Predicting the Collapse of the Solar System

Mysteries of the Universe
550 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedRecent research suggests the solar system is far less stable than previously thought. As the sun transitions into a red giant and then a white dwarf, asymmetric mass loss will likely trigger orbital chaos. This process could lead to planetary collisions, the ejection of planets into interstellar space, and a complete rearrangement of the system's architecture within billions of years.
In about 8 billion years, the sun will become a white dwarf, supposedly marking the end of
most interesting things happening in the solar system. Everything with an orbit interior to
Venus will certainly be destroyed, with Earth and the moon as possible, though not confirmed,
candidates for being destroyed as well. The solar system after this, assuming no instability before
this, will consist of maybe Earth, Mars, Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus, Neptune, and all the remaining
dwarf planets, which will be plunged into cold darkness they won't ever recover from.
Eventually, every object orbiting the sun will be ejected, and I've said in many videos in the
past that this is simply a numbers game. Things move around the Milky Way, and it's only a matter
of time before something moves close enough to destabilize the orbit of a solar system planet,
and this will happen over and over until there's nothing left and the sun is a solitary object.
At least, this used to be the most likely scenario, until this really interesting paper
came out this week that I thought was interesting enough to put on hold the other video I was making
to talk about. The scenario I just described would likely take trillions to even quadrillions
of years for the sun to lose every planet. According to this paper, the solar system is
going to become unstable much, much faster, as in either during the red giant phase of the sun,
or shortly after. Basically, all popular models about the deep future of the solar system are
wrong, and this system has far less time left being stable than previously thought.
This is an extremely interesting topic, so let's get into this paper and exactly what's going to
happen in our system's future. First off, a little bit about the solar system's current stability,
as it's very important for this video. The solar system is an extremely delicate system,
and everything depends on everything else to remain in their current orbits.
Mercury's orbital eccentricity is controlled largely by Jupiter, Saturn's axial tilt is
strongly influenced by Neptune, and in a topic I'll hopefully cover in next week's video,
Neptune's gravity might actually be responsible for causing the destabilization of the Saturnian
moons that eventually formed Saturn's rings. Earth just existing keeps the orbits of Venus
and Mercury stable, as without it, Jupiter would cause their eccentricities to spike.
The solar system is structured the way it is today because this was the stable arrangement
that arose after its formation. If something was then changed, then everything could be
thrown into chaos. This is what I talked about in one of my previous videos, the instability of the
solar system. That video largely talks about the influence of passing stars on the solar system,
and its effects for the main sequence lifetime of the sun, basically not touching the red giant
phase or the white dwarf phase, which is what this video will be about. The paper that video
is based on is how we know that Pluto has roughly a 5% chance of being ejected from the solar system
in the next 5 billion years, and in the same time frame, Mars and Earth have a 0.3 and 0.2%
chance of the same thing, respectively. And if Uranus and Neptune fall into a resonance,
which they are pretty close to doing, then everything falls apart.
Again, more information in that video. But the reason we were even able to get
that data in the first place is because an assumption in our models was challenged.
Previous models treated the solar system as isolated for simplicity, where other passing
stars could be ignored. That study challenged that and actually accounted for passing stars,
and thus the chances of instability rose. This new paper, linked in the description,
also challenged an assumption, this time about mass loss when the sun becomes a red giant.
As red giant stars, which the sun will eventually become, expand, they begin shedding their outer
layers and losing a ton of mass. When the sun eventually becomes a white dwarf, it will be
about half its current mass, and all of that mass is lost during the red giant phase.
Most models have operated under the assumption that as the red giant sun expands,
its mass will be lost smoothly and symmetrically. Due to this, it's been suggested that all of the
planets will gently and slowly move outwards, roughly at the same rate, preventing any large
scale instability. This is where we get the idea that the solar system's current or orbital
arrangement will last for trillions of years. However, all of these models so far have just
been an approximation of reality, and have not fully accounted for a recent discovery.
Red giant stars don't lose mass smoothly and symmetrically. This is based on observations
of white dwarf stars, the remains of most red giants, and observations of their motions that
suggest they lost mass asymmetrically. This paper uses these observations to create new models and
find something pretty shocking. The chances of a large scale planetary instability occurring in the
solar system during the red giant phase, as in some time in the next 5-7 billion years, is 40%.
This is not like the previous numbers that suggest a non-insignificant but still pretty
small chance of instability. This is a major possibility. After the sun becomes a white dwarf,
these chances rise to 90%. Meaning, within 3 billion years of the sun becoming a white dwarf,
a scenario where the solar system becomes unstable and collapses is not an interesting but unlikely
hypothesis, but by a significant margin, the most likely outcome. How exactly this instability will
play out depends on factors that are still unknown, including exactly how much mass the sun will lose,
and of course how asymmetric that mass loss will be. Let's first talk about what asymmetric actually
means before exploring some specific scenarios. Basically, it's now suggested that as red giant
stars lose mass, that mass is lost in random, but directed, directions. In simpler terms, this means
that as the red giant sun is losing mass, it will be shooting that mass off in random directions,
and thus going on what this paper describes as a random walk before settling as a white dwarf.
