#Rome#law#RomanHistory The Twelve Tables were the foundation of Roman law for centuries. Even later rulers such as Justinian used the Twelve Tables as a basis for their own legal codes. We even see the Tables serve as inspiration for some modern legal systems with both United State's law codes and traditional English Common Law being heavily influenced by the Twelve Tables. The Tables served not only as a compendium of legal remedies but also as a reminder of the rights, privileges, and duties that each Roman citizen held, Patrician or Plebeian. The Tables are without a doubt the most important writings from the Republican Era and are perhaps the most important Roman writings period. But what did each table say? How fair were the Tables? And how does each Table rank in our viewing of history? Let's talk about it.
This is the second in a two part series around the Twelve Tables and the 2nd Plebeian Secession. This video covers the tables themselves while the first episode talked about the background for the creation of the Tables.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Twelve Tables were the foundation of Roman law. Featured prominently in the Forum,
each table stated a right and or a duty of a Roman citizen. Cicero perhaps summed up their
importance best when he said, quote, Twelve Tables seems to me assuredly to surpass the libraries
of all the philosophers both in weight of authority and in plentitude of unity,
end quote. And Cicero was not exaggerating. The Twelve Tables quite literally formed the basis
for not only the Roman legal system, but how Roman society as a whole functioned.
So then, what did the Twelve Tables actually say? Why were they so important? And how does
each table rank among the other tables and in history? Let's talk about it.
Before we get any further into today's episode, I just want to quickly ask that you subscribe and
like if you enjoy my content. It really helps the channel out and it motivates me to make more
content. Now back to your regularly scheduled programming. As we discussed in the last episode,
the establishment of the Twelve Tables was part of the wider series of events known as the
Conflict of Orders. Rome had appointed two different ten-man commissions known as Decemvirs.
These commissions put together the Twelve Tables based on earlier Roman traditions, in 449 BCE.
Each copper table dealt with a different aspect of Roman society. The tablets were
featured prominently in the Roman Forum and provided a way for the plebeian class,
which didn't receive the same level of education as the patrician class, to learn and understand
what rights and privileges they held. Each of the first ten tables focused on one specific
aspect of Roman society, while the last two were cobbled together with various scraps that didn't
quite fit anywhere else. We should also note here that we don't actually have the text of
these tables in their originality. The original tables were likely lost during the Gallic sack,
and no reproductions that we know of survive into the modern day. Instead, we rely on people
like Cicero and others to give us quotations and other such writings, so keep in mind that we may
have some quotes that are not quite correct. The first table deals with the procedure for
the courts as well as individual trials. While you can see the actual writings on the screen
in front of you, I will attempt to sum this all up in some more modern language. Firstly,
if a defendant is accused of a crime, then he is typically required to show up in the courtroom.
If he is unable due to age or illness, then the plaintiff must provide some form of transportation
for the defendant to come to court. If the defendant attempts to run, or otherwise refuses
to show up, then the plaintiff is allowed to quote, lay hands on him. Essentially, this means
that the plaintiff is allowed to use force to get the defendant into the courtroom. Further,
only a patrician can represent a patrician, while anyone, patrician or plebeian, can represent a
plebeian. If or when the parties agree on a settlement, then the magistrate, the judge,
shall announce the verdict. If they cannot agree to terms, then the two parties shall meet with
the magistrate in the courtroom or the marketplace before noon, whereupon the magistrate shall render
a decision. If one party does not show up before noon, then the magistrate must rule in favor of
the party present. If both parties do show up, then the time limit for a decision is sundown
on the same day. The second table further elaborates on how exactly a trial should be
conducted. Firstly, this table sets up the amount of financial stake that each party is responsible
for during a trial. Typically, each case requires a deposit of 500 or 50 asses, an early form of
Roman currency. Next, this table details what to do in the case of some sort of impairment on
behalf of the judge and or one of the litigants. Mostly, the answer is simply to postpone the trial
on that day. Lastly, this table allows each party that needs witnesses to call for such witnesses
on every third day. We believe that the mention of this doorway on the table refers to the witness's
own home, in a similar manner to how the police may serve you a summons to court in your own home
today. So, all in all, these two tables are actually extremely fair, and were probably a
godsend for the plebeian class. For the plebeians to know that their accused must come to court one
way or another, or that the actual proceedings would occur at noon, or anything else from these
tables would have completely changed the way these trials were approached. While we don't quite know
just how widespread knowledge of these rights and procedures were among the plebeians prior to the
establishment of the 12 tables, we can imagine that it was fairly low. Suddenly having this
information at your fingertips was likely revolutionary, and probably changed the way
that trials would work and run forever. Overall grade? I'd say an A. The next table deals with
the execution of judgments from these various trials. This table gives 30 days for the person
who lost the trial to pay the debt owed, gives the creditor the right to lay hands on the debtor after
those 30 days if no payment has been received, and bring him back to the court. Further, it prescribes
that unless an individual, or someone on their behalf, can pay the debt, the person will be taken
into bonds by the other party. If the person in bonds wishes to, he can live on his own means.
