This audio-visual film commentary has been extensively edited, dubbed and transformed by Serious Feather in an original and thoughtful manner for historical, cultural and educational purposes. __________
As requested by Serious Feather subscribers (unaffiliated links):
This video explores the production of *Hush... Hush, Sweet Charlotte*, detailing the atmospheric direction of Robert Aldrich and the intense professional dynamics on set. It specifically highlights the legendary rivalry between Bette Davis and Joan Crawford, the eventual replacement of Crawford with Olivia de Havilland, and the disciplined leadership required to manage such powerful personalities.
Charlotte?
The winners of five prior Academy Awards and 21 Academy nominations
now bring you suspense unequaled in the history of the screen.
Shock that will leave you speechless.
Charlotte, what have you done?
Sweet Charlotte, Charlotte, don't you...
Hush, hush, sweet Charlotte, I'll love you till I die.
I told you, and I told your father too.
Why wouldn't I tell him that his pure darling little girl
was having a dirty little affair with a married man?
You're a vassal, a little tramp!
How was I to know it would end in murder?
But it didn't end with murder, it just began.
Where do you think you're going?
I'm going upstairs and I'm going to tell her what you've been up to.
What's going on up there that you don't want me to see?
Don't you think I know what you're looking for in my house?
But what does it matter if you haven't anything to conceal?
Oh, but I have, I have things concealed, vile things.
Where do you suppose I keep them? Haven't you guessed?
You know what it's costing me not to kill you.
Let me tell you, Miriam Dearing, that murder starts in the heart.
Don't turn on the light. It's only real when it's dark.
I won't turn on the light.
He's there!
Damn you! Now will you shut up?
This is one of the great houses of the Old South.
You may see it today just as it was in its great days, not far from Baton Rouge.
I've seen it again recently.
Joseph Cotton is my name.
I'd seen this wonderful house before, but never under such doubtful circumstances,
for I had fallen into the hands of a wizard.
You laugh and I repeat, wizard.
For what else do you name the man who calls forth spirits,
raises vestiges of the restless departed,
and conjures forth maleficent manifestations?
It's sometimes hard to recognize even a wizard,
such as Robert Aldridge going through what must seem to the casual observer
the rather tedious and certainly time-consuming business of directing a motion picture.
Each apparently unpremeditated move
has its deftly calculated place in the grand scheme
that will ensnare you, just as it has me,
in the doom of a lady named Charlotte.
They are asking you to leave this house
because they are going to tear it down,
not because of any of the ulterior motives that you seem to imagine.
Even so accomplished a spellbinder as Betty David
finds herself responding to the Aldridge legend of Maine.
This famous actress, this two-time Academy Award-winning star,
this battler, this remarkable woman,
will too fall under the spell of the magician,
or at least pretend to,
long enough to let him make her ultimately a sweet southern belle,
a persecuted innocent, a raging hellion,
a shattered and heroic human being,
and perhaps a poor mad creature they call Charlotte.
Once having decided that only the great Betty Davies could do the role of Charlotte,
then who in the world could stand up to Davies?
In the crucial role of the slatternly Velma,
Aldridge casts one of the screen's most versatile actresses, Agnes Moorhead.
For the role of Miriam, another wizard's stroke is evident
in the choice of the very star Davies described in her recent autobiography
as a fighter for integrity
and a favorite of mine as an actress and a person,
Olivia de Havilland.
Quite charming.
I didn't mean it.
I didn't mean it that way, and you definitely not.
Anyway, you don't have no call to be so high and mighty.
This is the workaday world for the movie maker.
This is a take.
Two-sixty, take seven.
I'll show you Papa's library.
Papa built this place up again, you know.
He bought back a lot of the original pieces.
Cut. Print.
But they will do it again.
There is the slate.
Two-sixty, take two.
Papa built this place up again, you know.
He bought back a lot of the original pieces.
Papa's library was like a playroom to me when I was a little bitty.
Back, Papa.
He was always so happy to...
Take your hands off!
You give that to me!
Now you get out! You get out, all of you!
Get out, you hear me?
You get out and you sit!
Supporting players scurry out of scene and hold their breath to hear it played to the end.
And Miss de Havilland agrees that her sister-in-arm, David, has done it again.
It is only in two such accomplished women as these, and two women so assured in their art,
one could see the little girl.
And that high school girl's humor seems to interrupt in no way the return to their part.
In the dark dream that this wizard has woven round them.
309, take three.
Hush, hush, sweet Charlotte.
And after this office laboratory coal mine workshop is closed for the day,
what do we movie makers do?
Well, you must have guessed.
We look at movies.
