China’s Fiscal Collapse: $100B Hole Cannot Be Filled, Civil Servants Go Unpaid, Mass Layoffs Begin

China Observer
822粉絲
Shenzhen, known as one of China’s wealthiest cities and a place where per-capita GDP has long surpassed Beijing, Shanghai, and Guangzhou, was once seen as a showcase and benchmark of China’s rapid economic growth. Now, the fact that even government employees there are struggling to get paid is hard to imagine.
Join this channel to get access to perks:
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCT2kPBcD6tXn8TP_aV7BmgA/join
#chinaobserver
All rights reserved.
⭐You can support us at: https://donorbox.org/china-observer-supporting-independent-news
⭐For business cooperation, please contact us: [email protected]
Some people still don't believe that even government employees can go unpaid.
Guys, I had dinner tonight with an old friend of mine who works in the Shenzhen government system.
He complained that he hasn't received a salary for two months.
I used to think that government jobs were highly desirable,
because everyone wanted that stability and a guaranteed income no matter what happened.
But now even those salaries are uncertain, and he's worried about layoffs.
The value of these jobs has dropped sharply.
Shenzhen, known as one of China's wealthiest cities and a place where per capita GDP has
long surpassed Beijing, Shanghai, and Guangzhou, was once seen as a showcase and benchmark of
China's rapid economic growth. Now, the fact that even government employees there
are struggling to get paid is hard to imagine. It's not just government workers. Even Bao'an
District, one of Shenzhen's wealthiest and most important districts, is reportedly
struggling to pay teachers' allowances. On social media, one teacher asked,
Where are we with the Shenzhen Bao'an's teaching allowance? Why hasn't it reached us yet?
Several teachers replied that they had been waiting for so long, they were almost going broke.
Shenzhen once built its reputation on using high salaries to attract talent. At one point,
it offered teachers annual salaries of 300,000 yuan, about 42,000 US dollars,
attracting many masters and PhD graduates from top universities such as Tsinghua University
and Peking University. Recruitment ads at the time boldly said,
Having some money, some free time, and dignity is no longer just a dream.
But within a few years, salaries began to fall. Bonuses and subsidies were cut one after another,
with annual pay dropping from 300,000 yuan to around 200,000 yuan, about 28,000 dollars.
Later, it was no longer just about cutting bonuses. Even basic allowances could not
be guaranteed. The fact that Bao'an district has now delayed even these allowances suggests
this may not simply be a matter of salary reductions, but that local finances are under
serious pressure. If even Shenzhen is struggling to maintain government salaries and basic teacher
allowances, what kind of challenges is the entire government system facing at the grassroots level?
What is the reality of the job situation now? Here, in county and district level public
institutions, monthly and quarterly performance bonuses haven't been paid for several months.
We're only receiving base salaries. Government employees are barely holding on. It seems there
may not even be enough money to pay salaries this month. What I'm saying is, this is happening
across government departments, and I work at a state-owned company. I also haven't received my
salary for two months. Government employees can't hold on anymore. They can't even get
their salaries. The so-called secure government job is almost falling apart. A few days ago,
a friend came to see me. He works at the Chengdu Water Resources Bureau, and he said his workplace
has even fallen behind on social security and housing fund payments. In other places,
salaries may be tight, but social security and housing funds are still paid on time,
yet their workplace can't even manage that. They tried resolving it for a long time but got nowhere.
A government agency like the Chengdu Water Resources Bureau,
reportedly struggling with basic social security and housing fund payments,
would have been unimaginable in the past. Social security and housing funds are almost
the biggest sources of security for government employees. If that safety net is broken,
it suggests serious problems with the government sector's credibility and cash flow.
More concerning is that similar problems are spreading across many cities at the grassroots
level. For grassroots government employees in Taizhou, it feels like the sky is falling.
Salaries have been cut every year. In the past, earning more than 10,000 yuan a month was easy.
Now, after paying into the housing fund, they are left with only 4,000 to 5,000 yuan.
They only dare to ride electric scooters to work. Their gasoline cars sit unused, covered in dust.
If managers or colleagues invite them out for dinner, they say food has already been prepared
at home and eating at home is healthier. But the truth is, they really can't afford it.
Government employees are really struggling now. In many cases,
employees are not paid on time and only receive their base salaries.
Performance pay is often withheld. Some places have even gone from guaranteeing 8 months and
aiming for 10 months of pay to guaranteeing 6 months and aiming for 8 months. That means they
can only insure 6 months of salary payments and hope to pay 8 months in total. Grassroots
employees are tightening their belts just to get by. Some people say government workers have good
benefits and receive many hidden benefits behind the scenes, but I would say only a small number
of senior officials have access to those benefits. Most grassroots employees rely on their salaries
to live frugally. Especially over the past two years, many government employees have
accumulated much higher debts than people might expect. In some even more extreme cases,
officials have reportedly come up with unusual solutions to hide the reality of financial
shortages. This is unbelievable. A few days ago, I was talking with a friend who became
a government employee in a county. Their department couldn't pay salaries. What was
solution from their leaders? The leaders helped arrange for several departments to take out bank
loans together to pay wages. Take out bank loans? My friend was stunned. He told me he never imagined
something like this could happen in his lifetime. The loan process was extremely smooth, and they
got the money right away. Because they are government employees, as long as nothing unexpected
happens, they can usually work until retirement, so the bank was very willing to lend them money.
