UN at a crossroads as world leaders gather for 81st General Assembly

Aljazeera
59 followers
103 Video Views·Sep 21, 2026
193 flags of member states flying side by side, each representing a sovereign nation,
a promise of diplomacy and a shared commitment to global peace.
Hello, I'm James Bayes, welcome to Al Jazeera's special coverage of the UN General Assembly
2026, live from the Rose Garden at UN headquarters in New York.
Today is September 21st, and that's the International Day of Peace. But as world
leaders prepare to gather in less than 24 hours from now, the irony could not be more stark.
We're at a critical inflection point, a world at war and the United Nations
at a crossroads. From the halls of the Security Council to the front lines,
the global multilateral system is being tested like never before.
And questions are being asked, can the international law still hold or are we
watching the rules-based order fracture in real time? To understand the sheer scale of the crisis
confronting world leaders this week, we've asked our correspondents reporting in six
active conflict zones to show us what that looks like. Here's Hani Mahmood in Gaza,
Nida Ibrahim in the occupied West Bank, Zaina Hoda in southern Lebanon, Sinem Kosaoulu in
Tehran, Audrey McAlpine in Kyiv, and al-Muqdad al-Ruaid in Sudan.
A graveyard for international humanitarian loss for the people living here in Gaza. Its failure
is written into its landscape, scarred by Israel's genocidal war, in the families shattered
by the loss of their loved ones, and in the minds of an entire people living with the consequences
of a conflict that has upended every aspect of their life. Here, the struggle to find food,
water, shelter, and medicine is real. Here, even under a UN-endorsed ceasefire,
Israeli attacks have continued. In the occupied West Bank, there is no official war,
yet it feels like a battlefield. In 2024, the UN General Assembly gave Israel 12 months to end its
unlawful presence. That deadline has long passed, and Israel's illegal occupation has become even
more entrenched. Israeli settler attacks have hit an all-time high, displacing at least 2,000
Palestinians this year alone. The UN can declare Israel's occupation unlawful,
but it has struggled to make that declaration change the reality for Palestinians living
under that occupation. And beyond Palestine, international law is being violated in Lebanon too.
UN peacekeepers have been here for nearly five decades to keep Israel and Hezbollah from
returning to war. But today, that buffer has collapsed. Israel has not just invaded
sovereign Lebanese territory, but it is actively occupying parts of the south,
deliberately razing entire border neighborhoods to the ground. A fragile U.S.-brokered ceasefire
is now in place, but people here ask the question, for how long?
Iran says it's a fight to preserve sovereignty and territorial integrity, even if it means a
long, grinding war with the U.S. Iran was attacked in what it describes as an unprovoked war,
but its Gulf neighbors also came under unprovoked Iranian attacks targeting civilian infrastructure
in countries that were not party to the conflict. A war between states that's now threatening
regional peace and global trade. And the impact of the war between Russia and Ukraine
is also being felt far beyond the battlefield. Expanding tit-for-tat attacks by Russia and
Ukraine are hitting ports and other critical infrastructure along the Black Sea, attacks
that threaten not just civilians, but global food supply, raising the stakes in what both Ukraine
and Russia have called an existential war. Here at this camp in Sudan's North Burdoufani state,
it's a fight for survival. People here feel abandoned by the wall,
caught in a power struggle between the paramilitary rabid support forces and the Sudanese
army, a country where U.N. investigators found evidence that bore hallmarks of genocide
in a fashion. The rules of conflict are clear. The question is whether anyone can or will
enforce them. Now, one of the most pressing questions facing the United Nations is whether
it's still fit for purpose for the millions caught up in conflicts around the world.
My colleague Folly Bartibo spoke to the U.N. Deputy Secretary General Amina Mohamed about the
challenges facing the institution and what it can realistically deliver at a time of deepening
global divisions. Deputy Secretary General Amina Mohamed, thank you so much for talking to Al
Jazeera. The theme of this year's General Assembly is restoring trust, but trust is restored by
results, right? So what do you say to a mother in Gaza who's waiting for aid, or a family in
Sudan, who basically says the world has abandoned us? Why should they still trust the United Nations
as an institution today? Because visibility and their voices are still very much on the agenda.