The movie called Hush, Hush, Sweet Charlotte.
I got a call to go meet Bob Aldrich, who was the director.
And I had been in Hollywood maybe two years.
And I went to Fox and I met Bob Aldrich.
That's how I became involved in the movie.
I made a mistake, Charlotte, that's all.
I get there and I know what the scenes are.
But I'm shocked.
This is nice to say because Betty's not here,
but I'm shocked that she's going to play herself in the flashback scenes with me.
Because she's 60 and I'm 25 and we're supposed to be lovers.
And she says, no, no, I'm going to do it.
I said, well, that's fine.
And I was a jerk enough to suggest that maybe it should be a double.
She looked me in the eye and she said, I think we better have a lesson.
And she sat me down.
And she smoked in that lesson, which lasted maybe 25 minutes over lunch,
my second day there.
She smoked a pack of Chesterfields in that lunch.
And she said, I never, ever have anyone double me.
I do it myself.
And in a scene like this, she said, after all,
one's read about Mr. Kazan's darling, Bruce Dern.
I'm not going to miss the chance.
And she says, besides, young man, are you telling me I look older than you do?
And she didn't.
I mean, at 60 years old, her face might have been physically older,
but her youthfulness inside of her came out so young and so adorable
and so she had nasty game.
By nasty game, I just mean they would go with the language any way you wanted to take it.
You wanted a locker room, they'd go in a locker room.
You want a gutter, they'd go in a gutter.
You want it uptight, New England, Catherine Hepburn, they'd go right with it.
They were wonderful that way.
But on that particular movie, on the opposite end,
you had Mr. Haviland, who I don't think, you know,
ever used a foul word unless it was in a script,
and then she probably argued about it.
But, I mean, she was just an absolute delight in a whole nother...
I mean, to this day, I never once...
And on that set, I never once called her...
Betty called her Libby.
I never once would call her anything but Mr. Haviland.
And after, like, the second or third day, she said,
I wish you'd cut that out.
And she said...
And I just said, who could cut out being allowed to say de Haviland?
I mean, it's just so cool.
And it wasn't until Betty told me one day the whole thing about the sister and her,
I didn't know anything about, that Joan Fontaine was her sister,
that they had had an arch rivalry since they were little kids
that was very similar to the whole Baby Jane story,
where one was the star as a kid and the other was held back,
and then it got reversed as they got famous and so forth and so on.
And they didn't ever speak.
They had no association with each other.
Both were Oscar winners.
Both were so forth and so on.
Neither one supported the other.
Neither one dealt with the other one.
And Betty loved it.
She just said, oh, wouldn't you love to get them in a room together?
And Hitchcock, when I worked with him then later, both on Marnie,
which I'd worked with him before on, but then later in Family Plot,
he told me stories.
He said he always tried to put them together in movies,
but there was just no way.
And so he got Joan Fontaine all the time, you know.
But he said, I always wanted to put, he said,
I always wanted to put Olivia in the crowd, in the scene,
and not tell Joan she was going to be there.
And then suddenly Joan would go in to the market to buy something,
and there would be Olivia.
And she wouldn't even know it.
And the other one wouldn't know it.
And they'd both see each other, and just to film it
and get their nasty faces looking at each other.
And he loved that.
I mean, that was Hitch.
He just loved that kind of stuff.
The one thing I did worry about more than anything else
was this enormous kid, Victor Bono,
who was a much more proficient actor than I was,
even though I was maybe a year older than he.
I didn't know what he thought about me.
But I do know that he had to come at me with a meat cleaver
about this big, through the greenhouse,
with this huge size, with a tuxedo on.
And I'm sitting there waiting for Betty to come, you know,
because it's the night we were going to run away together.
And Bob Aldrich comes up to me just before we shoot the shot.
He says, now I'm going to do this in two cuts.
And I laughed.
And I said, what do you mean?
He said, cuts, two cuts, you know.
Oh, yeah, right.
And he says, so in the first cut,
we're going to chop your hand off.
So he says, you make sure that you hold that prosthetic hand
and grab your fingers and don't let any of your fingers
come out like this, because they'll go.
Because I'm chopping the hand right here.
So the prosthetic hand gets hit,
and I want the sleeve to go with it.
So if you've got a knuckle or a finger there,
it's going to get chopped off.
And he said, I don't know a thing about this kid
at crunch time, the big kid.
That's what he called him, the big kid.
And he said, you know, he's a bit of a baby,
and he's a whiner and everything else,
and he has to have his sandwich at 930 every morning
and another one at 11.
And he said he's a little off today
because he missed his 11 o'clock sandwich.
And I'm sitting there thinking, oh, my god.
