Herodotus and India - Scylax of Caryanda Sails the Indus River, Gold-digging Ants and Other Tales

The Ancient Beliefs
23 followers
16 Video Views·Sep 23, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video explores the accounts of India found in Herodotus' \"Histories,\" the earliest preserved Greek records of the region. Since Herodotus never visited India, his descriptions rely on second-hand reports and the voyage of Skylax of Karyanda, blending historical observations of diversity and resources with legendary tales of gold-digging ants.
Lately, I've been reading a lot from Herodotus' monumental work,
Histories, and while going through it, I came across his fascinating stories of India,
and thought I'd share some of them with you today.
Now, it should be noted that Herodotus never went to India.
In fact, everything he heard and learned about the lands encompassing the Indus river
and beyond were relayed to him by others.
While it is possible that some Greeks from the pre-classical period,
such as traders, may have heard tales about the Indian subcontinent from their counterparts
in the Levant and Babylonia, this can't be proven with the few sources that we have.
Thus, Herodotus' Histories contains the earliest preserved account of India from antiquity and the
only information that the Greeks of the late 5th, early 4th centuries would have had about that
country and its people until the arrival of Alexander III of Macedon, better known as Alexander
the Great, about a century later. It turns out that there was one Greek speaker who may have had
first-hand knowledge of the Indian subcontinent a few decades before Herodotus, a certain
Carian Greek named Skylax of Karyanda, who explored the Indus region on behalf of the
Achaemenid Persian king, Darius I. According to Herodotus, Darius sent a group of explorers,
led by Skylax, to find the mouth of the Indus river. They're said to have explored the river
and finally reached the sea, in this case the Arabian sea, after which they then turned to the
west. In the words of Herodotus, Darius, desiring to know where this Indus empties into the sea,
sent ships manned by Skylax, a man of Karyanda, and others whose word he trusted.
These set out from the city of Kaspatirosa and the Patyikan country and sailed down the river
toward the east and the sunrise until they came to the sea. And voyaging over the sea westward,
they came in the 30th month. After this circumnavigation, Darius subjugated the
and made use of this sea. Thus it was discovered that Asia, except the parts toward the rising sun,
was in other respects like Libya. Assuming that such a trip did indeed occur,
this passage has puzzled scholars for several reasons. One is that there's no reference to a
city called Kaspatirosa or a country called Patyikan in any known text, so we don't know
from exactly where the voyage may have started. Adding to the puzzle is that Herodotus clearly
states that Skylax sailed east. However, the Indus flows southwest towards the Arabian Sea.
It's possible that Skylax sailed east along one of the Indus' western tributaries,
such as the Kabul river, before actually reaching the waters of the Indus itself.
Skylax is also known to have written a memoir of his travels called Periplus, meaning
circumnavigation. Though the original text is lost to us today, we know that it once existed
due to it being mentioned in the works of later historians and geographers such as Strabo.
But just like that of Herodotus, these accounts lack any concrete details.
The Indian subcontinent is today known for its great diversity. It's an area of the world
full of different peoples with various lifestyles, who speak a plethora of languages,
practice different religions, eat all types of food, and much more. According to Herodotus,
the India of his day was pretty much the same. He tells us,
There are many nations in India, and they do not all speak the same language.
Some of them are nomads, others are not.
It was not India's diversity that made it valuable to Darius and the Persians,
but its gold. The lands of the Indus river and beyond were apparently full of it. However,
the way that it was acquired was quite different than in other places, as Herodotus explains.
There are other Indians who live around the borders of the city of Kaspatiros and the
territory of Patyike, beyond the other Indians and toward the north. Their manner of life closely
resembles that of the Bactrians. These are the most warlike of the Indians, and they are also
the ones who go out to gather the gold, traveling to a region that is uninhabitable due to the sand.
Now in this desert of sand live huge ants, smaller than dogs, but larger than boxes.
Some of these ants were captured and brought to the Persian court.
The ants in India make their dwellings underground by mounding up the sand,
just as ants do in Hellas, and they also look very much the same. But here,
the mounded sand contains gold, so the Indians set out to collect this sand.
To his credit, Herodotus makes it known that he's highly skeptical of this story.
Some today though believe that there may have been some truth to it,
though the creatures in question may not have been gold-digging ants,
but the Himalayan marmot of Kashmir. Parts of the area which it inhabits may have had
significant amounts of gold dust in the soil during Herodotus' day, which would have been
dug up as the marmots burrowed into the earth. That's one explanation. Along with gold,
Herodotus also describes what we now know to have been cotton. In addition, gold is present
in immense quantities, some of it mined, some washed down by the river, and some plundered
from ants, as I have related. Moreover, there are trees in India which grow wild and produce
crops of wool which surpass sheep's wool in beauty. Indians actually wear clothing
made from wool harvested from these trees. That's just a little bit about what Herodotus
had to say with regard to India. Of course, Alexander's arrival and exploration of some
of these same regions confirmed or rejected many of Herodotus' claims, and opened up India
to the influences of Hellenism, something that I hope to cover in the future.
That's all for now. Thanks for watching. I'd also really like to thank the channel's patrons
for making videos like this possible. These include but are certainly not limited to
me. Check out the benefits to being a Patreon member, and if you'd like to join,
feel free to click the link in the video description. You can also follow History
with Sai on Instagram, Facebook, and Twitter, as well as continue to listen to special audio
programs on the History with Sai podcast. Thanks again, and stay safe.