We may not solve the problem today, but there is hope that it could be solved tomorrow.
The fact that the Palestinian president may not be here in person, but he's there on screen and
his voice is loud and clear about what he stands for and what he wants to the people in Gaza.
Let me ask you about that, because you brought it up. The U.N. is meant to be
the world's universal diplomatic forum, right? But Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas has again
this year been denied a visa. Iran has a smaller delegation. So what is the Secretary General's
office doing, publicly and privately perhaps, to defend that principle that every member and
observer should be able to participate meaningfully here at the United Nations?
The Secretary General continues to reiterate that in every possible moment he has, whether it's in
front of the camera or outside of it. More importantly, he's looking for how we keep that
voice in the General Assembly, how we keep that voice where it should be heard. And today we're
fortunate that we can bring voices into our General Assembly that don't necessarily have to
be physical because the challenges are to the physical participation.
Some of the most consequential diplomacy in the last few years,
whether on Iran or Gaza, happened outside of the United Nations in small groups, bilateral channels,
ad hoc coalitions. The diplomacy is increasingly happening outside of this building. What are you
doing to make sure, what is the U.N. doing to make sure that it gets back into these
where high-stakes diplomacy is happening?
I think speaking more to member states that this is their responsibility, creating an
enabling environment that will allow that to happen. The reality is that the geopolitical
tensions that we see around the world don't make for agreement within certain halls. They are
trying it outside the halls, it is not working, and they are slowly coming back into the global
town hall that matters in the different spaces. Deputy Secretary General, you know this
institution better than anyone else. Your term comes to an end in December. You said publicly
you're not running. And so what should the next Secretary General do differently to
restore public confidence in the United Nations? I think the next Secretary General will be facing
a different era, and so I'm not sure it's differently. I think it's that they will
need to respond to the times, and the times require for us to build bridges. If we are
not bringing back our international family together in this town hall and finding the
solutions to the problems that we have. Well that job has been called one of the most influential
jobs in the world, and one of the most impossible. Antonio Guterres leaves the post of U.N. Secretary
General at the end of this year, and the race to replace him is underway. Whoever takes over
inherits an office with far less power than the title suggests. Gabriel Elizondo reports from New
York. Within weeks of shipping grinding to a halt in the Strait of Hormuz because of the war,
U.N. Secretary General Antonio Guterres set up a U.N.-led task force to try to facilitate opening
it. Five months later, that task force produced its first plan to kick-start opening the passageway,
but for it to have a chance, the countries fighting over it would have to agree, and they haven't.
We have everything ready to do it. Of course, it can only be done if the countries that are
involved in this conflict all agree to accept the mechanism. The U.N.'s inability to reopen
the strait illustrates the limits of the organization and who leads it. But it wasn't
always this way. In 1956, when Egypt blocked the Suez Canal, Secretary General Dag Hammarskjold
stepped in and worked through the U.N. General Assembly to deploy an emergency force that
reopened the canal five months later. Seventy years on, the space for that kind of executive
action has narrowed, constrained by a risk-averse institution combined with a more fractured
geopolitical order. The U.N. Charter defines the Secretary General as the organization's
chief administrative officer with the power of Article 99, the right to put any threat to
international peace he deems urgent in front of the Security Council for action. In 2023,
he invoked Article 99, telling the Council that Gaza was deteriorating into a catastrophe
with potentially irreversible implications. A ceasefire resolution followed within two days.
Thirteen of the 15 Council members voted for it. We regretfully could not support it.
The United States vetoed. The war continued. Guterres' term comes to an end this year,
after which his legacy will be written. But on the conflicts that defined his tenure – Gaza,
Sudan, Ukraine – the office could appeal, but could not compel.
Throughout history, the leaders of the United Nations have faced
the reality that one of their main powers is trying to convince warring parties to sit down
and talk, rather than solving the underlying issues that they are fighting over.
Gabriel Zando, Al Jazeera, United Nations in New York.
The UN has been led by men for more than 80 years, and after nine men this year,
there's a significant push to elect the first woman Secretary General.
