Japanese Gardens Steal the Neighbor's Trees — Your 6-Foot Fence Blocks Them Out

The Beauty Of Nature
21 followers
33 Video Views·Sep 20, 2026
Japanese gardens skillfully "borrow" greenery from neighboring properties, turning distant foliage into a natural backdrop. However, erecting a 1.8-meter-high fence cuts off this view, causing the garden to lose its sense of depth, airiness, and subtle harmony with the surrounding landscape.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedKen explores the Japanese concept of *shakkei* (borrowed scenery), illustrating how to integrate views beyond one's property into a garden. He critiques the American tendency to build solid six-foot fences that block beauty, suggesting instead that we treat fences as \"trimming lines\" to frame external landscapes and foster neighborly reciprocity.
The man who priced my fence walked the back line of my yard with a measuring wheel and
he never once looked up.
Yours didn't either.
He read me a number of feet and a price per foot, $25 to $50 is the going rate this year,
and I signed.
Your quote, like mine, has a length on it and a height on it, and no line anywhere for
what the fence is about to delete.
But the best thing in my mother's garden has never been inside it.
It stands on the far side of her fence, and six solid feet of board on that line would
have erased it.
Japanese gardens have a name for taking a view they do not own.
I will show you how it works at a temple, then above and through the fence you already
paid for, from the chair you actually sit in.
At the end I will tell you whose tree it is and what my mother pays for it, because the
payment is why it has lasted.
I'm Ken.
I grew up in a Japanese house.
I've lived in America longer now than I lived in Japan.
You will find this filed under Zen, and whoever filed it there never priced Japanese land.
The word is shakkei, borrowed scenery, and the first person to write it down was a working
garden designer in China in the 1630s, in about the tone you would use for drainage.
Where my mother lives, ground is priced by a unit the size of two floor mats, and on
ground like that a view is the only acreage that comes free.
It costs nothing to buy, the tax office cannot see it, and somebody else does the pruning.
I did the opposite.
My neighbor's silver maple hangs a quarter of its canopy over my back corner, and for
years the only column I kept on that tree was raking.
The north edge of Kyoto, a temple called Entsu-ji.
You sit on the veranda boards, and you have to sit, because the garden was drawn for a
seated eye.
In front of you, moss and stone.
Behind that, a clipped hedge roughly five feet high.
Behind the hedge, the trunks of cedar and cypress going straight up like the bars of
a window.
And between those trunks, about four miles off, Mount Hiyai, nearly 2,800 feet of mountain,
sitting in the garden as if somebody had it delivered.
The temple has never owned that mountain.
The picture has three layers, and the three layers are the whole technique.
There is the thing you borrow, there is the ground you own, and between them there is
a line that edits.
That hedge is the line.
It removes everything between the moss and the mountain, the roofs, the road, the wires,
so the near thing and the far thing read as one picture.
Garden historians call it the trimming line.
The older Japanese word for the whole move is ikidori, to capture alive.
And I like it better, because it admits that somebody sat down on those boards and decided
where the hedge goes.
Keep that hedge in mind, because you own one.
Yours is pressure-treated pine, and nobody told you what it was for.
And keep an eye on those tree trunks.
I will come back to who owns them.
How tall is your back fence?
Six feet.
You knew that without going outside.
Now tell me why six.
I couldn't have.
I built what everyone builds, six feet of board across the back of my lot, because six
feet is what the fence company quoted.
Years later, I read my town's zoning code for an unrelated reason and found the number
sitting there in print.
Six feet is the legal maximum for a back fence where I live, and in most American towns.
The lumber aisle sells the panel to match, six feet tall, eight feet wide, and nobody
at the register mentions that you are buying the limit.
And it sells by the running foot.
At this year's prices, an ordinary backyard runs somewhere between $4,000 and $7,500,
in wood that lasts 15 or 20 years before you buy it again.
Think about what a price per foot rewards.
More feet.
One height.
Solid.
Corner to corner.
Nobody in that transaction is paid to ask which 30 feet you needed.
Privacy is usually one sight line.
One deck next door, one upstairs window.
I fenced an entire yard to fix a problem the width of a bathroom window, and I can show
you what that cost me from a chair.
Go and sit where you actually sit.
Skip the back door.
That is where you stand to judge the lawn.
I mean the chair with the coffee, or the kitchen sink.
Now do the arithmetic the man with the wheel skipped.
Sitting down, your eye is about three and a half feet off the ground.
Say the fence is 10 feet from your chair and six feet tall.
Run a line from your eye over the top board and keep going.
By the time it reaches a tree 40 feet away, that line is 13 and a half feet in the air.
