What Really Happened Inside the Amityville Horror House?
1 Video View·Sep 18, 2026
The Amityville murders are some of the most gruesome and harrowing
crimes in American history.
The story is so vile and evil that it's
taken on a supernatural life of all its own.
With 21 feature films, numerous documentaries, countless books,
and endless public speculation, the terrifying events
that transpired on November 13 of 1974
have haunted the American heartland for decades.
Today, on Scream to Screen, we're
going to take a deep dive into the story of the Amityville
horror.
On November 13, 1974, 23-year-old Ronald DeFeo Jr.
stalked from room to room of his family's three-story Long
Island home and mercilessly gunned down
all of the inhabitants.
The house at 112 Ocean Avenue was a large Dutch colonial-style
home placed within the sleepy suburban neighborhood
of Amityville.
The south shore of Long Island, New York
was not used to this type of extreme malice and violence,
but it had arrived nonetheless.
Rumors of the family being abusive and physically
aggressive towards one another would
swirl through the small coastal village
after these horrific events became public knowledge.
All we know for certain is that the occupants of the house
that night were 44-year-old Ronald DeFeo Sr.,
Louise DeFeo, aged 42, and siblings 18-year-old Dawn,
13-year-old Allison, 12-year-old Mark,
and 9-year-old John Matthew.
The family's bodies were found lifeless, laying face down.
This led authorities to ask some rather disturbing questions.
How did none of the neighbors hear the gunshots?
Why did the entire DeFeo family remain in their beds
when gunshots were going off in the house?
Why would Ronald mercilessly stalk from room to room,
ending the lives of his family?
Which leads us to the most perplexing element
of this entire case.
Why on the night of the 13th did Ronnie DeFeo Jr.
enter Henry's bar just down the street from his house
at approximately 6.30 PM and yell, you've got to help me.
I think my mother and father are shot.
After returning to the DeFeo family home
and uncovering the murders, Ronnie's friend Joe Yeswit
phoned the police, who then uncovered
the severity of the crimes.
Initially, Ronnie was taken into protective custody
after he mentioned to a police officer
that he thought the crimes had been carried out by a mafia
hitman named Louis Fellini.
When the police questioned Fellini,
he had a rock-solid alibi that removed him from consideration.
After further questioning exposed inconsistencies
in Ronnie's story, he eventually admitted
to killing his family.
DeFeo Jr. was brought up on criminal charges
and tried in court on October 14, 1975.
His defense attorney, William Weber,
attempted to provide a defense of insanity.
He claimed that DeFeo was acting in what
he perceived as self-defense because he
heard voices in his head telling him
if he did not murder his family, he would be killed.
DeFeo also claimed that he was given the weapon, a .35 caliber
Marlin .336C, by a woman who was wrapped in shadow
and who had black fungus covered hands.
However, this insanity plea proved unsuccessful.
The plea was supported by the defense's psychiatrist,
Daniel Schwartz.
But the prosecution's psychiatrist
concluded that Ronnie was aware of his actions
despite being both a heroin and LSD user
and suffering from antisocial personality disorder.
Ronnie DeFeo Jr. was found guilty of six counts of murder
in the second degree on October 14, 1975.
Despite his conviction and sentencing,
many questions remain about Ronald DeFeo Jr.'s heinous
crime.
Why did the muzzle blasts from his .35 caliber Marlin
not disturb anyone in the surrounding area?
Was there truly a woman with rotting hands that
proffered him the murder weapon?
Was he compelled by otherworldly voices?
No one has been able to answer these lingering questions.
One possible theory is that DeFeo Jr.
and his 18-year-old sister Dawn were in a relationship
and that they had reached the end of their rope,
suffering abuse from their parents.
Another is that Fellini had worked with accomplices
to take advantage of DeFeo's mental impairments
and murdered the family due to debts
that DeFeo Sr. had owed.
However, neither of these theories
answers the question of, why did none of the neighbors
hear the crimes take place?
Were other people involved?
Were the bodies killed elsewhere and then brought
to 112 Ocean Avenue?
Was there a demonic spirit in the house
who moved Ronnie Jr. to seek retribution?
After remaining empty for 13 months, in December of 1975,
the Lutz family moved into the home formerly
occupied by the DeFeos.
Kathleen and George Lutz seemed like an average American
family.
Their three children were typical 1970s kids.
Unfortunately, according to the Lutz family,
there was nothing normal about the house at 112 Ocean Avenue.
The Lutzes paid $80,000 for the five-bedroom home.
The highly distinctive Gambrell-style room
with its two small windows initially drew them to the home
but would quickly become a symbol of evil.
Many people say that those two windows looked like eyes
on a demonic face.
The Lutz family moved into the house on December 19, 1975,
and almost immediately claimed to be experiencing
otherworldly happenings.
