23 YEARS OLD! Nyetimber 2003. Does English sparkling wine age well?

Wine Regions Revealed
5 followers
1 Video View·Sep 19, 2026
Something a bit special - a 23 year old Nyetimber, their 2003 vintage Classic Cuvée, which I found at Hedonism Wines: https://hedonism.co.uk/products/nyeti...
…
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThe presenter reviews a rare 2003 vintage Nyetimber Classic Cuvée, an English sparkling wine aged for 23 years. The tasting highlights the wine's remarkable longevity, preserving a refreshing acidity and concentrated citrus notes. It serves as a historical window into the estate's early winemaking philosophy, offering a high-quality experience and exceptional value compared to vintage Champagnes.
Hello, welcome to another English Sparkling with Twainy video.
Bit of a special wine today and I picked it up sort of almost by accident,
not really an accident, but it wasn't the wine that I was anticipating to buy when I
went to that particular shop. It was at the same time as I bought that cuvee sherry from
Hedonism in Mayfair, which just happened to be reasonably priced for that cuvee sherry
compared to a couple of other shops that I looked at that stocked it in London.
While I was there I searched what else they had from Nightimber on their website and I found
this. To look at it you might not immediately think there was anything particularly special
about it. It does look like a fairly bog standard bottle of Nightimber. It is in the old style of
packaging, they have updated that a bit, but this looks very familiar to me and very ordinary in a
way. It's only when you look at the back, the label on the back, you see that this is in fact
a vintage release. Up until I think 2010 Nightimber were doing vintage releases for their
classic cuvee and then from then on they moved to a multi-vintage scheme. But this is a single
vintage and it's from 2003. All the way back in 2003. I'm filming this in September 2026,
so these grapes would have been coming off the vine 23 years ago. I don't think I've ever had
an English sparkling wine of that age before. So I'm very interested to see what this is going
to be like. Nightimber was a very different beast at that time. The head winemaker was I believe a
chap called Peter Morgan, who you don't seem to hear much from anymore. I think he moved to teach
at Plumpton College after his role as one of the earlier head winemakers at Nightimber. And the
owners were also different. Rather than current Eric Karima, it wasn't the original Mr and Mrs Moss
who'd started the vineyard in the 1980s. It was Andy and Nicola Hall. I think that's their names.
And Andy in particular is famous in his own right as a music producer and songwriter.
And he was particularly noted for having had something to do with bringing Buck's Fizz to
fame. It's a very appropriate band to be associated with for someone who, temporarily at least,
owned a vineyard specialising in sparkling wine. Did he possibly write their Eurovision
entry and some other songs for them? I don't remember. Anyway, let's see. 23 years old.
Let's hope this is not going to have any drama on opening. Seemed fairly straightforward to me.
Getting a nice, healthy foam, healthy stream of bubbles. But as always, the lighting is far from
perfect here. Quite a deep, dark colour, particularly for Nightimber, which is usually
Chardonnay dominant. It's not just the head winemaker and the owners of Nightimber back in
2003 who were noteworthy to me, at least. Their assistant winemaker at that time, very familiar
name, one young Dermot Segrue, right at the start of his career in English sparkling wine. I think
he was only briefly assistant winemaker at Nightimber before Peter Morgan left and he was
promoted to head winemaker. He wasn't there for very long. It was possibly only a couple of years.
But at least some parts of this would have been overseen, possibly the early stages by Peter
Morgan, but then a little later in the winemaking process of this, Dermot Segrue would have had a
hand in it. I'm very excited to try. I don't think I've had any Nightimber from Dermot's era before.
First nose pre-swirl.
Getting an almost liqueury sense to that, definitely a sense of age. Old booze. It's almost like a
sense of something like brandy or calvados even. There's definitely an appley note to that nose,
but it's apple as expressed in either really aged cider or something like calvados.
Around the edge, possibly hints of brown sugar there.
And a little bit of barnyard funk. There is a slightly cidery quality to that, not too much
subtle, but a tiny bit of, I don't know, rotanomyces might have crept in there,
which is very unusual in English sparkling. Slightly honeyed note, so let's give that a
swirl. I don't know if it's good to agitate it too much if it's really that old. Now coming into some
creamier notes, some slightly citrus notes. I think I'm getting a little bit of a sense of
could be slightly marmalady. Something sort of orangey, but tinned tangerine slices, something
like that. Yeah, a slightly syrupy and preserved sense of something slightly orangey actually.
So either marmalade or some segments of one of those orange relatives in a tin.
Well, first of all, that is still in great shape, I think. There's a lovely bit of zing at the start
and bubbles definitely attacking. You can hopefully see that in the glass. Sorry,
it's a bit misted up. Definitely has not lost its fizz, has not lost its acidity. This is not
a dying wine. This is a wine that's still going strong, which is great.
