Why did doctors diagnose a painting?

ArtEcho: Exploring Art History and Critique
24 followers
5 Video Views·Sep 20, 2026
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video explores the true nature of a famous grotesque portrait in London's National Gallery. Long misidentified as a medical study of a woman with Paget's disease, new curatorial research reveals the painting is actually a satirical \"punchline\" depicting a Carnival character—possibly a man in drag—mocking the folly of aging and desire.
You have seen this face before, it has hung in the National Gallery in London
for over 80 years. It is one of the most photographed,
most reproduced, most argued about faces in the building.
Some visitors love it, some refuse to look at it
and if it looks familiar even to people who have never been to London
that's because John Tenniel copied it. The Duchess
in Alice's Adventures in Wonderland is this face,
redrawn. For most of the last 40 years there has been a standard
explanation for what you're looking at. It appeared in a medical journal, it's
spread everywhere and it is repeated on tour guides and websites to this day.
The National Gallery's own curator says it's wrong.
She also says this is probably not a portrait of anyone
and that it may not be a woman. Start with the clothes because they're doing
more work than the face. That headdress is called a horned hennin.
In 1513 when this was painted it had been out of fashion for roughly a
century. Nobody in Antwerp was wearing that.
It's the equivalent of painting somebody today in a costume from the 1920s and
expecting you to notice. The dress is cut low and tight
in the style of a young woman at court. Beneath it,
painted with complete unsparing precision,
is an aged body and in her right hand held up carefully between finger and
thumb is a rosebud. That flower is not
decoration. In this period a rosebud offered in a
portrait means one thing, courtship and engagement. It is being
presented to somebody. So the picture in front of you is an
elderly person dressed a hundred years out of date in
the clothes of a young bride holding out a flower to somebody we
cannot see. Remember that flower, it becomes
important later. Now the face itself which is where the
trouble starts. The forehead is enlarged, the jaw is
heavy and pushed forward, the upper lip is
unusually long, the whole skull has an odd overgrown
quality that reads immediately as medical rather than simply old.
In the 1980s the painting was examined by a doctor
at University College London and the resulting suggestion was published in
the British Medical Journal that Massey's had painted a real woman
suffering from Padgett's disease of bone, a condition in which
bone remodelling goes wrong and bones thicken and deform,
sometimes dramatically in the skull. It's a satisfying
explanation. It fits the visual evidence. It turns a grotesque into a document,
a real unnamed woman with a real illness,
painted with unusual honesty 500 years ago.
It has been repeated in newspapers, textbooks, television programmes
and gallery talks for four decades. If you have ever heard anything about this
painting, you have almost certainly heard this and
this is the kind of thing that only comes apart when somebody goes back to
the object itself which is what this channel is for.
If you're enjoying this, a like helps other people find it and subscribing
means the next painting comes to you because in 2023 the National Gallery
took this painting off the wall and looked at it properly. The gallery's
curator Emma Capron built an exhibition around it. Her
assessment of the medical theory was blunt.
It isn't Padgett's disease, it isn't dwarfism, it isn't elephantiasis
and she said something else that's worth quoting, in substance
that she's reluctant to have doctors walking around galleries handing out
diagnoses because the diagnosis rests on an
assumption nobody had checked. It assumes this is a
portrait that Massey sat a real person down
and painted what he saw. There is very little reason
to think he did. Look again at what's in the picture.
Clothing a century out of date, a courtship flower,
an old body dressed as a young one. Those are not the observations of a painter
recording an unfortunate sitter. They are jokes and they are aimed at a
specific target. This isn't a document, it's a punchline.
In 1511, two years before this was painted, Erasmus of Rotterdam published
In Praise of Folly, one of the most widely read books in Europe.
Among its targets are old women who refuse to behave like old women,
who dress young, chase young men and put themselves forward as
objects of desire. Massey's knew Erasmus personally.
He painted his portrait. The two men were part of the same
Antwerp intellectual circle and Carnival,
the pre-Lent festival where the social order is deliberately inverted for a few
days, was full of exactly this kind of figure.
Grotesque old brides, men dressed as women, standard
recognisable characters that everyone in the crowd already knew.
So Massey's takes a stock figure of fun from the street and he paints her in the
most prestigious format available. The formal three-quarter portrait,
the thing you commissioned to record a merchant or a bishop for posterity.
That's the joke, not the face, the frame around it. He's using the visual
language of dignity on a character from a Carnival float,
which raises the obvious question, if she's offering a rosebud to somebody,
who is she offering it to? This painting
has a partner. Massey's painted a companion panel,
an old man turned to face her in the same format at the same scale.
They are a pair. They were made to hang together
looking at each other. Every double portrait convention
of the period, their husband on the left, a wife on the right,
dignity in both, is being invoked here so it can be broken. Because look at him,
he's not returning the gesture. His expression is closed,
his hand is raised and he is quite clearly declining.
She is offering, he is refusing. That's the entire picture and you cannot see it
if you only have one half. And for most of their existence, that's
exactly what happened. The panels were separated. Hers went to
the National Gallery. His went into a private collection.
They were reunited in London in 2023, for the first time ever as far as
anyone can establish. For decades, people diagnosed a disease
in a face that was making a joke to somebody who wasn't in the room.
There's one more part of Capron's argument and it's the one that got the
headlines. She has argued that the figure is most
likely male. A man dressed as a woman of the kind
Massey's would have seen at Carnival, where men impersonating women was a
standard part of the entertainment. Which, if you
accept it, reframes every feature people were
diagnosing. The heavy jaw, the broad brow, the long
upper lip. Not symptoms. A man's face under a woman's
headdress, as the joke requires. That reading is not
universally accepted and it shouldn't be presented as settled.
Other scholars keep the figure as a female folkloric type without the
cross-dressing element. But both readings agree on the part
that actually matters. And the part the last 40 years got
wrong. Nobody sat for this. There is no real
woman here. There is no patient. Which means the
most repeated fact about one of the most famous faces in London
is about a person who never existed. One last thread and it's still being
argued about. There is a drawing in the Royal Collection
of almost exactly this face. A grotesque old woman
in red chalk. Connected to Leonardo da Vinci
and generally now catalogued as the work of his pupil
Francesco Melzi. After Leonardo. Which came first.
The National Gallery's own position is that the drawing inspired the painting.
That a grotesque head travelled north from Italy
and Massy's built a picture on it. Others argue the traffic went the other way.
That Massy's and Leonardo were in contact.
Exchanged drawings and that the Italian grotesques
owe something to the north rather than the reverse.
Nobody has closed that question. What's clear
is that this face was travelling between studios across Europe as an idea.
Being copied and adapted. Which is exactly what you'd expect
of an invented character and exactly what you would not
expect of a specific woman with a specific illness in Antwerp.
So here is what's left. A carnival figure.
Invented, drawn and redrawn across a continent.
Painted as a joke about an old body in young clothes.
Offering a flower to a man who is turning her down.
Three centuries later an illustrator borrowed the face for a children's book.
And it became one of the most recognisable images in English literature.
And then for 40 years people looked at the funniest painting
in the National Gallery and diagnosed it.
She was never ill. She was never even there.
There's a version of that problem here too.
YouTube only shows you what it thinks you already follow.
So if you'd like the next painting to reach you,
subscribing is the only thing that reliably makes that happen.
It takes a second. It's free.
And it's the difference between finding this channel once and actually seeing it again.
Thank you for watching all the way through.
There's another painting hiding something on screen now.