You know, I mean, my hand, what if it does this or that?
And he's got this meat cleaver, and he's going to do it.
It's not going to be a stuntman or a prop man.
It's not going to be somebody else with my hand,
because he wants to see his whole body and my whole body
and the slice.
So I'm like that, and I said, well,
maybe I should say something.
Don't go near him.
Just let him do what he's been told to do.
He said you might cut him off.
Oh, god.
So I sat there like this, and he came, and he whacked it.
And boy, he did it right.
But oh, my god.
And then on take two and three and four,
he let other people do it.
But, I mean, imagine if I'd have just
done like that or something.
Then it came time for the head.
When I first came to Hollywood in 1960, 61,
it was right at the end of where they were working the 5
and 1⁄2 day week.
You'd work Monday through Friday, and then Saturday
you'd work till lunchtime.
And then everybody'd go home.
The star, this was on movies, not on television.
The stars of the movies then on Saturday afternoon
would have an open house.
One night, Betty was going to do it on a Saturday.
So she invited everybody to her house, not the crew,
but all the cast, to her house at 6 o'clock
on a Saturday night for dinner, drinks and dinner.
So we all got there.
And she said, beyond time, anybody that's late
can't go to the party.
So nobody was late, even me.
And I'm notoriously fudge five minutes.
So no one was late.
So we get there, and we come into the house.
And we're in the house.
There's no drinks.
There's no sign of a party.
There's nothing in the backyard.
And there's, I think, 28 of us, 14,
and each one had a partner.
So there were 28, counting her and her son.
And she claps her hands.
She says, can everybody hear me?
Yes.
OK.
Out in the driveway.
We go out in the driveway, and here's this big school bus.
We all get on the school bus.
Nobody knows what's going on or where we're going.
And the back of the school bus is an open bar.
So the school bus took us up to Yamashura Restaurant,
which just overlooks the whole city.
And on the way, it was an open bar.
And that was the drinks, the cocktail time.
Now we walk into the restaurant, and it's just us.
The whole restaurant is just for us.
And there's only 28 of us.
But we were like at separate little tables
that were all connected.
So everybody was together.
And it was just terrific.
And there were little prizes and little contests.
And during the course of the evening,
she called everybody out to do something
that she'd picked up on the set that they didn't like to do,
you know, something that embarrassed them.
And she'd say, this is your chance
to rectify your uncomfortable problem on the set
that I saw last week, Joe, meaning Joseph Cott.
You know, everybody always thought
that you didn't get the girl in the third man,
and that bothered you.
Well, it appears to be that every young girl
that walks on our set, you have to engage in conversation.
So we've brought three Eileen Ford models for you tonight.
And here come three models,
and they walk right over to Joseph Cott's table.
And she said, pick one, Joe,
and then shut the hell up for the rest of the evening.
She will be your date.
And he said, but my wife is my date.
And Betty says, oh, who knew?
And she would do that to everybody all through the night.
And I hadn't been called on, I hadn't been called on,
and I'm there with Miss Diane,
and I'm thinking, oh, my God, what has she seen me done?
I'm 28 years old,
and one day on the set,
and I don't know how she saw this,
I don't know what I was doing.
There were no cell phones then.
There was nothing that could distract you.
But I did something like this,
and I was disturbed by something,
or I don't know what it was I was thinking,
and I put my thumb in my mouth.
And she said, Bruce, now it's your turn.
You're going to stop sucking your thumb tonight.
How she saw it, I'll never know.
I hadn't done it in 20 years.
I don't know what it was,
but I had to suck my thumb in front of all these people.
And of course Miss Diane was just, she went nuts.
She just laughed, she absolutely couldn't believe it.
And I said, I don't know that I can do that.
And she said, you will do it,
or you will take your clothes off
and stand here the rest of the evening.
So I sucked my thumb for five seconds.
She said, I'll count to five.
Oh my God.
Anyway, that was the kind of evening.
Then we loaded back onto the bus
and went back to her house and dispersed.
And as we got ready to get off the bus,
everybody had had just a fabulous time.
She said, on Monday morning, I don't want to thank you,
I don't want to hear a word about it.
I don't, I just want you to understand,
this is the Hollywood I came to,
and I wish it would go on, but it won't.
And didn't say why, she just said, but it won't.
That's what Hush Hush Sweet Charlotte was about.
It was about the grandness of moviemaking.
In order to discuss Hush Hush Sweet Charlotte,
we must go back and discuss the original film,
which was Whatever Happened to Baby Jane,
where Joan Crawford and Betty Davis first worked together.
Both ladies were in their 50s.
It was a time where women didn't have facelifts.