If he doesn't wish to, then the other party must give him a pound of bread daily.
The person can be held in bonds for up to 60 days, and during those 60 days they must be brought
before a magistrate on three consecutive market days. Each day, the amount that the person has
been held liable for will be announced within the market, and if on that third market day the person
still has not paid, then he will either be subject to capital punishment, likely some sort of whipping
or some other such punishment, or be subject to sale abroad. Lastly, on that third market day,
each creditor, the winner in the case, shall have the right to take shares of the loser's property
in lieu of payment, up to the judgment in the case. Wow, that seems pretty harsh, right? Well,
these laws were at least able to restrict the debt slavery that had been so prevalent in Rome
to official business dealings, and at least gave the debtor a chance to plead his case. Remember
that debt slavery was a massive problem in Rome around this time, and one of the main causes of
the conflict of the orders in the first place. While this table certainly did not eliminate it,
it did likely give the plebeians a fighting chance. Overall grade, probably somewhere between a B and
a C. While the punishments were certainly harsh, for the time it wasn't all that uncommon.
The fourth table deals with the rights of the heads of families. This table is probably the
most shocking to our modern beliefs. Firstly, this table states that any notably or dreadfully
deformed child must be quickly euthanized by the head of the family. This included both mental and
physical deformities. Further, it states that sons are the only children born into the inheritance,
and that if a son is born less than 10 months after the death of his father, he is equally
entitled to an inheritance as the other sons. The table goes on to guarantee freedom for any son who
is unsuccessfully sold by his father three times, and gives the patriarch the right to remove his
wife from the household and order her to quote, mind her own business. Yeah, that one is really
rough. It's laws like this that many people miss in their examination of Roman law. Many people in
the public, and even some historians, like to paint Rome as this great and equal society. But the truth
is that it was a very patriarchal society, where the father of a family was essentially granted
supreme power over any other members of the family. We will see further examples of this as we go on,
but I think it is important to understand that Roman law was not equal, even after these tables
were created. Overall grade, an F, no doubt. Table 5 deals with inheritance and guardianship.
Firstly, women shall be under some sort of guardianship, even after obtaining their majority,
unless the woman is a Vestal Virgin. The property of women could not be transferred by the woman
herself, but only by her guardian. The next half deals with the person's will, and the laws
surrounding such documents. Firstly, any requests by the deceased made in regards to his property,
or other such possessions, shall be honored. And if that person died with no direct heir,
then his closest living male relative shall receive his estate, except in the cases of freed
slaves. Their estate shall be given over to their patron. Furthermore, if no guardians for either
women or young sons had been appointed in the will, then the closest male relative shall become
such a guardian. Lastly, shares of the inheritance shall be given equally to all heirs, along with
all debts incurred by the estate. This table is a mixed bag. Of course, the glaringly obvious and
horrible portions on women are quite shocking. In this table, women are treated like property,
and they are essentially given no rights of their own. This again simply reinforces the fact that
Rome was a patriarchal society. Rome was not some equal opportunity land where women had the same
rights as men, and it is important to remember that. The second half of the table is much more
understandable. While it does prohibit women from inheriting anything, it does give all a man's sons
right to an equal share of the estate. Overall grade for the inheritance, let's say a C. For women,
it's certainly an F, maybe even lower if that's possible. The sixth table deals with ownership
and possession. This table makes verbal promises or deals binding. It also grants land ownership
after a period of two years of open and continuous use by person or entity, as well as creating a
legal form of marriage if a man and woman live together for more than one year. If a woman wishes
to exempt herself from such an arrangement, she must leave the home for at least three consecutive
nights. You can see what the goal of this table is. This table is meant to formalize situations
where Roman law would normally view a person as landowner or a couple as married. Essentially,
this gives away for those who can't afford land or can't afford a marriage to receive that land
or recognition of their marriage after a certain period. Overall grade, probably a B. While it does
do a good job at recognizing marriages and the ownership of land, it does put the onus on a woman
to avoid the situation, and thus is pretty discriminatory. These next two laws are probably
the most complicated and the most detailed tables. Let's try not to get bogged down in the details,
as those are not all that important in our study of the tables, and let's instead focus on the
overall themes and try to combine some of the fairly lengthy notations. First, we have the
seventh table, which deals with real property, i.e. land. Firstly, this table deals with the setting
of boundaries for various types of property, including farms, cottages, and other such plots.