Leading the charge, out of Latin America and the Caribbean, Guiana's Karen Rodriguez-Burkett
and Costa Rica's Rebecca Grinspan. They're joined by former UN General Assembly President
Maria Fernanda Espinosa and veteran diplomat Yvonne Baki, both from Ecuador.
The four women are facing a number of male contenders. There's the head of the UN Nuclear
Watchdog, Argentina's Rafael Grossi, and former Senegalese President Maki Sall,
as well as the Ugandan diplomat Olara Otuno.
Right, well, let's speak to one of the candidates who's joining us right now.
Ambassador Carolyn Rodriguez-Burkett, you are the ambassador of Guiana,
you were the foreign minister, you've done jobs in the UN before, you know the UN very well,
you even served on the Security Council recently. Given how beleaguered the UN is,
why on earth would you want this job?
Because I believe in the UN, and coming from a small state, we have to think global,
because the rules that are made globally will affect us, and adherence to those rules
are very, very important for us small states. But I think large and small states have recognised
that we all need the UN to bring peace and security, development and human rights.
You mentioned you come from a small country, it would be the smallest country to have ever
produced a secretary-general if you get the job. In your campaign, do you think that's an advantage
or a disadvantage? Because it's the Security Council and ultimately those very big powers,
the five permanent members that really hold the key to who gets the job.
Well, I come from a small country and a region of small countries, but we have proven time and again
that smallness doesn't mean that you do not have big ideas. And the beauty about the UN,
193 member states, we are all equal in the General Assembly. Yes, the Security Council
is structured differently, but we're all equal. And the fact that we sit here as an equal member
state, each member state should have the opportunity to offer someone for secretary-general.
Helicopter traffic with VIPs in New York at the moment is something we have to contend with.
The current secretary-general, some have said, has been risk adverse and has not wanted to get
involved as much as some would have liked in conflict mediation. Will you do things differently?
Sudan, the US versus Iran, Ukraine and Russia. Would you directly get involved in any of those
situations? Do you think the UN would even be welcome?
The secretary-general has to get involved. This is my view. I've sat on the Security Council,
as you've said, and I've seen times when there's space for the secretary-general,
there's always space for the secretary-general. There are large and small fires everywhere,
and the world is waiting to exhale, to hear good news that we've ended some conflicts,
that we've prevented some conflicts. And it is time that we, in the UN, rally everyone
to reassert the central role of the UN in ending conflicts.
Would you, though, be prepared to stand up to the big powers as well? Because your country
is in a region where the US is now saying it believes it's a sphere of influence. It wants
to play a preeminent role in that region. Is that really in the spirit of the United Nations
and the UN Charter? And are you prepared to stand up to those five permanent members?
The UN has always had geopolitical fissures. This is why this organization was formed,
though, for us to come together. And I don't want to see it as standing up to anyone,
or standing alongside anyone, but working together with everyone. And there are countries in the
United Nations that we must have a good relationship, a working relationship with.
And this is what I want to do as secretary-general. We have many countries now, as well,
in the mediation space, I want to work with them, to work with the P5. I've worked with
the P5 on the Security Council. And it's not every issue there is a division on,
even though I recognize that we have many, many challenges that sometimes we are unable to solve
because of some of these fissures. But a secretary-general does not have the luxury of not
trying. And I will try if I'm appointed. The current secretary-general, I sat down with him
interview that will be on Al Jazeera soon. He said one of the key problems was the system.
UN reform was needed. And so many countries around the world say there should be UN reform,
particularly of the Security Council. You hear that clamor coming from Africa for an African seat.
And yet nothing ever happens. Would this be a priority for you as secretary-general,
given the current secretary-general says it's probably the biggest problem in the whole system?
Well, there's reform of the Security Council on the one hand that is in the hands of the
member states. And the secretary-general role is limited to providing the support services
for that negotiation process. But the reform of the UN to deliver better, the secretary-general
has a central role to play there. And I believe that we're at this point now where all of the
member states have agreed that we must have reform. We have to use these next few years
to advance that reform. But it must not be reformed for reform's sake. It must be reformed
to deliver better for the people of the world. They want to see this. They want us to deliver
better. And this is what I would certainly focus on. But let me say this, that I have served as
the permanent representative representing CARICOM in Security Council reform.