Due to this, all of the solar system planets are dragged on these random walks as well.
Basically, for about 3 billion years, the sun will be shaking the entire solar system around,
which as I'm sure you can imagine, would have adverse effects on stability.
The authors of this paper ran 48 simulations with different mass loss rates and directions
to create some theoretical outcomes of this, and the results are incredibly interesting.
In 37 of the 48 simulations, or 77% of them, planets crossing orbits with one another occurred
before the sun's mass loss was complete, or in other words, when it was still a red giant.
In 19 of the 48, about 40%, these orbital crossings resulted in violent disruptions,
where planets were either ejected from the solar system or collided with one another.
So there's a 77% chance the orbits of the solar system planets will be permanently and
significantly altered during the sun's red giant phase, and a 40% chance this will result in the
system losing planets by either collision or ejection.
But even in scenarios where that doesn't occur, things are still incredibly interesting.
Let's look at just a few examples of what things could happen to the solar system during this time
because of this instability. Again, the full paper and all of this information will be in
the description, but they listed a few examples of post-mass loss solar system architecture I
thought were worth exploring. In this model, at t equals 0, basically right when the sun
becomes a white dwarf, the entire outer solar system as we know it falls apart.
As you can see in this diagram, the orbital eccentricities of Saturn, Uranus, and Neptune
sharply rise. Saturn crosses paths with Uranus, Uranus crosses paths with Saturn and Neptune,
and Neptune's orbit has moved significantly outward. In this diagram, Jupiter and Saturn
remain relatively unaltered, but Uranus and Neptune have fully swapped places, making Uranus
the furthest planet from the sun by a significant margin, sending Neptune toward Saturn. The orbits
of all four outer planets have also been made significantly more eccentric as well. In this
scenario, Uranus and Neptune have fully swapped about 215 million years after instability occurred.
And in this one, Uranus and Neptune have once again swapped places, but they are much closer
to one another than the previous model, with the crossing occurring at t equals 0 again.
Jupiter and Saturn are once again relatively unaffected, but again, Uranus supersedes Neptune
and becomes the furthest planet from the sun. Those three are the most interesting orbital
diagrams, but we still have a few more to cover. In this model, for example, a bit more than 1
billion years into the red giant phase, about 6 billion years from today, Uranus's orbit completely
destabilized and for a brief period of time, put Uranus closer to the sun than Jupiter.
In this scenario, Uranus enters the asteroid belt before swapping orbits with Neptune to become the
furthest planet, thus entering the Kuiper belt too. And in this one, only a few million years
after the sun becomes a white dwarf, interactions with Jupiter cause Saturn to be ejected from the
solar system. In two models after that, Neptune is ejected both times, both within a billion years
after the sun becomes a white dwarf. These are the most interesting scenarios, but there's dozens
more. And this also goes to show that when I say instability, I mean instability that will
fundamentally alter the entire structure of the solar system, and in many cases, fully rearrange
the order of planets. In several scenarios, Neptune and Saturn become neighbors, and the
giant planets cross each other's orbits. In one scenario mentioned earlier, the order of giant
planets becomes Uranus-Jupiter-Saturn-Neptune for a short while. Saturn and Neptune being ejected
from the solar system entirely are also possibilities. It is worth noting here that
for the outer solar system, ejections are far more common than collisions. However, that's only true
for the giant planets. In the inner system, though as I'll talk about in a bit, this wasn't directly
modeled here, collisions with each other or with the white dwarf star are more likely. This is
backed up by direct observations. Many white dwarfs we see are polluted by rocky material,
suggesting they've consumed rocky planets, while material suggesting they've consumed gas giants
is much rarer, indicating those planets may have been ejected instead. But this completely throws
out any ideas we had about the far future environments of these planets, which I've
tried to theorize about in my Far Future of the Solar System series. The far future of Neptune
is a good example of this. In that video, I said that it may be a likely possibility that Neptune
ends up in the habitable zone of the red giant sun right at the end of its life, meaning at the end
of the solar system, Neptune could have temperate or near-temperate conditions. That scenario is now
significantly less likely because there's now the possibility that Neptune could either be thrown a
billion kilometers inwards and take Uranus' spot, or get flung super far out and end its time around
the red giant sun cold or ejected. And what does that mean for the moons of these planets and their
potential future environments around a red giant sun? I've also said in the Far Future of Jupiter
that it's unlikely that the Galilean moons will become temperate ocean worlds because water vapor
is a greenhouse gas and they have a lot of water, making steam planets and or planet-sized comets as
a more likely possibility. But this is based on the assumption that Jupiter will become much much
hotter. That is still all but guaranteed, but in scenarios where Jupiter is pushed further away
from a sun, the time scales on which the Galilean moons become steam worlds could become altered.
And this is even more prevalent for Titan, as Saturn has a much wider possibility for future
arrangements than Jupiter. There are scenarios where Saturn's orbit becomes so eccentric it
reaches all the way into Jupiter, a 5 AU jump, and all the way out to Uranus, an almost 10 AU jump,
meaning Saturn's future perihelion could be several AU closer to the sun than its aphelion.