Lovely mouthfeel. The effervescence, the fizz has settled down a bit, as is often the case
in older sparkling wines, particularly traditional method sparkling wines. It does tend to get a bit
more gentle, but it has a lovely texture for that. Certainly not disappeared. On the palate,
fruit-wise, I think I'm getting more sort of orangey, tangeriney. Again, I'm sure this is
segments of tangerine, mandarin in a tin, that sort of thing.
There is a sort of slight viscosity to it. Actually, it reminds me slightly of
cuvee sherry. We've gone about getting that, the demi-sec that I tried the other day. We've
gone about reaching that in two very different ways. This is extreme age. That was the addition
of quite a lot of sugar. But it does, again, seem to have this very slight viscosity to it
that I think has come from age. And yet that fizz is still very much present.
Really refreshing, actually. And then on to the tangerines, the sort of interestingly
orangey notes. There's something on the nose there I can almost recognise,
but can't quite put my finger on. I'm slightly put in mind of tobacco.
Something like cigars. Not a lit cigar, but the leaves that the cigar is wrapped in.
Dried. Subtle. It's quite a sweet version of that. Maybe pipe tobacco. A nice sort of sweet,
gentle version of tobacco, which is something I've never encountered in an English sparkling before.
I think that's possibly a tertiary note. I sometimes see that with a bit of age in burgundy,
and I think amazingly that's developed here. I should say there is a bit of blurb about this
on Nytimber's website, and it does have the grape breakdown. So there is a code on the back,
as always. It looks to me as though a little sticker has been put over that code, as if
they've perhaps changed at some point to a new coding system. I don't know the exact provenance
of this. I don't know if Haddonism bought it directly from Nytimber at some point,
or it's come indirectly via a third party. But there is a little stick on the back with the
code. Typing that in didn't seem to do anything. It recognised that it was a 2003 vintage,
but there is already a dedicated page, a dedicated paragraph at least, in the sort
of wine library section of the page on Classic Cuvée, and it talks about 2003. The grape breakdown
is 60% Chardonnay, 20% Pinot Mernier, 20% Pinot Noir. Oranges and tobacco. Something like that.
Really interesting. And yet everything else about it is actually quite fresh, refreshing,
mouth-watering, but just with a bit more seriousness and age than a much newer version
of this Classic Cuvée. I've got the sense possibly the acidity levels, as reported there,
are a little bit higher in the 2003 vintage than is the norm since then. I don't know if that's to
do with winemaking style. Nytimber today run all their wines, pretty much everything I think,
through malolactic fermentation, and that's part of the modern house style of Nytimber.
I've got a feeling that was possibly an innovation that came in when Sherry and Brad, the current
winemakers, started there. Dermot Segrue is well known for not doing malolactic fermentation,
for leaving that kind of bold, bracing malic acid in the wine. The character of the acidity here to
me is more citric acid, it's more sort of lemony, the zing, rather than that kind of harsh green
apple zing you get with malic acid. I don't know, maybe there is a twang of the green apple in there
actually. Yeah, perhaps there is, and we're into uncharted waters because it's been aged for so
long. But anyway, to cut a very long story short, what I want to say is that I think it's impressive
how intact that acidity is. That's one of the things that you would assume to tail off with
age. It's very, very present still, which is lovely. It's definitely not overpowering, it's wonderfully
balanced, and there are these interesting sweet notes that I think have just come with age. I don't
think this would have been a particularly high dosage wine initially. Yeah, I wonder if under
Dermot's brief reign at Nitember and Peter Morgan just before him, perhaps they weren't
doing malolactic fermentation, and maybe that's helped with the ability of these older wines to
age, I don't know. I really like that. It does come across as a little bit on the sweet side,
I think that's from age, and I really like this overall kind of orangey character. I think
normally with Nitember's classic cuvee, it tends to go a bit lemony, sometimes a bit appley,
which are of course things you get from Chardonnay. Here it's orangey, and maybe there is actually a
little bit of stone fruit influence there, possibly a bit of apricot. I'm still thinking of something
orange-adjacent here rather than necessary. There's a bit of stone fruit, a bit of,
yeah, okay, I'll give them apricots. I think that was in the official tasting though.
I'll put the price up there. It wasn't crazy for a fanboy like me, and perhaps for
an ordinary person who isn't as fascinated and really into English sparkling, it's going to
seem like a very expensive bottle, but for me to have that window into what I consider to be the
very early days of Nitember, I know officially they were established, the vines were planted
in the late 80s, but they didn't really start releasing wines until the late, was it 97 perhaps,
their first actual release? It took practically a whole decade really to get going, and so it's
still really pretty early days for them, and again a different set of owners, different head
winemaker, different assistant winemaker, a very different company really in many ways,
different philosophy. I think things like the Manilactic fermentation have probably changed
since then. It's almost a ship of Theseus thing really, isn't it? It's still Nitember.
