#trump#iran#isreal NewsNation correspondent-at-large Geraldo Rivera and “Batya!” host Batya Ungar-Sargon join “Elizabeth Vargas Reports” to discuss President Donald Trump's address to the U.N. General Assembly on Tuesday, where he made remarks on the war in Iran. They also address recent interactions between Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani.
Video Summary
AI Generated
A political panel featuring Geraldo Rivera and Bhatia Angarsargon discusses the diplomatic tensions surrounding Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, the humanitarian crisis in Gaza, and the provocative rhetoric used by Donald Trump regarding Iran. The conversation balances support for Israel's right to self-defense with criticism of its military excesses and diplomatic approach.
Joining in our political panel now, Geraldo Rivero is a News Nation correspondent at large
and Bhatia Angarsargon is the host of Bhatia right here on News Nation and she's the author
of a new book, The Jews and the Left.
Great to have both of you here.
All right, Bhatia, I'll give you the first shot here to react to the ambassador's interview
and Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu calling out Mayor Mamdani ahead of his visit here
to New York City and the United Nations.
So first of all, Elizabeth, wonderful interview, of course.
You pushed him on all of the right beats.
I was so happy that you brought up settler violence and also happy to hear him condemn
it, which I think is extremely important.
I think it's kind of embarrassing for Benjamin Netanyahu to be obsessing over Mayor Mamdani,
the mayor of a city in the United States.
It seems to me like this is kind of, should be beneath his notice.
I know that Mamdani has made these ridiculous claims that he's going to arrest Bibi.
He doesn't have the authority to do it.
And so for Netanyahu to act like he is a worthy foe, I think is a little bit embarrassing,
I have to say.
It elevates Mamdani, in other words.
Absolutely.
Geraldo, do you agree?
Well just on the point of the mayor, Bhatia's point of the mayor, look how different it
was when he was with President Trump.
Two guys got along.
They spoke about issues.
You couldn't be more different than those two.
And yet they were civil.
And they were political, but they were appropriate.
I thought the ambassador was embarrassing just now.
I think that he went way over the top with his histrionics and his selective view of
what's been happening.
I mean, we Zionists here have been forced to defend Israel.
The excesses.
Of course, October 7th was a gut punch.
But then since then, tens of thousands, literally tens of thousands of Palestinians have been
killed, including thousands and thousands of children.
And we have to recognize what our beloved Israel has done in its self-defense.
And in terms of the West Bank, his glossing over settler violence there, that was not
nearly condemning enough for what is happening there to the endearment of Jews everywhere.
Right.
And why isn't the IDF doing more to stop that violence?
Yes.
Good point.
And why isn't the IDF doing more to stop that violence?
Why doesn't Bibi Netanyahu take this passion that he demonstrated when condemning the mayor
of New York and direct it against some of the settlers who are embarrassing Israel on
the world stage, humiliating us and forcing us to defend the indefensible?
This stuff doesn't fly anymore.
Israel's going to find the world, they're going to lose friends, whatever friends they
have, they have to recognize excesses where it has been excesses.
I've covered the wars since Yom Kippur, my first or second foreign assignment.
I've seen it.
I understand the struggle and the fight and the underdog.
You're fighting against the mass forces of the Arab world and terrorism and all the rest
of it.
I understand it.
I cherish Israel for that, for its courage.
But my God, you've got to face facts.
You've got to face facts.
There's a reason for all of the young people, Jewish young people, saying to Israel, what
the hell?
That's where all this genocide rhetoric and bullshit comes from.
You're excused.
Batia, I'll give you a chance to respond.
I so appreciate where Geraldo is coming from.
The only thing I disagree with is that this is where the genocide rhetoric is happening.
The one thing that the ambassador said that is totally true is that the accusations of
genocide started on October 8th, three weeks before the Israeli invasion.
We now know that there were 73 around casualties of the war in Gaza, and a third of them were
military-aged men.
So the ratio of combatant to civilian was two to one, which is unheard of, unheard of
in urban warfare and in modern warfare.
The idea that this is a genocide, I do think that that is an anti-Semitic canard, but much
of the rest of what Geraldo said, I totally agree with.
No, two things can be true.
Absolutely.
Two things can be true, and I think you both have pointed that out.
It matters because Israel finds itself increasingly, as Geraldo rightly pointed out, and actually
you did too, Batia, increasingly isolated on the world stage, and that is going to matter.
When you are losing support from all the other countries and support from a whole generation
of Americans who are turning against you, maybe they're being poisoned on social media
by a bunch of BS, as Geraldo just put it.
Or as you just said, Batia, a quick reflexive, oh, they're committing genocide before they've
even done anything in response to the October 7th attacks.
But I did want to ask you about the Iran war, because the president talked, it was quite
something.
We have heard him talk about on social media and even on camera here in the United States,
should I or shouldn't I annihilate Iran?
It was another thing entirely to stand in the well of the United Nations in front of
delegations from Iran and all these world leaders and say, I might completely obliterate
this entire civilization.
I wanted to get your reaction, each of you, to that.
Batia, you start.
You know, I think it's very clear that Trump meant the Iranian regime.
He didn't say the Iranian regime, but every time he's used this maximalist language, he
has later clarified.
And I think it's obvious he doesn't mean he's going to wipe out 90 million innocent civilians.
He means obliterate the regime.
And I think the whole point was that the delegation was sitting right there to hear this tough
talk.
It would have been helpful to be a little more surgical with your language then, because
when you're saying you're going to wipe out an entire civilization, you're not saying
the guys in the bunker who are calling the shots and ruining everything.
Geraldo, your take.
I thought that he had, you know, that was very unfortunate, the annihilate stuff, all
that, that you call it maximalist language, it's, you know, that just end of the world
kind of stuff.
It's preposterous.
It's a caricature.
It's a comical.
And he doesn't mean to be funny.
It's pathetic.
It's beneath him.
And it was so unnecessary.
You know, it was a good time there.
To be presidential.
He had them right there.
And he had the most reasonable seeming Iranians there, the, you know, the civilian leaders.
Yeah, the foreign minister.
Not the IRG.
Yeah.
And that was the time to reach out and say, we have our differences, but here in this
hall where we extol the virtue of nations working together, this is now, you know, start
the process of disengagement because we got to get out of this war.
Yeah.
It's seven months and counting.
It's a.
Where do we go from here?
Well, I will say that the president might have said that in a speech, but he did say
afterward that the meeting went well.
There are more meetings taking place with any luck, a three hour meeting today with
the foreign prime minister.
With any luck, something will happen.
We shall see.
Everybody, everybody wants to see an end to this war.
Geraldo Rivera to end both wars, by the way, not just the war in Iran, the war in Ukraine
as well.
Geraldo Rivera, Bhatia Angarsargon.
Great to talk to you both.
And of course, be sure to watch Bhatia on Saturdays at 7 p.m. Eastern, right here on
NewsNation.