somebody else shot all this stuff.
And there are days when you say that idiot director didn't get this.
This pick up.
Yeah. You know, I didn't have him look left at least once, you know,
and then you have to deal with it.
And you've worked a lot with Maggie Renzi.
And I would like you to talk about what she brings to you,
because I think she's very important to your filmmaking.
Well, first of all, I couldn't produce a two car funeral.
It's a different job and it's not in my skill set.
I can understand some of the things that producers need
and try to help them with those things, but it's it's not what I do.
So with Maggie, who I also live with, you know, here's this person
who's in your corner, who's working with you, not despite you or against you
or with another agenda that you don't share.
And that starts with casting.
I want them in the room.
I don't want a producer going into a film
feeling like we didn't get the right actors.
And then that goes for the crew as well.
You know, there are people who you would hire as a DP
for an eight week movie, but not a four week movie.
They may have graduated to the point where I don't want to work that fast anymore.
And then during the making of the movies, one of the things that we really have
an agreement about how people should be treated, including the extras.
Now, Maggie's there making sure that they know when lunch is,
you know, that they're comfortable enough, you know, because quite honestly,
sometimes you get, you know, DGA people who treat them like props.
I'll put them over here and forget about them until we need them.
So that's an important thing, you know, in just running, running the show.
Let's talk about casting and specifically, let's start with Chris Cooper,
because you work with him on at least four, maybe more films.
The first was for Matewan, as I understand it.
Can you talk a little bit about how you found him
and how you developed your relationship with him?
Chris had mostly been doing theater.
He I think he'd been in maybe one movie before.
We had him come in and read for the lead in Matewan.
He was at great disadvantage because he was the very first actor
who came in and we saw 20, 30, maybe more people for that,
including some well-known actors who came in and in some very good readings.
And he kind of stuck in our head.
And it was one of those glorious times in independent filmmaking
where we got away with saying, oh, by the way, our lead is somebody
who nobody has ever seen in a movie.
Chris had that kind of Gary Cooper vibe to him.
You know, he rode around with his dad, who was a doctor,
but had some cattle when he was a kid.
But also he was an actor who could play a subtext.
That's just a knack that people have, which is that they can be saying one thing,
but you know something else is going on inside and they're not indicating it.
It's just going on.
Here's a guy who every time he asks a question is what happened in 1957?
He's really saying, what kind of human being was my father?
Subtext is very important to you as a filmmaker.
And how do you do that with respect to your writing?
For every character, even somebody who has three lines, I write a biography.
How long have I been married?
You know, is this a happy marriage?
You know, how long have you been sheriff?
Sometimes it's like a little short story.
And so that's a lot of where I'm giving them the ammunition for the subtext.
And we'll talk about it on the set.
But we have talked about a lot of that stuff before
because I don't do rehearsals.
I do blocking rehearsals.
But I want to see the shock of the new on when we're rolling the cameras.
So if you want spontaneity, do you allow them to spontaneously
throw in a line or change a line or color outside the lines?
Or are you rigorous with your writing that they have to say it exactly as you wrote it?
I often say it's written that way for a reason.
If you say it that way, it doesn't mean the same thing.
But what you do want to do is say,
you're here to give me your interpretations of this character.
There's where you have all your leeway.
I've had actors who come in and after the first take, I realize,
oh, my God, he read the biography and he got something out of it
that I even hadn't thought about this.
This is really interesting.
And without changing a line, they've totally changed the character.
And it works better.
Sometimes it works worse.
And then you have to ease them back into what you wanted to do.
But, you know, scene by scene, I want to see what they're going to do with it.
You direct a scene differently depending on what the emotion of the scene is.
And I direct it differently depending who the actor is.
So Elizabeth Pena, her instincts were great.
Her first two takes were really good.
Her first one was usually the best.
And then she started to overthink things.
You see the actor or the human being in front of you, what they need
and what they don't need.
And it's never the same way twice because no two people are alike.
Yeah. You're a director.
You're not teaching them how to act.
You're directing their talent.
Chris Kristofferson, here he was at the time that you made this film, a huge star.
And normally these big, heroic leading men, they don't want to play villains.
