Scientists Can't Agree On The First Ancient City
An exploration of the complex history behind the world's earliest urban experiments and why archaeologists have debated the definition of the first city for over 70 years (0:38). From the intentional burning of massive European settlements to the sophisticated water engineering of the Indus Valley, this video breaks down why many early communal experiments ultimately collapsed and demonstrates that urbanization was not an inevitable, straight-line path for human civilization (0:12).
#ancienthistory #archaeology #ancientcities #human civilization #historyofcities #scishow #urbanization #anthropology #historicalmysteries #earlycultures
Imagine building the biggest city the world has ever seen, thousands of people living
out their lives in close quarters along planned streets with a central meeting space.
And then you go, never mind, you burn the whole thing to the ground.
Over 5,000 years ago, that is exactly what the Cucuteni-Trypillia people in Eastern Europe
did.
Just one of their settlements may have been home to as many as 46,000 people.
That many people living in the same place was virtually unheard of anywhere in the world
at the time.
And then they torched it all on purpose.
And the early history of cities is full of bizarre stories like this.
Where and when did people build the first city?
Sounds like a simple enough question, but archaeologists have been arguing about it
for more than 70 years.
And spoiler, they still cannot agree on an answer.
While it's tempting to think of the history of human civilization as a straight line from
nomads to camps to villages to cities, that is not at all what happened.
The climate warmed and stabilized after the last ice age.
After that, early urban experiments popped up independently on nearly every inhabited
continent.
Most of those experiments eventually failed.
Lots of people came up with the idea of cities, but for all kinds of reasons, they didn't
necessarily pull it off.
Their cities collapsed, and they went back to living in more distributed communities.
Today, we're going to explore the idea of why cities fail, and why living communally
in cities isn't inevitable for humans.
So join me on a tour of the world's first cities, most of which didn't work out.
In the 1950s, an archaeologist named V. Gordon Child came up with a list of criteria to try
and define what constitutes a city across ancient cultures.
First, there are the obvious things, like a population larger and denser than anything
that came before it in the area.
Also, big monumental public buildings.
But the list also includes economic aspects, such as specialist jobs like craftspeople
and full-time artists, long-distance trade, and production of a surplus that can be taxed
and concentrated.
It even includes the presence of a social hierarchy and elite class, as well as a system
of writing that enables long-term planning.
His list is a little out of date in some ways, and it's definitely not universally used
by archaeologists, but it can help us think about what to look for when we use the word
city.
We can find a list of examples that check a few or even most of the boxes, yet their
people never achieved true city-building cultures for one reason or another.
Here is why so many early cities failed.
Our story begins in the Middle East, in Anatolia, or modern Turkey.
Archaeologists discovered Göbekli Tepe in the 1960s, but they did not fully recognize
its significance until they excavated it 30 years later.
The ruins date back to 9500 BCE, and it's part of a network of similar nearby sites,
some of which could be even older.
Archaeologists can figure out how old these settlements are through radiocarbon dating.
Carbon-14 is a radioactive version of carbon that slowly decays and turns into stable nitrogen.
Carbon-14 is constantly produced in the atmosphere, and plants naturally absorb it along with
regular carbon-12 as they photosynthesize.
But when those plants die, they stop absorbing new carbon, and what they've already taken
in is left to decay.
So by measuring the amount of carbon-14 that is left in a sample and comparing it to the
amount of regular, non-decaying carbon-12 in the same sample, scientists can figure
out how old it is.
At Göbekli Tepe, there are small bits of plant matter from soil in the wall plaster.
Radiocarbon dating reveals that the ruins were built between 9300 and 9700 BCE.
Once, over 20 oval-shaped stone structures stood here.
The largest featured 5.5 meter tall T-shaped pillars decorated with artwork of animals
and symbols.
This is the oldest known example of humans building monuments within a settlement.
So it checks off one of the boxes for being a city right there.
Initially, however, it was thought that no one lived there year-round, only coming there
periodically for religious festivals.
Without permanent occupation, that's a big strike against being a city.
But in the 2010s, archaeologists suggested some of the large buildings could actually
be communal houses.
And modern chemical analysis of residue in large cooking pots suggests they made huge
batches of carb-rich porridge to feed large groups of people.
These discoveries raise the question, could Göbekli Tepe be the oldest known city?
The answer is still unclear.
