#News#Politics#Trump MS NOW announces a lawsuit –along with CNN and POLITICO– over the Trump administration banning the three news outlets from the White House. The outlets releasing a joint statement saying quote: “This morning, we notified the government that we are filing a lawsuit today to protect our First Amendment rights and defend the principle that the government does not decide what the press reports or publishes. Without notice or process, the White House revoked our journalists’ credentials because it objected to our reporting. Left unchallenged, this threatens press freedom and the public’s right to independent journalism free from government interference." The Morning Joe panel discusses the latest developments.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
MSNBC, CNN, and Politico are filing a lawsuit against the Trump administration after the White House revoked their journalists' credentials. The news organizations argue that this move violates the First and Fifth Amendments, alleging retaliatory viewpoint discrimination that threatens press freedom and the public's right to independent journalism.
We have a development surrounding the Trump White House banning of MSNOW, CNN, and Politico
reporters.
A joint statement from those three news organizations reads as follows, quote, this morning we notified
the government that we are filing a lawsuit today to protect our First Amendment rights
and defend the principle that the government does not decide what the press reports or
publishes.
Without notice or process, the White House revoked our journalist credentials because
it objected to our reporting.
Left unchallenged, this threatens freedom of the press and the public's right to independent
journalism free from government interference.
Let's bring in right now MSNOW Legal Affairs reporter Falun Gallagher.
Falun, what can you tell us about this statement?
Yeah, Joe, this morning we notified the Trump administration that MSNOW, along with CNN
and Politico, which was also denied entry to the White House over the weekend and had
their credentials revoked, are filing a lawsuit against the Trump administration for this
ban on all three of our news organizations.
This is a complaint on grounds primarily of due process under the Fifth Amendment and
of course the First Amendment.
The complaint alleges that the White House is retaliating for lawful news gathering based
on viewpoint discrimination.
We are asking a federal judge in Washington, D.C. to get our access restored and have those
credentials that were confiscated over the weekend restored to all of our journalists
at all three of our news organizations who are credentialed with hard passes to the White
House.
And Jonathan Lemire, you spend a good bit of time in the White House.
You've seen how this is tracked over the first year and a half of this administration.
There have been battles with other news organizations.
There certainly has been the banning of legitimate news organizations from the Pentagon, now the
White House.
Tell me, how have those court cases gone and how has the press worked around that over
the first 18 months of the administration and how is this different or more of the same?
Let's be clear.
This will not stop the press from doing its job.
That will not stop journalists at MSNOW and the other two outlets from doing their job
and reporting on the Trump administration and bringing what we learn to our viewers,
to the American public.
That is the importance of a free press.
We have seen this a number of times already.
Trump administration, unprecedented assault on the press, as you mentioned, throwing reporters
out of the Pentagon.
Well, those Pentagon reporters still doing their job, still breaking scoops day in and
day out about the Department of Defense.
We have seen Trump administration file, and Trump himself personally, file lawsuits against
a number of news organizations.
We have seen them have federal agents raid the homes of reporters at times.
These are deeply dangerous steps.
And this is the latest in this all out assault against the press.
The three outlets were denied access on Saturday.
There's rumors in the Trump White House more outlets may soon be banned.
And this is hurts.
First of all, it hurts the president.
Yes, we know presidents, none of them like their press coverage.
This one in particular is obsessed with it.
But being able to explain to the people your views, your policy decisions, why you are
making moves that impact their lives.
That's part of the that's part of the press's job.
It's hurting the president when he does this.
He's already he and his team have hijacked the White House press corps system and the
pool where they have handpicked, you know, friendly outlets more times than not to be
there.
Joe in the room with him asking him questions.
It's very different than it was in the first term.
And we should also note, we'll see how this goes today.
There is the pool system, as you know, 13 reporters, some print, a TV crew, some photographers
travel with the president wherever he goes.
Well, today, as just mentioned, he's coming to New York to meet with Mayor Mamdani and
then begin his time at the United Nations.
The travel TV pool, CNN, CNN, though not permitted to travel.
It's unclear what TV pool access there will be at all today.
Trump, I'm told yesterday Trump White House trying to scramble to find a friendly conservative
outlet to fill in.
It's unclear if they've been successful as of this moment, which means, though, the president's
trip to New York, an extremely important development.
You just set the backdrop of all that's going on may not be broadcast to the American people
because of this ban.
Now, David Ignatius, you've been around a little while.
I can tell you when I was new to Washington thirty two years ago, I remember one time
I was flying, flying back to the district.
Alan Simpson seemed to be I happened to be on the same plane as me and he had been there
for a long time.
I just got there.
We were sitting next to each other.
I said, do you have any advice?
And Senator Simpson leans over.
He goes, when those sons of bitches in the press call you, call them back.
He said, that's the first thing I learned in Washington.
Even if you know they're coming at you, call them back.
You may not like it.
You may not like this story, but stay engaged with them in the long term and the long term.
You win.
And he was so right.
And so I see this coming down, by the way, The New York Times reporting that the White
House was caught off guard by the president's decision and didn't like it.
It sounds a good bit like his bouncing back and forth on Saudi Arabia.
But I'm not talking about this president in particular, but just in general, explain to
our viewers that are watching how in the end this hurts the politician.
