In this tomato taste test and review, I'm tasting 11 unique heirloom and specialty tomato varieties from my garden and sharing their flavor, texture, productivity, appearance, and what makes each one worth growing. We're tasting everything from purple and black tomatoes to huge beefsteaks, Italian heirloom tomatoes, heat-tolerant varieties from Africa and Puerto Rico, paste tomatoes, and even an incredible long keeper storage tomato that can stay fresh for months without refrigeration! Varieties featured include Sart Roloise, Owen's Purple, Polish Beefsteak, Midnight Sun, African Togo, Gajilete de Puerto Rico, Midnight Roma, Cuore Antico di Ravenna (Ancient Heart of Ravenna), Ananas Noire (Black Pineapple), Red Beauty Beefsteak, and Aosta Valley Long Keeper. If you're looking for the best tomato varieties to grow in your home garden, especially unusual, rare, heirloom, heat-tolerant, and great-tasting tomatoes you won't normally find at the grocery store, this video will give you plenty of ideas for your next tomato garden.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Comments are disabled for this video.
Today we're doing a tomato taste test and review, and I'm so excited because the varieties I've
been growing this season are not your average grocery store tomatoes. We're talking deep
purple beefsteaks, ancient Italian heirlooms, a tomato with roots in Puerto Rico, and even a
variety you can store for months without refrigeration. Which, if you have never heard of
a lawn keeper tomato before, we're going to get into that today. If you're new here, my name is
Jera. I'm a lifelong gardener, permaculture designer, and I own a seed and plant nursery
in Orlando, Florida. My mission is to help home gardeners grow more food by sharing the exact
plants, techniques, and industry secrets I use every day in both my garden and my nursery. If
you want to grow along with me, many of the seeds and plants I mention are available on my website
jerasgarden.com. All right, so let's get into these tomatoes. First up is Sartrolois, and this
is one that I've been growing for years. This is a Belgian heirloom tomato, and it's a beautiful
creamy yellow, slightly ribbed, medium to large-sized tomato. What's unique about this
variety is that it develops a purple type of coloration on its shoulders that gets more
intense when exposed to sunlight. This is due to anthocyanins, which is an antioxidant responsible
for the color of blue, purple, or black vegetables and fruits. You just never see a yellow and purple
tomato like this one at the grocery store. You have to grow it yourself. Sartrolois has a mild,
sweet flavor with lower acidity when compared to other tomatoes. It is one of my most popular
tomato seeds on my website, so if you see some seeds for it, make sure you grab them.
Let's slice into this one here, and I've grown some of these that get way more darker than this
one. This is actually on the lighter side. It's just I'm growing my tomatoes this year, and the
suction here and my house kind of casts a shade over a lot of these tomato plants, so the ones
that are purple and blue and that kind of thing haven't developed so strongly this season because
of that shade, but normally sometimes it's like almost black covering at least half of the tomato,
but that doesn't affect flavor at all. It's just like a visual thing, but let's slice into this
one. Upon slicing into it, it's very, very meaty, really thick. Now let me taste this one.
It's just sweet. It's mild and sweet. A lot of people that don't like the acidity of regular
tomatoes really like the flavor of this one, and it's always a great producer in my garden.
Next is Owens Purple, and if you love purple and dark tomatoes, this one is for you. Owens Purple
is a gorgeous deep purple and red heirloom that produces large stunning fruits. The dark coloring
in purple tomatoes like this one comes from the same anthocyanins that give Sartrelois its purple
pigments. Originally, this was a cross between a black tomato called Paul Robeson, which is another
one of my favorites, and Mortgage Lifter, which is famous for how big the fruits get, but it's been
stabilized over many generations and now considered an heirloom. The flavor is rich and
earthy with a good balance of sweetness and acid. Dark tomatoes like this one tend to have a more
robust, almost wine-like flavor profile, and Owens Purple is a great example of that. It's absolutely
one of my favorites, and it has a very good heat tolerance. These two here are actually on the
small side. Typically, it's at least double the size of these, so it is a larger beefsteak tomato,
but I'm getting towards the end of my season, so usually the plants will pump out the first initial
flush, which tends to be really big slicers and beefsteaks and all that, but then as the season
progresses and it makes subsequent flushes, the size of the tomatoes tend to get just a little
bit smaller going in or further into the season. But anyway, this one is super juicy. The cavities
are pretty big, the seed cavities with all that gel and juice, but still a very meaty tomato,
and I love the flavor of this one. It's just a little bit more complex and earthy compared to,
you know, your regular red grocery store tomato. Now we have Polish Beefsteak, and this one is my
absolute favorite tomato because of the flavor. Polish Beefsteak is a large, meaty, traditional
beefsteak-style heirloom tomato that has been grown and passed down for generations. It is known
for tasting like the old heirloom tomatoes that were grown in our grandparents' gardens. It's an
old classic flavor that I feel the majority of the newer varieties are really lacking. The slices
are so big that it will hang off both sides of your sandwich. This one doesn't produce a lot
of seed, so I don't always have a ton of them available on my website, but if you see some,
make sure you grab it because this one by far is my favorite. This is a late season tomato compared
to the other ones that I grow. This is typically one of the last ones to finally start ripening up
and producing, but totally worth the wait. But anyways, let's slice into one of these, and it
kind of has a pinky red color when it's fully mature or ripe. It's not like a deep, darker,
more intense red. Let's slice into it, and look at that. Really thick, really meaty. Oh yeah.
