Matt Harry has been writing since he was 10 years old. He learned to make movies at the University of Southern California, which was the closest he could get to attending Hogwarts in the real world. He has worked as an editor, screenwriter, director, producer, college professor, and pizza delivery technician. Matt has published six novels, written two immersive plays, and sold a TV pilot. He lives in Los Angeles with his wife and two sons, all of whom (thankfully) like to read.
The speaker explores the complexities of the screenwriting industry, distinguishing between the temporary \"optioning\" of a script and the commitment of full production. He emphasizes that passion and persistence are essential for overcoming development hurdles and encourages creators to define success through the joy of storytelling rather than purely financial gain.
What do you think the difference is between getting a screenplay optioned and getting it made?
Hmm.
So the difference between having a screenplay optioned and it getting made could be a very, very long gap.
It could be a long journey between those.
Optioning basically is just someone saying, oftentimes a producer, could be a director or an actor,
saying, I like this idea.
I want to take it out and see if we can get the money to make it.
Or maybe they want to rewrite it with you before they take it out wide to everybody in the town.
And then getting it made is really a different thing.
You really are getting people to commit their time, oftentimes years, to make something.
And I think that's the hardest thing in this business.
I think the reason it's so hard to get so many things made is because people are terrified about how they're going to spend their time.
That's the most finite resource.
Money, too.
But time is like, you know, you're asking when you take out a screenplay to a producer or an actor or director or crew,
you're going to set aside this amount of time in your life to work on this thing.
And it could be quite long, especially for a director.
And you are going to miss out on other things in that time.
Is this the kind of thing you're willing to miss out on other stuff?
Is this big enough?
And I think, as a writer, that's why I think your passion for the story is so important.
Because everyone else is like, you have this flame you're holding, and you're passing on this flame to other people.
And if your flame is not a giant bonfire, your flame is going to snuff out, right?
So you need to almost come in with this giant bonfire of excitement, and everyone else, you're lighting their torches to kind of carry on into this darkness.
I'm really pushing this metaphor.
I like it.
You know, the next year, two years, 10 years sometimes on these movies,
and they are going to have to each nurture all their own flames that came from your original flame.
So that, to me, is the difference between making something.
Optioning something is like, here, you can borrow this for a little bit.
I'm going to see if I like it or not.
It's kind of like dating versus marriage.
Option is like dating.
Agreeing to make something is like, OK, we're getting married now.
We're going to be together on this for a long time.
And it is a co-shared thing.
It's almost like having a kid with somebody.
You know, there's projects I've worked on where you spent years on it, and then it goes out into the world, and it exists, and it'll come up years later.
It's like, I still have that co-ownership, you know, almost like co-parenting with somebody over that project.
And, too, there will be changes.
There will be revisions, and there's going to be a need to, you know, collaborate, even though it might be your original work.
Yeah.
I have a script.
The first one that really started to get me some attention was 20 years ago, and that script still is kicking around.
Every couple of five years, like, someone will find it or get interested, and it's like, here we go again.
Like, we're starting, and it'll be optioned, and we're kind of like dating.
We're seeing if it's working out, and then it still hasn't been made.
So we haven't gotten to that place yet.
Like, it just hasn't been the right kind of combination of elements.
And so you have this on, like, one of these sites where people can...
That one, I think it might be on the blacklist.
It's just kind of, like, listed on the blacklist, I think, that one.
But it's just been one that, like, you know, sometimes I'll send it out as a sample still, because people like it.
And then when it gets sent out as a sample, someone sees it, and they're like, actually, maybe we would make this.
So, yeah, that's usually how it happens.
Or someone had read it.
Like, the most recent one was a couple years ago.
A director had read it 10 years beforehand and wanted to do it.
It's a very low-budget idea, which is why I think it's also attractive.
You could do it very low-budget.
It's like six actors in the desert.
And so he had remembered it and said, can I option this?
Because I think we could get this made, maybe.
And so we went through that whole process again.
So it's interesting how some ideas are like that.
You know, they're always there.
They don't die.
What causes a great idea to get stuck?
You know, kind of like a stale listing, which it never moves, you know?
Yeah, there definitely is a recency bias, I think, in Hollywood.
Every time I send a script out, I always do a new save, because I don't necessarily want people to know, like, it's 20 years old.
I think it's fine if it's 20 years old.
Like, it could still be made.
But it's like a weird alchemy.
I think if people knew the answer to this, by the way, they would be incredibly successful, because they would make things all the time.
But I think it's a real combination of timing, marketplace, kind of catching somebody at the right time.
Like, there's the famous story about Dallas Buyers Club with Matthew McConaughey, that that script was in development for 20 years.