This hurts the president that actually cuts off reporters, because at the end of the day,
it's not just him not talking to the press.
It's the people who work for him explaining what's going on.
You and I have both talked to this White House.
It's helped us understand better what they were doing across the world at the Pentagon.
And at the end of the day, sometimes if you get the facts, the story behind the story,
it can round off the sharp edges.
It doesn't mean they're going to like all the coverage.
It just means you want, like Alan Simpson said on that airplane trip three decades ago,
you want those sons of bitches to know what you're thinking and why you're doing what
you're doing.
God bless Alan Simpson.
He was a great man and he made you laugh even as he was telling you he disagreed with you.
So part of the job of a president, really right up the top of the list, is to communicate,
to communicate with the American people, to communicate with leaders around the world.
And the way that that's traditionally been done is through the news media.
President Trump has his own system.
He owns it.
It's called truth social.
And he thinks he can just issue a truth social post and that's communication.
But even so, he loves to be in phone calls with reporters.
One of them sitting across from me at the table this morning had loose regular telephone
correspond to the president.
But the president, this president also likes to have enemies.
He likes to communicate, but he wants to have somebody to beat up on.
And increasingly, it seems he can't do much about Iran, certainly doesn't want to beat
up on Russia, but he does like beating up on the press.
And as we head toward the midterm elections, I can't help but think that this new war on
MS Now and Politico and CNN is a little bit of finding a convenient enemy to attack.
And you know, where the press is not very popular with the public.
That's all right.
But but the president does need to remember that this country is confused about what he's
doing. If ever he needed to be on TV explaining himself, responding to real questions and
giving and giving answers, the public could understand this is that moment and he's not
doing it. It also wreaks the desperation.
He knows his poll numbers in the low to mid 30s and that his policies are unpopular with
voters. He knows the midterms are rapidly approaching.
So he comes after the press.
Instead, he's not able to sell the job he's doing.
So he attacks the messenger.
He also, of course, reiterates the news, the bubble that he lives in, this information
echo chamber where he's convinced himself that that the good news he has printed out and
handed to him by aides is reality when it is very much not.
And then Falun, he, of course, lashes out when he is confronted with the truth.
This is a this is a dangerous development.
We should we should underscore that.
The network bureau chiefs have been meeting a number of phone calls over the weekend to
figure out what's next. We see this lawsuit come out this morning.
So let's let's talk about what could be next.
What sort of other sort of timetable might we be operating under in terms of court
proceedings, decisions, injunctions, rulings?
Give us a sketch out the timeline.
Yeah, I cannot underscore enough how serious this is.
I cover a lot of cases.
It's very surreal to be covering a case about our own news organization.
But this is going to move very fast.
And that is because we are filing an emergency motion for a temporary restraining order.
So what that means is we are asking the judge to immediately block this for a period of
14 days and then we will ask for a longer term block after that.
That means that there will almost certainly be a court hearing in this case as soon as
this week where the judge could could block this policy and order the immediate
returning of the press credentials to the affected journalists.
I expect that part of this case to move very, very fast.
And I want to take a step back and talk about other cases.
You referenced the Associated Press earlier.
We have seen something similar to this in the first Trump administration.
The White House revoked Jim Acosta, then CNN correspondent's credentials.
CNN filed a very similar lawsuit at the time on the same grounds, the due process and
First Amendment grounds, saying that it was retaliatory and restricting lawful news
gathering. They went to a federal judge in Washington.
And I want to note that was also a Trump appointed judge who granted their request for a
TRO, immediately restored his credentials.
And the White House backed off of the fight after that.
The case did not go any further.
But there is also a case precedent in the D.C.
Circuit Court of Appeals for a scenario like this.
And that case precedent is a case from 1977 that holds that you cannot arbitrarily
restrict press credentials for credentialed reporters at the White House on grounds
that there is retaliation or for viewpoint discrimination.
You cannot do that once you have opened that forum to the press.
And so there is a lot of precedent here on very similar facts.
And I would expect the judge to weigh all of those things when this eventually does go
to court at some point, likely this week.
And of course, the White House Correspondent's Association also denounced this move.
MSNOW legal affairs reporter Falun Gallagher, thank you so much.
Come back to us if there are any breaking news updates.
And, Cady, I mean, you know, this is we know the president likes their press coverage, as
I said, but no one, none of them have put us, the media, at the center of his agenda
like Donald Trump has at times, you know, calling us the enemy of the people, suggesting
we should be tried for treason.
And this here is something that not a step that none of his predecessors ever undertook
before. And it is bad.
It is bad for the people at the end of the day.
Yes, it's bad for the media.
It's really bad for the president.
But at the end of the day, it's bad for the democracy if there's attacks on the free
press and our right to do our job.
Hey, it's me, Rachel Maddow.
If you like the story you just watched, you should know about a new way to see even more
from my show and from all of MSNOW live or on tape.
It's the new MSNOW membership.
You can watch everything we do on your phone or your tablet or your computer.
Plus, you can join conversations with me and the other hosts and with other folks who
care about the news as much as you do.
MSNOW membership. During September, you can sign up for just 40 bucks a year, which is
like just over three bucks a month.
Just click on the MSNOW logo right here or go to ms.now slash membership.
Hope to see you there.