Politics Unusual: NYS Comptroller DiNapoli, Assemblymember Carroll

Fox - 5 NY
45 followers
1 Video View·Sep 25, 2026
Welcome to Politics Unusual. I'm Morgan Mackay.
We are about a month away from when early voting starts in New York City,
so next up in our candidate series, we're sitting down with State Comptroller
and Democratic nominee Tom DiNapoli.
Then we're going to be joined by State Assemblyman Robert Carroll
to talk about the Olympics, AI, and more.
And then we're taking a look at affordability concerns in New Jersey.
But first, at 18 years old, DiNapoli became the youngest person in New York State
And now he's on track to possibly shattering another record.
So joining us now is State Comptroller and Democratic nominee Tom DiNapoli.
Welcome to the show.
Thank you, Morgan. It's great to be with you.
I should say welcome back because you were on a few months ago.
So I didn't realize though then, and I was looking at your biography now,
you won your first election when you were just 18 years old.
Tell our viewers a little bit about yourself and how that ended up happening.
Well, when I was in high school, like a lot of young folks,
especially back then, living in a very divided nation, many hot issues going on.
Obviously, the war in Vietnam was one,
and all the other social movements that were happening.
And I didn't want to be on the sidelines.
I wanted to be part of making change.
And the year I graduated high school was the first year 18-year-olds could vote.
And I had been active.
I was the school president, shock of shocks, right?
And went to some school board meetings,
didn't like some of the things going on at the Board of Education.
So I said, you know what?
I'm staying home, going to college at Hofstra.
I think I'll run for a seat on the Board of Education.
So I had that unique experience.
My very first vote was for myself.
Who gets to do that?
And I won.
The good people in the old school district put their faith in an 18-year-old
that campaign knocking on doors in jeans.
And I had long, dark hair then, a little different than now.
But that really is what got me committed to doing community service
and that evolution from serving on the Board of Education
brought me, you know, to democratic politics
and eventually, you know, running for the state assembly
and comptroller all these years later.
Yes.
And now you've been serving as state comptroller for nearly 20 years.
You were first elected in 2007.
Now, I know Arthur Levitt was the longest serving state comptroller.
He served for 24 years.
And if you were to win this election,
by the end of your term, you'd be at 23 years.
Almost beating the longest.
Almost. I'll be shy by a few weeks.
Because remember, I was appointed because my predecessor had to resign, as you recall.
So I was appointed in February of 2007.
Unfortunately, then the voters have elected me several times since then,
hopefully this year as well.
So why continue to serve?
Why continue to run?
Well, you know, I worked in the private sector, you know, for 10 years.
And I enjoyed doing corporate work.
But for me, making a difference was more important than making money.
And so public service is always very important to me.
And, you know, we're going through a time of great challenge.
In some ways, it's similar.
The issues may be a little different.
But the divisions and the challenges, similar to when I was 18 years old
and felt I wanted to make a difference.
So I still think given all the challenges New York is facing,
my experience and my proven track record has something to offer.
Through this office of state comptroller,
which unfortunately a lot of folks don't fully appreciate
the breadth and depth of the work that we do and how impactful it is.
But I've always strived to do the job with integrity.
I'm very mindful that my predecessor had to resign
and she went to prison, as you know.
So doing the job clearly, with integrity, with credibility.
There's been a lot of drama in Albany.
You've covered Albany for a long time.
I don't believe in drama.
I just believe in getting the job done,
looking out for the taxpayer interest,
protecting the public pensions for our 1.3 million New Yorkers,
doing the audits to make sure taxpayer money is not being wasted,
helping people save for higher education through the 529 College Savings Program.
You go down the long list.
This is just a smattering of the work that we do.
I think it's more important than ever to have a steady hand
at the helm of the comptroller's office.
Now, one of your responsibilities as state comptroller is
protecting and providing oversight of the state's fiscal health.
What do you think is the biggest threat facing New York right now?
Well, I'd say that really the one obvious one,
which is always there, is the state of the economy and the volatility.
I mean, we benefit from a strong stock market.
Revenues are coming in higher than projected.
All that's good news.
But I think that's a fragile situation.
So the possibility of an economic downturn
or a downturn in the stock market is always a challenge for us in New York.
The broader and more recent challenge, though,
is the impact of federal policies
and particularly the cuts coming out of Washington.