The Lutzes' beloved family dog, Harry, a Malamute Labrador mix,
was chained up in the backyard while the family began moving
their possessions into the home.
Harry, apparently driven mad by some unseen force,
jumped the fence surrounding the property.
Unfortunately, his chain was not long enough
to allow him to land on the other side,
and he choked to death, hanging himself from the fence.
The Lutzes were deeply distraught and concerned
for their family and well-being after this occurrence.
What had made Harry jump the fence?
Was he trying to get away from something?
A family friend recommended that they get the house blessed.
They contacted a local parish, and Father Ralph J. Pecoraro
came and blessed the house.
The blessing did not stop the paranormal happenings, though.
There was one room in the house that was infested with flies.
No matter how many times the Lutzes would exterminate them,
they would appear the next day.
The family also experienced locked doors, mysterious sounds,
and strange coincidences.
On one occasion, Kathleen Lutz entered a room,
and the windows burst open suddenly.
The Lutzes' son saw a shadowy figure
moving in the hallway at night, and when he called out to it,
it stopped, stared directly at him, and then vanished.
The Lutzes' youngest daughter, Missy,
claimed to see a large pig with glowing red eyes
that would come to her at night and talk to her.
When the Lutzes asked her what the pig would say,
Missy responded, he says that he's glad I'm here,
that I'll always be here from now on.
Less than a month after moving in,
on the night of January 14, 1976,
the Lutz family fled the home.
They simply could not tolerate these unexplainable phenomena
any longer.
They were contacted by noted mediums
and paranormal investigators Ed and Lorraine Warren,
who offered to come and investigate the property.
While the arrangements were being made,
the Lutzes were approached by the DeFeo's former lawyer,
William Weber.
He proposed a deal to the Lutzes that
would include a book adaptation of their story, which would
then be parlayed into a film production.
Weber was familiar with some Hollywood producers
who'd given him a verbal commitment
to produce a film based on the story of the grisly murders
and ensuing paranormal phenomena.
The Lutzes were initially reticent,
but eventually agreed to the idea in an effort
to offset the financial burden that
purchasing the former DeFeo residence had caused them.
Ed and Lorraine Warren, along with a local TV news crew,
set up a camera in the hallway of the now abandoned house.
The camera was set to go off every 30 seconds.
They left the camera alone and began
filming other segments with various members
of the household and skeptics, attempting
to discern if the house truly was haunted.
Ed and Lorraine Warren had a track record
of being paranormal investigators.
In the years since the incident, they've
been exposed as frauds, much like
many paranormal investigators.
However, one key element of the story
cannot be disproven as anything other
than an unexplained phenomenon.
The camera that was set to automatically take photos
captured one of a small boy peering out
from behind a doorway.
This boy was not in the house when the local TV news
crew was filming.
No one on the crew knew him.
And to make things even more eerie,
when the photo was shown to Missy Lutz,
she simply responded, oh, yes, that's my friend
that I used to play with.
Did the news crew accidentally stumble
upon a photo of an otherworldly specter?
No one will ever know for sure.
William Weber hired novelist Jay Anson
to write a semi-fictionalized account of the happenings.
The book would be titled The Amityville Horror,
A True Story.
It was published on September 13, 1977
by Prentice Hall Publishing.
It's estimated that the book sold roughly 10 million copies
and was turned into a mini-franchise of novels
spawning nine sequels.
Anson's book would be adapted into a movie, which
was released in 1979, starring James Brolin and Margot
Kidder.
The screenplay was written by Sandor Stern
and directed by Stuart Rosenberg.
It was a box office smash, pulling in $80 million,
spawning 21 sequel or re-adaptation films,
and instigating a mass obsession with the strange house
at 112 Ocean Avenue.
People traveled from across the globe
to pray on the front lawn, touch the house,
and even attempt to steal pieces of it.
The Lutzes became minor celebrities,
doing the late night talk show circuit
and telling their tale.
Ultimately, the attention was too much for them.
They moved to California to attempt
to find some peace and quiet.
Today, the house on 112 Ocean Avenue
still stands, leering at all those who still flock
to its purportedly cursed soil.
The house has changed hands a few times over the years.
The iconic eye windows have been remodeled,
and none of the subsequent owners
have reported experiencing any paranormal occurrences.
But there are still legions of people
obsessed with the house as a vortex of evil
from the great beyond.
Kathy Lutz passed away in 2004, George Lutz in 2006.
They largely kept out of the spotlight
since the Amityville horror movies became wildly popular.
The films have gone on to be adapted, sequelized, remade,
spun off, and re-adapted, from The Conjuring,
to The Amityville Playhouse, to Amityville Prison,
the story of the Lutz family, their brush
with the supernatural, and the lingering dread
has captivated multiple generations of people.