After receiving the salary, he didn't know whether to laugh or to cry.
He always felt that the money didn't really belong to him.
Having government employees take personal bank loans to cover what should be their salaries is
a highly unusual situation. When government departments need to rely on an employee's
personal credit to maintain operations, questions arise about the sustainability of this approach.
Public institution employees, state-owned enterprise workers, and even doctors,
nurses, and teachers, who were once viewed as having secure careers,
are also experiencing increasing financial pressure. According to a report by NetEase News,
salary cuts and delayed payments in China's healthcare system have reportedly expanded
from isolated problems into broader difficulties. Many doctors have taken to the internet to
complain that they are no longer receiving their salaries. Based on comments from medical workers
in different regions, the situation is severe. In Sichuan Guangxi province and Inner Mongolia,
some doctors at public hospitals reportedly earn less than 3,000 yuan a month, about $420,
while working frequent night shifts. Some have gone months without pay, and one doctor said
they struggled to find 200 yuan, about $28, for the child's birthday. In more serious cases,
some hospitals in Henan, Shandong, and Hubei are owing wages for 10 to 20 months.
Some grassroots hospitals have even stopped paying social security and housing fund contributions for
five years, and face bankruptcy or asset salaries. Amid widespread financial distress,
a hospital delaying salaries for only two months is already considered a good workplace.
What's even more frightening than salary cuts is that hospitals have started laying off nurses.
Some time ago, I was talking with a friend, and she told me she was only taking home a
little over 1,000 yuan a month. I was shocked. I said, are you kidding me? Only 1,000 yuan?
Why don't you quit? Are you messing with me? She sent me a screenshot of her pay slip,
and I finally believed that she really was only getting a little over 1,000 yuan.
They have also stopped paying to the housing fund. They only pay the five social insurance
programs now. But the employee portion is deducted from their salaries. Whether the hospital is
According to this blogger, as hospitals' profitability declines,
nurses have become the easiest targets. First, hospitals delay performance bonuses to test the
waters. Then they cancel bonuses altogether and only pay base salaries of just over 1,000 yuan.
Some hospitals have even dismissed older nurses because they consider their labor costs higher
and their leave periods longer. The logic behind these decisions is driven by extremely cold
financial calculations. Older nurses who are about to be laid off are asked to train cheaper
new graduates. Once the newcomers become capable, the older employees are discarded.
Seeing this happen in a public healthcare system that has long promoted saving lives
and helping patients is deeply troubling. So why have hospitals ended up in this situation?
Insiders familiar with the situation explain that hospitals now have little profit margin
because drug prices cannot be marked up, examination fees have been reduced,
and medical insurance authorities strictly control reimbursements for each service.
The most serious problem is the widespread financial pressure on local governments,
which has led to a sharp decline in government funding and subsidies for public hospitals.
As a result, hospitals are facing increasing difficulties.
In Jinan, Shandong Province, non-government-employed teachers in Shizhong District
are facing the desperate situation of having to pay for work. July salaries were delayed until
September without being paid. Teachers not only had to cover their own transportation
and teaching material, but also faced impatient responses from school leaders
when asking about their unpaid wages. One teacher even wrote online,
I have no money to see a doctor. When I'm hungry, I have nothing to eat.
In the central district of a provincial capital city,
teachers responsible for educating children have been pushed into such a situation.
Behind this is not only a major disruption caused by the decline of the population divided in China's
educational system, but also the result of growing pressure on local government finances.
If healthcare and education are already facing such difficulties, state-owned enterprises and
central state-owned enterprises, once considered financially powerful,
have also become major areas for salary cuts and layoffs.
Hey everyone, stop believing there is still such a thing as a secure job.
I've worked at a state-owned enterprise for 11 years, and now I'm about to be fired.
The secure jobs at state-owned and central state-owned enterprises that older generations
believed in are starting to rust. Ever since I was young, my parents planned everything for me.
What major to study, what school to attend, what organization to join,
and which job I could keep until retirement because they said no one could fire me.
But a few days ago, I received reliable information from a former colleague at a state-owned
enterprise. They said layoffs are about to begin, with 6,000 positions affected.
First, outsourced workers will be removed. Their newly graduated employees will be targeted.
It's easy to imagine that even permanent staff will eventually be screened out step by step.
Now, I'm actually grateful that I left a few years ago.
Otherwise, I would still be worrying about layoffs today.
I then called my classmates. Many of them work at central state-owned enterprises,
and many of their companies are also cutting jobs.
This is unbelievable. A state-owned construction company can actually go bankrupt?