Your regional group?
Our regional group. And I've heard two main messages in those negotiations. The issue of
expanded representation since the UN has moved from 51 to 193 member states since its formation.
And the issue of accountability. On the issue of representation, you're right. Latin America
and the Caribbean and Africa, they're not represented in the permanent category. And
this is one that is being called for. But also on the accountability side, the call is for that to
be better, especially now when it seems that we are in a flux in resolving the conflicts.
Ambassador, thank you very much for joining us. One of the candidates,
the very secretive UN Security Council process, three straw polls. That process continues.
Well, the world looks to the United Nations during moments of war and crisis and its ability to keep
the peace, protect civilians and deliver aid at scale. But that requires money and a lot of it.
Umar Khoslam Sharif takes a look at who funds the UN and who ultimately wields power.
The United Nations is funded by its member states. Each country pays according to its
economic capacity and population. There's minimum and maximum contribution, but no
country pays more than 22% of the regular budget of nearly $3.5 billion. The world's largest economy
is the United States and China contribute 22 and 20% respectively. But the UN has struggled
to get members to pay on time or at all, especially the US. Washington owes the UN nearly
$4 billion. China has also been late with payments in recent years. So what happens
when countries don't pay? Under the UN charter, a country can lose its General Assembly vote
if it doesn't pay for two years or more. But the UN's finances have also been complicated by a
decades-old rule requiring it to return unspent funds to member states each year based on the
full regular budget, even if those funds were never paid. That meant refunding phantom money,
draining its cash reserves. In June, the General Assembly voted to end their practice
on a four-year trial basis. But does paying the bills give you more power at the table?
The five permanent members of the Security Council, the US, China, Russia, France and the UK,
have veto power regardless of how much they contribute. But Germany and Japan contribute
more than some countries on the Security Council, but don't have veto rights. Many other UN programs
and humanitarian operations rely on voluntary contributions. That means,
while their nations can choose what to fund often based on their foreign policy priorities,
when the money dries up, the impact is felt on the front lines through cuts to food rations
and other aid in conflict or disaster zones. And while countries such as India and Rwanda supply
large numbers of peacekeepers, the UN has fallen behind on reaping them for those operations.
To survive, the UN has made historic spending cuts and tapped emergency reserves five times
in the past seven years, borrowing a record $607 million in 2024.
Well, Comfort Iroh is the president of the global think tank, the International
Crisis Group. She joins us. She's here in New York for the UN General Assembly.
Comfort, thank you for joining us. The state of the world right now,
this is the 16th UN General Assembly, I have to admit, that I've attended.
And every year, the situation gets worse. There is more and more conflict. Would you agree?
Absolutely. 65 and rising. It's a pretty existential moment. The United Nations,
whose principal mandate is about peace and security, finds itself at a moment where it
faces a tsunami of crisis. Every region that you can mention, from Latin America to Africa,
to Europe, to Asia, finds itself as a pivotal moment dealing with humanitarian and civilian
protection and refugees crossing various borders. So this is a pretty dire moment
for world leaders to be meeting this week in New York.
And what about the United Nations? I mean, how is it performing? Because
I increasingly hear from people who are not connected with diplomacy
that the UN is impotent and pretty irrelevant in their view.
Yeah, you know, the United Nations has become the whipping boy for all those who are frustrated,
especially when you look at the number of crises that we face. But I also think there's an
important role for the United Nations. It is still the universal body. It has still got the
largest infrastructure. It is still the only body that can provide and mount the kind of
humanitarian mission and operation that is required, whether it's in Gaza, whether it's
in Ukraine, whether it's in Sudan, whether it's in the Central Africa Republic as well.
So even without any other body, the United Nations still remains the universal body
that can provide the necessary framework, the necessary body to ensure that we get
delivery to the most important vulnerable communities that are affected by all the
conflicts that we see around the world. So what about the next secretary general?
