Watch Congress Grill Tech CEOs Over Misinformation

Sundar Pichai
1 follower
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedCongressional executives from Facebook, Google, and Twitter were questioned regarding their platforms' roles in spreading election disinformation and COVID-19 vaccine misinformation. While Twitter acknowledged some responsibility for the January 6th Capitol attack, Facebook and Google deflected, emphasizing their systems and policies over direct accountability.
I want to start by asking all three of you if your platform bears some responsibility for
disseminating disinformation related to the election and the Stop the Steal movement that
led to the attack on the Capitol. Just a yes or no answer. Mr. Zuckerberg.
Chairman, I think our responsibility is to build systems that can help.
I just want a yes or no answer, okay? Yes or no. Do you bear some responsibility for what happened?
Congressman, our responsibility is to make sure that we build effective systems.
Okay, the gentleman's purpose is not to answer the question. Mr. Pichai, yes or no?
We always feel a deep sense of responsibility, but I think we worked hard.
This election effort was one of our most substantive efforts.
Is that a yes or a no? Congressman, it's a complex question.
Okay, we'll move on. Mr. Dorsey.
Yes, but you also have to take into consideration a broader ecosystem.
It's not just about the technology platforms we use.
Thank you. Thank you, and I agree with that. Mr. Zuckerberg, independent analysis has shown that
despite all the things that Facebook did during the election, users still interacted with election
misinformation roughly 1.1 billion times over the last year. The initial Stop the Steal group
started on Facebook and gained over 350,000 followers in less than a day,
faster than almost any other in your platform's history, and they were immediately calling for
violence. In mid-December, you stopped promoting high-quality news outlets for election content
at a time when the disinformation was at its height. Finally, the FBI has released numerous
documents showing that many of the insurrectionists used Facebook to coordinate and plan the attack
on January 6th. So my question is, how is it possible for you not to at least admit that
Facebook played a central role or a leading role in facilitating the recruitment, planning,
and execution of the attack on the Capitol? Chairman, my point is that I think that the
responsibility here lies with the people who took the actions to break the law and do the
insurrection, and secondarily also the people who spread that content, including the president,
but others as well, with repeated rhetoric over time saying that the election was rigged and
encouraging people to organize. I think that those people bear the primary responsibility as well,
and that was the point that I was making. I understand that, but your platforms
supercharge that. You took a thing and magnified it in 12 hours. You've got 350,000 people
in your site. You gin this up. Your algorithms make it possible to supercharge these kinds of
opinions. I think we're here because of what these platforms enable, how your choices put our lives
and our democracy at risk, and many of us just find it unacceptable. I want to ask each of you
another question. Do you think vaccines that have been approved for COVID-19 work?
Just yes or no. Do you think the vaccines that have been approved work, Mr. Zuckerberg?
Yes. Mr. Pichai?
Yes, absolutely. Mr. Dorsey?
Yes, but I don't think we're here to discuss our own personal opinions.
I just want to know if you think the vaccines work. Yes?
Yes. Thank you. Okay, so if you think the vaccines work, why have your companies allowed
accounts that repeatedly offend your vaccine disinformation policies to remain up? I mean,
according to reports, just 12 accounts on Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram account for 65%
of all the vaccine disinformation on your platforms. You're exposing tens of millions of
users to this every day. I don't have the stats on YouTube, but my understanding is it's similar.
So my question is, why in the midst of a global pandemic that has killed over half a million
Americans that you haven't taken these accounts down that are responsible for the preponderance
of vaccine disinformation on your platforms? Will you all commit to taking these platforms down
today, Mr. Zuckerberg? Congressman, yes, we do have a policy against
allowing- I know you have a policy, but will you take the sites down today? You still have 12
people up on your site doing this. Will you take them down? Congressman, I would need to look at
and have our team look at the exact examples to make sure they violate the policy.
Well, give it today and give it back to us tomorrow because those still exist. We found
them as early as last night. Mr. Pichai, how about you? We have removed over 850,000 videos.
We removed them all. You still have people that are spreading disinformation on your platforms.
There's about 12 super spreaders. We have clear policies and we take down content. Some of the
content is allowed if it's people's personal experiences, but we definitely- Okay, thank you.
I see my time is getting expired. Mr. Dorsey, will you take these sites down?
You've got about 12 super spreaders. Will you take them down?
Yes, we remove everything against our policy. Today, some of Big Tech's top executives are
taking questions from Capitol Hill on the spread of misinformation on all of their platforms.
Facebook's Mark Zuckerberg distanced his company from one of the most obvious consequences of that
content, the Capitol insurrection. Brian Fung has been watching along there
in Washington. Brian, what has stood out to you?
Well, Brooke, as you said, the insurrection was a big focus of this hearing. The companies really
had a hard time talking about what their role was and whether or not they feel some sense of
responsibility for what happened on January 6th. Twitter was the only company to come out and say,
yes, we bear some responsibility for spreading misinformation that contributed to the violence,
while Facebook and Google had a much harder time coming out saying that.
You had Facebook's Mark Zuckerberg essentially deflecting blame onto President Trump.
Let's have a listen at what he said.
We did our part to secure the integrity of the election. And then, on January 6th,
President Trump gave a speech rejecting the results and calling on people to fight.
I believe that the division we see today is primarily the result of a political and media
environment that drives Americans apart. And we need to reckon with that if we're going to make
progress. And of course, Zuckerberg, even as he was saying that much of what's going on in America
today is the result of media and politics being inherently divisive, he himself did not acknowledge
Facebook's own role in that ecosystem. And this just sort of reflects the big divide here between
what the executives were saying and the anger and the outrage that the lawmakers were directing
at them. They really ran both ways, Brooke, with some executives, including
Jack Dorsey from Twitter, live tweeting from the hearing criticisms of the lawmakers who
were not engaging with his own policy proposals here.
The executives were having trouble containing their frustration with lawmakers. Lawmakers
clearly very upset at the executives and the platforms for their conduct.
Overall, a very, very tense hearing, Brooke.
Gone both ways. Brian Fung, thank you so much.
