The Greatest Roast Beef Sandwich Ever (Italian Beef) #ustomizing YourItalian Beef Sandwich

Chicago Cuisine
3 followers
4 Video Views·Sep 20, 2026 #ChicagoCuisine
AI Generated·May contain errors
If we're gonna do Italian beef,
we're gonna have to go to Chicago first.
So we're packing our bags,
going to Chicago to find the greatest Italian beef.
But not without the greatest recipes
from this cookbook, which is my book.
And it's available on Amazon
and it's a great gift for the holidays.
It's coming right around the corner.
Link in the description.
Like that?
Pretty good, huh?
Practice that.
Been here for two days.
Already trying to figure out how to move here
even though I just bought a house in Austin.
Good job, Josh.
Look, the architecture's beautiful.
The vibes are immaculate.
The serotonin level's so high.
But let's talk about this Italian beef.
We're here to have the proper,
most original Italian beef that we can get.
Consume, enjoy, observe.
We're gonna go back, make it as traditional
and authentically as we can in our abode.
So with all that being said, let's begin.
We started at Portillo's, the Italian beef spot
that seems to cover, well, every street corner in Illinois.
We're starting here for a reason, Portillo's.
Now you're thinking, Josh, that's a chain.
What are you doing there?
Look, there's something very special about Portillo's
and it's the fact that, albeit there are so many locations,
it's one of the few places that Chicagoans can know
that they're gonna get a consistent Italian beef
anywhere, pretty much in all of Illinois.
I know this sandwich is juicy,
because it's like wet.
When the bag is wet.
My peeper.
Jesus Christ, how do I eat this?
That's nuts.
It's like salty, it's acidic from the pickles.
Fatty.
Part eating a sandwich and part drinking a sandwich.
You ever drank a sandwich?
This is honestly fire.
If I lived near one of these, I would go here every day.
It's not like a million flavors compounded over one.
It's a bunch of very simple flavors
that are focused on and emphasized
to be as maximally powerful as possible.
That's all there is to it.
It's a great sandwich.
But let's move on to our next.
Next we checked out Buona Beef,
which honestly was kind of disappointing.
It's a lot less fatty, it's more dry.
There's less like juice to it all.
This isn't quite rounding out my experience.
So moving on from that, it's like a two or three in my book.
So we decided let's end our journey
with something truly special.
We're out here in Chicago at the real one and only Mr. Beef.
You've seen this before.
Where have I seen it?
Oh my goodness.
Like the show The Bear?
Hello.
Dupacavone.
Let's go.
I don't know what that means.
Should look like this.
It should be like dripping.
Look at this.
Glistening, 10, 20 in the morning
and everyone is here eating.
It's a beautiful day.
Good.
I get it now.
Hands down, this is the best one we had
out of all the places we went.
If you take a bite of this, your lips should be quivering.
I feel the energy and the culture
that they were trying to show off in The Bear.
One of the reasons why I love the show
and even the taste of this, the look, the ambiance,
all the photos on the wall.
I mean, there's like a real culture here.
I feel like I'm living it right now.
And it was at this moment I knew
I needed to meet this beef's maker.
So funny story, we actually completely left the city
only to somehow magically be put in touch with
and be given the opportunity to meet
one of the greatest Chicagoans since Michael Jordan.
Oh yeah, that's definitely him.
Yo.
Pleasure to meet you.
It's such a pleasure.
What's your name?
Mike.
Mike, it's okay if we roll on this?
Are you cool with that?
Yeah.
The owner of Mr. Beef, Christopher Zucchera.
Everybody.
Once I took my first bite of that sandwich,
the only thing I wanted to talk about was Mr. Beef.
Italian beef is our thing in Chicago.
Not pizza, not hot dogs.
I was practically born and raised here in this restaurant.
A piece of real Chicago history.
Yeah, if you ever come to Chicago
and you don't come to this place,
you're making a ******* mistake.
People would, hold on, no, no, no.
Do you mind if I do kind of business
while we're doing this?
I'm actually technically closed,
but I'll make you whatever you want, buddy.
You guys want fries?
Yeah.
What's a drink, guys?
I'll take a water and a squirt.
Water and a squirt.
All right, what are you, ******* 70 years old?
People would come into this restaurant
and they would eat like three or four times a week.
And then he'd tell me how my beef sandwich sucked.
You ate here three times already this week.
I don't care if you hate me or you don't like me.
I don't really give a ****.
I'm lucky I wake up every day with a ******* smile.
So I'm just like, eh.
First thing I do when I come here in the morning
is I eat a beef sandwich.
