Forget good ideas: consider the consequences. So argues economist-academic Thomas Sowell, a maverick who challenged popular ideas like affirmative action and the minimum wage. This final episode of Economic Game Changers tells Sowell’s unlikely story—how a high school dropout born in the Jim Crow South became a renowned voice on economics, race, and history. Introduce your teens to an American treasure, a prolific author who changed how we think about decisions, incentives, and the consequences of ideas.
On January 4th, 1965, at his State of the Union address, President Lyndon B. Johnson
proclaimed his vision of a great society.
We want to grow and build and create, but we want progress to be the servant and not
the master of man.
Just like President Roosevelt's New Deal more than 30 years earlier, what followed
was a massive expansion of government into every corner of society and a so-called War
on Poverty.
Johnson created a long list of new government programs with the intention of achieving favorable
economic and social outcomes on a grand scale.
First a food stamp program attempting to fight hunger, then Medicare, a program to give health
insurance for senior citizens, then education programs to fund public and private schools
and scholarships for students.
There were also programs for job training, civil rights administration, environmental
protection, transportation development, and even public broadcasting.
And on and on.
But there's no such thing as a free lunch.
And the Great Society programs came at a massive cost, with the federal budget more than doubling
between 1965 and 1975.
This contributed to the stagflation crisis of the 1970s, characterized by high inflation
and unemployment.
Even with this high cost, however, many applauded the government's noble intentions.
But a few didn't, including one uncompromising professor, Thomas Sowell.
That was the intention, but did those programs really end poverty or raise wages?
Intentions are one thing, but facts and outcomes are something else.
Sowell long defied expectations.
Growing up poor and fatherless in the South during the Great Depression, he found new
academic opportunities after moving to New York City.
He dropped out of high school at 16 to work, but he eventually graduated from Harvard with
honors.
Later, Sowell studied under Milton Friedman, an outspoken free market advocate at the University
of Chicago, but remained an avowed Marxist and a proponent of government intervention.
Yes, yes, it's true.
Marxism once seemed to explain the world around me.
However, the rigors of studying under Friedman taught him to examine all the facts and support
his arguments with evidence.
So, when Sowell landed a summer internship in 1960 at a federal agency that administers
and studies the minimum wage...
Sir, I need some data to determine whether the minimum wage affected employment levels
in Puerto Rico's sugar fields.
Ssss.
But we need some evidence to show whether the minimum wage hurt or helped workers.
Hush, you'll ruin us all.
It was here that he realized that government institutions pursued their own interests,
namely their jobs, rather than the interests of the people they claimed to be serving.
This experience led Sowell to abandon his Marxist perspective and his belief in government
intervention.
Rather than noble intentions, he now judged government policies like the minimum wage
by their outcomes.
Higher wages equal higher pay for workers.
Not necessarily.
The minimum wage sounds helpful, but there's a trade-off.
By artificially raising wages, minimum wage laws makes those same workers more expensive
to employ.
What?
And employers less likely to hire or promote them.
So you want people not to be paid their fair share?
It's not a matter of what I want.
It's a matter of outcome.
The outcome is that fewer workers will be hired, especially low-skilled and young people
who need experience.
Seriously?
Sowell's focus on outcomes framed his perspective on another popular government policy that
emerged from the Great Society.
Affirmative action.
This policy was intended to pressure colleges to admit more Black and minority students,
even if they didn't meet academic standards.
As a Black professor, Sowell shocked people by arguing against the policy.
He believed it was important to look beyond immediate outcomes or moral intentions and
judge a policy over time.
Students on affirmative action tend to struggle or drop out entirely because they are mismatched
academically.
As a result, they often become discouraged and less likely to develop the skills they
might have acquired had they succeeded at a lower-level college or pursued a more appropriate
path entirely.
Sowell followed the outcomes of affirmative action to an ironic conclusion.
A policy designed to reduce poverty might result in the opposite effect due to the disincentives
it creates.
If you lower the bar for people, you create an obvious disincentive.
People don't need to work as hard to develop marketable skills, and those skills really
matter for successful economic outcomes.
There is simply no way around it.
In 1980, Sowell joined the Hoover Institution, continuing to challenge anyone speaking the
language of good intentions.
How much will this cost?
What are the tradeoffs?
What outcomes will this create?
If you really care about the people you claim this will help, then show me the data.
Sowell gained notoriety for his TV appearances, including on Milton Friedman's Free to Choose.
Whether in print or on screen, he was always advocating for free market policies guided
by facts, incentives, and outcomes.
For centuries, people everywhere have survived, innovated, and helped each other with no government
helping them.
What makes government elites think they should step in and do the work for them?
Today, Thomas Sowell has more than 40 books to his name, addressing economics, education,
race, and policy.
He is a shining example of someone who defies public pressure to overlook facts and consider
only intentions.
He continues to shape how people think about decisions, the incentives those decisions
create, and their ultimate consequences.
And thus ends our journey through the game changers of economic history, which began
with Adam Smith.
We saw a glimpse into a few of the incredible minds that gave us the language of money,
trade, and value, which has reverberated throughout history and continues to do so today.
Who knows what great thinkers will shape the next century of economic thought?
It could be you.
Until next time.