All domestic projects are being transferred to another subsidiary under the group.
And they have already delayed my salary for an entire year. A whole year without pay.
I'm 25 years old, and even if you count everything, I've only worked for three years.
They owe me one full year of salary. Can you imagine that?
As one of the former engines of China's economy,
state-owned construction companies are experiencing severe contraction.
Projects are declining, salaries are being delayed, and young workers see little room
for career advancement. Even professional certifications have lost their value.
The end of an era of massive infrastructure investment has directly pushed many state-owned
companies dependent on construction projects towards decline.
I had lunch with a client from a state-owned enterprise.
He told me their salaries are now only a little over 3,000 yuan a month.
I said, did you accidentally join a fake state-owned company? Or are you a labor dispatch worker?
How could a state-owned enterprise employee only make a little over 3,000 yuan?
He said, it's absolutely true. Our salaries are only a little over 3,000 yuan now.
I said, I've worked as a loan broker in Nanning for at least three years,
and I've seen hundreds of housing fund and tax records.
Even lower paid workers normally take 5,000 to 6,000 yuan a month.
Better paid ones make 7,000 to 8,000 yuan, and some even earn over 10,000.
So hearing that you only make a little over 3,000 yuan really surprised me.
He said, that's the reality. Salary cuts have already started.
Some people's pay has been reduced by 40% or even 50%.
And only official employees are eligible for these salary cuts.
They call it reducing the income gap.
My salary has been cut. I really want to cry. Do you know how much it dropped?
I thought the cut would be at most 1,000 or 2,000 yuan.
But this time it dropped by 3,000 yuan. And including previous cuts,
I've lost a total of 3,900 yuan. Do you know what 3,900 yuan means?
In Xi'an, where salaries of 3,500 yuan are everywhere,
it's still 400 yuan more than many people earn.
3,900 yuan could be my mother's salary for two months,
my rent for five months, or my living expenses for four months.
But I have no choice, friends. What else can I do?
As employees within the government system struggle in despair,
a serious question is now facing many people.
China is such a large country and collects so much tax revenue.
Why has it reached the point where it cannot even pay the salaries of government employees?
First, let's look at the latest financial report from China's Ministry of Finance.
These reports reveal not only declining fiscal revenue,
but also the collapse of China's core economic model over the past two decades,
the land finance model. Data from the first eight months of this year
shows that three major taxes closely linked to real estate and land all declined.
D-tax revenue fell by 42.7 billion yuan, about 6 billion dollars.
Land value-added tax revenue dropped by 40.5 billion yuan.
Farmland occupation tax revenue declined by 4.2 billion yuan, about 590 million dollars.
But the combined loss of 87.4 billion yuan,
about 12.3 billion dollars, is only a small part of the problem.
The real issue is the lifeline of local governments,
revenue from state-owned land use rights transfers.
In just the first eight months, land sale revenue plunged 28.6 percent,
a loss of 551 billion yuan, about 77 billion dollars.
Adding the losses from land sales and related taxes,
even after accounting for slight increases in property taxes in other areas,
China's land-related fiscal losses still reached 610.8 billion yuan.
This is a massive financial hole for local governments.
In local government fund accounts, land sale revenue once accounted for the overwhelming
majority, reaching 76 percent. Apart from selling land,
local governments have few other major resources of income.
When the main source of land sale revenue collapses,
the entire industrial chain dependent on land finance begins to stall.
From local government financing platforms, to construction contractors,
to the lowest-level migrant workers, everyone is suffering from the broken chain.
The lives of migrant workers are very difficult.
Five years. Five years.
We worked and sweated here behind me.
More than 500,000 yuan.
When will we ever get our money back?
Migrant workers being unable to recover their hard-earned wages for five years,
and state-owned construction companies being unable to pay salaries,
are fundamentally linked to the drying up of local government finances.
More frighteningly, this is not just a temporary downturn,
but a death spiral that is difficult to escape.
The previous positive cycle of land finance was,
the government acquired land, sold it to developers for profit,
used the money to build roads, install utilities, and prepare more land,
causing land prices to rise and allowing land to be sold at even higher prices.
Now land is difficult to sell, and falling land revenue means local governments cannot
even afford the upfront costs of land development and demolition.
As a result, spending related to land transfers fell 18.5% year-over-year this year.
The harder it becomes to sell land, the less money there is to prepare new land.
Without new land to sell, future revenue becomes even smaller.
This creates a self-reinforcing downward spiral.
As the myth of land finance collapses, as the 600 billion yuan plus,
about 84 billion plus fiscal gap continues to widen,
and as every possible expense is cut to the minimum,
the large number of employees within the government system will inevitably become the next target.
From teachers in Shenzhen to government employees in Chengdu,
from older nurses pushed out of hospitals to state-owned enterprise workers
forced to accept salary cuts, they are among the first groups affected
as this massive system faces financial pressure.
In the foreseeable future, this difficult period is unlikely to end quickly.
Instead, more and more so-called secure jobs
may continue to face pressure from economic realities.