What should they do different from Antonio Guterres? The argument from some is that he's
been pretty risk averse. Others say he's been the unluckiest secretary general ever with two
Trump terms, with a pandemic, with two permanent members involved in active wars and with an
endless budget crisis. I mean, all those things are true. At one level, the UN sometimes finding
itself or missing in action and at the same time, the geopolitical environment that you've just
outlined so well. I think from our standpoint, we want a secretary general that is both secretary
and general at the same time, that is able to manage the internal bureaucracy that is the
United Nations, but also to be there at the centre of peace and security to go back to the essence
of the mandate that your mission, your mandate is to save us from hell. So we want you to be
at the front line. We want you to be able to be the credible, universal peacemaker. We want you
not to abdicate from your role by the tense geopolitical environment that the secretary
general faces himself from. So a little bit of risk, be bold, be radical and show that you can
be the principled person that can help lead at the front at this time of share scale crises
throughout the world. So given those big files that we talked about, those big wars, we've got
the situation in Iran and the Middle East, we've got Ukraine, we've got Sudan. Where do you think
the new secretary general should try to put their effort and where would they be welcome without
being snubbed? Look, all of those conflicts that you mentioned are critical. The first thing I would
want is we would want to see a secretary general is to go to one of the key conflict zones. So Sudan
is the one that you mentioned where much international attention is needed, where it's
important to get diplomacy from the United Nations side working, where it's important through the
envoy there to work with all the various diplomatic officials, where it's necessary to ensure that you
can get humanitarian access. There are other important conflicts, Haiti, ensuring that we're
working for disarmament, dealing with justice and critically the Central Africa Republic,
where you've got to make sure that you don't exit the country, that you make sure that
you're still dealing with civilian protection and that you're still dealing with a very vulnerable
border between Sudan and the Central Africa Republic as well. So it's important that the
secretary general puts peace and security at the front line and visits the most important countries
as soon as that person, she gets the mandate to lead the organization. Okay, Comfort Ero,
the president of the International Crisis Group, thank you for joining us on Al Jazeera. Every
September, leaders from the most powerful countries in the world meet here in New York,
beyond the United Nations. There is a fundamental question, does any of this matter? Does it have an
impact on people's lives? Al Jazeera has been looking beyond the podium to ask people around
the world what issues are being ignored and what they want those in power to address.
The United Nations was formed 1945 after World War II, and you'd think that the world would
be looking better now, but we are worse off. They should be celebrating eight years of a
comprehensive system of progress, but nothing of the sort. If I could speak to the world leaders
of the UN, I would tell them that they need to start actually supplying their different branches
effectively, because as it is right now, it's not working, it's very ineffective,
and they can definitely do better. I think they definitely have to discuss on issues like climate
change, emissions, garbage, contamination of the seas, for example. They should reinforce
better protocols for natural disasters they definitely didn't have in Venezuela, for example.
I'm saying no to war. War has never been and is not and will never be a solution.
Well, joining me now in the Rose Garden is Tom Fletcher, the Under-Secretary-General
for UN Humanitarian Affairs and Emergency Relief Coordinator, one of the Secretary-General's top
team. We had people there, ordinary people, talking about the United Nations. You heard one of them
say the UN needs to do better. Would you agree with that? Absolutely, absolutely. And I hear
our critics who say that we're incompetent. I think you said we were paralysed, a little bit
useless, a bit too weak. But tell that to the people I work with who are out on the front lines
right now, who are busting through the checkpoints in Afghanistan, in Yemen, in Haiti, in DRC, in
South Sudan, in Somalia. My colleagues, our humanitarian community, our movement is out there
right now saving lives. We've saved 35 million lives already this year. That's an extraordinary
number. It's almost an unbelievable number. And we're setting out to save many, many more.
Yes, you've saved those lives. Well, you say you've saved those lives, and I'm sure you have.
But you've also had huge cuts forced by the big countries, notably by the US. Do you think there
are people dying right now that a couple of years ago you would have been able to save because of
those cuts? Well, because of cuts across the international community. So we've gone from
a $50 billion coordinated humanitarian sector to probably a $20 billion if I'm lucky this year.