You hear that?
How many fries, guys?
One or two?
I'm very lucky, man.
I wouldn't have known about this place
like without the bear.
The director and I, we go back to first grade together.
Is it great, guys?
It's amazing.
All right, right on, thank you.
I didn't talk to him for like three years.
He came in and he's like, yeah, buddy.
I'm gonna shoot this pilot.
It's gotta be here.
You gonna be okay with it?
Yeah, go ahead.
I'll give it to you guys for free.
Just do what you gotta do.
Unbelievably grateful for what Storr did.
Immortalized this place.
I've never seen the show.
Whoa.
Yeah.
That's crazy.
I've never watched it.
People come in here and they're like,
hey, chef.
No, no, no, no, no, no.
Don't do that.
One guy called me an asshole for it recently.
But I also said on national TV that Chicago had pizza.
I don't care.
So everybody has to put all their bullshit aside.
That's what I think a lot of the beer is about, really.
You heard that?
You leave your ego at the door and you bring the beef in.
Of course, we want to thank Chris for talking with us.
But honestly, we went in just to meet
and ask a few questions
and ended up talking about life for over two hours.
One thing is for certain.
After this whole experience,
I think I know exactly what needs to be done.
Listen, you ain't got no sandwich with no bread
and you best believe we making it too.
So most Italian beef are served
on what seems to be called a long French roll.
To make, add two cups or 450 grams of water
at 95 degrees Fahrenheit to the bowl of a stand mixer,
followed by one and a half tablespoons
or 18 grams of instant yeast
and two tablespoons or 18 grams of granulated sugar.
Mix to combine.
Let this sit for a minute or two.
Then add two tablespoons or 24 grams of vegetable oil.
You're gonna add four and three quarters of a cup
or 800 grams of bread flour,
which I would recommend adding in two parts.
Obviously, the first half,
work on your spiral thingy.
With the mixing on low speed,
let it mix till combined,
followed by two and a half teaspoons
or 12 grams of fine sea salt.
The second half of your flour,
if it seems a little dry,
you can always add a little extra splash of water.
Should be in a good spot.
Now let that mix till smooth for about three to five minutes.
Place it into a greased bowl,
cover with plastic wrap and let that rise
for one to one and a half hours
or until doubled in ball-ness.
Lovingly push every little molecule of life out of it.
Place it under a lightly floured work surface
and divide into four even pieces.
Form those into light balls
and place it aside covered with greased plastic wrap.
Rest at room temp for 15 minutes.
Once it's rested, you pull it out,
dust both sides, flatten it out into an oval.
Fold that oval, pinch the seam shut,
roll your girthy boy into a 16 by three inch log.
Place it on a baking sheet lined with parchment paper.
Repeat with another.
Place that evenly spaced apart on the same baking sheet.
Listen, do not do more than two loaves per baking sheet.
Repeat with your remaining two loaves,
cover with greased plastic wrap
and proof at room temp for 45 minutes.
While that's proofing, preheat your oven
to 375 Fahrenheit or 190 Celsius.
Give that a light spritz of water.
Optionally, you can slash the top of your dough
with a sharp knife at a diagonal at three to four intervals
across the whole length of your dough.
Pop them into your oven and bake for 25 to 30 minutes
or until a deep golden brown beautiful loaf emerges.
I mean, look at this thing.
Now cool completely, cut off the tips
and divide into two evenly sized pieces
and set to the side.
The rest of the sandwich is pretty simple
but we need to address something you cannot forget.
Giardiniera.
Get a medium sauce pot, add one and a half cups
or 360 milliliters of white distilled vinegar,
three quarters of a cup or 175 milliliters of water,
one and a half tablespoons or 16 grams of kosher salt
and three tablespoons or 45 grams of granulated sugar.
Heat that over medium high until nearly boiling
and it's steaming hot.
Then separately in a large container,
you're gonna add four banana peppers sliced,
one to two large carrots peeled and sliced into rounds,
five ribs of celery cut into half inch cubes,
four serrano chilies sliced
and then add your hot pickle liquid over your vegetables
and then mix in one cup or 240 milliliters
of extra virgin olive oil.
Follow that with a petit sachet, which you can do
by first laying down a small layer of cheesecloth
and to that you'll add seven sprigs of fresh oregano,
one tablespoon or nine grams of black peppercorns,
one tablespoon or eight grams of celery seeds,
wrap it all up nice and tight,
tie it together with kitchen twine,
pop that in there too,
press them down so they stay submerged,
let those sit until room temperature
and guess what?