We're starting to see that, especially on health care, the Medicaid cuts.
Over the next couple of years,
you're going to see even more cuts on the nutrition program,
SNAP, education programs, energy programs.
Part of the challenge in this year's budget process
was to see to what extent the state could backstop some of those cuts.
But that's going to be a continuing challenge
because although the budget is in balance and seems to be holding together,
we do have out-year budget gaps already that are there that could get worse.
I've been calling for years for the legislature
and the governor to build up our rainy day reserve funds
to have a cushion against federal cuts
and against the economy going in the wrong direction.
They didn't add to those reserves this year,
which I think was a missed opportunity.
So I think navigating the change relationship
between Washington and the states, particularly New York,
that's going to be an important part of the work that we need to do.
Now, earlier this year,
the legislature and the governor weakened the comptroller's ability
to provide oversight on what the state is spending taxpayer dollars on,
limiting your office's auditing powers.
What sort of concerns did you have with this?
Well, we spoke out against the proposal.
So the good news is the more extreme version
of what the governor had proposed did not happen.
So basically, they raised the threshold for contracts for really its pre-audit.
We can still audit after the fact,
but we always make the case on contracts.
We should be able to evaluate a contract
before it's signed to a fund to avoid problems, right?
So it's great to say we can audit after the fact,
but then the problem has already occurred.
So the good news is that it's not as bad as it could have been,
but the threshold was increased.
So that is a concern.
It's not new.
Governors have traditionally tried to have more autonomy
and take away the oversight.
So again, I think we can live with however.
One of the things I want to do in the next term
is really focus on procurement reform related to contracting
because especially now with the thresholds being higher
and we're seeing more state agencies go for single source
or sole source contracts where they're not doing competitive bidding.
To me, in most cases,
competitive bidding is where you're going to get best value for the taxpayers.
So I do think we have to have more transparency
and accountability on the procurement end.
That's one of the legislative changes I want to make some proposals on,
especially in light of some of the changes in this year's budget.
Do you think there's more, though,
that you can do to try to get back some of those powers from the legislature?
I feel like you have a pretty good relationship with the governor.
Is there something more?
No, it's not.
It's certainly not a hostile relationship,
you know, in terms of the personal dynamic.
But there's always an institutional pull, right?
The controller is the one looking over everybody else's shoulder.
And sometimes folks don't like that.
But I do think where every tax dollar is precious,
especially because of what I said earlier about less money coming from Washington,
people not wanting to see any waste in government,
the role of the controller is more important than ever.
So I think the fact that we were able to resist,
and our friends in the legislature resisted,
the more problematic proposals that the governor was putting forth is good news.
We've had battles in the past with previous governors
where we had some restoration of some of our authority that had been taken away.
But I would say where we're at right now, I think we can manage it.
But certainly if in next year's budget process they propose changes again,
we're going to say, hey, folks, taxpayers want to know someone's looking at what's going on.
Don't diminish that watchdog role of the controller any more than you have already.
Definitely.
Now, turning to the pension fund,
one of your roles as comptroller is managing the state's pension fund.
Last month, your office celebrated that in the first quarter of the fiscal year,
the state's pension fund reached its highest level ever,
$309 billion with a 6.12% quarterly return.
Your opponent says it could be better.
And if elected again, what would you do maybe differently with this pension fund?
Do you think it could be better?
Well, my opponent tends to not know what he's talking about.
He says a lot of stuff.
We are the best funded of all the big state pension plans.
We're like 97% funded, virtually fully funded,
which is more important than how big we are.
And keep in mind that's over 6% returns just for one quarter, right?
So it's not for the whole year.
Our long-term goal, and we're more conservative than other pension funds,
is a 5.9% long-term goal.
Last year, at the end of the year, we were close to a 12% return,
really double our expectation.
And we have a diversified portfolio.
It doesn't make sense to pick one part of an investment portfolio.
Let's say the public markets, what's happening with the S&P.
We're not trying to beat the S&P.
What we're trying to do is have a diversified portfolio
that will be an all-weather portfolio
to survive the ups and downs in investing.
And that protects, and that's why we have that 97% funded.
That protects that retirement security.
We're not day traders, right?
We're not trying to run up numbers or take risky investments.
When the stock market is doing well,
everybody says, put more money in the stock market.