And it had a bunch of money against it, like millions of dollars against it.
And then Matthew McConaughey read it and was like, I got to play this character.
I'll pay the money, like the millions of dollars that was owed against this movie.
Lord of the Rings was the same way.
It was in turnaround.
They shopped around to every studio, and Harvey Weinstein had put it in a turnaround.
And they took it to the one last place, New Line, and they're like, let's take a chance on it.
So you never know what the elements are that are going to kind of come together.
I think the most important one, the one you can control, is your passion for it, your excitement for it.
And if you're still excited by it, there's no reason it can't happen, you know.
What's the most success that you've had with one of your screenplays?
I'm trying to think of which one that would be.
It's interesting.
So the most successful screenplays, there's like three answers, I think, that I would say.
One is the one you get paid the most for.
Some people would look at success as money.
And so the one that I've been paid the most for was that book I was mentioning earlier, Sorcery for Beginners,
which I had as an idea for a movie.
I wrote it as a book, and then I optioned it and got hired to write it as a TV show.
So that's been the most successful thing I've written in terms of people buying the book and optioning it.
It's been optioned a couple of times now.
And that's the great thing about having a book.
Again, I tell all my students, if you've got an idea, write it down and publish it, because then you have a piece of IP.
And you can option that piece of IP multiple times, and you can get paid each time.
So financially, that's probably the most successful, is Sorcery for Beginners, that whole book series.
The very first script I was hired to write, I was paid a very small amount of money.
But mentally, that was really important, because someone actually paid me to write a script.
So that was a big hurdle in my mind that I'd overcome.
And then I think there's the whole personal creativity.
So there's a couple that are in my mind.
I just had a novel that was published called Ashland that I really liked the way it turned out.
I felt like it was the best encapsulation yet of my personal voice.
It's like science fiction, but it's funny, but it's also a detective story.
It's really like someone asked me, how did you develop the voice for the main character?
And I said, the voice is basically me.
It's just in a strange scenario.
And then the other one is a book I published last year called Time Travel for Beginners, which is in that same series, the Sorcery for Beginners series.
But I just had so much fun writing it.
I had so much fun entertaining myself as I was telling the story that those two, I think, I feel like are the most successful to me personally, like I'm most proud of.
So I think those are the three things I would say.
There's the financial success, but then there's the personal success of I really saw what this could be, and I feel like I reached it almost 100% completely.
I almost feel like that answer is a choose-your-own-adventure.
No, there's like three or four different doors I could go down if I'm entering your mind.
And it's cool, because I see that that really matters to you.
And it is a great vehicle for storytelling.
Yeah.
And again, I think it's helpful for people to think about, what do I see as success?
Like, ask yourself that question as you're getting started.
Because I think, and this is something else they told us at film school.
The first day of film school, they said, who here wants to make money?
And a couple hands went up in the air.
And they said, great, you should go be a pharmacist.
Because pharmacists, you only have to go to school for two years.
You graduate, you make six figures.
You will make tons of money as a pharmacist.
If you want to make movies, maybe the money will come.
Maybe it won't.
But you have to love making movies.
And that, I think, has been really true for me.
And I learned this really young, too.
I was very lucky.
Because I was sending short stories out when I was a teenager
to magazines and articles and stuff.
And I was getting rejected.
And I would get rejected.
And I would feel really depressed for like a month.
And I wouldn't write anything.
But then I'd always find my way back to writing.
And finally, I got a rejection letter.
And I realized, maybe I should give up.
And then I thought, I don't know if I want to do that.
And I said, what's the worst case scenario?
Worst case scenario is, nothing ever gets accepted anywhere.
I write for my whole life.
I stick them in a box in the attic.
And when I die, my kids were like, huh, dad was a writer?
I didn't know that.
And I thought about it.
And I was like, I'm okay with that.
If that is the worst case scenario, I would be happy doing that.
Because I just like doing it.
I just like sitting there in a coffee shop or even in my car
and just telling myself a story.
And I've been very lucky that that wasn't the worst case scenario.
I have published things.
Things have gotten made.
I've gotten to sit in audiences and watch like a packed, sold-out house
watch a movie that I wrote and produced, which is incredible.
But it was like once I had that thought, that acceptance,
when I was like, I was probably 21 or something,
it really took a lot of the stress away of like the whole,
should I do this, should I not do this?
I'm like, I'm just going to do it.
So now I need to figure out in my life,
how can I do that as much as possible?
How can I find a day job?
How can I do something else?
How can I figure out ways of getting money to do the things that I want to do?
And I've been able to do it so far in a way that's been pretty great.