And I'm going out there, of course, this week, fundraising hard to try and reach the $23 billion
we need to save 87 million lives. But without doubt, those cuts are costing lives. You know,
I was in Afghanistan recently and sat with mothers who lost their children because they
were forced to give birth by the side of the road because choices that I was forced to make
closed the maternity hospital nearer them. And this is happening across all the crises in which
we work. And how do you explain that to those people? Is it what happened to our maternity
hospital? It's the hardest part of my job. And increasingly, you know, in Somalia, South Sudan
and South Sudan recently, people are echoing back to me the language of cuts. They're saying we know
that there are these cuts and it's very hard to explain. And they're saying, but how is it
that the world is spending so much on guns and arms and these drones that are coming to hunt us
down and also cutting aid at the same time? And I don't know the answer to that. I don't know if
you know the answer, James, but it's very hard for me to explain why we're not even getting one
percent of what's being spent on guns and arms and defence and security right now. More conflicts
than at any time since the UN was created at the end of World War Two, 81 years ago.
Lebanon, Yemen, Sudan, conflict ridden DRC with Ebola. How do you choose?
Well, we're everywhere. We're in all those conflict spaces.
You have to make decisions.
We do every day. And those are the toughest choices that I have to make and my colleagues
have to make, which projects to cut and which projects to leave. And that means
which lives to save and which lives not to save. So we have an enormous process across
2000 organisations to what we call prioritise, hyper-prioritise in a global humanitarian
overview. And that's where we make horrific decisions, life and death decisions about where
to fund and where not to fund. And it's my job to do that in the most principled, neutral,
impartial, effective way possible. But it's really, really hard.
We have this rather strange secret process to choose your new boss now underway, the next
Secretary General. You've been in this organisation now, I think, for nearly two years.
You previously were an academic and a senior British diplomat. And what now, two years in,
what do you make of the whole UN system? Because the Secretary General's changed things,
but it's not actually in his power to change everything. Lots of it's in the power of member
states. Are there things that really are not fit for purpose?
There's a lot that can be improved. And look, Antonio Guterres has done more reform in the
last year of an SG than I think anyone on record. And as you were saying earlier on,
he was dealt a pretty difficult hand. He's played a bad hand pretty well,
actually, in the circumstances. But now if you look forward to the next election,
I think this is the most consequential SG election for generations. Because right now,
humanity is losing control of AI. We're losing control of the climate. We're losing control of
weapons. I was in Kherson recently and saw the drones being used against civilians there. And
we're losing control of the global economy right now. It's being put on a war footing. We're losing
trade through Bab al-Mandab, across the Black Sea, through the Straits of Hormuz. So the next
SG is going to have to future-proof the world for the realities of AI, of the climate crisis,
and of this war footing on which leaders are putting the global economy.
Does he have to be tougher with the big countries? Because there's an argument that Antonio Guterres
has been risk-adverse and has not wanted to get involved in direct mediation of some of
these conflicts. For example, what's going on in the Gulf, the war that's spreading across
the Middle East? The UN is missing in action, is it not? Well, let me correct a couple of things.
Firstly, it won't necessarily be a he, and I think a lot of people are thinking it will be a she.
Secondly, are we absent? There's a lot that goes on. And I sit with the SG a lot and see the calls
that he's making, the meetings that he has been having to try and shift the dynamic there. This
week, I'm trying to reach 11 million people, 11 million people in 10 crisis zones through
diplomatic agreements. If we get these deals, then we can save 11 million more lives. So there's huge
amounts going on behind the scenes. But yeah, we have to be tough. We have to take some risks. We
have to be in the conversation. That's what the charter mandates us to do. And it's what the
people I serve demand us to do as well. Because for them, we talk about the international system
disappearing. For the people I serve in Sudan, in South Sudan, in Somalia, in Haiti, in Yemen,
in DRC, it's already disappeared. Tom Fletcher, the humanitarian coordinator of the UN, the man
who coordinates all the humanitarian efforts. Thank you very much for joining us on Al Jazeera.
Now, don't forget to watch our continuing special coverage of the UN General Assembly Leaders Week
live from UN headquarters. We have presidents, prime ministers and senior diplomats. They start
speaking on Tuesday, less than 24 hours from now. We'll join you again in the coming hour from the
Rose Garden here in New York. With that, though, it's back to Niamh at Al Jazeera headquarters in
Doha.
