How Much Is John Hancock’s Signature Worth? | Pawn Stars (S1)
#PawnStars
The Pawn Stars are used to paying big money for celebrity John Hancocks but will they know how to price one from the actual John Hancock? See more in this scene from Season 1, Episode 11, "John Hancock's Hancock."
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedA man brings a document signed by John Hancock to a pawn shop, hoping to sell a family heirloom inherited from his grandfather. After an expert verifies the document's authenticity and high value due to rare double signatures, the owner and the shop owner fail to reach a price agreement, resulting in the owner keeping the item to seek a better offer.
What do you got here, man?
Hey, I got a signed John Hancock document.
Okay.
Your John Hancock or the John Hancock?
The John Hancock, I hope.
I considered selling this item online, but I just really didn't trust online buyers,
and I'd rather come down here to someone that knows what they're talking about.
I have no idea how much this thing is worth, but I'm just looking to get as much money
as I can.
This is an autographed John Hancock document.
You mean a signed document, not an autograph?
Yeah.
So how'd you get this thing?
Well, my grandfather got a hold of it I don't know how long ago, and he recently passed
away kind of divvying through all his stuff, and I got a hold of this.
I think it's extremely valuable.
I think it's the best thing that he left, so I wanted to see what I could get for it
today.
I have never owned anything with John Hancock's signature, so if I can get this at the right
price, I'll buy it in a minute.
Looks like it's an invoice for something.
It looks like it's real.
I mean, it could be vellum.
It doesn't look like normal paper.
What's vellum?
On really important documents, they use sheepskin because they knew it lasted forever.
The Declaration of Independence is not written on paper, it's written on vellum.
The amazing thing about this document, it's from 1791.
It's over 200 years old.
It was made with nice ink.
It isn't yellowing.
It isn't falling apart, and that you just don't see.
Everything looks good.
It doesn't appear to be fake.
Someone spent a fortune on framing it.
It does look old.
The ink's all oxidized.
When they used to make ink, they used lamp black.
That's the ash off an oil lamp, and iron filings, and when they wrote it, this would have been
completely black, but over time, the iron and the ink would rust, and that's what gives
it that orange appearance.
One of my issues is the J and the H. They don't look like the John Hancock we all know.
They just look a little squiggly.
I don't know.
It just doesn't look right, and I'm not saying this is fake.
I'm just saying it could be.
I can tell this document is old, but I don't know how old.
It's not like fakes have been around for 10 years.
Fakes have always been around, so how do I know that some guy in the 1800s didn't fake
this?
I'm going to have to call somebody up.
He's an expert in Revolutionary War documents, and he can tell me if it's real, and he can
tell me what it's worth.
All right.
Sounds great.
Hi, Rick.
How are you?
I'm pretty good.
I'm an expert in American history, colonial period, Revolutionary War period.
What I love about that area is it was the founding of our nation, how we came to be
what we are today.
What you have is a document that is signed by John Hancock while he was the governor
of Massachusetts, and this is paying 200 pounds in full.
He's paying himself his salary.
You have to look at the paper that it's written on.
That's absolutely critical that it's the correct paper of the period and correctly manufactured.
I'm going to turn the flashlight on.
It's on handmade laid paper, which means that somebody actually made this paper by hand,
which was the process years ago.
The reason that it looks so great today is because the paper that they made back then
is better than the paper that they make today by machine.
Rick, why don't we go ahead and put it down?
The paper looks authentic.
One of the interesting things about the document also that you'll note right here is the use
of an F in lieu of an S. They were pronounced the same way, the words, but the old English
grammar just interjected that difference from what we do currently.
Does the signatures look correct?
Well, the signature, which is the most important thing about this entire document, that's really
unusual.
It's possible that it could be a fake or reproduction of some nature.
That's why I'm going to have to carefully examine the signature itself.
I've seen a lot of John Hancock signatures.
This one is later in life.
He's older here.
You'll see there's a little bit of squiggliness to the line of the pen.
When he became more elderly, his signature was a little shakier, and that's basically
his not being as flowing with his handwriting at this later stage of life.
This is absolutely consistent with it being authentic and correct, and you even have a
confirmation of it on the reverse.
That's really unusual.
It's really an amazing thing.
The one on the back is gigantic.
It's incredible, and the signature on the back, he must have been excited about getting
the money because it's even bigger than on the front.
The signature, which is the most important thing about this entire document, looks fabulous.
After examining the document, I couldn't believe it was here.
I couldn't believe that Rick actually had that piece come into his shop.
It's beautiful.
It's one of the nicest John Hancock signatures that I've ever seen.
This is just remarkable.
It's a great item that you have here.
It's very exciting.
What do you think this thing is worth?
Be quite honest, just a standard document that's in average condition, signed by John
Hancock, typically is worth about $4,000 in the marketplace.
This is not your standard John Hancock document.
The most important thing is you have two signatures, one on the front, one on the back.
It really doesn't get too much better than that.
If it were consigned to my auction house, I think that you'd be looking at somewhere
in the vicinity of an estimate range of $6,000 to $8,000.
When the expert said it's worth $6,000 to $8,000 or even more, I mean, I was floored.
You know, to have a treasure like this, you're very lucky.
You'll be rewarded well, and I wish you good luck with that.
This is the type of item that makes my pawn shop stand out.
That's why I like these items, and that's why I want this.
Take care.
No problem.
Thank you.
Good luck.
All right, man.
So how much do you want for this thing?
Well, based on what he said, I figured at least $8,000 considering the condition of
everything and the double signature.
You know, I'd give you like three grand.
Three grand?
You know, I just don't think I really want to sell it for that.
I can come down a little bit, but you got to meet me in the middle.
You got to look at it from my perspective.
I'm not buying this to put in my house.
I'm buying it to resell, okay?
If you put this in an auction, the guy buying it is buying it to keep it.
Okay?
And I'm not, you know, I'm not a retail client.
Can you come up a little more?
I'll do four grand on it.
I just don't want to go more than that.
I think it's worth more.
$4,500, and I'm really not even comfortable doing that.
I really was looking to get six out of it.
All right.
Sorry we couldn't do business.
Okay.
Thank you.
Thanks for bringing it in.
Not a problem.
Thank you.
I'm really disappointed we didn't come to a deal, but unfortunately the price was just
too steep.
I don't need money today.
This was just handed down to me, so I can hang on to it for a little bit, research it
out and get more money for it.