I don't know what it is about this tomato that makes it my favorite for flavor, but it just has
a really good balance of sweetness and acidity. It's just perfect. Next is Midnight Sun, and this
is the first time I'm growing it. It is a bicolor heart-shaped, or what is called ox heart-shaped
tomato. This one is one of the last ones that I pulled off the plant, so it's a little bit smaller,
but typically it gets much larger, at least double the size. But it ripens with a beautiful golden,
yellow-orange color with pink streaks. It's incredibly sweet. It's fruity and sunshine
flavored, almost like eating something very tropical. Let's slice it, but this would be
really beautiful in slices, like on a salad or something, just because of all the color. It's
definitely one that I'm going to be growing next season. So let me just take a taste test for you
all. That's really good. It's just sweet, very sweet, but interesting in a very good way. It's also
very, very meaty. It doesn't have a lot of seeds, so it's also another variety that's kind of hard
to get a hold of. Now this one has a really interesting story, African Togo. This is an heirloom
variety with roots tracing back to Togo, a country on the west coast of Africa, and it is a reminder
of just how global and diverse the world of tomato genetics really is. Tomatoes originated in South
America, spread through Europe, and were then carried and cultivated all over the world, with
different cultures selecting and saving seeds that performed well in their specific climates.
African Togo is said to be heat tolerant, so that's why I decided to grow it. It produces these small
ribbed tomatoes with a lot of variance in size, but don't let that fool you. It produces a massive
harvest. Every day I'm harvesting some, like this basket right here. It produced the most in terms
of pounds out of all the tomatoes that I'm currently growing. A lot of these tomatoes have like a funky
little belly button type thing. I don't even know what you call that at the bottom. Others are flat
like a normal tomato, but don't let that bother you. I'm going to use this all to make tomato
sauce anyways. So let's give this one a taste test. Yeah, it's good. It's very juicy, bright. I love the
flavor. It's just a good standard little red tomato, and I do have to agree. So far it's been producing
very, very well in my hot Florida garden. We're already getting days, you know, 90 degrees Fahrenheit
and above, and it's just been non-stop. So I do agree that it has some pretty decent heat tolerance.
So next is a tomato called Gajilet de Puerto Rico, and it's said to be very heat tolerant and from
Puerto Rico. So that's why I decided to grow this variety. It does have a size or shape very similar
to like the African togo in that it's kind of like a ribbed tomato. The color on this is more like an
orangey red though, while the African togo is like a pinkish kind of red, just a little bit different.
But the size of the Gajilet de Puerto Rico is much bigger overall. Like on average, the fruits from
this one are much bigger than the African togo. But I would still say that the African togo is
more productive. So let's give this one a try. There's the inside. It's very, very juicy.
This one has some high acidity, really, really bright flavors. Still really great. Now we have the
Midnight Roma tomato, and if you love Roma-style paste tomatoes, but you also want something
visually dramatic, this is the variety I recommend. Midnight Roma produces deep, dark, almost black,
purple Roma-shaped fruits thanks to anthocyanins, giving this tomato some extra antioxidant
properties on top of all the usual tomato nutrition. Roma-type tomatoes are meaty with
less juice and fewer seeds, making them ideal for sauces, roasting, drying, and canning. So let's
give this one a try. So this one is pretty dark because the sun was hitting it pretty directly,
which causes it to develop more of this purple coloration, whereas some of the other ones were
more hidden like in the foliage, but they still look really cool. They have like this orange color
with a little bit of some purple streaks. But sometimes when I've grown this in other spots
in my garden, they are completely dark, almost black, like the whole thing. So it really just
depends where you're growing them. But anyways, let's slice into it. And again, this is a Roma
tomato. They're not known specifically for like fresh eating. Roma tomatoes are a sauce type of
tomato, so they're best used in making sauce. With that said, it still tastes really, really
good. Definitely beats any tomato you'll buy at the grocery store. I just taste a very mild
sweetness. But the thing with the sauce tomatoes, once you start cooking them, it develops a lot
more flavor. This next one is called Core Antico de Ravina, if I'm saying that correctly. But that
translates to Ancient Heart of Ravina. And the name alone tells you something special about this
one. It's an old Italian heirloom from the Ravina region of northern Italy and has a very large kind
of pear shaped type of tomato. But I'm impressed by how meaty this one is. And I personally love
growing lots of old Italian heirloom tomatoes. They don't disappoint. And I love making tomato
sauce and so many other types of Italian dishes. So that's why I have a tendency to really grow lots
of old heirloom Italian tomatoes. All right, so let's slice into this one. This is considered like
another black type of tomato. As you can see, it's pretty thick and meaty. The skin color has like
dark green shoulders and then like a rust, deeper red base. But this one, this one's really good and
just savory. Really, really good. I have a tendency to like the black tomatoes. I don't know what it
is, but I just really like how much more complex the flavors are. Next is Ananas Noir, which is French
for black pineapple. This is one of the very first tomatoes that I ever grew and I was shocked by how
sweet the flavor was. Plus, it's one of the most visually beautiful heirloom tomatoes you can grow.