Secondly, this table makes a landowner responsible for building a road over his land for travelers
to follow, and gives those travelers the right to choose an alternate route if that road becomes
damaged. Think of this as a sort of insurance that a landowner cannot punish or attack a traveler
for having to walk on some other portion of the land. This table also gives landowners the right
to remove trees which have fallen onto their property, and the right to collect fruit which
has fallen onto their property as well. Further, this table ensures that no articles of ownership
can be given to a buyer unless he first gives the agreed upon payment or some other sort of
promise or guarantee. Of course, as you can see on the screen in front of you, there are quite a bit
more exemption specifics and so on that we don't really need to get into. Just know that this table
was certainly one of the most important, as the rights around land and other such ownership was
likely only known to the patricians, and that exclusive knowledge would have made it much easier
for a patrician to get won over, so to speak, on a plebeian. Again, much like the table dealing with
trials, this table was likely revolutionary, and probably greatly changed the balance of power in
The eighth table is the longest of the twelve, and without a doubt the most complicated,
so bear with me here. This table deals with torts, an act or statement that causes civil
wrong to a person, and delicits, a criminal wrong. So this table essentially describes punishments
for common crimes and civil actions. Firstly, anyone singing, chanting, or otherwise saying
harmful incantations shall be subject to execution. Remember, Rome was a very superstitious
society, and the idea of wishing or attempting to cause some sort of harm by incantations
was widely believed in fear. Secondly, injuring another person results in one of two things.
It could result in a retaliation, whereby the same injury is inflicted onto the person who
committed the act in the first place, or it could result in some sort of payment as compensation.
Eye for an eye and all that. Anyone who steals crops knowingly shall be put to death as a sacrifice
to Ceres, the Roman goddess of agriculture, and anyone who knowingly destroys a bundle of crops
or a building shall be burned to death. Pretty hardcore, right? Although we should remember that
in these times, those crops would have been all that a person had to feed his family, or make any
sort of money with. Crops were the lifeline for farmers, and destroying them was paramount to
We will skip a lot of these, but feel free to pause the video to read any that you wish.
But two more that I feel the need to point out are the penalty for false testimony,
being thrown off the Tarpaian Rock, and the fact that this table banned nighttime meetings within
the city. Some of these punishments seem severe or a little overboard, but we should remember that
laws within Rome were not only civilly important, but were religiously important. So if you lied in
court, not only were you committing an injustice before your fellow citizens, but that injustice
was also committed against the gods themselves. And when you look at it like that, it kind of
makes sense that death was required to satisfy the gods. The point here is that the Roman legal
system was undoubtedly harsh, but when you consider just what it meant to the people of Rome,
it's kind of unsurprising just how harsh it was. Overall grade, for the period, an A. For our
modern period, probably an F. The ninth table deals with public law and the conduct of magistrates.
Firstly, laws of personal exemption, meaning laws that granted privileges or immunity to singular
people, were forbidden, and laws dealing with capital punishment could only be passed by the
comita curata, or general assembly. Next, any judge or magistrate who was found to have been bribed
in a case shall be executed. And lastly, the law prescribes the death penalty to anyone who incites
rebellion or treason, and guarantees that no person shall be executed without first facing trial.