It was certainly a place for ceremonies and feasts, but whether it was permanently occupied
is still up for debate.
While there is evidence the inhabitants collected rainwater, there isn't another easy source
of water near the site, which would make it difficult to live there through all seasons.
Even so, the discoveries at Göbekli Tepe have turned old ideas of early urbanization
on their head.
See, Child coined the term urban revolution to refer to the social, political, and economic
shifts that took place as ancient humans started living closer together.
For him, it was the next reorganization of society following the Neolithic Revolution,
when nomadic hunter-gatherers transitioned to small agricultural settlements with domesticated animals.
But Göbekli Tepe makes all those lines very blurry.
This settlement actually predates farming, animal domestication, and even pottery.
So it has many elements associated with the urban revolution, but they would have occurred
before or during the Neolithic Revolution.
And its emphasis on monumental ceremonial buildings suggests that maybe the first city
didn't grow from a village, but instead came from communal ceremonial practices.
However, after 1500 years of use, Göbekli Tepe was abandoned.
So early urbanism wasn't a one-way path for ancient cultures.
Maybe it's better to think of these as experiments rather than revolutions.
Archaeologists long thought that people buried the city intentionally.
However, new research points to the surrounding landscape as the culprit.
It neighbors steep hillsides that could give way to landslides during heavy winter rains,
so it may have just been that that particular site was too much work to maintain.
Remember the first three rules of early city planning.
Location, location, location.
This early urban experiment may not have been a total failure, though.
We'll come back to that idea in just a bit.
One location that has stood the test of time is Jericho, located in modern Palestine.
Radiocarbon dating indicates that humans have lived here since 9000 BCE.
Its main claims to fame are its monumental stone walls and watchtower, dating back to 8000 BCE.
This is another example of people coming together to complete monumental projects
for the benefit of the community.
This tower was just over 8 meters tall, and it even had an internal staircase,
which was incredible engineering for the time.
It was essentially the world's first skyscraper.
But archaeologists disagree about why it was built.
For example, whether it was intended for defense.
One study hypothesized that it was an ancient astronomical marker and timekeeper,
since the shadow of a nearby mountain falls exactly on this tower each summer solstice.
While building such a monument requires social organization and planning,
it's not clear how intricate this was.
And the population was still small, only a few thousand at most.
Jericho didn't fully urbanize until thousands of years later,
around 3000 BCE.
But what sets Jericho apart from the other settlements on this list
is that while the population has gone up and down over the millennia,
there are still people living there today.
People just kept coming back and congregating in the same spot,
and that's about as far from an urban failure as you can get.
And the reason why is likely pretty simple.
While it is in a desert, it has the spring of Ain al-Sultan,
which provides a reliable source of fresh water.
Once again, location, location, location.
Heading back to Anatolia, we're skipping ahead to around 500 years
after the burial and abandonment of Göbekli Tepe.
Because while the urban experiment at Göbekli Tepe didn't last,
it was very far from being the only such experiment in the region.
Beginning in 7400 BCE, Çatalhöyük grew to be a huge, sprawling village.
Archaeologists first noticed two large mounds of earth in the 1950s,
although the locals were, of course, already well aware of them.
These kind of mounds are called tels,
mounds that form from the gradual accumulation of debris
produced by humans living and building in one place over generations.
Archaeologists disagree about how many people lived here,
with some estimates as high as 10,000 and some as low as 600.
Çatalhöyük had many dense mud-brick houses without any planned streets between them.
Many buildings had entrances in their ceilings,
so walking along the rooftops may have been the most efficient way
of going to visit your neighbors.
People here actually buried their dead directly underneath the houses they lived in.
Interestingly, female children buried here have five times more grave goods than male children.
And there was actually a study of ancient DNA from the site that found,
while people buried together were not always biologically related,
houses remained within maternal lineages.
All of this evidence paints a picture of a culture that held women in high regard.
Artistic female figurines are also common finds at Çatalhöyük.
While this settlement was certainly a dense group of people
living together with their own social customs,
there's no evidence of communal public spaces like temples or marketplaces,
or a central government.
So it ticks a few boxes for being a city, but not many.
After a long, slow decline, Çatalhöyük was abandoned by 5950 BCE.
A changing climate may have been one reason,
but researchers have found evidence of many problems
that come along with living in dense groups.