When the stock market goes down, everybody says,
why do you have so much money in the stock market?
It's too risky.
So we have a big part of the portfolio in the stock market, for sure.
And that did very, very well, better than the 6%.
We have a significant part of the portfolio of fixed income,
most of which is managed in-house, as is most of the public equity.
But then we have alternatives, real estate,
private equity, infrastructure, real assets.
Those other parts of the portfolio are meant to provide a balance.
So whatever's happening with the stock market,
we're going to have a more consistent level of investment return.
And we've proven that that's a formula that works.
And I would just end by saying,
we've had independent evaluations of the fund.
In terms of our asset allocation, the fees that we pay,
our long-term goal on investment,
Department of Financial Services, our independent fiduciary review,
we always come out with high marks.
We're viewed as a well-managed pension fund.
But you know, Morgan, we're not static.
So every five years, we do a deep dive on our asset allocation.
And soon enough, we'll be doing that again.
Maybe we'll do little changes about how much money we're putting where.
But we're still going to have a diversified portfolio.
I know that you have a busy next month or so ahead of you.
And I hope it goes by fast.
Yes. And you have a first debate coming up as well.
So thank you so much. I appreciate you coming on.
Great to see you again.
Coming up next, could the Olympics return to New York?
We'll be joined by State Assemblyman Robert Carroll
about his push to bring back the Winter Games to the Empire State.
Welcome back to Politics Unusual.
The last time that New York State hosted the Olympics was in 1980 in Lake Placid.
The United States men's hockey team pulled off a miracle on ice.
And State Assemblyman Robert Carroll wants it to happen again.
And he's joining us now.
Thank you so much for being here.
So thank you, Morgan.
So Governor Kathy Hochul just recently named you to the exploratory committee
that has now been given the task to study whether New York City
and Lake Placid could jointly host a coordinated Winter Olympics.
Explain more.
Sure. So for a number of years, since New York State invested heavily on modernizing
the legacy sites in Lake Placid for the World University Games in 2023,
there's been a group of us who've been going around saying, you know what,
we can build on this.
And Lake Placid is a phenomenal place.
I'm lucky to have a home in the Adirondacks.
But it's too small to host a modern Winter Olympics on its own.
But if we partner it with New York City,
we, of course, could host the Winter Games and we could host them
without having to build any new sports infrastructure.
And it really would build on the model of what just happened in Italy.
The Milan Cortina Games took a big modern city like Milan
and married it to a small mountain town that famously previously had the Olympics Cortina.
And so we would take that same approach.
And Milan and Cortina are about the same distance apart as New York City and Lake Placid.
So New York City would host all the ice events like hockey and figure skating and speed skating,
and maybe some interesting snow events like big air or aerials or even a cross-country sprint.
And then the rest of the events, the alpine skiing, the bobsled,
the ski jumping, the biathlon would all happen in Lake Placid and the Adirondacks.
And so we're exploring this idea to see if it's viable.
I think it really is, and trying to socialize it among New Yorkers
to see if they would like us to host a future Winter Olympic Games.
And if we say yes to that over the next year, if people seem to be interested,
a big committee could be formed that could go out and try to win
the next available Winter Games for New York City and Lake Placid.
Now, I know you guys are still exploring many of the ideas and details,
but how would New York City, for example, be able to build, or not necessarily build,
but where would the bases, like where the Olympians, where they would be living,
how would that fit in New York City? Where would that go?
Great, great question. Where's the Olympic Village, right?
And the Olympics has changed a lot. They've allowed for people to be much more adaptable.
So in L.A., the Olympic Village is actually UCLA, the big college out there,
and they're using dormitories. So dormitories at NYU or Fordham or Columbia or Hunter could be used.
People have thought about cruise ships and saying, we could use cruise ships.
People have thought about, well, we could use it to kickstart an affordable housing project.
These are all the things that not just an exploratory committee is going to look at,
but if we say, yes, this is a good idea, a future bid committee
and a host committee would have to look at. And so nothing's set in stone,
but these are the big questions that we're trying to ask.
And I really appreciate that Governor Hochul is bringing us all together
and helping lead that effort to make sure that we ask those big questions.
Now, an exploratory committee, it's not the same as an official bid,
but what are the deadlines that you guys are trying to work with?
So Governor Hochul has made it clear she wants us to kick the tires on this for about a year.