I feel very lucky.
Not everyone can do that.
But I think that's a great thing everyone should ask themselves
is what is that success?
What does that look like?
What are you looking for?
And is this the best way to achieve it?
For me, it was like I want to tell stories to myself.
That was the most important thing, more so than like I want to make money.
I want to win awards and stuff like that.
That stuff's great.
I would love to do that too.
But that was the most important thing.
And then do you think that those goals change?
Like at 21, you wanted to be maybe the next Tarantino.
Nothing wrong with that.
But then it may be at another age,
it was just about more feeling gratified by the work.
Yeah, it's definitely a process.
Yeah, you're absolutely right.
When I was 21, I wanted to be famous.
I wanted to be well-known.
I wanted to be at that like upper echelon,
go to Cannes, travel the world, all that stuff.
And then you go through life and you start to interrogate to yourself,
what is really important?
Do I really want to be like on camera all the time?
Paparazzi was like, actually, no, that sounds terrible.
Like I actually feel bad for actors who can't go on vacation
and there's like cameras everywhere.
So I like a little bit of anonymity.
I do think you kind of grow into it.
But I also think that answer was always there for me.
Like the thing that I really like doing
is just telling myself stories.
So if I had, you know, again, kind of been
maybe a little bit more mature at a younger age,
I would have gotten to that answer sooner
because I think that that was always there for me mentally.
Can you explain what the optioning process is like as a writer?
Someone's agreeing to option your screenplay, you have a contract.
Yeah, so an option is basically an agreement,
a legal agreement that you are going to exclusively let somebody
borrow the rights to this thing.
They don't own the rights yet.
They're borrowing the rights for a certain amount of time.
And they're very negotiable.
It tends to be what I'm seeing right now recently
is it tends to be like 18 months to two years
is the length of time people want to option stuff for.
And it tends to be for very little money.
It depends.
So the nice thing about, again, having a piece of IP
like a book or a podcast is because it's an established thing
that has already a monetary value to it,
you generally get paid a certain amount.
And then what that amount is that you sell your options for,
that's now your baseline for stuff.
So I just had a producer option my books,
my Sorcerer's Beginners books again.
So it was a short legal contract. It's a couple of pages.
Basically says, like, you agree to let them take it out.
They can pitch it around.
They can show it to people for a set amount of time.
And then at a certain point, you can re-up the contract
or you can, you know, let it go and take it to somebody else.
So then by a certain date, it lapses
and those rights revert back to you.
Right. Yeah, you actually still own the rights.
That's the nice thing about having a piece of IP,
which a screenplay is a piece of intellectual property.
A book is an intellectual property, a podcast, whatever.
They're just borrowing the rights to take them around.
If someone was to actually buy them,
that's when you get a whole different negotiation,
a different contract about, like,
I'm now going to sell you the rights to this.
If it's a screenplay, you are actually selling ownership.
And this is a thing I always tell my screenplay students,
like, be careful when you sell your screenplay rights
because once you do that, they do own it
and they can do whatever they want with it.
The nice thing about having a different piece of IP,
like a book or a play,
is the author of that original work
owns the copyright always.
Okay, so it's not like a house where they're tying it up
and you can still option it to other people during that time?
Probably not. It depends on the contract.
Okay, I see.
So some contracts might say, we have exclusivity,
you can't show this to anybody else,
only we can show it to people.
Some are more open, like where you can say,
you can show this to other people.
And, like, if someone came in and made an offer on it,
you could consider that.
So it depends on the contract.
There's variations, okay.
Yeah, and I encourage people, I mean, like,
there's, like, a lot of writers I know who just sign it.
They don't read it. Read it.
Like, I have a lawyer.
So I've had, in this business,
I've had two literary agents, four managers, and one lawyer.
And I've had my lawyer for 15 years.
And I think the lawyer's the most important one
because the lawyer knows all that language, first of all,
and will read the whole contract.
But even my lawyer, there's times where we've had,
like, a contract, like when I optioned
the Sorcerer for Beginners books,
it was a 38-page contract, so it was extremely dense.
And I noticed some things there
that the lawyer didn't notice.
So you should read your contract
because it's your thing you're signing away.
Right, you know, you hear so many stories
of different things, whether it's an actor,
filmmaker, author, and somehow that contract
came down to deciding the fate of their life
in a lot of ways.
Yeah, so I always think it's great
taking a little extra time to really read through it,
understand what you're asking.
There's a lot of resources, again,
that you can reach out to.
There's a lot of stuff online.
So just make sure you know what you're signing.
Thank you for watching the video all the way to the end.
Here is a complimentary question
from our Book Story questions.