Early farming of grains allowed Çatalhöyük to support a dense population,
but that change in diet led to tooth decay.
Cavities are present in about 10% of teeth.
Analysis of the proteins in several cooking vessels
also reveal some of the earliest evidence of humans drinking cow's milk.
However, there is residue of both animal and human feces on the walls of the houses,
which would indicate poor sanitation, potentially leading to disease.
Possibly indicative of this,
one third of human remains from the site had signs of infection on their bones.
Even more upsetting, over one quarter of remains had skull fractures from violence.
The residents of Çatalhöyük were still learning to get along in close quarters,
from public health to playing well with others.
So it seems like the downfall of this particular experiment in communal living
was all of those pesky other people.
Though let's end our tour of the Middle East
on probably the least disputed early city out there,
the one you probably know as the First City.
While calling anything that came before them a city is somewhat controversial,
you would be hard-pressed to find an archaeologist
who says Mesopotamia did not have true cities.
The Tigris and Euphrates rivers bring nutrient-rich soils to the area,
allowing for efficient agriculture to supply dense settlements.
These include Tel Brak, Ur, and a little bit later, the famous Babylon.
But let's focus on Uruk in what is today southern Iraq.
Uruk formed around 5000 BCE, and within a thousand years,
it was the largest settlement in the world.
The city had temples, a social hierarchy, and a system of government and bureaucracy.
For example, pottery bowls were manufactured in standardized sizes,
which dictated the size of grain rations people received.
To grow these grains, people engineered networks of canals and dams
to provide irrigation to their fields.
So Uruk checks a lot of the economic and bureaucratic boxes,
such as long-term planning, community projects,
and concentration of agricultural surplus.
And perhaps most importantly, they even had the earliest known writing system,
cuneiform, evolving around 3400 BCE, just before Egyptian hieroglyphs.
They used this to track and record transactions in the city's growing economy.
There's no doubt that Uruk met all of Childe's criteria for city status.
The city's power declined gradually,
but it was inhabited all the way up until 700 CE,
long after most other ancient Mesopotamian cities.
That's literally the Middle Ages,
so cities are very firmly established by the time this one is fully abandoned.
Changes in climate are often blamed for the collapse of many great Mesopotamian cities,
but a 2021 study found that by the time of a sudden shift
to a cold and dry climate around 2200 BCE,
the cities were already feeling the pressures of dense urban living.
These researchers looked at nearly a thousand radiocarbon dates
to estimate the population over time,
and they found that there was a rapid increase in population
before the change in climate, and a fall afterwards.
So climate might have been the nail in the coffin,
but the cities were already under pressure from rapid growth beforehand.
We're going to now leave the Middle East
and tour some early maybe cities around the world.
But first, a quick message.
This SciShow video is supported by Delete.me,
the hands-free subscription service that removes your personal information
from hundreds of data broker and people search sites.
Delete.me has been the leading expert
in personally identifiable information removal for over 15 years,
and was recently named by Wirecutter as the number one data removal service.
So lots of folks trust them, from medical providers to judges.
Even our executive producer signed up and had tons of listings removed for her.
They reviewed 1200 records for her.
They also made it easy for her to request removal
of additional listings herself with the click of a button.
You can join all those folks using Delete.me with the QR code on screen,
or at joindelete.me.com slash SciShow with the promo code SciShow at checkout.
You'll get 20% off Delete.me consumer plans.
So that's the story of the first cities as we normally hear it.
But the Fertile Crescent isn't the only place
where humans experimented with coming together to live in groups.
In fact, it happened just about everywhere humans existed.
And many of the same factors existed to draw people together or push them apart.
So let's move over to Eastern Europe, what is today Ukraine, Moldova, and Romania.
Back around 5000 BCE, the Cucuteni-Trypillia people lived here.
Their settlements boasted over a thousand houses and as many as 46,000 people.
That would make them way larger than the Mesopotamian cities that existed at the same time.
However, other estimates suggest the sites were smaller with only around 12,000 people.
These settlements all followed a similar plan.
Large rings of houses with streets between them leading to a large central plaza.
We don't have big, obvious ruins to study since their settlements were made of wood.
But we can still see where they were and how they were built.
Archaeologists can see where these buildings stood using geomagnetic surveys.
Every material reacts to Earth's magnetic field a bit differently.
So by measuring the magnetic field over a wide area,
archaeologists can see faint outlines of where humans concentrated particular materials,
like wood or clay.
