ABC, CBS, Fox News, NBC stand in solidarity with MS NOW, CNN and Politico over Trump media ban

Washington TV
7 followers
3 Video Views·Sep 21, 2026
MS NOW, CNN and Politico are suing President Trump and other senior administration officials over Trump banning their reporters from the White House. Now, TV networks will not cover pool events for Trump. MS NOW Legal Affairs Reporter Fallon Gallagher, MS NOW Senior White House Reporter Vaughn Hillyard, Co-host of MS NOW's "The Weekend" Eugene Daniels and First Amendment expert Amanda Shanor join Luke Russert to discuss the latest developments.
MS NOW: My Source for News, Opinion, and the World.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Let's bring in MSNOW legal affairs reporter Falun Gallagher,
senior White House reporter Vaughn Hilliard. He and his crew,
might I add, are set up on a public street corner outside the White House perimeter because of the
ban, although also with us is First Amendment scholar and UPenn associate professor Amanda
Scheiner. But I want to talk to Vaughn right now. Vaughn, you are out. Sorry, Eugene's here with me
at the table, my bad, who is also a former president of the White House Correspondents
Association. How do I forget Eugene right here at the table next to me, my friend?
All right, Vaughn, I want to start out with you. You are located across the street from the White
House on a public street. I want to add two things here. One, this perimeter of the White
House at the behest of Donald Trump is built out, has been going on for a while, not just related
to the media. As a member of the public, used people to go up and take a selfie by the fence.
You can no longer do that. They pushed out people away from the people's house. Two,
how much of this do you think is a result of he wants to switch the media narrative and he
doesn't have a real White House press secretary right now, so the people in his ear might not
have the smartest interest for the country at heart? Two parts to that, Luke. Number one,
you're right. This is the closest that we can get to the White House. I wish we had a better
camera position to at least offer you. But we're on 17th Street. This is the Eisenhower Executive
Office building. So we're about a block away. There is an active effort to construct permanent
fencing by individuals who've been appointed by Donald Trump to the National Planning Commission
around Lafayette Park and up along 15th Street and 17th Street. So for folks that may be coming
to Washington, D.C., there is no indication that there is ever going to be access again
along that fence line where you'd be able to stand outside. That really is why we are here alongside
of the actual ban from entering that security perimeter. I just want to emphasize here,
this isn't just about my ability, Vaughn Hilliard's ability, or Jake Traylor, or Laura Baron-Lopez,
or Akayla Gardner, MSNOW, or CNN, or Politico's, but this is about future organizations' access.
The President of the United States, before implementing this ban on Friday, made it very
clear from the Oval Office, Luke, that in this country, purposely negative stories should not
allow to be written. Those were his words. And in this lawsuit filed by MSNOW, Politico, and CNN,
our legal team makes very clear that it's viewpoint discrimination, and that the President
and the White House cannot arbitrarily decide which journalists have access, because the President
acknowledged this is a ban on the free press. Again, a ban on the free press, his own words,
and there are ultimate damages from that. Our ability to not only ask him, the Chief Executive
of the United States, questions, but also cabinet members and administration officials
in that secure perimeter. We no longer have that access.
And Luke, the one other point you made was about the infrastructure around him. He doesn't have a
press secretary anymore. He does have a communications director, Stephen Chung,
but this is Donald Trump's decision. And this goes back to 2024, back to during his first term
there. Ultimately, there has never been an explicit allegation made publicly by any member
of Donald Trump's campaign or by the White House that MSNOW, formerly MSNBC, has ever asked an
inappropriate or unfair question. I keep coming back to that. And for the last 18 months, we at
MSNOW have been asking the President of the United States for an interview, and he has declined
repeatedly to do so. So this ban not only restricts our ability, and we expect the courts to intervene
and allow us back in here, but this is a moment here where we're talking about not just MSNOW,
but about future news organizations three years from now, 10 years from now,
50 years from now, and the ability of the chief executive to not be able to be the one who decides
who does and does not have the ability to ask him questions.
That's a very good point, Vaughn, because I think we here at MSNOW have adhered to a high
standard of reporting about truth. And we've always made sure that our viewers are informed
of the truth. And sometimes Donald Trump doesn't like the truth. And we're sorry,
but presidents don't get to decide what the truth is. This is not a zone for alternative
facts. Vaughn Hilliard from outside the White House, outside the People's House and the People's
Streets, thank you so much for joining us. I want to go to Falun. Falun, this legal process is
moving forward. I understand there's some new information about the judge who got this case,
who was assigned this case from the three networks.