You got a classy giardiniera.
Now before we can talk about the beef,
we need to talk about beef stock.
First you need to mix a four pounds or 1.8 kilos
of oxtail and three pounds or 1.3 kilos of beef soup bones.
Place that on a foil lined baking sheet,
spray them generously with cooking spray,
pop into an oven preheated to 475 Fahrenheit,
ideally with a convection setting,
until deeply browned, about 30 to 45 minutes.
Pop all those into a large pot
along with two onions quartered,
three ribs of celery rough chopped,
one head of garlic cut in half
and two carrots rough chopped
and one tablespoon or nine grams of whole peppercorns.
Add just enough water to cover the bones,
set over medium high and once it begins to boil,
reduce to low and simmer for three to four hours
or until reduced enough to taste mad good.
Anyway, remove the solids from your broth,
strain through a large fine mesh strainer
and that's a lovely, gorgeous beef stock
that Papa would kiss.
Now for the moment we've all been waiting for,
the thing that puts the beef in Italian beef,
which is the beef.
You'll need a beef top round roast
that's around four pounds or 1.8 kilos.
Season that bad boy heavily with salt and pepper to taste
then get a large Dutch oven,
at least seven to eight quarts ideally.
Add enough oil to coat the bottom of the pot,
set over medium high and once it's nearly smoking,
add your beef and sear for two to three minutes
or until deeply browned.
Repeat on all sides,
then just leave that bad boy in the pot.
Add enough of your fresh beef stock
to nearly submerge your beef.
To that broth, add one teaspoon
or two grams of red pepper flakes,
one tablespoon or seven grams of ground paprika,
one tablespoon or eight grams of celery seeds,
five whole heads of garlic cut in half.
Yeah, I didn't misspeak, five.
One onion quartered,
leaving some of the root bottom attached
so it doesn't, you know, fall apart in there.
Now this isn't traditional,
but I threw in a little bit of mushroom soup-based powder
for that pizzazz.
One bay leaf and four sprigs of fresh oregano.
Bring that up to a boil over medium high.
Once it begins to boil, reduce heat to low,
cover with the lid and place it in an oven
that's been heated to 350 Fahrenheit.
Braise that for around one hour
or until the internal temperature
reaches around 130 to 135 Fahrenheit.
Then take the beef out, reserve absolutely everything,
and leave in the fridge overnight.
Now once your boof is chilled,
slice that bad boy as thinly as you possibly can.
I would highly recommend a deli meat slicer.
You don't have one?
Well, I don't know what to tell you,
but look at these beefy ribbons.
I mean, come on.
Now once you've sliced all your beef,
strain your braising liquid that you cooked the beef in
into a large deep pan or a medium pot, whatever works.
Heat that till steamy hot but not boiling,
then add all of your sliced beef back to the broth,
and this is the gateway to arguably
one of the most succulent, beautiful bath times
you'll ever see.
Assembly is the last pillar, which is also very specific.
First off, grab a roll.
Cut it in half, leaving one side attached,
and toss into a 350 degree oven for five to six minutes.
Once that sucker is piping hot,
use tongs to grab your meat
and aggressively stuff your buns with your hot meat.
Boy, that does not sound right.
Once it's filled to the brim,
add a few generous spoonfuls of your giardiniera,
making sure some of that oil and the pickling juices
come along with each spoonful.
Really max out that juice.
Now for my favorite part, the dipping.
You can fully dip, half dip, whatever.
I like it with both ends dipped,
dunking deeply into the broth.
Then immediately wrap up your sandwich and you're ready.
Now we tear into what might be
my new favorite sandwich of all time,
and I'll show you why.
I couldn't be more excited.
Look at this.
Cross section.
Wow.
I know Christopher is watching.
Christopher, the Mr. Beef.
I think he'd be proud.
Listen, the juice, the flavors, they're all there.
The pickle, juicy.
I mean, it is ridiculously juicy.
You're half drinking this sandwich.
I really think we hit the mark,
but we have a true Chicagoan actually here,
and he goes by the name of Bicklin.
Wow, there he is.
That's right.
Here's your Italian beef.
I've been waiting for Josh to make this for two years now.
I'm glad it's finally happening.
I'm so nervous.
There's only one way to do it.
That is an Italian beef.
That is insane.
This is the best way to eat beef.
Like, you need to do it fully dunk.
Flavor overload.
Oh, we found Belle Delphine's bathwater.
Hanna, what are you doing?
That's an approved Chicago Italian beef.
Give it the respect and juice it up.
But do you want to know what else is juiced up?
B-roll.
