Evolution of International Humanitarian Law

Global Affairs Academy
6 followers
2 Video Views·Sep 25, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis text examines the two Additional Protocols to the 1949 Geneva Conventions, adopted between 1974 and 1977. These protocols update international humanitarian law to address modern weaponry and expand protections for civilians and victims of both international and non-international armed conflicts, while balancing humanitarian needs with state sovereignty.
The two additional protocols to the 1949 Geneva Conventions were adapted by consensus at the
1974 to 1977 diplomatic conference on the reaffirmation and development of international
humanitarian law applicable in armed conflicts. They emerged out of concerns that modern
developments in weaponry, including weapons capable of inflicting massive casualties and
extensive and long-term damage to state infrastructure and the natural environment,
call for the adoption of new rules of conduct applicable to armed conflict.
The additional protocols are also known as the optional protocols. The protocols
have not conventions and unlike many of the principles of the conventions,
legal scholars do not consider them to constitute norms of customer international law.
Protocol one pertains to protection of civilians and military civilian medical personnel during
international armed conflict. It expands upon the provisions of the original conventions
and includes limitations and explicit discussion of the methods of warfare,
its effect on the civilian population and protection of civilians.
One controversial aspect of additional protocol one relates to words of national liberation.
Article one clause four of the protocol includes as international those armed conflicts in which
people are fighting against colonial domination and alien occupation and against racist regimes
in the exercise of their right of self-determination. This represents a
depression from traditional definitions of international as opposed to non-international
armed conflicts by including a classification based on the cause for which one of the parties
is fighting. Article one clause four raised the concern for several states including United States
of America, India and Pakistan that the expanded definition would give cover to terrorist groups
and anxiety exacerbated by the protocol's sympathetic treatment of irregular fighters.
Part two consisting of articles eight to thirty-four develops the rules of the first
and the second Geneva convention on wounded, sick and shipwrecked. It extends the protection
of the convention to civilian medical personnel, equipment and supplies and to
civilian units and transports and contains detailed provisions on medical transportation.
Part three and several chapters of part four articles thirty-five to sixty deal with the
conduct of hostilities that is questions which hitherto were regulated by the hate conventions
of 1899 and 1907 and by customary international law. Their reaffirmation and development is
important in view of the age of hate conventions and of the new stage which had no part in their
elaboration. Articles forty-three and forty-four give a new definition of armed forces and
combatants. They contain a definition of military objectives and prohibition of attack on civilian
persons and objects. Further articles sixty-one to seventy-nine deal with the protection of
civil defense organization, relief actions and the treatment of persons in the power of a party
to a conflict. Part five articles eighty to ninety-one brings some new elements to the
problem of the execution of the convention and the protocol. Article one of the protocol one
provides the following general principles. Number one the high contacting parties have
to ensure respect for this protocol in all circumstances. Number two in cases not covered
by this protocol or by other international agreements civilians and combatants remain
under the protection and authority of the principles of international law derived from
established custom from the principles of humanity and from the dictates of public
concerns. Number three this protocol supplements the Geneva conventions of 12 august 1949 for the
protection of war victims and shall apply in the situations referred to in article two common to
those conventions. Number four the preceding situations include armed conflicts in which
people are fighting against colonial domination and alien occupation and against racist regime
in the exercise of their right of self-determination as enshrined in the charter of the united nations
and the declaration on principles of international law concerning friendly relations and cooperation
among states in accordance with the charter of the united nations. The international committee
walking on the lines following after the 1914 to 1918 war first collected the fullest possible
preliminary information on those aspects of international law that require confirmation
enlargement and amendment. In october 1945 the first meeting of the experts comprising of
neutral members of the mixed medical commissions in brief mmc was held. The members of the mmc
had visited the wounded and sick prisoners of war during the conflict to decide about their
repatriation. The preliminary conference of national red cross society was held in july and august
1946 at geneva. From april 14 to 26 1947 the conference of government experts for the study
of conventions for the protection of war victims was held in geneva. Protocol 2 is a 1977 amendment
protocol to the geneva conventions relating to the protection of victims of non-international
armed conflicts. Protocol 2 elaborates on the international humanitarian law principles
relating to non-international armed conflict situation providing an additional 28 principle
set out in common article 3. Although in specifying certain criteria including a degree of
organizational requirement for non-state parties it defines certain international laws that
strive to provide better protection for the victims of international armed conflicts that
take place within the borders of a single country. The scope of this law is more limited than those
of the rest of the geneva conventions out of respect for sovereign rights and duties of
national governments. Common article 3 applies to the armed conflicts that are not of an
international character but that are contained within the boundaries of a single country. It
provides limited protection to victims including persons taking no active part in the hostilities
should be treated humanely including military personnels who have ceased to be active as a
result of sickness injury or detention. The wounded and sick shall be collected and cared for.
The extent of the scope of common article 3 in international law to cover additional humanitarian
rights in the context of internal conflicts centered on two conflicting ideas. First the
distinction between internal and international armed conflict is artificial from the point of
view of a victim. Humanitarian principles should apply regardless of the identity of the combatants.
Second international law doesn't apply to non-international situations. A nation has
sovereignty within its borders and must not accept judgments and orders from other countries.
The scope of this protocol is founded on the following factors. Number one material field
of application. Article one of this protocol provides that this protocol develops land
supplements. Article three common to the four geneva conventions of 1949 without modifying
its existing conditions of application. It said apply to all armed conflict which are not covered
by article one of the protocol one additional to the geneva conventions of 1949. This protocol
shall not apply to situations of internal disturbances and tensions such as riots
isolated and sporadic act of violence and other acts of similar nature. Number two
personal field of application. Article two of this protocol provides that this protocol
shall be applied without any adverse distinction founded on race color sex language religion or
political or other opinion national or social origin wealth birth or other status or any other
similar criteria to all persons affected by an armed conflict as defined in article one.
Number three non-intervention. Article three of the protocol mandates that nothing in this
protocol shall be invoked for the purpose of affecting the sovereignty of a state
or responsibility of the government by all legitimate means. This shall also not be invoked
as justification for intervening directly or indirectly in the armed conflict as such.
This protocol simply aids the red diamond as an additional valid international symbol of
ICRC. The valid symbols of the ICRC are the red cross red christian and now the red diamond.
Protocol additional to the geneva convention number three refers to this additional emblem
as the third protocol emblem. The fundamental principle on which the law of armed conflict
based is expressed as follows. Number one the first prohibits the use of weapons projectiles
in material and matters of warfare of a nature to cause unnecessary injury. Number two the second
in order to ensure respect and protection for the civilians population and civilian property
obliges the parties to the conflict to distinguish at all times between the civilian population and
the military objective and to direct their operations only against military objectives.