But high temperatures, like you get in a fire, reset the magnetic field within minerals.
So rock or soil that's been burned shines extra brightly in a magnetic survey,
even thousands of years after the fire.
This is very cool.
We can see into the past.
These settlements may have been created to establish strength in numbers.
The Cucuteni-Trypillia had some dangerous neighbors.
But it's unclear if they had a centralized government or hierarchical social structures,
and some researchers think they were not even occupied year-round.
So that's three strikes against.
However, recent discoveries show some buildings were larger or given more decoration than others,
and a set of figurines appears to depict a council-like gathering.
This could hint toward both hierarchy and governance.
So some archaeologists have started making the argument that these were true early cities.
But the strangest thing about the Cucuteni-Trypillia settlements
is that they burned down roughly every 70 years.
This is why the outlines of Cucuteni-Trypillia buildings show up so clearly on magnetic surveys.
Now, this could have been the result of accidents or invaders.
However, experiments based on reconstructed Cucuteni-Trypillia homes
have found that they are incredibly difficult to burn down.
Researchers conclude that because the structures would have required so much fuel to ignite and burn,
this must have been done deliberately.
Why these cities were burned and abandoned is a mystery that persists to this day.
Perhaps these people needed to find new arable land after they had farmed one spot for a while,
and they burned their own cities.
Starting around 3200 BCE,
the Cucuteni-Trypillia people stopped building megacites altogether,
returning to smaller villages.
It's not clear why they made this decision,
but it demonstrates that urban civilization is not an inevitable one-way path for ancient cultures.
Before we leave Europe, we need to give an honorable mention to Solnitsata,
a village located in modern Bulgaria.
Founded in 5500 BCE, it grew to its height by 4700 BCE.
While small, consisting of only a few hundred people,
it is important because it's one of the earliest examples of a settlement with economic specialization.
They mined and traded salt.
In fact, it was traded so frequently and over such long distances
that it may have acted as one of the world's first currencies.
The value of Solnitsata's salt production created a tremendous accumulation of wealth in the village.
Surrounded by huge defensive stone walls three meters high and two meters thick,
it may have been the strongest fortification in the world at the time.
The houses inside were also made of stone and had multiple floors.
And that wealth was on display at a nearby cemetery,
which was found to be incredibly rich in gold and copper grave goods.
The village ended in 4200 BCE when it was destroyed by an earthquake.
But a drought may also have played a role in its downfall.
Of course, no tour of early urbanism would be complete without a trip to Egypt.
Let's focus on one of the earliest settlements.
Before the time of the pharaohs, this was a city called Nekon,
later known by its Greek name Hierakonpolis.
Neolithic cultures gradually settled along the Nile around 5000 BCE.
The fertile soil and reliable freshwater provided
some of the necessary building blocks of urban development.
Nekon's height was during a wet period in the climate.
Its location had a slight elevation that offered some protection against floods.
By around 3500 BCE, the city could have had as many as 10,000 people.
While the Nile was vital for the cities of Egypt,
it also makes an archaeologist's job challenging.
Over the course of millennia, the river can shift by multiple kilometers
and lay down many meters of sediment.
In fact, Nekon extended beyond the Nile floodplain,
which could be a factor in why we have the site preserved today.
In many ways, the city was a template for the great Egyptian cities that came later.
Industrialized pottery production, administrative buildings,
and what may be the oldest known decorated tomb.
Archaeologists uncovered a building full of large ancient vats.
Mass spectroscopy of the residue in these revealed that
this was one of the world's first large-scale breweries.
In these vats, skilled brewers fermented barley with yeast
and even added dates for flavor.
I'd like to try it.
Nekon also had what may have been the world's first zoo.
Animals kept not for food, but as a display of power,
which is evidence of an elite class.
You could draw a direct line from Nekon to the later Egyptian cities of the pharaohs.
But when the climate dried out a little bit,
people spread out and power shifted away from Nekon.
It was largely abandoned by 2300 BCE, although its temples were still used long after.
While smaller settlements in China incorporated detailed urban planning much earlier,
Liangshu in the Yangtze Delta was arguably the first large-scale city in ancient China.
Discovered in the 1930s during the construction of a highway,
workers kept finding jade artifacts.
As archaeologists learned more,
they realized the elite members of the Liangshu culture were particularly rich in jade.