It was a time where when you were over 35,
you were really basically over as a woman in this business.
One day, Betty showed me an ad
that she'd taken out in the trades.
I think it was in 59.
Just with a picture of her.
Didn't say her name, didn't say anything.
It just said, 5-time Academy Award nominee looking for work.
Can you imagine that?
But out of that came Baby Jane.
Robert Alder's career was just coming up,
and those ladies' careers were just coming down.
So I think, in a strange way, they both needed each other.
They all needed each other to make this thing work.
I was very surprised at some of the movies that Robert Aldrich made,
which just proved to me how diverse he was
and how his interests varied.
I mean, when you go from Hush, Hush, Sweet Charlotte,
working with those 2 powerful women at that time,
very powerful, even though they were waning in their careers,
it was towards the end of their careers,
they were still powerful, powerful women,
and he had to deal with these 2 women.
When Robert Aldrich approached Joan Crawford and Bette Davis
to do whatever happened to Baby Jane,
he was taking a chance because they were considered unbankable.
It was a risk, but nobody expected that risk to pay off in such a big way.
But Davis and Crawford were very cooperative at first
because they realized they weren't going to get this kind of offer again.
Not only did she have to look horrible to do this role,
but she had to also be on the set with Joan Crawford
and she had to deal with 2 big stars being together.
Her opinion, it wasn't going to surprise you,
is that she is the biggest star.
Bette Davis took the part because of Robert Aldrich
because he is that kind of very strong yet creative man, very strong.
Robert Aldrich was the boss on the set,
and she recognized it, and she recognized his talent.
There was really a tidal wave of acclaim for Baby Jane.
All in all, they were both extremely happy to be in the limelight again.
And for Davis to get the Academy Award nomination
was a very, very important thing.
They had been rivals through the studio system for so many years before that.
Each had their own Academy Awards.
I think that Miss Crawford felt, if you will, slighted
or they both should have been nominator,
whatever the situation was for that time.
And I think that could have been the core of when
the dynamics of their relationship changed.
I was at that Oscar Awards ceremony.
I can tell you that we went,
and that I think my mother felt that she was going to win.
I think she felt she had an excellent, wonderful performance.
And I think she felt a little bit that she deserved to win.
It would have been her third Oscar,
which at the time was more than anybody else had.
My mother was very competitive.
She wanted that third Oscar.
And all I can tell you is that she was extremely disappointed afterwards.
And not only disappointed in a way that, you know,
oh, this is, whoa, it was me.
She was angry.
Betty Davis was nominated for Best Actress for the Academy Award
for whatever happened to Baby Jane.
Joan Crawford wasn't nominated for anything.
So Joan, very crafty lady,
contacted the other four nominees for Best Actress
and said, if there's any chance that you won't be able to attend,
I'd be glad to accept for you.
Sure enough, Anne Bancroft, who was nominated for The Miracle Worker,
was busy doing a play, Mother Courage.
So she said, oh, I'd love to have Joan Crawford accept for me if I win.
Sure, Joan, thank you so much for offering.
They announced the winner is Anne Bancroft.
Joan Crawford struts down, supposedly stopping at Betty Davis,
saying, sorry, Betty, excuse me, I have an Oscar to accept.
That was the blow that Betty Davis never recovered from.
Nothing that happened during the making of Baby Jane,
as rancorous as it may have been,
stuck in her craw the way that evening did.
I thought Bob Aldrich ran Fox.
I mean, he just, he had the run of the place.
And he seemed to be, nobody messed with him.
Nobody messed with Robert Aldrich.
I mean, he was, and he did wonderful movies.
I mean, the great thing for me was, when I went to work for him,
I was not just honored that I got to work with Bob Aldrich,
but privileged because I loved two of his movies.
One, Vera Cruz, in which he had that great thing
between Lancaster and Gary Cooper, that great Western.
It was done really well.
And the other, which is one of my favorite all-time movies,
which is The Big Knife.
It was a real humanity to Robert Aldrich
that I find very many other places in my career.
My mother really enjoyed working with Robert Aldrich,
and I think that she respected his work greatly.
He loved making films. He loved telling stories.
When we got to Hush, I Sweet Charlotte,
it was an entirely different set.
It was fraught with problems from the very beginning.
After the success of whatever happened to Baby Jane,
it was inevitable that there would be a follow-up.
Henry Farrell, the writer,
drew up a synopsis of Hush, I Sweet Charlotte,
sent it to my father.
My father liked it, thought this could be quote-unquote a sequel,
even though it was really not a sequel,
and everybody assumed
Betty Davis and Joan Crawford would do this again.