Ananas Noir is a large bicolor tomato that is dark green and black on the outside with a stunning
interior that is a mix of red, orange, yellow, and green when you slice into it. The name refers to
both the dark skin and the flavor, which is said to have a complex, fruity, almost tropical quality
that reminds some people of pineapple. And I have two of them here that I harvested today, but these
are both on the small side. This is a huge, large beefsteak tomato, but when you slice into it, it's
really pretty. It's one of those like photogenic type of heirloom tomatoes that you see on Instagram
all the time. But as you can see, the inside is like green with swirls of red or pink. It's just
really pretty, especially when you get one of the big ones. But let's taste test this one.
It's just super sweet. There's been times when I've harvested one and tasted it and it was
so sweet. It was almost like cloyingly sweet, not in a good way. That's how sweet they get.
But what I really like to do with this one is dice it up with other, you know, red regular tomatoes,
like a big mix of different varieties, and make bruschetta with it because then you get like all
these flavor profiles in it and it's the best bruschetta you'll ever have. Now let's talk about
This is the first time growing it and I'm really impressed by just how productive it has been. I've
harvested a ton of beefsteak tomatoes from just a couple of plants. The coloration is what caught
my attention. The base is red with orange streaks, but then it develops these purple shoulders if
exposed to sunlight. So just a big, huge mix or kaleidoscope of colors. It is a large beefsteak
type of tomato and it delivers everything you want from a garden tomato. It's big, productive,
beautiful, meaty, and full of flavor. If you want a tomato for thick slices or big sandwiches,
Red Beauty is perfect for that. So I'm gonna slice into this one. What I've noticed about
the interior is that it's kind of like a pinky color, not like a really intense red, but it's
very juicy, very meaty. I could keep eating more and more of this one. And last but absolutely not
least, we have the Aosta Valley Lawn Keeper. And I have to take a moment to explain what a lawn
keeper or storage tomato actually is, because this is a category of tomato that most people
have never heard of. A lawn keeper tomato, sometimes also called a storage tomato or a
winter tomato, is a variety that's been specifically bred or selected over generations to stay fresh
at room temperature for a very long time. We're talking weeks to months after harvest without
refrigeration. Lawn keeper tomatoes were developed before the age of refrigerators as a way to enjoy
fresh tomatoes deep into winter. In places like the Aosta Valley in northwestern Italy, nestled in
the Alps, farmers would harvest these tomatoes in the fall and hang up bunches from the rafters.
They would slowly ripen and stay edible well into the winter months. The secret is in the skin and
internal structure. Lawn keeper tomatoes have thicker skin, denser flesh, and lower moisture
content than typical tomatoes, which slows down the breakdown and ripening process dramatically.
The trade-off is that they are not quite as rich and explosive in flavor as a peak season
slicing tomato, but the fact that you can harvest in fall and still be eating a truly fresh room
temperature tomato in the winter time is a great benefit. For anyone who wants to extend their
tomato season without a freezer or a canning jar, this is the variety that you should grow. So I will
still taste one of these, but just so you know, they're not the best for like fresh eating, but
they're really good like if you want to throw some on a pizza or roast them or something like that.
Kind of has a little bit of a more chewy and dry texture, but you can store these without
refrigeration and they last a really long time. As for flavor, I would just say it's like mild and
kind of acidic and sweet, but very mild. There's lots of different varieties of lawn keeper
tomatoes. This is just one, but it's definitely something worth looking into if you want to
harvest some tomatoes in fall time and still be able to eat them fresh during the winter time.
If you want to try growing any of these varieties, plus many more, head over to my website
jarrasgarden.com. I'll link it down below in the description. I have several tomato taste tests and
review videos because I like to show you all what they actually look like. You can find more videos
like this one on my tomato playlist, also linked below in the description.
As always, happy gardening and I'll see you in the next video.