The city began around 3300 BCE, as rice agriculture began to pick up in the same area.
Producing an agricultural surplus gave craftspeople the time to develop intricate
artistic practices, which in turn allowed the elite class to showcase their status.
Buildings were made out of grass and clay bricks, all formed in a standard size.
But the city was built on wetlands,
so they engineered a massive compact earth foundation to support it.
To manage the constant threat of water, there was an extensive system of 11 dams.
They even built earthen walls and a large elevated section
to protect palaces and the royal cemetery from water.
But it was not enough.
A study of oxygen and carbon isotopes from stalagmites in a nearby cave
reveals ancient precipitation patterns.
Around 2300 BCE, a period of particularly intense monsoons
appeared to have overwhelmed the dams, and the city was abandoned.
This was sudden, and there is no evidence of significant
human development in the region immediately afterwards.
So while the city of Liangshu never returned, the technology and customs developed there
spread out across China along with its former inhabitants.
Across the ocean, in North America, early versions of cities looked very different.
Poverty Point in Louisiana is a mound site that was built starting in 1800 BCE.
That's not its original name,
and we don't know what the inhabitants of the site originally called it.
It's not the oldest mound site, but it's certainly one of the most impressive.
A grand earthen monument of six massive semicircular ridges around a central plaza.
While people worked on building it over a period of 600 years,
the largest mound was built in less than 90 days.
Constructing such a monument that fast would have required as many as 9,000 laborers.
The site facilitated long-distance trade.
Archaeologists have found many artifacts made of materials from far-off places,
such as copper from the shores of the Great Lakes.
They also found an abundance of clay balls,
so many that they are now simply called Poverty Point objects.
The landscape surrounding the site lacks natural stones,
so these clay balls were heated and used to warm pit ovens.
They made their own rocks.
Mound sites like Poverty Point may not have been cities in the modern sense,
since it's not clear whether they were inhabited year-round.
However, these examples prove that you don't need intensive agriculture
or a written system of record-keeping to come together and construct large monuments.
So Poverty Point shows there was not a single path of progress that cultures followed
as people came together in large numbers for the first time.
We're going to move back across the Atlantic for our final city.
In 2500 BCE, the city of Mohenjo-Daro could have had 40,000 residents.
This was part of the Harappan civilization in the Indus Valley.
Today, this is part of Pakistan.
They had a written language, but the catch is that we have not been able to decipher it yet.
Mohenjo-Daro had many features that we now take for granted in modern cities,
but were revolutionary at the time.
It had a square grid pattern of roads, multi-room and multi-story houses,
and large public buildings for people to gather in.
But it was their ability to engineer water that was especially unmatched.
They built large, almost monumental public baths,
waterproofed by placing tar between the bricks.
There was a sophisticated water collection and distribution system
with one water well for every three houses.
It even had a centralized sewage disposal system
with a direct output pipe from many of the houses.
All of this water management might have come from necessity,
since the city was completely flooded on up to six different occasions.
So they also built large flood defense platforms.
But Mohenjo-Daro and other Indus Valley cities were abandoned by 1700 BCE,
possibly due to shifts in the monsoon patterns and rivers.
These shifts were partly due to the same global climate anomaly
that put so much stress on the cities of Mesopotamia.
The Indus Valley experienced both repeated floods and droughts,
so even their remarkable ability to engineer and harness water
wasn't enough to respond to unpredictable patterns.
And this amazing civilization also faded.
After the cities on this list sprung up, the urban revolution spread fast.
A ton of fascinating cities appeared in the next couple of thousand years,
from San Lorenzo to Great Zimbabwe to Angkor and so many more.
But humanity's path toward building cities wasn't a straight line.
It was thousands of years of trial and error,
with attempts and false starts by many different cultures.
And these cultures often did not have direct contact with each other.
So urban life did not evolve once and spread.
It started independently all over the world.
But sustaining these early cities was clearly difficult.
Ancient people needed to learn new ways of producing food,
keeping a city clean, and dealing with social unrest.
And when a natural disaster struck or the climate shifted,
these experiments were often abandoned.
People came together when the factors were right,
and they broke apart when they weren't.
But they kept trying.
And clearly, we eventually figured it out.
Now we just need to bring back the rooftop highways of Catalhoyuk,
and hopefully that will speed up my morning commute.