So sure enough, they announced we're doing Hush, I Sweet Charlotte.
Once again, we're reteaming Betty Davis and Joan Crawford.
Robert Aldrich was brave.
He could have gotten someone else to be in the film
instead of trying to get Davis and Crawford again
and go through the same kind of fireworks
he'd gone through on the first film.
But really the winning combination would be the same actresses
because it was their hit.
Davis wanted so much money, and then Aldrich said,
well, I can't pay you that much.
Only a producer gets that much money
and that many percentage points.
She said, well, then I will be an associate producer
without credit.
But then of course it gave her leverage
to wreak havoc against Joan Crawford.
I don't know whether Joan Crawford liked my mother or not,
but I know that my mother didn't like Joan Crawford.
Robert Aldrich always had rehearsals.
He established early on in his career
that there would be a week-long prior-to-filming rehearsal.
Nobody was paid.
You were expected to be there.
Always the script supervisor,
which is myself and a dialogue coach,
and the cameraman.
And you would read the script over and over.
You would get your characters.
You would know who you are.
There were time for discussions.
You went to lunch together.
Day 3 or 4 you'd be on your feet
and you'd be walking in the real sets
and you'd get a sense of what was going to happen.
Everybody was expected to be right there.
Miss Davis knew what she was doing.
Others around her still had their little scripts with them
trying to get it,
but she came to that table the first day of rehearsal.
She knew exactly what she was doing,
every line, every movement.
When Joan Crawford flew to Louisiana
to film her location scenes in Hush, Hush, Sweet Charlotte,
from the minute she got there,
she realized that A, war was on,
and B, the odds were against her.
She got there, there was no one to meet at the airport.
Her lodgings had been messed up.
Davis had already made friends
with all the crew and the journalists,
and Crawford was really 5 steps behind.
But what really took the detole
was the constant undercutting that she was getting from Davis,
who legally could do it
because she was now an associate producer.
I think it had to do with their relationship with each other
and putting aside the fact that who was the bigger star.
I don't think that my mother really liked
the way that Joan Crawford did her business, if you will.
I don't think she liked the way she was on the set.
She didn't like the way she approached other people.
She was a big cleanliness person, I guess.
She had to wear gloves all the time.
She just didn't like the way she operated her life,
and I think you throw that in with the competitive nature
about who she was in her career
and who my mother was in her career,
and, you know, the competition,
I think that was sort of the overall idea.
But it was pretty clear that my mother
did not want to work with Joan Crawford.
Joan Crawford had been married to Alfred Steele,
who was the chairman of the board of Pepsi-Cola Corporation.
And he passed away in 59, and Crawford remained with the company,
so she had a vested interest in Pepsi.
Bette Davis made it a point never to be seen on the set
of either of these two films without a Coca-Cola bottle in her hand.
We had shot everything in Baton Rouge, Louisiana,
all the exteriors, which were filmed.
Crawford shot all the scenes required in Louisiana.
Then she came back to Los Angeles,
and she filmed scenes with Joseph Cotton,
scenes outside the mansion.
They got a lot done.
Joan Crawford finally succumbed
to the aura of hatred and hostility and viciousness.
She could have stayed and fought, but it would have probably killed her.
She came down with pneumonia,
ended up in Cedars-Lebanon Hospital.
Did she become ill? Don't know.
It's a ploy to get more money or to strike back at Davis.
On the other hand, as Aldridge said, and quite logically,
an insurance company is not going to pay on a faked illness.
Production shot down for 3 1⁄2 weeks,
and in that time, my father was given a list of women to replace her with.
And he went to Loretta Young and Barbara Stanwyck,
and both of them said no because Crawford had told them to say no.
So then he tried Vivian Lee.
Davis, who had lost Gone with the Wind to Vivian Lee,
was not happy about Vivian Lee,
but she took the upper hand and said,
I could almost stand to look at Joan Crawford at 6.30 in the morning.
I don't think I could stand to look at Betty Davis.
My father thought Olivia de Havilland would be the best for this.
She and Betty Davis had worked together in the system, were personal friends,
and he flew to Switzerland to talk Olivia de Havilland into doing this.
I think it took him 3 or 4 days.
But he had great charm, and she came back to do this film.
And we started shooting it again,
but there was not the luxury of going back to Baton Rouge.
And when Mr. Havilland took over,
it became the set just like Baby Jane again.
They were friends.
They respected each other as actors.
You could see it.
And yet it was the difference of the two ladies in their personal life.
Olivia de Havilland was refined.
And then there was Miss Davis, who was Charlotte.
It became a wonderful film to be part of at that time.
And they respected each other, as did all the actors on that film.