Possibly in those early days they were more confined to their home vineyard. There is a
winery at the estate called Nitember, but now they have multiple sites across Sussex, Hampshire,
and do they possibly even occasionally have grapes from Kent? So this for me is a very interesting
window into the Nitember of the past, and quite a different beast from what it is today.
You know what I think this actually reminds me of? It is slightly Reiky Bottom-esque,
and I think no finer compliment in my opinion can be given to an English sparkling wine.
Dermot Segrue and Peter Hall were great friends I believe. You would often go and visit him there,
and I'm sure Dermot picked up a few tricks from Peter and quite possibly vice versa.
Partly this is probably because I haven't had a lot of very seriously aged English sparkling wines,
and so that is my main frame of reference. Reiky Bottom still have a wonderful library of old
vintages that rightfully so get more and more expensive the further back you go, and they
absolutely should. And one of the earliest I think that is still available, at least was still
available last time I checked, was the 2009 Gerard Huffnum, which is quite possibly one of my
favourite English sparkling wines of all time. I think definitely the favourite from Reiky Bottom,
and that has this incredible intensity despite its age, and it is a very, I think a very citrus
style of English sparkling. But this is a sort of a mix of that, it has some slight hints of that,
plus Michel Moreau, which is I think 2014 from Reiky Bottom. So both of these are the
the Gerard Huffnum and the Michel Moreau are both the Chardonnay and Pinot blends. Of course
Reiky Bottom also make Sable based wines. This is two of the wines with the classic
Champagne grapes from 2009-2014, and I remember Michel Moreau to me had this wonderful vivaciousness,
liveliness that kept really well with age, and that had quite an orangey quality, a zesty
orangey quality to it. So yeah, I think this is slightly reminiscent of that, even though as I say
the citrus character, it's a little bit like tinned. I don't mean that in a bad way, just
because it is a bit more concentrated perhaps, a bit more preserved, a bit more aged, a little bit
like tinned slices of mandarin, tangerine. It's something I haven't had for probably 20 years,
those tinned oranges. Why bother when you can so easily get fresh citrus fruits all year round?
Yeah, I think something about that surprising intensity, despite the age,
the way that acidity is so beautifully preserved, and the quite concentrated,
that's a nicer way of saying it rather than tinned fruit, concentrated essence of
citrus character. I think actually quite orangey citrus character, and that has to be
an interplay. I don't think you get orangey citrus from Chardonnay alone, I think you can get
lemon from Chardonnay, but I think that's some interaction between the 40% of the two pinots,
particularly Pinot Meurnier I think can often lend a slightly orangey character.
And they've melded in a wonderful way in the 23 years they've been in this bottle, it's amazing.
For an English sparkling, that's to me amazing. And created this
orangey, mandariney, tangeriney, mikan, you'd say in Japanese, character.
Lovely stuff. What a treat that is, I'm really happy that I just stumbled across that when I was
basically looking for something else. The Cuvee Sherry the other day.
So, good old Hedonism, who would have thought? I don't think they have a good
English sparkling wine selection, it's decent, but they cover so much. They're really big on
Burgundy and on Bordeaux and Champagne and a bit more of the kind of old money wines basically,
they're in Mayfair, and I think they have a certain kind of clientele there, and I imagine
the majority of people who shop there see English sparkling as a bit of a fun novelty at best.
Not really, they wouldn't take it as seriously as Champagne and Burgundy, etc.
And thus this is only 72 quid. I mean, imagine a well-regarded Champagne house
releasing a 2003 vintage, the sort of prices you're going to pay
for vintage Champagne that's 20 plus years old. It's going to be a lot more than £72, isn't it?
I fear I could just babble on about this indefinitely. I know I'm trying to get the
English sparkling channel up to 4,000 watch hours, but perhaps making each video
half an hour long isn't necessarily the best way to achieve that at some point,
but I'm really enjoying that. That, to me, absolutely money well spent. What a wonderful
window into an earlier era of night timber and a wonderful opportunity to see how well
English sparkling can age, and that is beautiful. That really is in very good condition. I imagine
it'll be good for some years to come. It's hard for me to guess. This is all uncharted waters,
as I say. 23 years on, remarkable freshness, liveliness, full of life, full of interest,
doing something quite different now to how I imagine it would have been 20 years ago.
Very enjoyable, but I'll stop talking.