Yeah. And he plays one of the worst racist guys.
And he did this for scale.
Yeah. What I what I didn't want was to cast a guy
you'd seen play that part a bunch of times, you know, because then it's like
the minute you see him, you know what's what's going to happen.
And and I wanted the audience to be a little shocked.
Oh, my God.
Chris did a little movie called Pharaoh's Army.
I think one of his daughters was one of the producers of the movie.
Didn't get much of a release or anything like that.
And I saw him. I said, you know, he could do this.
You know, he's got that great deep voice.
He's a Texan. He's from the border.
You know, he's from Brownsville.
We learned this when we made Make One.
And we we spent like months looking for a James Earl Jones type
because we figured, well, we'll never get James Earl Jones, you know,
in a little movie to work for scale.
And it finally said, well, the hell with it.
We were like, and we and he called like two days later.
Well, now that I've got Christofferson, I've got a scene
where somebody stares him down without getting out of their chair.
One of the things wonderful about that scene is that you totally don't expect it.
You know what Chris Christofferson is doing is wrong.
And, you know, no one's going to say anything.
And then this guy does.
And he's not Matthew McConaughey yet.
He's just a guy who had been in a really nice part
and dazed and confused.
When I wrote the first draft of the screenplay, I didn't know the ending.
I had the situation, but I didn't exactly know what went down.
Hollis is a fantastic character.
And yet you think of him as just helping explain what's going on.
But then it turns out he obviously knows who Pilar's father is.
He knows the secrets.
He's from that generation, though, that you don't bring it up.
You keep the legend alive.
So these cultural relationships are very important in the film.
You know, the Miriam Cologne character, she calls the border patrol
when she sees the people crossing the border illegally.
You know, she wants to assimilate.
We don't speak Spanish. We speak English.
This is a real thing in our community.
It was very knowing.
I mean, you really had the courage to dig into it, put stuff on the screen
that maybe the community doesn't necessarily want to be put on the screen.
But that's real.
When you say Mexicans, look at the range of people you're talking about.
She was a wonderful actor.
Miriam had started the Puerto Rican traveling theater.
She went back to the Appaloosa and when I Jax very often as the only Latina.
And yes, so many of the actors came up and said, I'm getting to work
with Miriam Cologne.
You know, that's like been a dream of mine.
You know, we talk about the fact that you're saying, you know,
I'm a Gavacho and I'm doing a movie about Latinos.
But the movie is more than that, because we're talking about
the African-American community, the Native American community.
But also, you're not from Texas.
There's a cultural journey that you had to go through in order to really capture
the world of Charlie Wade and Sam Deeds, as well as the world of Pilar Cruz.
Yeah, I had I had hitchhiked across the country a couple of times.
And Texas is big.
So when you're hitchhiking across the country, you spend a lot of time in Texas.
And I even hitchhiked on the border route one time.
So I had a feel for that.
And then we did.
We started calling up sheriffs who worked on those border counties.
About a third of them, somebody would answer as well.
He's under indictment now.
He can't really talk. He's not free.
There was this drug thing happening.
And it was there was a lot of pressure and a lot of money there.
It was, you know, you either do this or we shoot you.
And a lot of chiefs of police got shot during that period.
So I realized, oh, there's other things going on here.
When was the moment that you said, I got to tell this story?
What gave you the idea to tell this story?
And then how long before you actually got it made?
I think, you know,
Piranha was made in like nineteen seventy nine.
And this movie was nineteen ninety six, I think.
That's a long gestation.
So I've been thinking about doing something on the border for quite a long time.
What finally do you want people to take away
from Lone Star when they see this film?
I want them to cross the border.
You know, we're meeting these people as human beings with their own problems.
We're also seeing them deal with those rules.
And when these people in this movie can get around
or ignore those borders, those lines, things go a lot better.
So we have to become like the birds that fly over the border.
Yeah, not that the birds don't care.
But we have to actually say there's somebody I could meet
and there's a lot of stuff we have in common.
And that the past is not the past.
That it's it's something we carry with us and it can be useful
or it can be destructive.
Yes. If it's destructive.
The only way to counter that is to really look into it
and be very honest about what happened.