Yeah, Luke. Moments ago, we found out that the judge assigned to this was going to be Judge
Timothy Kelly. He is a Trump appointee. But what's really notable about this is that he is
the same judge who was assigned to Jim Acosta's lawsuit in 2018. And that was a very similar case
to the case that our lawyers filed this morning jointly with CNN and Politico. Back in 2018,
the White House confiscated Jim Acosta's press credential, his hard pass, because they didn't
like the questions that he was asking in a press conference. CNN filed a very similar lawsuit on
grounds to ours. They went to the judge asking for what's called a temporary restraining order,
meaning an immediate block. Our lawyers have done the same thing this morning. We are asking for a
temporary restraining order to block the ban and also restore those press credentials to our
reporters so they can get back to the White House and start reporting. Judge Timothy Kelly granted
that TRO, and that is as far as that suit went. The White House backed down. CNN withdrew their
suit. But they made similar arguments. And what's really interesting about what he did then
is he ruled on the due process grounds. We also made a due process argument saying that
our reporters didn't receive appropriate notice before the president implemented this ban on
Friday afternoon via Truth Social. We are also making a First Amendment argument saying that
this is retaliation for lawful news gathering because the president doesn't like the news
that we're reporting. It's called viewpoint discrimination. We're saying that it's unfair
for the president. It's a violation of the First Amendment for the president to block our
reporters from the White House, which is a non-public forum. There is abundant case precedent
that says once you open the White House to press, you cannot arbitrarily discriminate against
certain reporters. And so we have filed that lawsuit this morning. I expect this will move
very quickly because we filed that temporary restraining order that I was talking about,
and we could be in a courtroom as soon as tomorrow. It moves quickly. And we should mention
that Jim Acosta, when that case was ongoing, was the chief White House correspondent of CNN,
so there is a history of the White House not liking people who ask aggressive questions and
hold them to truth and accountability. Falun, thank you so much. Let's get more into legal
theory here now with Amanda. Amanda, I want to ask you, in regards to this case, the press
is the only private institution that the founding fathers actually took the time to mention in our
Constitution, in the First Amendment. What do you see as the legal theory here that is allowing
for MSNOW, Politico and CNN to really make the argument that, hey, look, we are inside the House,
you don't get to silence us right away? So the First Amendment protects, you know,
speech we like and speech we don't like, and that includes with regard to the president.
And just as Falun was saying, I mean, it's clear under the First Amendment,
even though there are some questions about press access to certain government buildings
and other issues, this one is a really clear case because the president said the quiet part
out loud and was very clear that he's excluding these outlets because they have, you know,
written negative things or reported negative things against him. And under the First Amendment,
if, you know, the government opens, for example, the White House press room to outlets generally,
they can't exclude people on viewpoint grounds, but basically because folks are
right, critical or report critical things on them. That's very obviously unconstitutional.
So when Donald Trump says, I like freedom of the press, I just don't like fake news.
So when he says, I basically just want media outlets around me that are friendly and nice
and do what I say, that's legally not OK. No, no, it's not. It's legally very clearly.
It's wildly unconstitutional. But the president is clearly not concerned with that. And I'll say,
I think part of that, he's really, I think, in this administration more broadly is attack is
normalizing attacks on American institutions and American values, including the freedom of the
press in ways that would have been unthinkable, you know, not that long ago. And I think not just
to try to delegitimize them, but also change how ordinary Americans think about what the president
has the power to do and what our rights are. And that includes the right to have a free press,
meaning not people just selected for, you know, to be sycophants to the president,
but to have a free press that reports on what our government is doing.
Eugene, you're here with me. The first thing I thought about when I got the news of all this
happening was this White House has actually allowed some very friendly media outlets inside
of the door. And those are the ones they like. The Pentagon press pool, in fact, is filled.
Lindell TV, it was started by MyPillow CEO Mike Lindell, the gateway pundit, human events.
Today in New York City, Real America's Voice, a small pro-Trump network, was listed as the
secondary crew for this important trip to the U.N. OK, he's surrounded by people that will
literally repeat every single lie that he says. What is it? I mean, if that's allowed,
why is he so concerned about MS Now and Politico and CNN? He has the outlets that
say whatever the heck he wants, right? Because we see the things that he doesn't like.
Like one of the things when I was president, we started to see this expansion of the kinds
of folks they wanted to be at the White House. And what's interesting is and I no longer speak
for the W.H.C. I'll make that very clear. But the W.H.C. has never historically been
against the expansion of folks that are allowed into the White House, covering the White House.
It has always been about the subtraction. And that is what we're seeing here, because, again,
as Vaughn said, it's not about me, you, Vaughn, any of the folks that actually go to the White
House and cover him every single day. It is about the American people having eyes on the president.
And right now, Real America's Voice, a lot of you have probably not heard about it,
is going to be the only video camera that is going to be technically pooling. I will say,
watching all five of the major networks saying, actually, we're not going to engage and participate
in any of this means that what Real America's Voice gets is probably just going to be on Real
America's Voice and used by other. And I think that's an important thing for us to contextualize
for the audience here, is that CNN was supposed to be the outlet that was going to report on this
very important trip that Donald Trump had to the U.N. today. Donald Trump is going to meet with
the head of China. OK, that's a country that we know has nullified any semblance of press freedom
over the years. So here we have a handpicked propaganda outlet from the Trump White House
covering Trump's meeting with the head of China. That's quite a thing in the United States of
America, where the freedom of the press is protected by the First Amendment.
Protected by the First Amendment. And it is the only job other than the ones in the government
that's in the Constitution. And I think when you look at this largely, you zoom out from just
talking about the press. This is a president in an administration that don't like accountability,
whether it's from the press, whether it is from the courts or Congress. The folks that are
literally supposed to be their whole job is to hold the president and his administration
accountable. They don't want that to happen. And the question for the American people is why? What
are the things they are trying to hide? No president likes the press around. No president
likes us asking questions about the things they're doing, using the money and in the name of the
American people. None of them do. But it's very different to be upset with it and then to do the
actions that are illegal that the president did today. Part of it is they want to switch the
narrative. They like to fight the media. But part of it is they keep going in this autocratic
direction. And that's sadly ground that's also very comfortable for him. Eugene Daniels, thank
you so much. Amanda Shiner, appreciate you being on the show. Appreciate it.
Just click on the MSNOW logo right here or go to ms.now membership. Hope to see you there.