The fence took everything under it.
So a big shade tree survives your fence.
My neighbor's maple clears mine easily.
Anything small does not.
A dogwood, a Japanese maple, a plum.
At that distance, an ornamental tree is cut down to its top few feet, and those are the
trees that flower.
Now slide the chair back 10 feet and run it again.
The same line crosses the same tree under 10 feet.
You got almost four feet of somebody else's tree back by moving a chair.
What you just did has a page in a book I wrote, The Small Garden, 379 pages, and every chapter
ends in a box with one job for one Saturday.
The fence chapters have three.
Look up your town's real fence numbers and measure your own.
Find the one border that needs shielding and measure only that.
And the borrowing survey, which you have half finished.
It's $47.
Scan the QR code on screen or go to thesmallgardenbook.com.
That is all the advertising this fence gets.
Stay in the chair.
Now look at what the fence is doing in that picture.
It hides their shed, their trampoline, their air conditioner, and it stops about where
the branches start.
That is the hedge at Ensuji.
You already built the trimming line and you paid by the foot for it.
And what sits above it has a price.
A Forest Service economist studied house sales in Portland and found a street tree added
about $8,800 to the house behind it, and nearly $13,000 combined to the houses near it.
Most of what that tree was worth landed on people who did not own it.
So I am not going to tell you to take the fence down, and this is where America gets
the point.
A fence answers real problems, a dog, a pool, where the fence is the law and ought to be.
The neighbor's second floor looking straight down at your table.
Japan never had to solve that, because Japanese houses assume enclosure, walls by default,
frosted glass, nobody on display, and the lane I grew up on is a corridor of walls because
of it.
The American lot is open on every side by design, and wanting one solid wall at the
back of that stage is the sanest wish in the yard.
I would build mine again.
But read what the rules ask for.
The model pool code that most states and towns work from wants a barrier at least 48 inches
high, nothing a child can climb, no gap a four-inch ball fits through, and a gate that
latches by itself.
None of it says solid.
A see-through metal fence passes.
Your town's version is the one that counts, so read yours.
Which is why the trick works above the fence and through it, never instead of it.
Above it, keep your own planting low on the one line between your chair and their tree.
Stain the boards dark.
New pine is the loudest object in the yard, and a dark fence sinks behind whatever stands
in front of it.
And through it, on the stretch where nobody is looking at anybody, trade one solid panel
for an open one.
None of this cares about your climate.
A sight line works the same in Phoenix as in Maine, which leaves the one part you cannot
stain, move, or buy, the tree itself, and the person it belongs to.
The window over my mother's kitchen sink.
Every March, there is a plum in full bloom in it, white, early, a little too much, standing
exactly between the bare shoulder of our persimmon and the line of the fence, as if the garden
had been built around it.
It was.
My father set the stones with that tree already in the picture.
The tree belongs to Mrs. Okabe, next door, and not one branch of it is my mother's to
prune.
I was about nine when I found out.
I had told a boy at school we had a plum tree, and my mother corrected me from the sink without
turning around.
I felt robbed.
Mrs. Okabe prunes that tree.
Mrs. Okabe rakes it.
My mother gets the bloom in March, the shade at the fence corner in August, and the fruit
in autumn, which lands on her gravel.
And here is what she pays.
The plums go back over the fence in a bag.
In July, a bag of cucumbers goes over, too.
And she has never said one word about the branch that hangs across her line, which the
law says she could have had cut.
I put the word steel in the title, and I should take it back.
This is borrowing, and with borrowing, something goes back over the fence.
It has to, because a borrowed view is never owned.
In most of America, you have no legal right to a view at all.
Ensuji never owned the mountain, and it never owned those tree trunks, either.
They stand outside its wall.
When apartment blocks began climbing into the picture, the city had to step in.
And in 2007, Kyoto passed a law protecting 38 views by name.
That veranda is one of them.
Mine took me longer.
One October, I sat in the patio chair and saw that the maple I had resented for a decade
is the best color in my yard and the only shade at the hour I sit there.
I had been borrowing it for 20 years by accident and billing myself for the privilege.
It was never a burden with a view attached.
It was a view with a rake fee.
Leave the fence alone this week, one chair.
Sit in it, look out, and name the best thing you can see that you do not own.
Then look at what of yours is standing in front of it.
That is the whole job.
Leave one word in the comments, done, and tell me what the tree is and whose it is.
I read those.
Mine is a silver maple.
It belongs to the man next door.
And this fall, I am taking him something.
My raised bed died in September, as usual, so it will not be cucumbers.