This is actually a pretty progressive table. It essentially guaranteed a trial to anyone before
execution, and actually gave a pathway to punish corrupt magistrates. Overall grade, an A. The
tenth table deals with Rome's sacred laws, as well as burial practices. This table prohibited the
burial of dead people inside the city limits. This table also limited expenses for a funeral
to just three professional mourners, a mourner wearing a purple tunic, and ten flutists. Yeah,
a Roman funeral was pretty fun to be honest. I definitely want professional mourners at my
funeral. Women were not allowed to tear their cheeks, nor make loud outcries at funerals,
and no gathering of bones for a second funeral was allowed, save for deaths in battle or a barrage.
This essentially limited each dead person to one funeral. If the dead person had gained some sort
of crown by his property, by honor, or by valor, then that crown would be put upon him at his
funeral. This table also prohibited any excessive displays of wealth, the adding of gold, save for
gold teeth, and excessive drinking at funerals. So overall grade, probably an A. Anything with
professional mourners is great for me. Now, these last two tables are mostly addendums for previous
tables. The eleventh table is based around marriage, and pairs with the fourth, fifth,
and sixth tables. This table first bans intermarriage between patricians and plebeians.
This would eventually be changed in 445 BCE, just four years after the formal creation of the tables,
along with requiring soldiers to put their marriage on hold to finish training, and providing
regulations on what days official legal proceedings could occur. The twelfth table lists more punishments
for common crimes, and lines up with the eighth and the third table. False accusers face double
the punishment. A theft, committed by a slave with the knowledge of their master, results in the
forfeit of the slave to whomever was stolen from. And lastly, and perhaps most symbolically, any act
or ordainment by the people shall be legally binding, no matter the circumstances. I really
believe that the last note in the twelfth table was almost certainly done on purpose, to place the
ultimate power for decision making with the people. Overall grades? For the eleventh table, probably a B
or a C. The whole intermarriage thing did not last long, and was obviously discriminatory, but the
other two points are important and do kind of make sense. For the twelfth table, probably a B+. While
the punishments might be slightly severe by our modern sense, they are actually pretty common for
the time in history, and frankly unsurprising. The last line, though, is very impactful, and will be
important throughout Roman history. So, you still with me? That was a lot of information, but we should
remember that this was the culmination of hundreds of years of Roman legal tradition, so it's not
really that surprising that it would be dense and fairly hard to follow for someone like us, who
didn't grow up with these laws. So then what was the significance of these tables? Well, these are
probably the most influential pieces of writing in the history of the Roman Republic, and possibly all
of Roman history. No joke. This was the foundation of Roman law, and heavily influenced later law
codes such as Justinian's laws, and even the American legal system, with James Madison himself
even highlighting the importance of the 12 tables on the Bill of Rights. Common law, one of the most
influential types of law in most English-speaking countries, was also greatly influenced by the 12
tables. Hell, even if we discount the content of the tables entirely, the simple idea of presenting
the people with codes of laws that actually enumerated their rights, privileges, and duties
is massively important in the history of law. The historical significance for both the Romans
and our modern Western legal system cannot be overstated. This is really the beginning for many
of the legal systems in the West. But how important were these tables to the Romans during their
creation? Again, extremely important. We must remember that Rome didn't have public schools.
Polybians were not granted the same education as their patrician counterparts, and this left them
at a distinct disadvantage when it came to legal rights, practices, and so forth. The fact now that
any Roman who could read could walk to the forum and see their rights enumerated was revolutionary.
Cicero tells us that most Romans learned about the 12 tables from their childhood,
and that the rights guaranteed within them were imprinted into Roman minds.
This just captures the importance of the tables. The tables were not just laws that each Roman must
follow. Instead, they were guarantees. Guarantees that no one would face death without a trial.
Guarantees that the accused would show up in the court. Guarantees that judgment would be fair.
And guarantees that power ultimately rested with the people of Rome.
This isn't to say that the tables had no flaws. Women were treated as little more than property,
and the legal system still favored those with the means to pay fines. But it was a start. It was a
start towards equality in Rome, and it was a start towards equal justice for all. So in the end,
I don't think I'm exaggerating when I say that the 12 tables might be the most important legal
document ever written, not only for the Romans, but for all of Western civilization.
Thank you for watching. I hope you enjoyed it, and I hope you learned something. I'm sorry if
this video seemed a bit like an information dump, but the 12 tables are the culmination
of hundreds of years in Roman law, and hopefully I managed to condense them down into understandable
bits. If you have any comments or questions on the video, or really if I made a mistake,
please comment down below. And please like and subscribe if you enjoyed. It really helps the
channel out. Peace.