How does that affect its moons? Could we see a scenario where Titan cools down during the red
giant phase, only to suddenly spike into uninhabitable temperatures as Saturn screams
towards Jupiter's orbit? And what about their minor moons? Neptune's furthest moon is 0.3 AU,
a full third of the distance between Earth and the sun away from it. As these planets get closer
to the sun, their hill spheres, the area where moons are stable, will shrink. You could imagine
scenarios where as the eccentricity of these planets spike, their outermost minor moons get
ejected and captured by the sun. Not to mention what effects close passages with other planets
will have. And that's just some speculation I've thought of off the top of my head as I was writing
this script. We really have no idea what could happen, and of course the exact scenario will
depend on how the instability occurs. All we know now is that a large scale instability during the
red giant phase is likely, and an instability shortly after the sun becomes a white dwarf
is nearly guaranteed. Unfortunately this paper doesn't touch on the inner planets,
but as I've mentioned already, the orbits of the inner planets are dependent on the
stability of the outer solar system. Of course this largely won't matter, as in the time frame
we're talking about, Mercury and Venus will be destroyed, and Earth and the moon maybe as well.
There's not really a point in modeling the inner solar system if three of the four planets are
likely to be gone before the models start mattering. So really the only inner solar
system we have to talk about is Mars, and I guess Ceres and the asteroid belt.
This paper doesn't talk about Mars at all, though like all inner solar system planets,
it is affected by the pulls of the outer ones, and while I don't have any concrete scenarios to give,
it's highly likely that Mars will be affected by all this somehow, we just don't know exactly how.
The asteroid belt is a similar story, though to a larger degree, as the entire structure of the
belt is dictated by Jupiter and to a lesser extent Saturn. It's likely the asteroid belt
will be thrown into chaos during this time as well, just based on the movements of these two
planets, not even mentioning the scenario where Uranus enters the asteroid belt.
So clearly the solar system's stable lifetime has been significantly shortened
if this paper is correct, which it likely is. Even if these exact scenarios don't come to pass,
we do now know that some kind of large scale instability is going to occur either during
the red giant phase or at the start of the white dwarf phase. Even if the exact models
turn out to be wrong, the reasoning for these models are based on direct real observations,
so we know for a fact something like this will happen even if it's not any of the scenarios
mentioned here. But the thing is, this won't just apply to the solar system.
These instability scenarios will apply to every star that becomes a red giant,
meaning this has occurred to billions of systems and billions of planets,
and will occur to billions more. This could be a major source of rogue planets throughout our
galaxy. I've said in other videos that rogue planets outnumber stars in the Milky Way by an
order of magnitude. It's been estimated that there's anywhere from 8 to 40 rogue planets
for every star in this galaxy. Instabilities during the red giant phase could help explain
why this is the case. We know that an ejection of at least one planet is the most likely scenario
for the solar system, and we can assume this may apply similarly to sun-like stars across
the Milky Way. Instability at the end of their main sequence lifetimes is not a rare scenario,
but could very well be the default. Though of course, how many planets those systems
eject will be based on their planetary arrangements. I would also like to mention
here that though many systems may experience a period of chaos, it doesn't necessarily mean the
entire system is destroyed. In the scenario I mentioned earlier where Saturn is ejected,
for example, Jupiter, Uranus, and Neptune survived, the ice giants falling into a stable
2-1 resonance with one another. Even though the solar system won't survive in its current form,
some kind of stable planetary system will take its place, in whatever form that may be.
And we do see examples of stable multi-planetary systems around white dwarfs today.
A good example is KMT-2020-BLG-0414L, a system containing a 1.9 Earth mass potentially rocky
inner world with an orbit of about 2 AU, and an outer giant brown dwarf of 27 Jupiter masses,
22 AU away from the star. Basically, both of these planets correspond orbitally to much
larger versions of Mars and Uranus respectively, and the fact that they still exist around this
white dwarf suggests their orbits must be at least somewhat stable.
But other than this, there's unfortunately nothing else we can say other than speculation.
But as you've hopefully seen, this is some of the most interesting information about the far future
of the solar system in a very long time, and it has wide-reaching implications for planetary
systems across the Milky Way. It's a strong possibility that when their stars become red
giants, a significant percentage of star systems will literally shake themselves apart, and this
and shows the stability of the outer solar system likely won't be destroyed by a passing star,
but by our own sun. And this will of course affect the inner planets as well.
Or rather, the one or two remaining inner planets and a bunch of remaining asteroids.
Unfortunately, Mercury, Venus, and possibly Earth won't be around to experience this
tumultuous time. But getting consumed by the sun is pretty interesting in its own right.
Clearly, the solar system's far future is a lot less certain than previously thought,
but also much more exciting and chaotic. Hopefully we can find out more information
about this soon. Thank you for watching. If you enjoyed, check out my other videos
about planets and space exploration.
