Magnus vs Hikaru Lie Detector Test

Chess Mastery
3 followers
9 Video Views·Sep 25, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedMagnus Carlsen and Hikaru Nakamura engage in a candid, lie-detector style interview. They discuss their professional rivalry, mutual respect, and personal opinions on each other's skills and personalities, touching upon specific tournament memories and the impact of content creation on the modern chess landscape.
Would you describe me as arrogant?
Do you think I'm overrated?
I'm going to start with a couple of profiling questions.
Yeah, of course.
What is your name?
My name is Hikaru Nakamura.
What is your name?
My name is Magnus Carlsen.
Do I ever lie?
Yes, sometimes.
Yeah.
You're giving me a great one.
Everybody lies.
Over to you, Magnus.
Have you ever suspected an opponent of cheating mid-game?
Mid-game?
No.
That's straight into a bit of a reaction there.
Maybe not mid-game, but you've suspected someone of cheating.
I think we all have.
Okay.
Before the start of a game or at the end of the game, yes.
First question, Magnus, is do you believe you're the greatest chess player of all time?
Yes.
I actually did a similar test earlier and I gave a different answer,
which I thought I believed,
and now I've kind of realized that maybe I was lying to myself.
100%.
Do you consider me your greatest rival when it comes to blitz chess?
Absolutely.
Yes.
Do you hold a grudge against me for anything?
Yes.
You're reacting.
You might have held a grudge at some point, but you don't anymore.
That is true.
I think specifically the Norway Blitz tournament back in 2009.
That really hurt me.
Ah, yeah.
The look of the pawn race.
Yeah.
One of them all.
But you've got over that now.
You've got over that.
So.
What do you think is my greatest weakness?
It's openings.
No, I think these days probably it's great.
Do you genuinely think I am your equal?
No.
Are you jealous of anything I have achieved?
Yes.
Probably the World Blitz Championships that you won.
That's the truth.
Do you think Fabiano is a better chess player than me?
Over the course of his career, yes.
You?
Yeah, I'm not sure.
The thing is, if you're talking about total volume of work,
then Hikaru is miles ahead.
But if you're talking about classical chess specifically,
then Fabiano has had a slightly better career.
Okay, that makes sense.
Do you think chess drama helped you become successful?
No.
That's inconclusive there.
You finally got an inclusive one.
I think there's something there.
It's in between.
Okay, which would make sense with what I'm saying.
You're not lying, but you're not telling the truth either.
Probably played a role, but I don't think it's the defining reason.
Do you think I'm overrated?
I'm doing the deep breath again.
Generally, no.
This is a good one.
Would you describe me as arrogant?
Yes.
Telling the truth.
I don't disagree.
Do you think you're overrated?
No.
Are you jealous of any other chess players?
Yes.
I'll just say.
A little bit jealous in some ways of Levy.
Gotham chess.
He's not a...
Well, there you go.
Now that's the...
Yes, there you go.
I actually like him a lot.
So, flip that.
Have you ever privately celebrated one of my losses?
Many times.
Yes.
Is there one game that comes to mind?
No, I would say it's more of a stream hate watch kind of thing.
Yeah, that's been many times.
My wife, when we first met, she was a bit mad that I would watch your streams.
Would you trade your streaming career for my chess career?
No.
100% no.
That is not surprising, I would say, to me.
But I think it could be surprising to others.
Which game between us are you most proud of?
It's hard to say.
The first one that came to my mind was, for some reason, from Romania in 2011.
With Winger White?
Yeah, like the Queen's Gambit.
Yeah, this is one a lot of chess fans have been thinking about.
Would you miss competing against me if I retired?
No.
You would definitely miss.
You've tested me there, haven't you?
Yeah, I was trying. I have to lie on something, otherwise there's no content.
You would definitely miss.
There's no content.
Definitely miss this man.
Would chess be less interesting without me?
Yeah.
Straight away.
Do you see yourself playing chess for the rest of your life?
No.
100% yes.
Let's say we're in 2040, and you're occasionally, you know, testing your strength.
You know you're pretty good. Would you consider playing?
It's a 50-50, so let's see how I answer this.
I'd say no.
I would consider playing.
What do you think is my greatest strength?
Understanding of structures.
Yeah, he believes that.
But I feel like kind of what sets you apart the most when I see you play,
people especially, that's not me, is finding the right structures and maneuvering.
Like, there's no contest to people like Fabiano, for instance.
I don't know why they added—I know why they added this one, but it just annoys me.
Do you think Gotham Chess will ever become a Grandmaster?
Yes.
You're not sure there, are you?
You're not sure on that one.
I'm trying to trick you. I can't just answer honestly to everything.
I know. That was quite a big no there.
Which loss against me still bothers you the most?
I think we're still coming back to 2009, that's for sure.
I mean, there are many others. Champions Chess Tour, the first season.
Roman Games, yeah.
Do you think you'll eventually fall off?
No.
There's a caveat to that. It's because I'll retire before that happens.
That's the caveat.
If I play until 60, I will fall off.
Do you believe I sacrificed chess achievements to become a content creator?
No, I think you balance them very well.
Have you ever let someone win on purpose?
Not that I can recall.
It might have happened when I was young, but not that I can recall.
Have I ever completely outplayed you in a game?
Many times.
I guess the first time in a classical game was 2010, I guess, Tata Steel.
In this Real Opus, you completely outplayed me and I managed to fight back.
London, that one time in the Scorch.
That's just classical. In Rapid and Blitz, it's been many, many times.
This is not in the script. This is what I wanted to ask.
If we're taking you back to the candidates this year
and pondering for 70 minutes against Sindarov,
were you mostly mad at yourself or your team
for the situation you had gotten yourself in?
During the game?
Yeah.
I was probably more annoyed at myself. Slightly more.
65-35.
I think you're taking one for the team there.
Does it annoy you that Levi Rosman constantly uses you for content?
Yeah. Yes, it does.
Would you consider me a friend? And let me just say, I hope not.
Depends on definitions. Now I would say yes.
First, like 75% of my career, the answer would be 100% no.
But now you have a healthy respect for each other.
There's no bad blood.
Are you jealous of my success outside competitive chess?
No. I know the answer to this.
Have you ever rooted against me in a chess tournament?
On many occasions, yes.
There's no good way to lie on that one.
Do you believe I've done more than you to popularize online chess?
Yeah.
Have you ever pretended a controversy didn't affect you when it actually did?
It's a question that's too hard to lie on. Obviously, yes.
There's no good way to lie on that one. I won't leave it at that.
I think we're done. And I think that was quite illuminating.
Any other questions that you might like to add while he's strapped up?
Did you think that I was going to play the World Championship in 2023?
Yes.
That's all the questions I have.
Well, I've got to say I enjoyed that a lot. I was kind of disappointed there wasn't more.
For more content like this, click here.