It started this summer. So hopefully by next summer,
we'll have some ideas of where people stand.
And I think people are excited about it once they hear that, look,
we don't have to build new sports infrastructure.
The Winter Games is much more manageable than the Summer Games.
So there's about 3,100 athletes in the Winter Games.
There's almost 13,000 athletes in the Summer Games.
We're going to split them basically evenly between New York City and Lake Placid.
It's a much more manageable event.
It still gives us that great opportunity to figure out how to better organize our cities,
how to better connect upstate and downstate,
have people from rural New York and urban New York working together.
I think it's going to be an amazing opportunity.
Now, before I let you go, I also wanted to quickly get your take on
artificial intelligence in the classroom.
You chair the Assembly Committee on Libraries and Education Technology.
What did you think about the ban for using AI in the classrooms
for younger students here in New York City?
I think it's a great idea.
I carried the piece of legislation in New York State that would ban
forward-facing artificial intelligence in K through eighth grade,
except for certain diagnostic testing or for certain students with disabilities
when their IEP requires it.
I think that's what this has done.
I sit on the mayor's task force around AI in schools
and look forward to working with him and Chancellor Samuels.
I was at the press conference when they announced this,
and I think that this is a really thoughtful approach of saying,
we're going to do a big pause for one year.
We're going to figure out what's right.
We're going to allow for some very specific programs in the high school where,
you know, hopefully our students have gotten foundational skills
and, you know, now they're using AI to turbocharge those skills
versus younger grades where what we really need to focus on,
and you know I care deeply about foundational literacy skills,
is making sure students have foundational literacy skills and numeracy skills
so that then they can use technology to turbocharge those skills
and not the reverse where AI becomes either a crutch
or ends up papering over deficits,
and we never remediate those problems.
Well, I would love to have you back on very soon.
Thank you so much for staying this morning.
Love to come back on and talk about AI,
talk about the Olympics or anything you'd like.
Thank you for having me.
Thank you.
Coming up, is New Jersey dealing with an affordability crisis?
What residents are saying about the cost of living in the Garden State next.
New Jersey Governor Mikey Sherrill is calling for the resignation
of her own Lieutenant Governor Dale Caldwell.
It comes after an independent investigation looking into his conduct in office
found he acted inappropriately around women.
Sherrill gave Caldwell a Friday deadline to step down.
Rising rent isn't just a problem in New York City.
New Jersey is also dealing with the housing affordability crisis.
A new report found New Jersey is the fifth most expensive state in the nation for renters.
Stats show a full-time worker in the Garden State
must earn nearly $44 an hour to afford a modest two-bedroom apartment.
We asked residents if they are concerned about affordability in the Garden State.
Very expensive, especially this area, Hoboken and Jersey City.
And also now I live in Union City, it's now expensive too.
It's a huge difference from what I was paying like during COVID,
like compared to now, like a huge difference, but I mean it is what it is, right?
I've lived here for 14 years and it's been pretty expensive to say the least,
especially all like the new buildings that are going up and I feel like there's a lot of
drawing people in here.
I grew up in New Jersey, lived in the city for six years and now I'm in Weehawken.
So it's cheaper technically than what I paid in the city.
Next up, we're going to test your knowledge, so stay with us.
We're flashing back to this week in history.
On September 19th, 1926, the Feast of San Gennaro officially began.
The event originally started as a one-day block party by newly arrived Italian immigrants
to honor San Gennaro, the patron saint of Naples.
Finally tonight, we're testing your knowledge.
Last week we asked you what New York City building was damaged by fireworks
celebrating the laying of the transatlantic cable in 1858.
The answer, City Hall.
Sparks from the fireworks ignited the roof back in 1858.
The fire caused heavy damage to the upper level and destroyed the original sculpture of justice.
Now to this week's question.
What New Jersey city held the first organized baseball game?
Don't google the answer.
If you want to take a shot at it, go ahead, scan that code on your screen.
That's going to take you to our website, fox5ny.com, where you can type in your answer
and check back here next week to see if you're right.
That does it for this episode of Politics Unusual.
If you missed any part of the show or just want to check it out again,
we're now on Spotify and any other platform you listen to podcasts on.
So be sure to follow us.
Thank you for joining us.
I'm Morgan McKay.
Have a safe weekend.
We'll see you next week.
